Mulholland Drive Blu-ray Review
DigiBook StudioCanal Collection
Score: 65
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Region B-locked Blu-ray of 'Mulholland Drive' boasts excellent video, powerful audio, and comprehensive extras—highly recommended for fans and newcomers alike.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 59
Mulholland Drive's Region-B locked Blu-ray offers a near-perfect 1080p presentation in 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The MPEG-4 AVC transfer showcases excellent color saturation, robust blacks, and comprehensive detail, despite minor soft touches and edge enhancement. Fans will appreciate the grain retention and lack of major artifacts.
Audio: 65
The English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track excels with clear dialogue, potent bass, and intelligent rear channel use, creating an unnerving and superb experience. Lynch’s sound design retains fidelity with no pitch issues, although some original production murkiness persists.
Extra: 67
The Blu-ray extras for 'Mulholland Drive' meticulously delve into Lynch's elusive style with insightful commentaries, retrospective documentaries, and intricate breakdowns, though the limitations in scene selection navigation and absence of the original TV pilot remain minor frustrations.
Movie: 80
An intricate tapestry of haunting visuals and a surreal narrative, 'Mulholland Drive' is David Lynch's enigmatic masterpiece; the Blu-ray edition from Optimum Home Entertainment boasts superior image quality, an evocative Angelo Badalamenti score, and features insightful extras like exclusive documentaries, though it’s Region-B locked.
Video: 59
David Lynch's "Mulholland Drive" receives a high-definition transfer on this UK Region-B locked Blu-ray, presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 with a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer. This rendition meticulously upholds Lynch’s artistic vision, exhibiting intentional slight softness and diffused tones to complement the dream-like sequences. Although the film’s TV-based origins imbue it with slightly softer, less vibrant colours in some segments, these are purposefully integrated to enhance the surreal narrative. Viewer immersion is bolstered by an unadulterated layer of fine film grain, preserving the movie's filmic integrity without succumbing to digital tampering.
The color scheme is richly rendered, with particular praise for the vibrant reds of lipstick and the deep blues previously plagued by blockiness in SDVD releases. Contrast levels hold consistent, delivering impeccable shadow detail and potent blacks. Occasional instances of minor edge enhancement and mild noise corrections are present but do not detract from the overall viewing experience. Highlights include scenes such as Club Silencio, where facial details – including makeup and hair – are impressively precise. These subtle nuances contribute to a near-perfect representation of Lynch's vision, even if some dark scenes necessitate a dark viewing environment for optimal clarity.
Furthermore, the transfer displays commendable stability and depth when projected digitally, free from significant flecks, debris, or artifacts. Filmed originally with 16:9 HD broadcasts in mind, the transfer to 1.85:1 widescreen retains the intended framing effectively. One point of note is the continued presence of a digitally blurred scene during Laura Harring’s nude moment, a directorial choice bound by contractual obligations and only noticeable under extreme viewing conditions. Overall, this Blu-ray release stands as a substantial visual upgrade, faithfully capturing the atmospheric and haunting nuances of "Mulholland Drive."
Audio: 65
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track on the "Mulholland Drive" Blu-ray earns accolades for its potent and immersive sound design. While maintaining clear and coherent dialogue across the frontal array, the audio mix excels in utilizing the LFE channel to drive the film's atmosphere, particularly through Angelo Badalamenti's haunting score. The low-end frequencies are powerful, capturing Lynch's intent to create an oppressive, almost visceral aural experience. Key sequences harness dynamic range brilliantly, transitioning from soft whispers to dramatic crescendos at a moment's notice. This range is enhanced by the absence of balance issues or unwanted noise such as pops and hissing, ensuring an uninterrupted viewing experience.
Technically, the audio on this release rectifies previous issues found in the HD DVD version, particularly regarding pitch accuracy—a crucial improvement for purists. Despite mixed opinions on rear channel utilization, which some believe could benefit from greater clarity and activity, the mix generally excels in its experimental approach, blending eerie soundscapes with sudden bursts of intense audio. The diverse dynamics, from rumbling car crashes to delicate whispered exchanges, showcase the track's flexibility. It's worth noting that while some ambient effects may at times feel buried, this likely stems from the original production rather than the transfer process. Ultimately, this DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 presentation provides a suitably engaging and unsettling soundstage for Lynch's complex narrative.
Extras: 67
The Blu-ray edition of "Mulholland Drive" offers an array of compelling extras that delve deeply into the film's production and intricate narrative. As per David Lynch's unique request, there's a quirky scene selection feature that prevents easy chapter skipping, aligning with the non-linear essence of the film but potentially frustrating for some viewers. Highlights include an insightful introduction by Thierry Jousse, detailing the film's journey from TV pilot to big screen, and "In the Blue Box," a retrospective documentary featuring directors like Richard Kelly and Jaco Van Dormael, among others. There's also "On the Road to Mulholland Drive," a making-of featurette offering both on-set and post-production insights, with comments from Lynch and stars such as Naomi Watts and Laura Harring. Numerous interviews with key collaborators and a particularly enlightening featurette "Back to Mulholland Drive" further elucidate this cinematic labyrinth.
Extras included in this disc:
- Introduction: Thierry Jousse discusses the film’s production history and Lynch's influences.
- In the Blue Box: Retrospective documentary featuring varied opinions on the movie.
- On the Road to Mulholland Drive: Making-of documentary with on-set interviews.
- Interviews: Conversations with Mary Sweeney and multiple interviews with Angelo Badalamenti.
- Back to Mulholland Drive: Featurette explaining the entire narrative using Lynch’s clues.
Movie: 80
David Lynch's "Mulholland Drive" is a masterfully twisted exploration of the dreams and nightmares lurking beneath Hollywood's glitzy exterior. What began as an unfinished TV pilot evolved into this highly acclaimed film, a journey both baffling and profoundly captivating. Renowned for its surreal narrative, the film dives into the story of Betty (Naomi Watts), an aspiring actress, and Rita (Laura Harring), an amnesiac survivor of a car accident. The two characters embark on a quest to discover Rita's identity, leading viewers through a labyrinthine plot filled with Lynch's signature abstract imagery and unnervingly beautiful visuals. The film’s unpredictable, dream-like structure ensures that it raises more questions than it answers, yet compels audiences to stay engaged throughout its unfolding mystery.
Technically, "Mulholland Drive" boasts exceptional visual storytelling paired with Angelo Badalamenti's hauntingly atmospheric score, which blends ambient and electronic elements to enhance its unique, almost otherworldly feel. The film’s construction is notable for its combination of original scenes shot for television and additional footage created later, adding layers of complexity to the already intricate narrative. As intriguing as it is confusing, watching this film can feel like deciphering an unsolvable puzzle – an experience Lynch himself has suggested should be driven by emotion rather than logic. Despite any perceived narrative disarray or leftover TV pilot elements that occasionally distract, this film remains hypnotically compelling and richly rewarding.
Critics recognize "Mulholland Drive" for its emotional depth and captivating performances, particularly Naomi Watts', which deservedly catapulted her into stardom. The movie’s potent blend of conventional storytelling elements with Lynch's deeply unsettling surrealism captures the essence of Hollywood’s duality – its promise of dreams against a backdrop of hidden darkness. Through meticulously crafted scenes that blend reality with illusion, "Mulholland Drive" stands as a cinematic experience that continues to intrigue, perplex, and mesmerize audiences nearly two decades after its release.
Total: 65
The Blu-ray release of "Mulholland Drive" from British distributor Optimum Home Entertainment offers a compelling combination of excellent video quality and robust audio performance. This David Lynch classic has been meticulously transferred, providing viewers with a rich and immersive experience. The disc includes a substantial array of extras that delve into the complex production history, offering insights that may help in deciphering Lynch's intricate narrative. It is regrettable that this release is Region B-locked, limiting access for some audiences despite the high technical standards it maintains.
Though some fans of Lynch might argue that "Mulholland Drive" revisits themes seen in his earlier works, this film stands as a notable entry in his oeuvre, complete with a few scenes that showcase his enigmatic brilliance at its best. The Blu-ray's visual presentation benefits from outstanding clarity and depth, while the audio track effectively enhances the film's atmospheric tension. The supplementary materials further enrich the viewing experience, making the package a comprehensive offering for enthusiasts.
In conclusion, this Region B-locked Blu-ray delivers excellent video, powerful audio, and an impressive selection of extras that not only illuminate the film’s production but also assist in unraveling its elaborate mystery. Fans of Lynch should not hesitate to add this beautifully curated release to their collection. For newcomers, "Mulholland Drive" serves as a dark, seductive introduction to Lynch's unique cinematic vision. Highly recommended.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 90
This is simply not the kind of material that one would expect to come across as flawless, and it will certainly never make for a showcase for your home cinema equipment, but it is nevertheless a near-perfect...
Audio: 90
Sure, the dialogue comes across clearly and coherently, and is neatly sandwiched across the frontal array, and yes we do get a few noticeable effects – but again you have to keep in mind the source of...
Extras: 90
It’s a comprehensive compilation of reflections not only on the movie, but also on Lynch’s style and body of work as a whole, and for those prepared to sustain reading the subtitles for the duration of...
Movie: 90
Beautifully acted, mesmirisingly constructed, with superior visuals, abstract imagery and a haunting, oppressive score, the convoluted production history (which basically saw this film come into existence...
Total: 90
Fans should not hesitate in picking up this release – it’s a beautiful package – and newcomers who know little about the movie, or about Lynch’s work in general, should consider this sexy, dark and powerful...
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 80
The color-scheme does not disappoint either - reds, yellows, greens, browns, and blacks look fresh and well saturated; the blues, however, are most impressive as none of the blockiness they were plagued...
Audio: 100
The bass is remarkably potent, the rear channels very intelligently used, and the high-frequencies not overdone....
Extras: 80
Booklet - a 20-page illustrated booklet containing Adam Woodward's essay "Mulholland and Drive" (the author has worked as online editor for Little White Lies magazine since 2009 and currently writes for...
Movie: 100
Meanwhile, a successful director (Justin Theroux, Inland Empire) is ordered to offer the leading role in his upcoming film to a girl he does not like....
Total: 90
I don't know why some of his best films are yet to be released on Blu-ray in the United States, but I certainly hope that things change in 2011 (Studio Canal already released on Blu-ray The Elephant Man...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Fortunately, it was composed with 16:9 HD broadcasts in mind, so the framing translates well enough to the 1.85:1 theatrical aspect ratio that has been preserved on this disc....
Audio: 60
In regard to sound quality, I can say with certainty that the Blu-ray's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack is an improvement over the earlier HD DVD, which suffered a pitch increase problem common to Studio...
Extras: 40
The French director and film critic explains about the movie's origins as a TV pilot, discusses some of its interpretations and references, and calls Lynch the "anti-Scorsese."...
Movie: 60
Because the TV episode was never intended for a quick resolution, and has many characters and plot threads still at the very beginning of their arcs, Lynch decided that there was no point in attempting...
Total: 60
If not for that issue, the disc has satisfying technical aspects and supplements, and is a worthy purchase for fans of the film....
Director: David Lynch
Actors: Naomi Watts, Laura Harring, Justin Theroux
PlotA dark-haired woman survives a car crash on Mulholland Drive in Los Angeles, escaping with a head injury and amnesia. She takes refuge in an apartment that belongs to an aunt of an aspiring actress named Betty, who arrives from Canada, bright-eyed and optimistic about her Hollywood prospects. The two women cross paths, and Betty, shocked to find the amnesiac woman taking shelter, is moved by her plight. They form an unlikely friendship borne of necessity, as the dark-haired woman adopts the name "Rita" after seeing a poster of Rita Hayworth. Betty, showing compassion and a sprightly can-do attitude, decides to help Rita figure out her true identity.
Together, Betty and Rita embark on a seemingly straightforward quest to unearth Rita's past, delving into the shimmering, seductive underbelly of Los Angeles. As they follow a trail of clues that includes a mysterious blue key, an enigmatic box, and a set of cryptic encounters with an eccentric cast of characters, their journey takes on a dreamlike quality. Meanwhile, another narrative thread follows a film director named Adam Kesher, who grapples with strange and sinister forces in the film industry that appear to be manipulating his latest project and personal life. These narratives intertwine, creating a complex tapestry of illusion and reality that suggests the underpinnings of Hollywood are as much a fantasy as the stories it projects on the silver screen.
Writers: David Lynch
Release Date: 19 Oct 2001
Runtime: 147 min
Rating: R
Country: France, United States
Language: English, Spanish, French