Brotherhood of Blades 2 Blu-ray Review
绣春刀II:修罗战场 Xiu chun dao 2: Xiu luo zhan chang
Score: 69
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A visually alluring Chinese period piece with dense plotting, strong technical merits, and engaging action; recommended for fans of intricate narratives.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 84
The 1080p Blu-ray of Brotherhood of Blades II shines with impeccable color grading, intricate detail, and deep blacks, captured via Arri Alexa cameras and presented in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. While occasional banding and minor fine detail loss in darker scenes occur, it remains a near-flawless visual experience.
Audio: 89
"Brotherhood of Blades II" boasts a truly epic DTS:X mix in Mandarin, delivering an aggressive, immersive audio experience with clean dialog, dynamic surrounds, and devastating bass. The high-flying action is given pinpoint precision with extensive use of overheads, creating lifelike ambient sounds and overwhelming sonic presence.
Extra: 11
Featuring insightful behind-the-scenes footage on production design in 1080i and a theatrical trailer in 1080p, this Blu-ray by Well Go USA seamlessly transitions through various supplemental trailers, enhancing viewers' experience with automatic play for a streamlined presentation.
Movie: 66
Brotherhood of Blades II: The Infernal Battlefield stands out with intense martial arts, intricate political intrigue, and stunning production design, despite occasional narrative complexity and melodrama. The prequel's non-stop action and breathless pacing make it a compelling watch, surpassing many contemporaries in the genre.
Video: 84
"Brotherhood of Blades II: The Infernal Battlefield" is presented on Blu-ray with a stunning 1080p AVC encoded transfer in 2.39:1. Digitally captured using Arri Alexa cameras and finished at a 2K DI, the picture quality is impeccable and captivating. The traditional “blue” hue prevalent in Asian cinema is well-managed here, offering a neutral and vibrant palette. Intricate detailing in costumes and environments stands out, with deep inky black levels adding significant depth. The aggressive color grading with blue and sepia tones adds a stylistic flair that enhances the visual narrative without overpowering the viewer.
The transfer showcases remarkable detail, particularly in the intricate brocaded robes and maroon blood spatters during combat scenes. The lake scene with Shen and Bei Zhai is notably impressive, revealing an astonishing level of detail in the water. Moreover, despite some dark scenes showing minor detail deficits, overall fine detailing remains exceptional. Director Lu Yang and cinematographer Han Qiming’s creative framing techniques—with focal characters often placed in deep focus in the background—highlight the film’s visual intricacy. While minor banding issues were noted in some Well Go USA releases, they are rare in this presentation and do not detract from the overall visual excellence.
Overall, "Brotherhood of Blades II: The Infernal Battlefield" offers a stellar video experience on Blu-ray. The immaculate digital capture, combined with expert color grading and high levels of detail, ensures a visually compelling and technically superior viewing experience.
Audio: 89
"Brotherhood of Blades II: The Infernal Battlefield" boasts a truly epic DTS:X audio mix in Mandarin, delivering an aggressive and immersive soundscape. This dynamic mix envelops the listener with relentless sonic intensity that is felt throughout the film. Dialogue remains crystal clear amidst the action, while the surround channels offer impressive levels of immersion, featuring combat sounds and projectiles zooming from all directions. The Wu Xia genre's signature flying martial arts are perfectly captured, with heroes whooshing across the screen with pinpoint accuracy. The mix leverages devastating bass to enhance the viewing experience, shaking the audience to its core during intense sequences.
The overhead channels are utilized extensively, highlighting the film’s high-flying action with impeccable detail. Blades, whirling balls on chains, and crashing rocks emanate vividly from the upper channels, further amplifying the sensory impact. A number of brief yet intense fight scenes showcase seamless effects panning overhead, while outdoor sequences feature lifelike ambient sounds that contribute to an overall immersive experience. The optional DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix in English is competent, offering good surround activity; however, it cannot match the overwhelming presence and enveloping sonics of the DTS:X track. Both dialogue and musical score are finely balanced and given proper priority within this meticulously crafted audio mix.
Extras: 11
The extras section for the Blu-Ray of "Brotherhood of Blades 2" offers a commendable peek behind the curtain of this action-packed period film. The "Behind-the-Scenes Footage" is presented in 1080i and lasts approximately 4 minutes and 44 seconds, providing valuable insights into the film’s production design, which aficionados of the craft will find particularly compelling. Additionally, the disc includes the "Theatrical Trailer" in 1080p at 1 minute and 45 seconds, showcasing the high impact and dramatic elements that define this historical thriller. The disc is authored to transition seamlessly between these supplements, ensuring a smooth viewing experience. Notably, other trailers for Well Go USA releases appear both at boot-up and following the main trailer, although these can be bypassed if desired.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind-the-Scenes Footage: Offers insights into film production design.
- Theatrical Trailer: A high-definition preview of the film's dramatic elements.
Movie: 66
"Brotherhood of Blades II: The Infernal Battlefield" is a standalone prequel to the 2014 film that immerses viewers in a richly detailed historical narrative set in the waning days of the Ming Dynasty. The film opens with an intense prequel scene in 1619, featuring the aftermath of the Battle of Sarhu where Shen Lian (Zhang Zhen) saves several high-ranking officials, leading to an intertwined fate with Lu Wenzhao (Zhang Yi). As the timeline jumps forward eight years, Shen Lian investigates a murder, only to become ensnared in a web of blackmail and political conspiracy that threatens both his career and life. The intricate plot, driven by themes of loyalty and treachery, offers a compelling mix of high-stakes action and political intrigue, woven with masterful choreography and visually stunning set pieces reminiscent of classic Wu Xia stylings.
The film retains the high-flying action and dense political scheming that characterized its predecessor, though it adds deeper layers of complexity. The narrative begins on a strong note, leveraging a mysterious blackmail plot to drive momentum, but approaches melodrama relying on familiar tropes in the latter half. Despite this dip, Zhang Zhen’s portrayal of Shen Lian provides a stabilizing, compelling core to the unfolding chaos. The relationship between Shen Lian and artist Bei Zhai (Yang Mi) introduces a romance element that, while seemingly forced, integrates well into the overarching narrative. The film’s relentless pace, underpinned by continuous action sequences and elaborate fight scenes intended for 3D viewing, keeps the audience engaged despite occasional plot confusions.
Production values are noticeably higher this time around, allowing for even more breathtaking visuals and authentic historical settings. While the labyrinthine storyline may necessitate multiple viewings to fully grasp its complete intrigue, "Brotherhood of Blades II" successfully expands on the original’s foundation with a more intricate plot and visually arresting presentation. It is an immersive film filled with meticulously choreographed martial arts sequences and political subtext, setting up considerable anticipation for the announced third installment.
Total: 69
"Brotherhood of Blades II: The Infernal Battlefield" delivers a captivating blend of political intrigue, high-stakes action, and moral complexity, establishing itself as a noteworthy entry in mainland Chinese cinema. Directed by Yang Lu and starring Chen Chang, Mi Yang, and Yi Zhang, the film excels in maintaining an engaging narrative pace that pulls viewers into its richly layered world. While some may find the political intricacies in the second half slightly overwhelming, the movie more often than not strikes a fine balance between storytelling and visual spectacle. The romantic subplot adds depth to the otherwise tense atmosphere, enhancing the overall viewing experience.
The Blu-ray release under Well Go USA is impressive, particularly in terms of technical quality. The 2.39:1 AVC aspect ratio showcases vibrant visuals, supporting the lush production design that stands out throughout the film. The audio options are equally robust, with Mandarin DTS:X and English DTS-HD MA 5.1 tracks providing a deeply immersive auditory experience. Subtitles are available in English and Mandarin (Simplified and Traditional), catering to a wide audience. Despite the barebones extras, the excellence in audio and video presentation make up for this minor shortcoming.
In conclusion, "Brotherhood of Blades II" is a thrilling journey through historical drama and fast-paced action, marked by exceptional technical execution on Blu-ray. It’s a visual delight that warrants multiple viewings to fully appreciate its complex narrative layers. Highly recommended for fans of Chinese period pieces and those looking for a dynamic cinematic experience.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 100
Every bit of blood, and every fiber on the characters clothing is revealing to the max, and I was literally shocked at how detailed the water was in the lake where Shen and Bei Zhai have their little “encounter”....
Audio: 100
The nature of Wu Xia and the flying martial arts makes for an experience that allows for the heroes to whoosh from one end of the screen to the other with pinpoint precision, as well as DEVASTATING bass...
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 70
I am not trying to be negative, but there is a distinct dip in quality from the first half of the film to the second half, with the second half miring itself with too much double backing and typical Chinese...
Total: 80
A mixture of politic intrigue, action, moral qualms, and lots more action, Brotherhood of Blades II: The Infernal Battlefield is a fun little mainland Chinese film that works way more often than it doesn’t....
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Update: Member qw0aszx has sent along screenshots from the mainland China release of this film, which bears a 2.66:1 aspect ratio, reportedly the OAR for this film....
Audio: 100
There are any number of well done sequences throughout the film that offer not just great placement in the side and rear channels, but which seem to waft various effects panning overhead, especially in...
Extras: 10
After the trailer for this film plays, the disc then automatically moves on to trailers for other Well Go USA releases....
Movie: 70
The Infernal Battlefield has many of the same elements that made its progenitor so satisfying, with an attention to historical detail (helped by what I assume was at least a somewhat larger budget) and...
Total: 70
Anyone who enjoyed the first Brotherhood of Blades is nearly certain to like this prequel as well, since it shares the first film's dense plotting and layers of subterfuge, along with a nice romantic subplot...
Director: Yang Lu
Actors: Chang Chen, Mi Yang, Yi Zhang
PlotIn the late Ming Dynasty, Shen Lian is a loyal captain of the Imperial Guard who finds himself embroiled in a complex conspiracy. Tasked with a secret mission to eliminate a traitorous eunuch, Shen's life takes a dramatic turn when he encounters Bei Zhai, a talented painter accused of being a part of the rebellion. The encounter pits him against powerful foes, dragging him into a web of deception that threatens his integrity and life. As Shen navigates through various obstacles, he struggles to unravel the intricacies of the conspiracy while grappling with his evolving feelings for Bei Zhai.
Shen's isolation deepens as he becomes uncertain whom to trust, and his once clear sense of duty is clouded by conflicting moral choices and hidden agendas. While trying to prove his innocence and unveil the true culprits behind the plot, Shen uncovers darker secrets about those closest to him. In a world laden with betrayal, shifting alliances, and deadly revelations, Shen must rely on his martial prowess and inner resolve. The stakes grow increasingly higher as the line between friend and foe blurs, leading to a series of intense confrontations that test Shen's loyalty and determination.
Writers: Shu Chen, Yang Lu, Yang Yu
Release Date: 01 Dec 2017
Runtime: 120 min
Rating: N/A
Country: China
Language: Mandarin