A Star Is Born Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Bradley Cooper's directorial debut, featuring Lady Gaga, delivers captivating performances and stunning visuals, complemented by a rock-solid Atmos soundtrack—highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 70
"A Star Is Born" on Blu-ray delivers a visually captivating 1080p presentation, with intricate detail in costumes, environments, and character facial features, though some stage performances suffer from slight clarity dips and mild blooming. The color palette is vibrant yet balanced, featuring deep blacks and richly-saturated hues.
Audio: 80
The Dolby Atmos soundtrack of 'A Star Is Born' delivers a dynamic, full-bodied, and immersive audio experience, particularly shining in concert scenes with pronounced low-end support and stage-filling instrumentals. The overhead channels enhance spatial immersion, making for an invigorating listening experience throughout.
Extra: 41
The Blu-ray extras for "A Star Is Born" provide a comprehensive dive into the filmmaking process and musical performances, featuring an in-depth making-of documentary, jam session rehearsals, multiple music videos by Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper, and a compilation of all musical scenes from the film, all presented in 1080p high definition.
Movie: 81
Bradley Cooper’s directorial debut, *A Star Is Born*, shines with its raw and real portrayal of love and stardom, balancing intimate character dynamics with sprawling musical moments, though it leans on narrative clichés. The Blu-ray's presentation by Warner Home Video offers crisp visual and auditory delight.
Video: 70
The Blu-ray release of "A Star Is Born" delivers a visually captivating experience with its 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode, exhibiting high-quality detailing and vibrant colors throughout the film. Even though it’s sourced from a digital shoot, the transfer maintains an impressive balance between sharpness and softness. Razor detailed close-ups, such as Jack’s face showcasing individual pores and beard hairs, enhance the lifelike quality of the characters. The film wisely captures the essence of various environments, from concert venues to home interiors, with inviting clarity and attention to detail. Notable visual elements include Ally’s dramatically colored red/orange hair and high saturation levels preserved within the film’s visual profile. Black levels in well-lit scenes are commendably rich and accurate, adding depth to the visual narrative.
However, some minor issues do arise. Viewers may notice source noise during lower-light shots, particularly in scenes like Jack retreating into a vehicle after a concert. There are also instances where definition and resolution experience slight dips, especially during bright stage performances. These moments sometimes cause contrast and brightness to lose consistency, resulting in mild blooming and flattening of black levels to dark grey tones that suppress finer shadow details. Despite these minor drawbacks, the color palette remains remarkably consistent, favoring warm earth tones, ambers, and cyans that align with the cinematographic vision. The presentation is enhanced by richly saturated primary colors, particularly reds and blues that dominate the stage concert scenes, making "A Star Is Born" on Blu-ray a visually rewarding experience.
Audio: 80
The Dolby Atmos soundtrack of "A Star Is Born" delivers an impressive, immersive audio experience that exudes a rich, full-bodied sonic presence. From the opening concert scene, the audio is thunderous and immersive, with a pronounced low-end support that balances harmoniously with detailed instrumentals and crowd noise. While the overhead channels do not offer discrete elements, they add to an obvious sense of spatial immersion, placing the listener on stage and heightening the film's intimate, on-stage sequences.
Throughout the film, the Atmos presentation consistently distinguishes hard-edged guitar riffs and low-end Pop beats with remarkable clarity and accuracy. Every audio component works in agreeable harmony, never overshadowing dialogue, which remains anchored in a front-center position with seamless spoken word detail. Environmental sounds, such as barroom din and concert reverb, are faithfully recreated, maintaining a healthy listening experience across various settings and scenes. The stellar audio performance of the Blu-ray matches that of its Ultra HD counterpart, ensuring an engrossing experience regardless of format.
Extras: 41
The Blu-ray extras of "A Star Is Born" offer a robust and engaging supplement to the film, providing viewers with a comprehensive behind-the-scenes experience. The primary documentary, "The Road to Stardom: Making A Star Is Born," delves into the intricacies of the film's development, covering authenticity, character beats, performances, and Bradley Cooper's multifaceted role as both actor and director. For music enthusiasts, "Jam Sessions and Rarities" presents raw rehearsal performances, while "Music Videos" and "Musical Moments" compile key musical scenes and official videos from the film. These meticulously curated extras enrich the viewer’s appreciation of the film’s artistry and production.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Road to Stardom: Making A Star Is Born: Thorough behind-the-scenes documentary.
- Jam Sessions and Rarities: Includes musical rehearsals and rare performances.
- Music Videos: Official music videos from the film.
- Musical Moments: Compilation of music scenes from the film.
Movie: 81
Bradley Cooper's directorial debut, "A Star Is Born," reinvents the classic 1954 tale for a modern audience, swapping the old Hollywood backdrop for today's fame-drenched world where success is measured by YouTube views and Grammy awards. The film captures the stark contrast between public acclaim and personal fulfillment through its gritty, raw portrayal of characters who navigate love, fame, and personal demons. Cooper, who also stars as Jack Maine, delivers a nuanced performance alongside Lady Gaga’s Ally, forming the heart of a story that navigates their opposing trajectories—one experiencing an ascendant rise to stardom while the other grapples with decline exacerbated by alcoholism. Despite its reliance on narrative clichés, the film excels in its small-scale intimate moments that secured eight Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture and multiple acting nods.
The film's most captivating elements are the contrasts and juxtapositions it explores. Ally's meteoric rise to fame and Jack's internal turmoil form the crux of a narrative that balances grandiose musical performances with intimate personal struggles. Lady Gaga's portrayal of Ally transitioning from a bar singer to a global sensation is impressively rapid yet feels organic and believable. Jack’s struggle provides a poignant counterpoint, as both characters must confront the harsh realities of their changing lives and redefined identities. Sam Elliott's performance as Jack's half-brother adds further dramatic depth, revealing familial tensions that mirror Jack’s personal battles.
Cinematographer Matthew Libatique uses visual storytelling to great effect, blending large-scale concert scenes with moments of personal vulnerability. The character-driven focus persists even during the film’s most dynamic musical scenes, maintaining an emotional connection between the audience and the protagonists. Cooper demonstrates an adept understanding of seamlessly integrating character development with visual spectacle, offering a promising glimpse into his future directorial endeavors. With a strong narrative spine supported by exceptional performances from Cooper and Gaga, "A Star Is Born" resonates deeply, making it a standout cinematic experience.
Total: 69
"A Star Is Born" marks Bradley Cooper's directorial debut and his ambitious take on the classic tale of stardom and personal turmoil is nothing short of commendable. Cooper and Lady Gaga deliver standout performances, with Gaga in particular showing her range and depth as an actress. Cooper's portrayal of a troubled musician spiraling downward contrasts deeply with Gaga's ascension into stardom, creating a captivating dynamic that resonates emotionally. The film is a masterclass in character intimacy, tackling themes such as identity crises and alcoholism with a nuanced touch.
The Blu-ray release of "A Star Is Born" delivers in both technical excellence and supplemental content. The high-definition video is stunningly clear, showcasing every detailed nuance of the film’s engaging visuals. The Dolby Atmos soundtrack is particularly noteworthy, enhancing the musical elements of the film with breathtaking realism and enveloping audio detail. The overall audio-visual experience brings the story’s heartfelt performances and intricate soundscapes to life brilliantly.
Though the selection of bonus features on the Blu-ray might be considered modest, the inclusion of behind-the-scenes footage and additional content still offers meaningful insights into the film's production. This Blu-ray is an essential pick for movie enthusiasts and music lovers seeking an immersive home viewing experience.
In "A Star Is Born," first-time director Bradley Cooper takes genre clichés and crafts a picture of resplendent character intimacy. His confident direction and compelling performance alongside Lady Gaga’s complex, layered portrayal make this film shine. Warner's Blu-ray release delivers rock-solid video, a terrific Atmos soundtrack, and several extras. Very highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
While the picture does exhibit a good bit of source noise in lower-light shots -- one of the most obvious examples comes minutes into the film when Jack, after a concert, retreats to a vehicle and begins...
Audio: 100
The rest of the track offers nothing above and beyond but does deliver a full, healthy listening experience wether recreating essential barroom din or location environmental sounds, reverb during a pre-concert...
Extras: 50
What You Want Me to Do (Jam Session, 2:22), Midnight Special (Jam Session, 2:41), and Is That Alright by Lady Gaga (1:58), which is presented more in the style of a music video with clips from the film....
Movie: 90
It's brilliant work and Cooper shows great promise behind the camera, here crafting an excellent film that overcomes several narrative obstacles thanks to his sure-handedness and understanding of cinematic...
Total: 80
In A Star Is Born, first-time Director Bradley Cooper takes genre clich� character cornerstones, including identity crises, alcoholism, and the journey from talented nobody into overnight sensation, and...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There are a couple moments when overall definition and resolution dips slightly, mostly related to the stage performances with lots of bright lights, but the presentation nonetheless maintains excellent...
Audio: 80
The film debuts on Blu-ray with the same fantastic and wonderfully engrossing Dolby Atmos soundtrack as its Ultra HD counterpart....
Extras: 40
"Shallow" "Always Remember Us This Way" "Look What I Found" "I'll Never Love Again" Musical Moments (HD)....
Movie: 80
After a couple skippable promos, the screen changes to the usual menu with options along the bottom of the screen, full-motion clips and music playing in the background....
Total: 80
Demonstrating the plot is a timeless tale that can be retold for every generation, this fourth remake charms audiences with excellent performances, catchy tunes and some highly talented filmmaking....
Director: Bradley Cooper
Actors: Lady Gaga, Bradley Cooper, Sam Elliott
PlotJackson Maine, a seasoned but troubled country music singer and alcoholic, meets Ally, a talented but struggling singer-songwriter working odd jobs to make ends meet while performing at a drag bar. After witnessing her perform, Jackson is captivated by her talent and they quickly form a personal connection. Ally shares her frustrations about the music industry and her dreams of performing, while Jackson struggles with his inner demons and fading career.
Encouraged by Jackson, Ally joins him on stage at one of his concerts, performing a song she composed, which becomes a pivotal moment in her career. Her performance captivates the audience and draws the attention of music industry professionals. The two artists begin a whirlwind romantic relationship, as Ally's career starts to take off, securing her own record deal and gaining popularity. Meanwhile, Jackson's ongoing battles with addiction and hearing loss threaten to overshadow their happiness and success.
Writers: Eric Roth, Bradley Cooper, Will Fetters
Release Date: 05 Oct 2018
Runtime: 136 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, French