The Promise Blu-ray Review

Presented in an aspect ratio of 1.67:1, the Blu-ray release of "The Promise" (La Promesse) is encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, providing a 1080p transfer that exhibits significant improvements over previously available formats. Supervised by Director of Photography Alain Marcoen, the high-definition digital transfer was meticulously created from a 35mm blowup interpositive using a Spirit Datacine. Extensive cleaning processes were employed, including MTI's DRS and Pixel Farm's PFClean for removing dirt, debris, and scratches, while Image Systems' Phoenix addressed smaller artifacts and noise reduction. The effort ensures that the presentation boasts enhanced clarity and stability in both detail and color reproduction.

Despite being shot on 16mm film stock, which inherently limits the resolution benefits when scaled up, the transfer maintains stable colors without appearing overly boosted or collapsing during darker sequences. The close-ups reveal commendable depth and definition, and larger shots retain pleasing clarity. Although there are fluctuating contrasts and softer-than-usual grain in some darker scenes due to the original raw cinematography, these elements do not detract significantly from the viewing experience. There are no signs of excessive denoising or sharpening, nor serious stability issues; artifacts such as flecks and scratches present on the older DVD release are notably absent here.

While digital noise is occasionally noticeable along with some persistent white specks that resemble dead pixels, these are minor distractions. The vibrancy of colors stands out remarkably against the backdrop of the small Belgian city where the film is set, with elements like Assita's traditional African dresses vividly popping on screen. There are no issues with artifacts, aliasing, or banding, and edge enhancement is minimal. Overall, this Blu-ray release of "The Promise" offers a substantial visual improvement over older formats and is highly recommended for its faithful adherence to the source material's aesthetic.

The Blu-ray release of "The Promise" features a singular audio track: French DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1. Criterion has provided optional English subtitles. Historically, the film was released with a 2.0 surround soundtrack, but this release boasts a 5.1 surround track, which has been meticulously remastered from the original LCRS magnetic masters at 24-bit resolution. The remastering process, undertaken with advanced tools such as Pro Tools HD and AudioCube's integrated workstation, effectively removed all unwanted noise including clicks, thumps, hiss, and hum, resulting in impressive audio clarity.

However, despite the upgrade to a 5.1 mix, the dynamic movement within the soundtrack remains very limited. This preservation of its original minimalist sound design aligns stylistically with the works of directors Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne. The surround channels are barely utilized, rendering the mix functionally close to a 3.0 setup - heavily relying on the two front speakers and the center channel without any notable input from the subwoofer or rear speakers. This restraint could contribute to the film's raw and authentic feel, though it may disappoint those expecting extensive use of a full 5.1 surround experience. Nevertheless, dialogue remains crisp and exceptionally clean, enhancing overall intelligibility and immersion for the viewer.

The extra features on the Blu-ray of "The Promise" provide a comprehensive and engaging exploration of the film's creation and the Dardenne brothers' distinctive filmmaking approach. Viewers can delve into an illuminating hour-long conversation with directors Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne, conducted by film critic Scott Foundas, where they discuss their filmmaking philosophy, their decision to stray from the traditional French cinematic style, and their evolution from documentary filmmakers. The actors' segment, featuring interviews with Jérémie Renier and Olivier Gourmet, provides valuable insights into their experiences working on the film and their collaboration with the Dardenne brothers. The package is rounded out with a high-definition trailer and an insightful essay by Kent Jones within an illustrated booklet.

Extras included in this disc:

Trailer: Original trailer for "La Promesse" with optional English subtitles.

Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne: In-depth interview with the directors discussing their unique filmmaking style and career decisions.

Jeremie Renier and Olivier Gourmet: Separate interviews with the lead actors sharing their experiences on set.

Booklet: Illustrated booklet featuring Kent Jones' essay "One Plus One."

Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne's "La Promesse" is a seminal work in contemporary cinema that has earned its place on Blu-ray, thanks to Criterion's meticulous release. This emotionally charged tale centers on Igor (Jeremie Renier), a young boy embroiled in his father Roger's (Olivier Gourmet) illicit business of smuggling illegal immigrants into Belgium. The plot takes a pivotal turn when an immigrant worker, Amidou, faces a deadly accident and extracts a promise from Igor to care for his wife, Assita, and their child. This narrative is delivered through the Dardenne's hallmark style—utilizing simple camera movements, authentic locations, and a notably restrained score, which draws focus to the film’s raw content.

The immersive experience of the film arises from its stark and unembellished filmmaking approach. The lack of intricate zooms or close-ups and the documentary-like framing bring an urgent authenticity to the narrative. The absence of a soundtrack intensifies the bleakness and compels the viewer to engage more deeply with the visual storytelling. The performances by Renier and Gourmet are extraordinary, especially considering it marked their significant onset collaboration with the Dardennes. The transformation of Igor underscores the film’s thematic exploration of morality sans conventional Hollywood resolutions. This Criterion release offers further insight through exclusive interviews and essays, enriching our understanding of the Dardennes' artistic motivations.

"La Promesse" remains profoundly impactful despite its inherently grim subject matter. The film’s capacity to evoke contemplation rather than resolution sets it apart, delivering an experience that immerses the viewer in the lived realities of its characters. Echoing Belgian social realism, this release is essential for those seeking cinema that challenges perceptions and elicits genuine emotional response. The Criterion Blu-ray format enhances this engagement through superior technical quality and insightful supplementary features, making it a must-see for cinephiles and newcomers alike.

Jean-Pierre and Luc Dardenne's breakthrough film, "La Promesse," makes a remarkable transition to Blu-ray, offering both visual and auditory upgrades that will please serious film aficionados. While the video quality isn't up to par with most Criterion releases—owed to the transfer originating from a 35mm blown-up print of an original 16mm reel—the film still looks the best it ever has. The audio has been upgraded from the original 2.0 to a 5.1 lossless mix, although it rarely utilizes the surround or rear channels. Despite these technical limitations, Criterion compensates with an outstanding array of special features, most notably a captivating, over-hour-long interview with the Belgian directors discussing their unique style and body of work.

"La Promesse" stands as a defining moment in the Dardenne brothers' careers, marking their decision to diverge from traditional filmmaking into a more immersive and socially aware narrative style. The film begins as a potent piece of social commentary but evolves into a richly engaging storyline that captivates its audience. It successfully blends a sense of social reality with compelling storytelling, reminiscent of other sophisticated dramas such as the 2012 Oscar-winning "A Separation." This not only makes for an absorbing viewing experience but also offers thought-provoking insights that resonate well beyond the screen.

In conclusion, "La Promesse" on Blu-ray is an essential addition to any film collector’s library. While the technical aspects may fall short by Criterion's high standards, the film’s historical significance and the quality of the added content make it a highly recommended purchase. The Dardenne brothers’ bold approach to filmmaking and the depth of discussion about their work in this release provide an invaluable resource for anyone serious about cinematic studies. This Criterion release is VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.