Superman Blu-ray Review

The “Superman: Extended Cut” Blu-ray is a notable technical achievement, especially considering the unique challenges faced in its restoration. Presented in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 with an aspect ratio of 2.40:1, the film preserves Geoffrey Unsworth's original visuals while presenting restored segments in high-definition widescreen. Warner Archive Collection (WAC) found an interpositive with no prior technical specifications, which Warner's Motion Picture Imaging (MPI) scanned at 2K, offering surprising clarity for material initially believed lost or only existing in subpar formats. MPI's color correction efforts were extensive, aiming to smooth out transitions and maintain consistent color in key elements such as Superman's iconic uniform. Despite the disparate sources, the meticulous work ensures a consistent and immersive viewing experience.

Comparisons between the Extended Cut and other high-definition versions reveal variations in color timing, contrast, framing, and grain texture, underscoring the distinct provenance of each version. While the Extended Cut exhibits some inherent softness and occasional detail inconsistency due to source limitations, the presentation exceeds expectations. The encode bitrate averages a healthy 28.84 Mbps despite the film’s extensive length, ensuring visual fidelity. Critics have noted slight inconsistencies in grain structure and color from scene to scene, yet these discrepancies are minor and unobtrusive. Overall, MPI’s work emphasizes seamless integration of restored footage, making it challenging even for discerning fans to pinpoint differences without direct comparison.

The result is a cohesive visual presentation that stands on its own, distinct yet comparable to the Original Theatrical Cut and the Special Edition. Despite its extended runtime and disparate source material, the Extended Cut’s high-definition release showcases commendable technical prowess. WAC and MPI have succeeded in delivering a version that honors Geoffrey Unsworth's cinematography while offering a coherent visual experience that will satisfy both purists and new viewers alike.

The audio presentation of the Extended Cut of "Superman" on Blu-ray employs a DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track, derived from the original mono mix created for early 80s television broadcasts. This mix has been meticulously cleaned of any age-related damage and distortion by Warner Archive Collection (WAC), resulting in what they describe as "enhanced mono." This enhancement uses re-equalization and subtle sonic adjustments to provide a greater sense of spatial separation between the left and right channels. While this format does not achieve the dynamic range and impact found in the Special Edition's 5.1 remix, the resultant audio maintains clarity in dialogue and effects, along with a clean reproduction of John Williams' iconic score. The beginning and end title sequences have been upgraded to true stereo, offering a noticeable improvement over the main mono track.

Despite its limitations, the DTS-HD MA 2.0 track impresses with its balanced integration of additional dialogue and the seamless retracking of Williams' score. Standout moments include the reinstated Krypton sequences, replete with somber strings and chaotic horns that enhance the narrative without jarring tonal inconsistencies. However, comparisons to the Special Edition reveal a constrained dynamic range and limited channel separation, reminiscent of a high-quality FM radio broadcast. While audiophiles might wish for a discrete 5.1 mix or a full stereo soundtrack similar to the original 1978 theatrical release, the practical constraints and prior controversies involving altered sound effects may justify this conservative approach.

Audiophiles experimenting with different playback settings may find direct stereo or receiver-based five-channel stereo modes yield the best results. Engaging Dolby Pro-Logic or other DSP processing generally fails to extract significant surround information, maintaining a primarily monophonic experience. This DTS-HD MA 2.0 mix represents a diligent effort to preserve and enhance the original audio, presenting it in the best possible quality given its historical context and technical limitations. Despite minor imperfections and editorial changes in the opening credits, this track succeeds in rendering "Superman" a more enjoyable auditory experience, albeit one that falls short of contemporary multi-channel formats.

The Special Edition disc of the "Superman" Blu-ray provides a comprehensive set of extras, thankfully carried over from previous Blu-ray releases. Although the Extended Cut lacks added supplements or the inclusion of technical documentaries and running commentaries, any fan of the franchise will appreciate the Special Edition's rich array of content. Notable features like director commentary, documentaries detailing the development and filming processes, as well as a set of screen tests and additional scenes, ensure an insightful experience. The inclusion of additional music cues and a music-only track further enhances appreciation for the film's score.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary from Director Richard Donner and Creative Consultant Tom Mankiewicz: Insightful perspectives from key production figures.
• Taking Flight: The Development of Superman: Documentary on the movie's initial stages.
• Making Superman: Filming the Legend: Behind-the-scenes details on the film.
• The Magic Behind the Cape: A deep dive into the special effects.
• Screen Tests: Audition footage.
• Restored Scenes: Enhanced versions of original scenes.
• Additional Scenes: Extra footage not in the main cut.
• Additional Music Cues: Unused music tracks.
• Music-Only Track: The film's score in its entirety.

Richard Donner's "Superman: The Movie" is widely recognized for its pioneering role in validating the superhero genre. Debuting in 1978, the film has seen several versions over the decades, each attempting to refine or expand upon the original. The most recent offering, the Extended Cut, clocks in at 188 minutes and brings back rarely seen footage once aired on television, fully restored and now available in high definition. This cut notably lengthens the film with previously excised scenes, adding more depth to characters like Lex Luthor and providing new subplots. This addition of new scenes is not solely meant to enhance the plot; some serve purely to expand character interactions or provide light-hearted moments, often at the risk of slowing down the already lengthy pacing of the film.

The Extended Cut showcases scenes such as a childhood Lois Lane cameo and an elaborate setup where Lex Luthor reprograms ICBMs with the help of his hapless henchman Otis. These inserts offer nostalgic value and are fascinating for long-time fans of the franchise, yet they arguably don't contribute significantly to the overall narrative. Adding these scenes may gratify superfans who've kept their bootleg TV recordings for years but might not appeal broadly due to the increased runtime and potential narrative bloat.

While some may argue that the Extended Cut offers more value by including nearly every conceivable scene from various releases, it does not necessarily enhance the cinematic quality of Donner's original film. However, it does a superb job of satisfying long-time enthusiasts with its comprehensive inclusion of John Williams's score and other hard-to-find footage. For those devoted fans, this release can feel like unearthing a hidden treasure, even if it doesn't come without its flaws. The original 1978 cut remains the benchmark for many, balanced perfectly between runtime and storytelling efficiency.

The recent Blu-ray release of "Superman: The Movie - Extended Cut" brings a significant piece of cinematic history to an enthusiastic audience while providing a comprehensive technical upgrade. This edition presents the extended cut that many believed would be confined to old VHS tapes shared among superfans, offering a pristine restoration that can now be appreciated by everyone. Notably, the issuance of this version allows for a complete comparison between Richard Donner's 2000 Special Edition and the more extensive TV version, adding new dimensions to the viewing experience. The nuanced restoration work showcases remarkable fidelity, enhancing both video and audio quality compared to previous releases.

One of the main highlights is the inclusion of scenes omitted even from Donner’s revered cut, such as the tense opening confrontation between Jor-El and Krypton’s council. For die-hard aficionados, these additional moments enrich the narrative and offer fresh perspectives on familiar plot elements. Nevertheless, it is crucial to acknowledge that the extended cut's pacing may not appeal to casual viewers due to its length. It’s tailored more towards enthusiasts who relish every extra frame of this classic film. Despite some criticism about potentially bloated sequences, this release stands as an essential acquisition for collectors and fans who cherish expanded storytelling and technical superiorities.

In conclusion, while the extended cut may not become the go-to version for all viewers, it undeniably showcases the preservation effort and commitment to delivering a comprehensive "Superman" experience. With Warner Bros.' meticulous restoration and packaging, this release is highly recommended for anyone interested in cinematic history and high-quality home viewing. The Blu-ray allows fans to delve into an enriched universe of Superman, affirming its place as a valuable addition to any collection. It also sets expectations for future extended releases, such as a possible extended cut of "Superman II," keeping the anticipation alive among fans of the series.