Saige Paints the Sky Blu-ray Review
Score: 44
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Saige Paints the Sky offers solid video and passable audio but is hampered by poor storytelling and a lack of special features.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 64
Universal's 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode for 'Saige Paints the Sky' delivers a crisp, film-like presentation with sunny, well-saturated colors and deep black levels, despite minor macroblocking and banding issues. The 1.78:1 aspect ratio allows for finely tuned details and pleasant contrast throughout.
Audio: 49
Saige Paints the Sky's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track is serviceable, with clear dialogue and a fairly convincing soundfield, but it suffers from weak LFE output, unimpressive directionality, and problematic audio prioritization. For a direct-to-video kids' film, it adequately meets expectations.
Extra: 0
American Girl: Saige Paints the Sky disappointingly lacks any supplementary content, offering viewers no additional features or insights beyond the main film.
Movie: 46
"Saige Paints the Sky" offers heartwarming, empowering messages for young girls, but its overly simplistic and predictable storyline, lackluster performances, and overt branding make it a lackluster viewing experience for anyone outside its target demographic.
Video: 64
The Blu-ray presentation of "Saige Paints the Sky" is meticulously executed with Universal's 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 encode, delivering a crisp and film-like visual experience. The 1.78:1 aspect ratio enhances the detailed clarity, evident in closeups that reveal intricate textures, such as the fine lines in Jane Seymour's face and the detailed makeup of younger actors. Colors are vivacious, spanning the entire spectrum from playful pinks and purples to warm, natural skin tones. Moreover, the black levels are deep and satisfying, adding to the picture’s consistent contrast. Although some scenes bear softness and diffuse lighting, these elements do not stem from encoding issues but rather artistic choices, allowing for reasonably well-resolved fine textures and intact, unobtrusive grain.
Technical performance is robust for this Blu-ray release. The edge definition comes across as clean and refined, ensuring that delineation maintains high standards throughout. The encode is largely free from significant faults, though minor instances of macroblocking and banding do occur. The landscape shots at the ranch offer impressive depth, contributing to a vibrant and engaging viewing experience. Despite some detected motion blur, the overall video quality holds up exceptionally well, maintaining its visual integrity without any dirt on the print. Overall, the Blu-ray's video presentation elevates "Saige Paints the Sky," providing a technically sound and visually appealing backdrop to its storyline.
Audio: 49
The audio presentation of "Saige Paints the Sky" features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that offers a competent, if unremarkable, listening experience. The dialogue is a high point, consistently clear and intelligible, firmly centered in the mix. However, the overall soundfield, while sometimes convincing, lacks the depth and directionality expected in higher-tier releases. The LFE output is notably weak, resulting in minimal low-end impact. Rear speaker activity is similarly underwhelming, contributing to a rather flat sound design that does little to immerse the viewer.
Dynamic range is average at best, with the bass barely making its presence known. The soundtrack is free of unwanted artifacts such as cracks, pops, or hissing. Nevertheless, there is a notable issue with sound prioritization. Effects and music too often overshadow the dialogue, resulting in an unbalanced mix where background elements sometimes dominate the aural landscape. This overemphasis on music and effects detracts from the overall clarity and may prove distracting for discerning listeners.
In summary, while "Saige Paints the Sky" won't be earning any accolades for its audio presentation, it fulfills its purpose as a direct-to-video children's release. The technical limitations and lackluster sound design are consistent with other offerings in its category, making it adequate for its intended audience but far from exemplary in the broader spectrum of Blu-ray audio quality.
Extras:
The Blu-ray release of "American Girl: Saige Paints the Sky" unfortunately does not include any extra features. For fans hoping for behind-the-scenes content, interviews, or additional materials to complement the main film, this could be a disappointment. The absence of extras means the viewing experience is limited strictly to the feature presentation. While the technical quality of the Blu-ray is commendable in terms of video and audio clarity, the lack of supplementary content does not enhance the overall package, making it minimalistic in its offering.
Extras included in this disc:
- None
Movie: 46
Saige Paints the Sky is a modern-day story featuring nine-year-old Saige (Sidney Fullmer), a talented artist with a deep-seated passion for horses. In the seventh installment of the American Girl series, Saige's world is disrupted as her favorite art class is cut from the curriculum, and her best friend, Tessa (Alex Peters), begins to drift towards a new companion. Guided by her grandmother Mimi (Jane Seymour), a renowned artist and horsewoman, Saige learns to navigate these challenges with courage and determination. Although heartwarming and well-intentioned in its depiction of perseverance and self-discovery, the film's characters and plot trajectories are predictably conventional, tailored exclusively for its young audience without introducing any intricate narrative layers.
Visually, the film delivers bright, engaging cinematography that complements its buoyant themes. However, its appeal may be limited to the core demographic of young girls aged 4-12, who might identify with Saige's dreamlike existence, surrounded by a loving family and expansive opportunities. The film grounds itself in palatable yet shallow conflicts, causing it to miss the mark in creating a more nuanced or authentic portrayal of pre-adolescent struggles. It tends to prioritize the promotion of the American Girl brand over delivering a genuinely intricate storyline.
While Jane Seymour's portrayal of Mimi adds a touch of elegance, her performance feels somewhat disinterested and lacks depth, coinciding with the overall lackluster acting within the film. The primary takeaway of courage and accepting change is evident yet delivered in a predictably saccharine manner. Ultimately, while Saige Paints the Sky provides wholesome entertainment with its moral lessons on friendship and perseverance, its overly sanitized delivery and absence of compelling storytelling makes it suitable predominantly for young viewers already enamored with the American Girl franchise.
Total: 44
"American Girl: Saige Paints the Sky" caters expertly to its intended preteen demographic, particularly fans of the American Girl franchise. The Blu-ray offers a robust video presentation that is free from any significant flaws. Its DTS-HD Master Audio track is functional, adequately complementing the narrative though not exceptional. Regrettably, the absence of special features leaves much to be desired for those seeking additional content.
Critically, the film itself presents a mixed bag. While it aims to highlight the journey of a young girl overcoming her fears and making a positive impact, it often falters into portraying a privileged protagonist whose behavior might come off as unnecessarily entitled. For adults, especially those not familiar with the American Girl series, this might make the viewing experience considerably less enjoyable. It's clear that the story capitalizes more on its built-in fanbase than on compelling storytelling or character development.
In conclusion, "Saige Paints the Sky" is a satisfactory Blu-ray purchase if aimed at preteens already invested in the American Girl universe. Its technical merits are competent, ensuring a visually and audibly pleasant experience. However, for those expecting depth and engaging content extending beyond its target audience, this release might fall short. Engaged buyers should anticipate mixed reactions based on individual expectations and existing fan loyalty.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 80
There's quite a bit of softness and diffuse lighting, but none of it traces back to the encode, which doesn't exhibit any major problems either....
Audio: 70
Yes, LFE output and rear speaker activity leave a lot to be desired -- low-end effects are pretty weak and directionality is unimpressive -- but for a direct-to-video kids' film, it isn't all that surprising....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 50
Sit down to watch Saige Paints the Sky with your girls, though, and you're in for an hour and a half of maddeningly cookie cutter characters finding a maddeningly cookie cutter path to true happiness....
Total: 50
If, after putting away your wallet and mumbling to yourself about the pricey perils of parenthood, you're concerned with the quality of the disc, have no fear....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Every color of the prism is used in this movies as Saige and her friends paint, do arts and crafts, and perform a skit in front of the entire school....
Audio: 60
The music in the film is the worst there is, but comes across louder than the dialogue at times through all speakers, as if they turned the volume up on everything....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 0
Sure, if your daughter is a fan of the line of dolls, she will get some of the references, but these lessons of conquering stage-fright, accepting new people, and being an all-around decent person have...
Total: 20
I think they wanted to show a story of young girl trying to do some good and overcome her fear of stage-fright, but the end result was showcasing a bratty rich kid who throws a hissy fit when she doesn't...
Director: Vince Marcello
Actors: Sidney Fullmer, Alexandra Peters, Alana Gordillo
PlotSaige Copeland, a spirited and artistic fourth grader, is excited for the new school year, particularly because she's eager to dive into her passion for art classes. Her excitement quickly dampens when she learns that budget cuts have led to the cancellation of the art program. To make matters worse, her best friend Tessa seems to have found a new companion, leaving Saige feeling isolated and disheartened. Encouraged by her free-spirited grandmother Mimi, Saige decides to take action. She partners with a fellow classmate, Gabi, to rally support for their cause and plans a community event to raise funds for the art program's revival.
As Saige grapples with the challenges of leadership and friendship, she learns invaluable lessons about perseverance and creativity. Along the way, she faces various hurdles that test her resolve, but with Mimi's guidance and the rekindling of her friendship with Tessa, she finds the inner strength to continue fighting for what she believes in. The journey becomes an empowering experience for Saige, allowing her to grow both as an artist and as a person. Throughout this quest, Saige's unwavering determination underscores the importance of community and the impact of art in education.
Writers: Jessica O'Toole, Amy Rardin, Jessica Haas
Release Date: 02 Jul 2013
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: TV-G
Country: United States
Language: English