The Vow Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Vow offers engaging performances and a compelling love story despite some narrative flaws, with solid video and audio quality on Blu-ray; recommended for genre fans.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0747b/0747ba49e8f2104eed1079ff74ff61ad016aa10f" alt="The Vow Blu-ray Front Cover"
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
The Vow's 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer delivers handsome, film-like texturing with light grain, excellent color balance, and sharp, detailed imagery, albeit slightly soft at times; minor flaws include edge enhancement in a few scenes and strong blacks, preserving a crisp and natural viewing experience.
Audio: 58
The Vow's DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack excels in delivering dialogue clarity and smooth music integration, though it often feels flat due to front-channel dominance and lack of dynamic surround mixing. Effects and bass impress, but overall audio performance could have been more engaging and immersive.
Extra: 41
The Blu-ray extras of 'The Vow' include insightful yet routine commentary by Director Michael Sucsy, a set of underwhelming deleted scenes, an entertaining gag reel, and several featurettes exploring the film's themes, casting, real-life inspirations, and the medical perspective on amnesia.
Movie: 51
The Vow, a sentimental tale with an engaging premise of rediscovering lost love through amnesia, delivers mixed results; while Channing Tatum and Rachel McAdams share commendable chemistry and deliver heartfelt performances, the film suffers from a meandering plot and pretentious characterizations, ultimately failing to fully exploit its emotional potential.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2b2cc/2b2cc9080010215c816d97adcf7cb0c140e39aa9" alt="Loading"
Video: 68
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Vow" is showcased in a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 format, presented with a 2.40:1 aspect ratio, maintaining Sony's reputation for high-quality output. The transfer excels in delivering a handsome, film-like texture, with a light grain that accentuates details and provides a balanced color spectrum. The image is consistently crisp and well-defined, presenting fine details that are striking, whether it's the intricate facial pores, fine body hairs, or the smallest shards of slow-motion windshield glass. This meticulous approach ensures that various elements, such as the brick walls of Paige's art studio and the trinkets around Leo's home, appear sharp and naturally resolved.
Color reproduction is naturally saturated and lifelike, with an excellent color balance that leans towards clear and neutral flesh tones. While the blacks are generally strong, they can occasionally appear overpowering, suggesting a slight imbalance that could have been fine-tuned for better depth. One noted flaw is the sporadic use of edge enhancement, which can render certain close-up shots uncomfortably sharp and offsetting, though this occurs only in a handful of scenes.
Moreover, the transfer is commendably free of compression artifacts such as banding or blocking, and there is no application of DNR, ensuring the preservation of natural film grain without introducing any noise. The overall image cleanliness and sharpness are exceptional, with no visible wear and tear throughout the viewing experience. Despite minor setbacks like occasional softness and slight aliasing, "The Vow" stands out as a strong contender in Sony's Blu-ray release collection.
Audio: 58
"The Vow" presents its DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack with commendable professionalism, even in its dialogue-driven format. Dialogue remains clear and precise, effortlessly delivered through the center speaker. The music, ranging from soft and romantic to energetic dance beats, benefits from a well-defined bass and evident surround support, enriching the cinematic experience. Ambient sounds, like the lively hum of a wedding or the passing traffic, add a natural touch without overwhelming the primary audio. While not particularly groundbreaking, the soundtrack excels in clarity, smoothness, and overall effectiveness.
However, there are nuances in the audio presentation that suggest opportunities for improvement. Although effects like car doors slamming in frigid air are impressively realistic, their consistency in mixing is less than ideal. The soundscape often prioritizes the front channels, leading to an underutilization of surround and rear channels. Establishing scenes depict immersive imaging, yet this dimensionality frequently dissipates in main scenes. The soundtrack’s music, while featuring strong bass use, similarly favors the front channels and lacks dynamic deployment across the entire setup.
Overall, "The Vow" employs its 5.1 DTS-HD MA track with a mix of solid execution and potential missed opportunities for aural depth. Textures of dialogue, ambient noise, and musical scoring play competently within their bounds but seldom push beyond to fully leverage the multi-channel capabilities. This results in an audio experience that is serviceable rather than spectacular, consistently clear but seldom sonically adventurous.
Extras: 41
"The Vow" Blu-ray offers a range of engaging extras that enhance the viewing experience. The audio commentary by Director Michael Sucsy delivers an in-depth exploration of the true story's adaptation into a largely fictional film, alongside insights into shooting schedules, cast performances, and thematic elements—though it may not be the most captivating commentary. The deleted scenes, while minimal in value, provide additional context through brief yet inherently forgettable moments. The gag reel, however, stands out with its collection of humorous flubs showcasing Rachel McAdams' candid on-set moments. Featurettes delve into various aspects, from dynamics concerning the real-life inspiration to medical perspectives on amnesia, offering both entertainment and educational insights.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Director Michael Sucsy discusses the film's inspiration and production details.
- Deleted Scenes: A few additional scenes featuring interactions and character insights.
- 'Til Death Do They Part: Insights into plot dynamics, real-life inspirations, and production aspects.
- Profiles of Love: Paige and Leo: Detailed look at the lead actors and characters.
- Trying to Remember: Discussion on the themes and medical perspectives on amnesia.
- Gag Reel: Humorous behind-the-scenes moments.
- Previews: Additional Sony titles.
Movie: 51
"The Vow" tackles an intriguing narrative premise of true love tested by profound memory loss, exploring the tenacity and patience required to rebuild shattered bonds. Channing Tatum portrays Leo, a devoted husband to Paige, played by Rachel McAdams, who loses her memory following a tragic car accident. The film effectively poses existential questions about the nature of love, soulmates, and whether love can transcend physical and mental barriers. Initially robust with emotionally charged drama and intense chemistry between the leads, the movie challenges audiences to ponder if love is predestined or subject to the whims of chance. Both actors excel in their roles, with notable performances even as they navigate a rather formulaic plot.
Despite its promising setup, "The Vow" occasionally suffers from narrative misdirection and pacing issues. The screenplay complicates rather than enriches the story with unnecessary subplots concerning Paige's family, diverting attention from the core romantic struggle. Voice-over narration used sporadically feels more like a narrative crutch than a meaningful addition, keeping viewers in partial suspense about key revelations known to other characters. Some argued that the depiction of Paige's character shift—particularly her regression to a past, unlikable persona—dilutes audience empathy and stretches credibility.
"The Vow" blends massively satisfying emotional beats with occasional hiccups in storytelling. Its portrayal of modern hipster culture—replete with pretentious undertones, non-traditional art scenes, and contrived lifestyle choices—may alienate some viewers but serves as a backdrop for exploring deeper philosophical themes. Admirably acted by Tatum and McAdams, the film thrives in parts despite its flaws, offering dynamic sentiment and solid performances amidst an uneven yet captivating narrative exploration of love’s endurance.
Total: 57
"The Vow" Blu-ray release by Sony offers a mixed yet compelling cinema experience for viewers with varying tastes. The film's narrative, rooted in a true story, follows the turbulent relationship between a couple dealing with amnesia-induced emotional turmoil. While the middle portion of the film struggles with pacing and coherence, this thematic detachment mirrors the characters' inner chaos. Rachel McAdams and Channing Tatum deliver commendable performances within a plot that intertwines elements of drama and romance, creating an engrossing, albeit emotionally challenging, saga.
The film's technical execution on Blu-ray deserves recognition. The video quality showcases sharp, vibrant visuals that enhance the storytelling, although some viewers might find room for slight improvement. Sony’s audio production is equally robust, offering a clear auditory experience that complements the film's emotional scenes. The Blu-ray package includes a range of special features, though they tend to rehash interviews and insights rather than providing fresh content, which may be underwhelming for those seeking in-depth extras.
In conclusion, "The Vow" presents a heartfelt story that struggles at times but ultimately captivates through its emotional depth and sincere performances. The Blu-ray release upholds Sony’s reputation for quality video and audio production, despite some repetitive supplements. While it might not resonate with everyone, especially those less inclined towards romance dramas, it remains an honest and engaging film that's worth watching. Recommended for fans of the genre who appreciate a well-acted, emotionally driven tale.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Details are strong-to-striking, with faces complex, clothing tactile, and everything around the frame -- including the trinkets around Leo's home and the brick walls of Paige's art studio -- appearing...
Audio: 90
This one's not exactly memorable, but it gets the job done and completes all that's required of it with great clarity, smoothness, professionalism, and ease....
Extras: 50
Til Death Do They Part (1080p, 8:15): Cast and crew discuss the dynamics of the plot, the real-life events that inspired the film, the work of Director Michael Sucsy, casting the lead roles, and set design....
Movie: 70
The movie challenges audiences to define "true love," to question whether it can, should, or will extend beyond the mind and body, if it truly exists deep within the very essence and housed inside the...
Total: 70
The Vow struggles to keep it momentum going in a crowded middle stretch, but that sense of detachment, confusion, and jumbled ideas and actions is thematically appropriate for the experience....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Of the possible compression issues, a couple of minor instances of aliasing are the only noticeable flaws....
Audio: 60
While the integrity of great-sounding music is supposed to be a pert of our characters' lives, the music also falls victim to a lack of dynamics by coming mostly from the front channels, occasionally from...
Extras: 40
Gag Reel (SD, 3 min.) - Filled with flubbed takes, physical goofs, prop troubles, chocolate and - yes - farting, the most surprising thing about this gag reel is what it reveals about Rachel McAdams: one,...
Movie: 40
When you learn that 'The Vow' is "inspired by real events, you're going to call me a heartless punk, but know that 'The Vow' is so loosely based on the real events that the real-life couple is only named...
Total: 60
Both have stories with great potential, but both take them down the most contrived and unsatisfying roads....
Director: Michael Sucsy
Actors: Rachel McAdams, Channing Tatum, Sam Neill
PlotA newlywed couple, Paige and Leo, are deeply in love and enjoy a happy life together in Chicago. One snowy evening, they are involved in a severe car accident. While Leo escapes with minor injuries, Paige suffers significant head trauma and loses her memories of the past few years, including the entirety of her relationship with Leo. Struggling to recall her marriage and with no recollection of falling in love with him, Paige reverts mentally to the time before they met, when she was still engaged to another man and living a completely different life.
As Paige grapples with her memory loss, Leo is determined to help her rediscover the love they once shared. He navigates the challenges of reacquainting Paige with their life together, hoping to reignite their bond. Meanwhile, Paige's estranged parents seize the opportunity to reinsert themselves into her life, pushing her toward the path she had originally chosen before meeting Leo. Torn between the familiar world of her past and the unfamiliar relationship she has with Leo, Paige must navigate her feelings and choices to rediscover who she truly is.
Writers: Abby Kohn, Marc Silverstein, Jason Katims
Release Date: 10 Feb 2012
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Australia, France, Canada, Germany, Brazil, United Kingdom, China
Language: English