Top Five Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Top Five merges humor and depth with Chris Rock's standout performance, presenting a top-notch Blu-ray package with excellent video, audio, and engaging extras. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
`Top Five' on Blu-ray delivers a near-reference 1080p AVC MPEG-4 transfer with a clean, detailed, and robust image. Colors are natural and saturated, with deep blacks and excellent depth. Despite minor noise and occasional softness, the disc avoids major artifacts and maintains impressive clarity and contrast.
Audio: 73
The Blu-ray of Top Five delivers an engaging DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack; while front-loaded at times, it effectively uses ambient city and club sounds, boasts clear dialogue, strong directional imaging, and robust low frequencies in dynamic scenes, ensuring an immersive listening experience.
Extra: 47
The Blu-ray extras of *Top Five* offer a comprehensive and engaging collection, including an insightful and humor-infused commentary by Chris Rock and JB Smoove, an array of behind-the-scenes featurettes, and highly entertaining deleted scenes, all presented in 1080p with Dolby Digital 2.0 sound.
Movie: 73
Chris Rock’s 'Top Five' adeptly merges humor and heartfelt exploration, overcoming an initially scattered narrative to offer a gratifying character study. With strong direction and performances, including standout work from Rosario Dawson, and bolstered by witty dialogue, the film ultimately delivers a deeply satisfying viewing experience.
Video: 73
"Top Five" makes a striking appearance on Blu-ray with a 1080p transfer that excels in both clarity and detail, achieving a near-reference quality throughout. The 2.35:1 aspect ratio presentation benefits from the AVC/MPEG-4 encoding, which ensures the image remains free of major artifacts like banding and blocking. The digital photography captures the nuances of urban settings with lifelike precision, especially in bright daytime sequences where the cityscape reveals intricate details including textures and hues. Darker scenes, such as those set in nightclubs or outdoor nighttime locations, maintain exceptional clarity without succumbing to noise or loss of detail. Black levels are deep and well-controlled, with no detectable crushing or compression artifacts, contributing to a solid and engaging visual experience.
Color reproduction is exceptional, adhering to a natural palette that brings vibrancy without exaggeration. In more dynamic interior scenes, like those in bars or clubs, the colors shift toward a neon glow which remains free from banding and pixelation issues. Flesh tones are rendered faithfully, portraying lifelike and tactile skin textures. While some shots exhibit a mild diffusion that slightly softens details and adds a bit of bloom to white areas, this effect appears intentional and complements the film’s aesthetic.
Despite minor, fleeting moments of shimmering, the overall image maintains high clarity and visual depth. The transfer avoids common pitfalls seen in digitally shot releases, providing a strong, robust picture with impressive contrast and sharpness levels. "Top Five" on Blu-ray delivers on nearly all fronts, proving to be a commendable addition to Paramount’s portfolio.
Audio: 73
The Blu-ray presentation of "Top Five" boasts a highly dynamic DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack that immerses the listener in its rich and vibrant auditory landscape. The audio effectively captures the bustling cityscape of New York, with nuanced ambient sounds that rotate naturally around the soundstage. The dialogue, crucial for this dialogue-heavy film, is consistently clear and well-prioritized, emanating cleanly from the center channel without any distortion.
The mix provides a robust sense of spatiality by leveraging both front and surround speakers for directional effects and natural imaging. Ambient noise, from chirping backgrounds to nightclub cacophonies, enlivens scenes with an appropriate sense of atmosphere. Although some club scenes initially feel a bit restrained in bass performance, sequences like the Bachelor Party deliver aggressive low frequencies and deep, satisfying bass tones. Music tracks benefit from strong fidelity and good stage placement, contributing to the overall immersive experience.
With additional audio options including Spanish, French, and Portuguese Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks alongside subtitles in several languages, "Top Five" ensures accessibility for an international audience. The overall range of audio elements—dialogue clarity, musical richness, and ambient detail—makes for a well-rounded and engaging presentation that complements the film’s witty dialogue and atmospheric settings. This meticulous sound design assures that while the soundscape might occasionally feel reserved, it never fails to keep audiences engaged.
Extras: 47
The Blu-ray release of "Top Five" boasts an impressive array of extras, all presented in 1080p with Dolby Digital 2.0 sound. The Audio Commentary by Chris Rock and JB Smoove provides a mix of serious insights and humor, touching on plot details, editing, improvisation, and various production aspects, while also highlighting the contributions of the cast and crew. It's Never Just a Movie: Chris Rock and Top Five offers an in-depth look at the film's realism, Rock's roots in standup, career path, story themes, cast assembly, and the integration of New York into the plot. The Making of Top Five featurette delves into Rock's directing style, casting process, and tone of the film with behind-the-scenes footage and interviews. Fans will appreciate the Top Five Andre Allen Standup Outtakes and Top Five Moments You Didn't See in the Film, which add more humor and character depth. Additionally, Deleted Scenes provide more content that enriches the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: A mix of insights and humor from Chris Rock and JB Smoove.
- It's Never Just a Movie: Chris Rock and Top Five: Analysis of the film's realism, Rock's career, story themes.
- The Making of Top Five: Behind-the-scenes footage and interviews about directing, casting, and tone.
- Top Five Andre Allen Standup Outtakes: Additional funny standup routines by Chris Rock's character.
- Top Five Moments You Didn't See in the Film: Cut lines, jokes, and extra footage.
- Deleted Scenes: More scenes including Andre Raps, First Day Your Movie Comes Out, and These Shoes.
Movie: 73
"Top Five," directed, written, and starring Chris Rock, presents a refreshingly deep character exploration while balancing humor and heartfelt moments. Rock portrays Andre Allen, a once-celebrated comedian grappling with the aftermath of personal and professional failures. The film artfully juxtaposes Allen's past glory with his current struggle to transition to serious drama—highlighted by his somber film “Uprize,” which receives lackluster enthusiasm. Much of the movie follows Allen's candid dialogue with Chelsea Brown (Rosario Dawson), delving into his experiences with fame, addiction, and the essence of true personal success.
While the narrative initially appears disjointed and aimless, it eventually coalesces into a profound examination of celebrity life and personal redemption. Rock's multifaceted portrayal of Allen—bolstered by Dawson’s compelling performance—evolves throughout, rendering the character both accessible and deeply textured. The script is rich with humor and keen observations, addressing serious themes like race and addiction without veering into melodrama or cliché. Notably, the film's tonal shifts from comedy to drama are handled adeptly, enhancing its relatability and emotional impact.
Rock's personal touch pervades the film, blending sharp wit with raunchy yet memorable moments, ensuring "Top Five" is not merely entertaining but also thought-provoking. Supporting performances from Gabrielle Union, Cedric the Entertainer, and cameos from stars like Whoopi Goldberg and Jerry Seinfeld enrich the viewing experience. Overall, "Top Five" stands as one of Rock's finest cinematic achievements, adeptly merging humor with heartfelt storytelling, revealing his prowess both in front of and behind the camera.
Total: 68
"Top Five" stands out as an engaging and genuinely funny film that showcases Chris Rock's comedic talent and storytelling ability. The movie expertly balances humor with heartfelt and dramatic moments, creating a nuanced and layered narrative enriched with underlying satire. Rock's performance in the lead role is complex and compelling, further elevated by his efficient direction. The free-form approach can be likened to the French New Wave, offering a refreshing take on modern comedy.
Paramount's Blu-ray release is exceptional, presenting a high-end technical experience. The video quality is crisp and vibrant, capturing the film's dynamic visual style with clarity. The audio is equally impressive, delivering a robust and balanced sound that enhances both the comedic and dramatic elements of the movie. The supplementary content is substantial, featuring behind-the-scenes featurettes and deleted material that offer valuable insights into the film's production process.
In conclusion, "Top Five" takes its time to find its footing, but once it does, it proves to be a rewarding journey. The strong video and audio presentation, coupled with a solid collection of extras, make this Blu-ray release highly recommended for fans of Chris Rock and comedy enthusiasts alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The digital photography largely leaves behind the sense of flatness and glossiness that accompanies the lesser images and instead features a tight, detailed, somewhat deep, and fully complex image that...
Audio: 90
The track springs to life with a healthy and vibrant cityscape atmosphere that doesn't simply place sound in the listening area but envelops the listener in even the smallest little bits that transport...
Extras: 50
It's Never Just a Movie: Chris Rock and Top Five (1080p, 20:08): Cast and crew and Chris Rock himself look at the hints of realism in the movie, Rock's roots in standup (with clips of his early career...
Movie: 70
Still, his portrayal of a complex character proves accessible and smart, even if, again, it takes the entire movie, and arguably a second watch, to truly appreciate all of the details....
Total: 70
Some may find it might work better, and play somewhat differently, a second time through with the greater context in mind....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Clarity is good throughout, but detail can be on the soft side during certain sequences which use a noticeably diffuse lighting style that can blur the image just a tad....
Audio: 80
The soundscape is a little restrained, but general city and club ambiance helps to liven specific scenes with an appropriate sense of atmosphere....
Extras: 40
Commentary by Chris Rock and JB Smoove – Rock and Smoove offer a fairly informative and entertaining track, touching upon the plot, editing, improvisation, locations, and other bits of production trivia....
Movie: 80
Funny, endearing, and wonderfully entertaining, this is a really good movie through and through, finally successfully translating the comedian's unique voice to the big screen....
Total: 60
Heartfelt, hilarious, dramatic, and edgy at the same time, this is one of 2014's best comedies....
Why So Blu? review by Gerard IribeRead review here
Video: 90
There’s a natural color palette throughout the film unless we’re inside a bar or club and then it goes into neon overdrive but the color wheel remains nice and steady absent of banding and pixilation....
Audio: 90
Dialogue Reproduction: Top Five is primarily a dialogue driven film and the center channel reproduces the dialogues faithfully and without any hints of distortion or hiss....
Extras: 60
Top Five on Blu-ray has a nice and hearty array of special features that include and audio commentary with Chris Rock and JB Smoove – it’s a serious/funny blend, as they talk about the filming and what...
Movie: 80
Total: 80
Top Five could have been a throwaway of film focusing on Rock’s stand-up comedic talents but as funny as the film is it doesn’t squander the opportunity to tell a good story, with some underlying satire...
Director: Chris Rock
Actors: Chris Rock, Rosario Dawson, Gabrielle Union
PlotAndre Allen, a successful comedian who has transitioned into serious acting, is struggling to be taken seriously in his new career path. He’s preparing for the release of his new film, which is a drastic departure from his previous work, while also dealing with personal issues, including an impending and highly publicized wedding to reality TV star Erica Long. As he navigates the promotion of his film, Andre is increasingly disillusioned with the superficiality of fame and his own artistic choices.
During a critical day leading up to the premiere, he agrees to an in-depth interview with Chelsea Brown, a talented and insightful journalist. Throughout their day together, they explore various parts of Andre’s life—his past struggles with addiction, his comedic influences, and his insecurities regarding his current career trajectory. Chelsea’s probing questions force Andre to confront his true desires and the fear that he's lost touch with what makes him happy. This introspective journey ultimately serves as a catalyst for Andre, leading him to reassess both his professional and personal life.
Writers: Chris Rock
Release Date: 12 Dec 2014
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English