Gunfight at the O.K. Corral 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 72
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Gunfight at O.K. Corral's 4K by Kino Lorber mixes drama and history; some find it lacking, others a must-have.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 77
Kino Lorber's Gunfight at the O.K. Corral 4K release dazzles with improved color, detail, and contrast, enhancing a classic with a modern visual restoration.
Audio: 74
The release features English DTS-HD MA 5.1 and 2.0 audio tracks with clear, stable dialogue and optional English SDH subtitles, offering a rich audio experience.
Extra: 60
Exclusive, entertaining audio commentary by C. Courtney Joyner & Henry Parke on 4K & Blu-ray editions of 'Gunfight at O.K. Corral,' covering production insights and discrepancies, plus a vintage trailer and a gallery of KLSC trailers.
Movie: 75
John Sturges' 'Gunfight at the O.K. Corral' on 4K Blu-ray blends historical drama with Hollywood glam, stirring debates on accuracy vs. entertainment.
Video: 77
Kino Lorber's 4K Ultra HD release of "Gunfight at the O.K. Corral" marks a significant uptick in the film's visual presentation when compared to its previous Blu-ray iterations. The new 4K scan, from the original 35mm negative by Paramount, brings an unprecedented level of clarity and detail to this classic western. The included Dolby Vision and HDR10 options enhance the viewing experience with richer, more robust colors, especially noticeable in the film's many outdoor sequences and in the vividness of period costumes. The earthy and warm palette, true to cinematographer Charles Lang's original vision, is faithfully preserved here. Light to medium film grain ensures the image retains its organic cinematic quality, despite occasional softness during optical titles and transitions. This release, even while introducing upgrades in color grading and detail definition, at times reveals discrepancies such as a push towards turquoise in scenes meant to display primary blue, a common issue with modern 4K restorations.
Critically observing the dual presentation of the film in both its 4K and downscaled 1080p Blu-ray formats reveals areas where this restoration excels and others where it slightly falters. The attention to detail is apparent, showcasing Lang's expert interior lighting and the textural nuances of the period-set pieces and landscapes. Shadows are deep and highlights vibrant, significantly benefiting from the high dynamic range rendering. However, comparisons with earlier releases do highlight some inconsistencies, such as a tendency towards crushed blacks in darker scenes, particularly noticeable in the 4K version. Despite these minor issues, the overall improvement in visual quality is undeniable, especially in terms of color accuracy and saturation, not to mention the enhanced depth and clarity that bring a new life to this cinematic gem.
While some may find the color temperature changes and the slight crushing of dark areas a point of contention, it's important to recognize the substantial upgrade this release represents. The film now sports an aesthetic that's closer than ever to what would have been seen in its original theatrical exhibition. Skin tones, fabric textures, and environmental details pop with a newfound crispness, supported by a grain structure that underscores the film's filmic integrity without veering into digital excess. The meticulous remastering provides a fresh perspective on "Gunfight at the O.K. Corral," showcasing its iconic scenes and legendary performances with an enhanced visual fidelity that respects its source material while embracing the advantages of contemporary home theater technology.
Audio: 74
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Gunfight at the O.K. Corral" offers viewers an exceptional auditory experience with two main audio tracks: a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix and a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono mix, both of which deliver clear, clean dialogue and a rich, full-sounding score by Dimitri Tiomkin. The 5.1 mix slightly expands the soundscape, utilizing surround channels for music and ambient sound, providing a more immersive experience without diverting from the film's original essence. On the other hand, the 2.0 track honors the film's original theatrical 'Western Electric' mono audio presentation, ensuring a faithful reproduction that is impressive in its own right.
Both audio tracks demonstrate outstanding clarity with no detectable encoding anomalies or signs of age-related degradation. The clean, stable dialogue across both tracks ensures that viewers will not miss any crucial narrative details. While the 5.1 channel setup offers a broader soundstage that enriches the film's atmospheric elements, the 2.0 track impresses with its faithful rendition of the original sound mix. It effectively maintains all elements of the soundtrack, ensuring that nothing is lost in translation from its cinematic roots.
Viewers will appreciate the versatility offered by these audio options. The inclusion of optional English SDH subtitles further enhances accessibility. Whether opting for the enveloping 5.1 mix to capture the ambiance and depth of the western landscape or choosing the 2.0 mono mix for a more authentic audio vintage, both tracks ensure a gratifying auditory experience. The meticulous preservation and presentation of these audio tracks underpin a commitment to quality and fidelity, ensuring that "Gunfight at the O.K. Corral" can be experienced as intended, with every gunshot and line of dialogue crisply rendered for today's audience.
Extras: 60
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray extra presentation of "Gunfight at the O.K. Corral" notably enhances the viewing experience with its well-curated extras, headed by a detailed and engaging audio commentary from C. Courtney Joyner and film historian Henry Parke. Their discussion not only enriches the narrative by connecting the historical with the cinematic but also delves into the production nuances and discrepancies between the film's storyline and the actual events. This commentary is a treasure trove for both cinephiles and history aficionados alike, offering deep dives into behind-the-scenes aspects and the folklore surrounding the titular event. Furthermore, the inclusion of a vintage trailer and a diverse KLSC trailer gallery adds considerable value, showcasing previews of other classic films, thereby broadening the contextual understanding of this cinema era for the viewer.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: An engaging commentary by C. Courtney Joyner and Henry Parke, offering insights into the film's production and its historical foundation.
- Trailer: The original trailer for "Gunfight at the O.K. Corral".
- KLSC Trailer Gallery: A compilation of trailers for classic films including "The Devil’s Disciple", "Vera Cruz", "The Train", "Valdez is Coming", "The Indian Fighter", "Paths of Glory", "Lonely Are the Brave", "Backlash", "The Great Escape", "The Satan Bug", and "Joe Kidd".
Movie: 75
John Sturges' cinematic rendition of Gunfight at the O.K. Corral has been given a spectacular 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation by Kino Lorber, enhancing both the legend and the spectacle of this 1957 classic. Despite its historical inaccuracies—a common critique highlighted by enthusiasts and scholars—the film stands as a monument to the Hollywood Western's golden era, primarily through its star-powered portrayal of Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday by Burt Lancaster and Kirk Douglas, respectively. Their electrifying on-screen chemistry and performances far overshadow any debate over the film's fidelity to the true events of that fateful day in Tombstone, Arizona.
The film itself, while taking considerable liberties with the actual events and characters involved in the legendary shootout, creates a narrative that is as engaging as it is visually striking. Sturges, alongside director of photography Charles Lang, skillfully utilizes the scenic vistas of Old Tucson and meticulously crafted sets on the Paramount lot to immerse viewers in an appealingly stylized version of the Wild West. These efforts are complemented by strong supporting roles, such as Rhonda Fleming's portrayal of a lady gambler, which enrich the storyline leading up to the climactic gunfight, making for a compelling build-up filled with drama and anticipation.
At its core, Gunfight at the O.K. Corral transcends its historical inaccuracies by virtue of its storytelling and visual grandeur, enhanced by this 4K UHD release. The film's presentation on this format affirms its status as a cinematic spectacle first and foremost, with every frame underscoring Sturges' intent to captivate and entertain. While history buffs might quibble over details, the film's enduring appeal lies in its ability to mythologize its heroes and villains, casting them in the larger-than-life roles that continue to captivate audiences, making it an essential addition to any collection of classic American Westerns.
Total: 72
The 4K UHD Blu-Ray release of "Gunfight at the O.K. Corral" by Kino Lorber Studio Classics has been a subject of much anticipation, given its prominent place in the annals of Western cinematic history. The film itself, starring Burt Lancaster and Kirk Douglas, arguably sets a high watermark for tales of the American West, weaving a narrative that, while not strictly accurate in its historical recounting, presents an engaging portrayal of Good versus Evil through its dramatized retelling of the iconic stand between Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday. This release offers viewers a new 4K restoration of the movie; however, opinions seem to vary regarding its execution. While there is an acknowledgment of the inherent drama embellishments made for cinematic appeal, some viewers may find aspects of the restoration lacking, suggesting potential buyers preview the quality before adding it to their collections.
The technical merits of this release, despite the polarized views on its visual restoration, cannot be denied. It features an impressive 4K Dolby Vision transfer that, for many, dramatically enhances the viewing experience. Accompanied by two formidable audio tracks and a new audio commentary, these elements contribute to a package that fans of classic Westerns will find hard to pass up. The film’s character-driven drama and action sequences benefit immensely from this upgrade, providing a vividness and immediacy that befits its storied legacy.
In conclusion, "Gunfight at the O.K. Corral" in 4K UHD Blu-Ray is a commendable release from Kino Lorber Studio Classics that offers significant upgrades in both audio and visual fidelity. While there may be reservations about the consistency of the restoration's quality, this edition still represents a must-have for aficionados of both the film and the Western genre at large. Its enhanced presentation breathes new life into this legendary cinematic tale, making it a highly recommended addition to any collector's library. This release solidifies the film's place in history, ensuring that both new audiences and seasoned fans can appreciate its allure with renewed clarity and depth.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 70
Also, and this is the biggest issue for me, both presentations of the new 4K makeover push primary blue toward turquoise, which unfortunately happens quite often on 4K restorations/remasters that emerge...
Audio: 70
I thought that it was a solid track, but in several areas I switched to the 5.1 track to compare the action, and it is fair to write that there is a lot to like in both....
Extras: 100
It covers a wide range of topics, from the production of Gunfight at O.K. Corral to some major discrepancies between the famous story that inspired it and its reconstruction of it....
Movie: 70
This makes disappointment with it extremely unlikely because the overwhelming majority of these films, when dealing with popular historical events, are doomed to be inaccurate....
Total: 60
However, I think that to a certain extent this is unavoidable, and if its issues with historical accuracy are ignored, it is a film that becomes quite easy to like....
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 95
The palette is generally warm and earthy, but colors are accurate and well-saturated at all times, with occasional bold splashes in costuming (seen in women’s dresses in particular)....
Audio: 85
The former really only broadens the soundstage a bit and uses the surrounds for music and light ambience, while the latter faithfully reproduces the film’s original theatrical ‘Western Electric’ mono experience....
Extras: 70
...
Movie: 85
Yet before leaving, he helps a scoundrel named Doc Holiday (Kirk Douglas), and his girl Kate Fisher, escape a lynch mob that means to take justice into its own hands....
Total: 84
Interestingly, Sturges would revisit its subject matter a decade later with Hour of the Gun (1967), a film that’s perhaps too faithful to historical events but that features one of actor James Garner’s...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The Dolby Vision grade does wonders for all aspects of this transfer letting those highlights in color, black level, and contrast breathe....
Audio: 80
Listening to the 5.1 mix, it sounded very similar if not the same as what came with the 2014 disc - which isn’t bad at all....
Extras: 20
The pair offer a lot of thoughts and insights into the film while keeping the experience engaging without long pauses or dead air....
Movie: 80
John Sturges’ The Gunfight at the O.K. Corral wasn’t the first to tell the story of Earp’s famous gunfight, but it is possibly the one that cemented the overly romanticized version of events into the cultural...
Total: 80
Light on actual historical facts, the film plays up a romanticized version of events with terrific performances from the key players....
Director: John Sturges
Actors: Burt Lancaster, Kirk Douglas, Rhonda Fleming
PlotIn the late 19th century American West, lawman Wyatt Earp, who is widely respected for his strong sense of justice and bravery, arrives in the town of Fort Griffin, Texas. Earp is on the trail of an outlaw, but his mission takes an unexpected turn when he meets and befriends John "Doc" Holliday, a charismatic gambler and gunslinger suffering from tuberculosis. Despite their stark differences, Earp and Holliday form a close bond, united by a shared code of honor. Earp, determined to clean up the lawless towns of the West, convinces Holliday to join him as he moves on, setting the stage for their legendary partnership.
Their journey leads them to Tombstone, Arizona, a town under the thumb of the violent Clanton gang. Recognizing the threat to peace and justice, Earp decides to take a stand and bring law and order to Tombstone, with Holliday at his side. The escalating conflict between the Earp brothers, Holliday, and the Clantons inexorably leads to the historic showdown at the O.K. Corral. This confrontation, emblematic of the struggle between lawlessness and justice in the wild West, cements the legacies of Earp and Holliday, as well as the myth of the American frontier.
Writers: Leon Uris, George Scullin
Release Date: 30 May 1957
Runtime: 122 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English