Baggage Claim Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The lively cast can't overcome 'Baggage Claim's' routine plot and forgettable romance, despite a decent Blu-ray package for curious viewers.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
"Baggage Claim" on Blu-ray offers a high definition 1080p AVC presentation with exceptional clarity and fine detail, though some scenes reveal cheap greenscreens and stock footage. The vibrant color reproduction, balanced black levels, and rich, lifelike textures contribute to an overall sharp, aesthetically pleasing viewing experience.
Audio: 66
Baggage Claim's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix, while lacking low-end punch, manages to offer a decently immersive experience with clean dialogue reproduction and effective ambient environmental effects, supported by R&B music selections, albeit with minimal surround sound impact.
Extra: 43
Extras include deleted scenes with optional commentary, a brief 'Behind the Scenes' segment, various promotional featurettes like 'Fly Girls' and 'Wing Men,' and an audio commentary by David E. Talbert. While the package is robust, the content mainly serves dedicated fans rather than a broader audience.
Movie: 30
"Baggage Claim" attempts to soar with a star-studded cast led by Paula Patton, but ultimately lands predictably, offering a cliché-driven and rote romantic comedy with minimal surprises, yet engages through its well-executed comedic encounters and glossy portrayal of upscale African American life.
Video: 70
The Blu-ray presentation of Baggage Claim boasts an exceptional video quality, presenting a visually satisfying experience. The AVC 1080p transfer with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio delivers razor-sharp detail and exquisite definition, particularly in close-ups where even the subtlest facial features are revealed with precision. The film, shot with the Arri Alexa, captures textures with lifelike accuracy and offers an engaging three-dimensional perspective. While there are instances of stock footage that do not match the clarity of the primary footage, overall, the high-definition visuals remain consistently high-quality. Color reproduction is outstanding with punchy primaries and well-delineated secondary hues creating a vibrant and colorful palette.
Contrast is applied robustly without overstatement, enhancing the vivid tonality of fleshtones and driving deep blacks that maintain their richness and dynamism even in mixed light scenarios. Mid-level camera pans and elaborate shots flesh out the depth and dimensionality, enhancing the immersive experience. Despite some scenes being highlighted as using greenscreens and cheaper sets, the Blu-ray still manages to capture a coherent cinematic look that aligns with the film’s aesthetic intentions. The overall studio-produced polish is maintained throughout, minimizing noise and artifacts which results in a pristine encoding.
In conclusion, despite minor inconsistencies due to the use of diverse footage sources, Baggage Claim stands out as a reference quality presentation on Blu-ray. The detailed traversal across different lighting conditions coupled with well-segregated, vividly colorful spectrums contribute to its highly detailed visual appeal, making for an engaging viewing experience that is visually stimulating and technically commendable.
Audio: 66
The Blu-ray audio presentation for "Baggage Claim" employs an English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that, while lacking significant low-frequency impact, provides a reasonably engaging sound experience. The ambient effects and frequent use of source music help create a sense of immersion, which is crucial for a romantic comedy. Dialogue is pristinely clear and stands out as one of the strongest elements of the audio mix, ensuring that the spoken word drives the film effectively without distraction.
Technically, the mix features several audio tracks, including English Descriptive Audio 5.1, Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1, and French DTS 5.1. Subtitles are available in English SDH and Spanish, expanding accessibility. Despite notable limitations in low-frequency extension, the track's dynamics compensate to some extent, especially with R&B music selections that seamlessly blend into the narrative. Surround sound capabilities were predominantly highlighted during musical moments, but otherwise, remained subtle. Nonetheless, the overall track structure supports the film’s narrative flow, affirming its role in enhancing the viewer's experience.
Extras: 43
The Blu-ray extras for "Baggage Claim" offer a robust collection of features, blending insightful commentaries and promotional content. The Audio Commentary by writer/director David E. Talbert delivers a deep dive into the filmmaking process, although it may not captivate everyone. Deleted Scenes add roughly 10 minutes of supplementary footage, accompanied by optional commentary, but they mostly provide non-essential content. "Behind the Scenes with the Director" is a concise, illustrative segment with optional commentary that complements the viewing experience. A series of promotional featurettes—including "Fly Girls," "Wing Men," and "The Story"—alongside an "Interview with the Cast," provide standard EPK material that sheds light on the film’s creation and the cast’s perspective. Additionally, the disc includes a theatrical trailer, offering a glimpse into the film's promotion.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scenes: Additional footage with optional commentary by David E. Talbert.
- Behind the Scenes with the Director: Short featurette with optional commentary.
- Promotional Featurettes: Standard promotional interviews and behind-the-scenes looks.
- Fly Girls: Insight into the female characters.
- Wing Men: Spotlight on the supporting male characters.
- The Story: Discussion on plot development.
- Interview with the Cast: Cast members discuss their experiences.
- Audio Commentary with David E. Talbert: In-depth look at the film-making process.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer for the movie.
Movie: 30
"Baggage Claim," led by Paula Patton in a vivacious performance, weaves a comedic narrative that exudes charm and lighthearted fun. The plot revolves around Montana Moore, a smart and sexy flight attendant desperate to find her true love within a tight 30-day window, aiming to get engaged before her younger sister's wedding. This premise sparks a series of humorous encounters as Montana's clever co-worker crew orchestrates “accidental” meetings with her numerous ex-boyfriends, creating laugh-out-loud moments and wild adventures.
However, despite its attempts to generate humor and romantic tension, "Baggage Claim" largely adheres to familiar rom-com clichés without adding much fresh perspective. The storyline is predictable, with Montana's inevitable connection with her childhood friend William (Derek Luke) standing out as a foregone conclusion. Supporting characters like Gail (Jill Scott), the randy best girlfriend, and Sam (Adam Brody), the gay best male friend, contribute to the film's stock ensemble rather than bringing unique transformative elements.
The film's comedic approach, driven by the likable Patton and her vibrant cast, attempts to uplift an otherwise formulaic plot. Yet, the predictable developments and lack of substantial character depth make it a mere pleasant watch instead of a standout in the rom-com genre. While it successfully showcases glamorous, upscale African American lifestyles confronting light-hearted romantic dilemmas, "Baggage Claim" ultimately lands safely within the bounds of conventional romantic comedy polarities.
Total: 59
"Baggage Claim" offers a mixed viewing experience marked by its enthusiastic cast but let down by a clichéd narrative. The performances are earnest, though often shadowed by an air of desperation, signaling the actors' struggle to elevate the material. The film’s plot is predictable and borrows heavily from better-executed romantic comedies, occasionally reminiscent of Tyler Perry's films. Despite its mediocrity, the endearing efforts of the cast provide a few enjoyable moments.
As for the Blu-ray presentation, it caters well to enthusiasts with its solid technical specs. Video quality is commendable, with sharp, richly colored visuals that enhance the viewing experience. Sound design is also up to par, offering clear dialogue and dynamic audio that complements the visual clarity. The overall package is decent and should satisfy fans and curious newcomers, though it won’t offer much for those looking for an exceptional home theater experience.
In conclusion, "Baggage Claim" is an inoffensive yet ultimately forgettable film. While it shines in brief moments thanks to its lively cast, its routine plot and meddling romance make it less memorable. The Blu-ray release does it justice with quality audio and visual presentation, appealing primarily to dedicated fans and those seeking light-hearted entertainment. For everyone else, it remains an inessential addition to their collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Shot with the Arri Alexa, the film boasts the typically smooth, nicely detailed ambience of this format, though director David E. Talbert appears to have used some stock footage for establishing shots...
Audio: 80
Baggage Claim's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix is a bit anemic on the low end, but otherwise offers a decently immersive experience, at least when it comes to ambient environmental effects and the...
Extras: 40
Promotional Featurettes include Fly Girls (1080p; 4:37), Wing Men (1080p; 4:30), The Story (1080p; 4:21), and Interview with the Cast (1080i; 4:37)....
Movie: 30
The fact that the film has already posited a childhood friend named William (Derek Luke), who's always lurking just in the background and who obviously has feelings for Montana, doesn't mean there's even...
Total: 40
The cast of Baggage Claim is certainly game and tries hard, but there's the whiff of desperation in many scenes....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 94
Blacks are rich, gradationally strong and dynamic which makes them pop nicely during sequences containing a mix of light and dark elements....
Audio: 82
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SV Sound PB-13...
Extras: 50
...
Movie: 30
Fortunately, her co-worker crew has cooked up a high-flying scheme for Montana to “accidentally” bump into all her exboyfriends, leading to hilarious encounters as she attempts to land the perfect guy!...
Total: 64
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SV Sound PB-13...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 70
Depth: Not a lot to most of these characters, but the film is represented on Blu well enough, in terms of the look that was achieved cinematically....
Audio: 80
Audio Format(s): English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1, English Descriptive Audio 5.1, Spanish Dolby Digital 5.1, French DTS 5.1Subtitles: English SDH, SpanishDynamics: Between the use of R&B music selections,...
Extras: 50
Behind the Scenes with the Director – Pretty self-explanatory Promotional Featurettes: Fly Girls, Wing Men, The Story, and Interview with the Cast – All standard EPK material, as the cast and crew go over...
Movie: 40
Total: 60
The cast is lively enough, but the plotting is routine, the romance is pretty meddling, and the film, overall, is forgettable....
Director: David E. Talbert
Actors: Paula Patton, Taye Diggs, Jill Scott
PlotMontana Moore, a flight attendant, is determined to find a man before her younger sister's wedding. Feeling the pressure from her mother and driven by her desire to avoid being the last unmarried woman in her family, she sets herself a 30-day deadline to get engaged. To accomplish this, Montana enlists the help of her fellow flight attendants, Gail and Sam, to track down and orchestrate encounters with her numerous ex-boyfriends who might be Mr. Right. This plan involves crisscrossing the country and arranging "chance" meetings with these past flames, hoping one of them will rekindle a romance.
As Montana reconnects with her exes, each encounter brings its own set of challenges and comedic mishaps. Despite the best-laid plans, she discovers that revisiting past relationships may not be the solution to her quest for true love. Throughout her journey, Montana learns more about herself, what she truly wants in a partner, and the importance of genuine connections. The story takes her on a whirlwind adventure filled with humor and heart, ultimately leading to unexpected revelations about love and relationships.
Writers: David E. Talbert
Release Date: 27 Sep 2013
Runtime: 96 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, French