Charlie Zone Blu-ray Review
Score: 32
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Charlie Zone features solid direction and performances but suffers from an unbalanced experience with convoluted plot, basic audio, noticeable artifacts, and no extras.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 41
Charlie Zone's 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer in 1.78:1 aspect ratio offers inconsistent detail, with daytime scenes appearing clean but nighttime sequences plagued by noise and occasional artifacts, affecting overall image quality. Colors are adequate, albeit underwhelming, and black levels often show unevenness.
Audio: 38
Charlie Zone's Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack offers clean and clear dialogue with respectable imaging but lacks dynamic range and bass. Action and ambient effects are restrained, and overall sound design fails to fully engage or realize its potential, highlighting the film's low-budget roots.
Extra: 0
Charlie Zone Blu-ray offers no bonus content or special features, with only trailers for Pawn and Chained preceding the main menu.
Movie: 43
While 'Charlie Zone' offers a gritty, low-budget Canadian thriller with a convoluted plot and underwhelming twist, it is hindered by amateur production values, inconsistent character motivations, and unimpressive A/V quality, making it a difficult recommendation despite solid performances by Glen Gould and Amanda Crew.
Video: 41
The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer of "Charlie Zone" presents a high definition experience that, while effective, often exhibits a flat visual quality with limited detail revelation. The presentation mostly maintains clarity and definition but falls short of delivering razor-sharp and purely lifelike visuals. The palette, featuring dull blues, purples, grays, and yellows, aligns adequately with the film's atmosphere, yet colors can appear undersaturated. Flesh tones tend to capture a bit of warmth, giving a natural touch to the character depictions in some scenes.
Daytime scenes benefit from a clean digital source, displaying good sharpness and pleasant fine details. However, nighttime sequences suffer from problematic noise spikes and minor banding. Black levels are particularly inconsistent, occasionally leaning towards purple with an excess of noise. Anomalously, some scenes exhibit irregularities where one part of the screen is inky black while the other is lighter with a blue tinge. This uneven lighting detracts from the movie's visual coherence. Despite some positive moments, the sporadic artifacts ultimately hinder the overall presentation from reaching high standards.
While "Charlie Zone" does manage to deliver a few impressive visuals, the transfer is hampered by distracting quirks and inconsistent performance. White levels are adequately balanced, but the softened and sometimes smeary look in low light conditions can disappoint viewers seeking a more pristine viewing experience. This presentation reflects the film’s modest production value, which unfortunately results in a hit-and-miss viewing experience that may not wholly satisfy high-definition enthusiasts.
Audio: 38
The Blu-ray of "Charlie Zone" features a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack, standing at a midlevel. This presentation is somewhat reserved, lacking in pronounced dynamics and pure aggression. The initial scenes set a restrained tone, only gaining marginal intensity as the film progresses. Heavy action effects and ambient elements fall short of their potential, offering basic, unremarkable delivery whether it be gunshots or environmental soundscapes. Despite this, dialogue remains consistently clear with quality delivery and precise front-center placement.
The mix exhibits a front-loaded sound design, with occasional use of side speakers for ambiance and music cues. Imaging is commendable across the front soundstage, though limited in its outreach. The soundtrack reveals the film's budget constraints, delivering a respectable but not immersive experience. Directional sound effects such as punches, kicks, motorcycles, and gunshots contribute to a restrained sense of excitement, indicating situational isolation when appropriate (e.g. door knocks). However, the mix suffers from subdued bass activity and noticeable dynamic range limitations. Distortions are absent, but the overall engagement remains low.
One notable issue is an unbalanced dialogue track, where speech in the center channel is often too low in comparison to other elements of the mix. This imbalance necessitates leaning in to catch spoken words, which can detract from the viewing experience. Foley effects can occasionally seem overdone but generally stay within tolerable limits. Additionally, the spatial atmosphere is constrained by scenes set in enclosed spaces, limiting opportunities for surround sound utilization. Overall, while the audio mix on "Charlie Zone" is decent, it does highlight areas needing improvement to achieve a more vibrant and engaging soundscape.
Extras:
The Blu-ray release of "Charlie Zone" unfortunately lacks dedicated bonus content, detracting from the overall value that extras typically provide. Trailers for other films, such as "Pawn" and "Chained," are presented before the main menu, but no additional special features accompany the main film. This bare-bones approach might disappoint fans who look forward to supplementary materials for deeper engagement and behind-the-scenes insights.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailers: Promotional trailers for "Pawn" and "Chained" before the main menu.
Movie: 43
"Charlie Zone" immerses viewers in a gritty, low-budget Canadian landscape where complexity and chaos reign supreme. Glen Gould stars as Avery Paul, an ex-boxer reduced to fighting in underground circuits and now hired to rescue a runaway junkie named Jan, portrayed by Amanda Crew. The film attempts to delve deep into Avery's reluctant anti-hero persona but falls short of thorough character development, rendering him a mere trope. While initial scenes promise a straightforward rescue mission, the plot takes numerous, often bewildering twists, throwing Avery into unpredictable scenarios. The chemistry between Gould and Crew tries to anchor the film, but the forced dialogue and inconsistent character motivations undermine their efforts.
Visually, the production feels like a relic of 90s television, marred by generic aesthetics, occasional slow-motion effects, and clunky action sequences. While Gould portrays a tough exterior with sporadic moments of Jack Bauer-like intensity, his character doesn't evolve beyond cliché. Supporting roles are underwhelming, with many characters fading into indistinct villains or unconvincing plot devices. The narrative is further bogged down by subplots that add little value and contribute to an overall sense of disjointed storytelling.
Despite its low production values and unfulfilled potential, "Charlie Zone" contains brief flashes of intrigue and suspense. The third act introduces a significant twist regarding Jan's importance, injecting an unsettling yet ultimately anticlimactic turn into the story. The film's ambition to present a nuanced thriller is overshadowed by its convoluted script and broad direction, making it difficult for viewers to become fully invested in the characters' fates. In summary, "Charlie Zone" offers a Canadian take on familiar thriller tropes but struggles to rise above mediocrity due to its flawed execution and uneven pacing.
Total: 32
"Charlie Zone" is a mixed bag featuring both compelling and lackluster elements. The film, helmed by Michael Melski, attempts to blend action-thriller dynamics with deeper emotional undertones, but struggles with coherence and pacing. Glen Gould delivers a standout performance alongside Amanda Crew, who together exhibit notable chemistry. However, the script is often convoluted and tries too hard to impress with needless twists that only serve to confuse rather than engage. The modest production values lend the film a small-screen feel that detracts from its overall impact.
The technical presentation on Anchor Bay's Blu-ray release warrants a similarly mixed review. The video quality is decent in parts but is marred by noticeable artifacts, reducing the overall viewing experience to a merely satisfactory level. The audio is straightforward and functional, yet lacks the depth and complexity expected from a high-definition format. Compounding these issues is the complete absence of supplementary materials—a significant shortcoming for collectors and film enthusiasts who appreciate behind-the-scenes content or additional context.
In conclusion, "Charlie Zone" is a surprising little movie. It's straightforward, often bleak, and it effortlessly pulls its audience into the mayhem. It enjoys solid and no-frills yet, at the same time, textured and nuanced direction from Michael Melski (Growing Op). Also helping the movie achieve success is an excellent performance from Glen Gould and a strong budding chemistry with co-star Amanda Crew. Anchor Bay's featureless Blu-ray contains decent video and mediocre audio. For those interested in a gritty Canadian thriller, it's worth a rental but warrants caution for its uneven story and lack of special features. Rent it.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 60
Black levels occasionally push towards a purple streak while dealing with what is sometimes an excess of unsightly noise....
Audio: 50
Both heavy action-oriented effects and ambient elements both fail to deliver beyond the basics; whether pop cap-like gunshots or simple environmental atmospherics, nothing is really fully realized to its...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 70
It's firmly grounded in an uncanny and discomforting sense of authenticity, bringing audiences closer than they would ever want to be to one of the most externally unassuming but at the same time one of...
Total: 50
Also helping the movie achieve success is an excellent performance from Glen Gould and a strong budding chemistry with co-star Amanda Crew....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Production value is on the cheap, amateur side, but the image has sharp clarity with pleasing fine details and a solid sense of dimension....
Audio: 60
Effects work isn't exactly standout, but various punches, kicks, revving motorcycles, and gunshots add a restrained sense of excitement, and sounds are isolated directionally when appropriate (a door knock...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
He takes a beating and keeps on ticking like the best of his breed, and even manages to escape from a hairy torture scenario in a very '24'-esque fashion, but there's little about Avery that actually stands...
Total: 40
The script tries to blend action/thriller sensibilities with abuse melodrama, but the results are very forced and the modest production values give the whole affair a very small screen feel....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 50
There are times when the 1:78:1 frame is full of great detail, but the next moment is a very soft smeary looking night sequence....
Audio: 50
There’s not a whole lot of room to focus on in the surround as a lot of scenes take place in small enclosed rooms....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 30
There are side characters, but once they are not key to the plot, the movie still kind of follows them, but we don’t really care anymore....
Total: 30
I’ll give it credit for being a film shot in Canada and not trying to hide the fact it’s in Canada....
Director: Michael Melski
Actors: Glen Gould, Zach Tovey, Cindy Sampson
PlotA disgraced ex-cop, Avery Paul, is hired to rescue a runaway named Jan from a notorious drug den. Plunging into a treacherous underworld, Avery navigates a maze of criminal elements and deceit to locate her. As he delves deeper, Avery discovers that Jan is not just another lost soul but has become embroiled in an intricate web of violence, addiction, and betrayal. Each step closer to her reveals more about the depths of the criminal underworld and the personal demons Avery must confront. Jan's captors are ruthless and will go to any lengths to hold onto their latest pawn, posing constant dangers to Avery's mission.
As secrets unravel and confrontations escalate, the lines between ally and adversary blur, complicating Avery’s efforts. He grapples with his fractured past while trying to steer Jan towards redemption. The rescue mission transforms into a fight for survival where trust is scarce, and every decision has life-or-death consequences. Avery’s journey becomes a testament to resilience, highlighting the grim realities of addiction and the struggles for personal and moral redemption. What started as a simple retrieval mission morphs into a profound odyssey of courage and sacrifice.
Writers: Joseph LeClair, Michael Melski
Release Date: 16 Sep 2011
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: R
Country: Canada
Language: English, French