Fireproof Blu-ray Review
Score: 49
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Fireproof's compelling story and message of God's love may override its technical flaws and mixed reception, with a solid 1080p transfer and adequate audio.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 51
Fireproof arrives on Blu-ray with a bright and colorful 1080p, 1.85:1-framed transfer; while it excels in vibrant color reproduction, fine detail, and strong black levels, it suffers from occasional overblown colors, a persistent yellowish tint on skin tones, and inconsistent image depth.
Audio: 41
The audio presentation of 'Fireproof' via Dolby TrueHD 5.1 is underwhelming with dialogue clarity issues, minimal surround engagement, and weak bass response. While some localized sounds are passable, the overall mix is basic, lacking the immersive quality expected even for a dialogue-driven drama.
Extra: 61
The Blu-ray of 'Fireproof' is rich in bonus material, including insightful commentary from the Kendrick brothers, deleted scenes, a lighthearted gag reel, a 23-minute behind-the-scenes feature, and a brief piece on the companion book 'Love Dare.' Despite some repetitiveness, fans will find the behind-the-scenes video blog particularly engaging.
Movie: 46
Fireproof offers a technically improved experience over previous efforts, with a stronger budget and refined direction led by Kirk Cameron's genuine portrayal, though it remains divisive with its heavy-handed Christian messaging and somewhat predictable plot resolution.
Video: 51
The Blu-ray presentation of "Fireproof" arrives with a solid 1080p, AVC MPEG-4 encoded transfer framed at 1.85:1. Shot digitally, the film features excellent resolution and color reproduction that brings out an eye-catching and vibrant palette. The transfer excels particularly in rendering bold and bright colors; Caleb's pristine white firefighter captain’s shirt and the striking red of the fire engine stand out sharply, alongside the realistically detailed yellow firefighter gear. Each piece of worn and grimy equipment is beautifully detailed, making even the long-distance shots incredibly sharp and full of fine detail.
However, the transfer is not without its drawbacks. There is an apparent inconsistency in skin tones, particularly affecting Kirk Cameron, whose complexion occasionally takes on an unnatural yellow tint, disrupting the overall visual fidelity. While many scenes offer clean edges and a high level of detail without apparent signs of digital noise reduction or other manipulative techniques, there are instances where the image appears flat and two-dimensional. Certain softer shots lack precision, thereby compromising the generally high standard set by the rest of the transfer. Despite these minor issues, for a low-budget, digitally-shot film, this Blu-ray translates remarkably well to home media, offering a pleasing and largely immersive visual experience.
Audio: 41
The audio presentation on the Blu-ray of "Fireproof" is equipped with a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack, but it leaves much to be desired. The dialogue is generally clear, though there are instances where words become mumbled or lost amidst the mix. Essential sound effects like rumbling fire engines and the horn blasts register, albeit without impressive sonic depth. Significant sequences, such as a train barreling towards a car stuck on the tracks, manage a decent if not entirely compelling presence. Ambient sounds, particularly in quieter scenes like a father-son walk in the woods, are conveyed adequately through the front channels, but the rear channels are sparingly utilized.
While the soundtrack essentially fulfills its role, it lacks the dynamic range and engagement one would expect from a more action-oriented film or a higher-budget production. The surround speakers are often neglected, resulting in a somewhat barren auditory landscape that fails to immerse the viewer fully. Bass impact is minimal, restricted mainly to the low-frequency rumbles from fire trucks and scenes involving a flaming house.
Considering the film is primarily dialogue-driven, the overall audio mix can be deemed serviceable but underwhelming. The limited use of surround channels and the lackluster bass performance contribute to an experience that is far from sonically rich. Given these factors, "Fireproof’s" audio track does a basic job but doesn't rise above mediocrity, sticking strictly to the needs of its narrative without offering any compelling auditory enhancement.
Extras: 61
The Blu-ray release of "Fireproof" features an impressive array of extras that provide valuable insights and a rich behind-the-scenes look at the production. Spearheaded by a commentary track with Writer/Director Alex Kendrick and Writer/Producer Stephen Kendrick, the inclusion offers an in-depth exploration of shooting locations, thematic elements, and cast performances. The collection also boasts a series of deleted scenes, light-hearted bloopers, and interviews that enrich the viewer's experience. Notably, features like "Marriage Matters" and "Filming a Movie in 30 Days" delve into both technical aspects and the spiritual beliefs influencing the film's themes, augmenting its narrative depth.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: With Alex and Stephen Kendrick discussing various production details.
- Deleted Scenes: Includes optional introduction by Alex Kendrick, providing context.
- Firegoofs/Jokes and Pranks: A gag reel showcasing humorous moments from the set.
- Behind the Scenes: Explores production, featuring cast, crew, and their spiritual reflections.
- Marriage Matters: Discusses the film's focus on marital themes.
- 'Fireproof' in 60: A humorous, minute-long recap of the film.
- Wayne on Wayne: An interview with Stephen Dervan in character as Wayne Floyd.
- Love Dare Promo: A promotional piece for the film's companion book.
- Filming a Movie in 30 Days: Fireproof Video Blog: Behind-the-scenes footage and interviews.
- Fun with Mr. Rudolph: A brief comical segment featuring one of the film's characters.
- Wayne’s Firehouse: Another character-centric piece with Stephen Dervan as Wayne Floyd.
- Music Video – Slow Fade by Casting Crowns: An associated music video.
- Trailers: Includes a trailer for "Facing the Giants".
Movie: 46
"Fireproof" arrives on Blu-ray as an inspirational film with a commendable transfer and various extras. Directed by Alex Kendrick, the movie focuses on Albany, Georgia fire captain Caleb Holt (Kirk Cameron), whose profession embodies teamwork and sacrifice. However, his marriage to Catherine (Erin Bethea) lacks these elements of collaboration and commitment. Their union is on the brink of collapse until Caleb’s father challenges him with "The Love Dare," a 40-day spiritual and relational program aiming to reignite their relationship by reconnecting them through faith. Caleb’s initial skepticism is met with ongoing encouragement from his father and best friend, unveiling a story that juxtaposes his life-saving work with the spiritual task of saving his marriage.
Technically, "Fireproof" is a noticeable improvement over Sherwood Baptist Church’s previous effort, "Facing the Giants." With a more substantial budget, the movie achieves a refined presentation and benefits from Kirk Cameron's genuine portrayal of Caleb. The cast, largely comprising volunteers from Sherwood Baptist Church, deliver performances that align with the movie's message, even if not Oscar-worthy. Despite mixed reviews regarding its overt religious messaging and perceived heavy-handedness, the film persistently underscores its central theme: the transformative power of Godly love in marriage.
Some may find elements contrived or preachy, such as the extreme measures taken against internet pornography or the heavily-scripted faith discussions, prompting criticism for failing to resonate beyond religious audiences. Moreover, while "Fireproof" sets out to inspire and save marriages through a Biblical lens, its portrayal sometimes veers into predictable resolutions detracting from its intended subtlety. Nonetheless, for those aligned with its spiritual underpinnings, the film succeeds in conveying messages of unconditional love and unwavering faith.
Total: 49
"Fireproof" on Blu-ray delivers a potent narrative centered on rekindling marital love through faith, but it comes with notable technical constraints. The film's 1080p transfer is generally solid, capturing the emotional nuance of the characters and providing clarity in the cinematography, though it isn't without minor imperfections. The audio, while lossless, is somewhat underwhelming but adequate for the film's primary focus on dialogue and subdued background score.
Thematically, "Fireproof" centers on the transformative power of God's love in human relationships. While its religious messaging is unapologetically overt and perhaps narrow in scope, it provides a compelling emotional journey for its target audience. The portrayal of personal struggle against modern-day temptations may not resonate universally and is executed with varying degrees of tact. The accompanying bonus materials are a commendable addition, offering behind-the-scenes insights and adding value to the viewing experience.
In conclusion, "Fireproof" is a meaningful and enduring film that can be forgiven its technical shortcomings for the importance of its story. Sony's Blu-ray release does justice to the movie with a solid 1080p transfer, an adequate lossless soundtrack, and a nice selection of bonus features. This release comes highly recommended for audiences seeking inspirational cinema rooted in faith, resulting in a compelling narrative that forgives its missteps in favor of its impacting message.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Said gear, though colorful, also features a layer of grime and general wear-and-tear that lends to it a realistic flair, and the transfer allows for plenty of the small details in these uniforms -- and...
Audio: 60
With a train coming in the distance, workers struggle to move the vehicle and avoid the train; it blows through the soundstage with a halfway decent presence, but the same effect in a more action-oriented...
Extras: 70
Fireproof: Behind the Scenes (1080i, 22:56) takes a sincere look into the production, showcasing the cast and crew's own spiritual beliefs, shooting some of the scenes both action-oriented and dramatic,...
Movie: 80
Scripture equates a husband's love with Christ's love for the church in Ephesians chapter five, and Fireproof retains that theme throughout, building both the dare and Caleb's subsequent spiritual journey...
Total: 70
Though the theme and message here are a bit more narrowly-focused than that of Facing the Giants, they nevertheless all end with the same conclusion: that God's love can conquer anything and man's trust...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
I found numerous sequences that were very strong in portraying minute details, even at a distance....
Audio: 60
There are a few occasions of localized sounds coming from rear speakers, like radio noise, an incoming train, or the movement of fire trucks, and a few bits of movement (also from the fire trucks), but...
Extras: 60
The scenes cover deodorant discussion, comparisons between God and Spider-Man that were actually funny (why delete the only funny scene in the film?), further proof the Catherine character is massively...
Movie: 20
From the cheesy back and forth cuts of two conversations merging as one that go on for about ten cuts too long, to an abandoned cross setting that looks like a sacrifice would be a more likely occurrence...
Total: 40
A note to Christian movie makers... after a pornographic pop up on a computer, don't have someone fighting their urges grunting "why is it so hard?!?!"...
Director: Alex Kendrick
Actors: Kirk Cameron, Erin Bethea, Ken Bevel
PlotCaleb Holt is a dedicated firefighter who excels at his job, yet his marriage to Catherine is coming apart. Though he saves lives every day, Caleb struggles with understanding and connecting with his wife. Catherine feels neglected and unloved, leading to frequent arguments and a growing emotional distance between them. Caleb’s primary focus has always been his firefighting career and expensive hobbies, while Catherine seeks emotional support and companionship. Despite his father’s advice to avoid rushing into a divorce, Caleb’s frustration mounts, putting additional strain on their relationship.
At his father’s urging, Caleb reluctantly agrees to endure a 40-day challenge known as "The Love Dare," designed to help him rediscover love and commitment in his marriage. The challenge requires Caleb to perform selfless acts, show kindness, and make sacrifices that he initially finds difficult. As Caleb progresses, he begins to confront his own selfishness and learns valuable lessons about love, both selfless and unconditional. Meanwhile, tensions at work test Caleb’s patience and resolve, revealing the complexities of balancing personal and professional responsibilities.
Writers: Alex Kendrick, Stephen Kendrick
Release Date: 26 Sep 2008
Runtime: 122 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English