The Creator Blu-ray Review
Score: 82
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A visual spectacle with first-rate technical merits, 'The Creator' has captivating visuals and unexpected heart, despite some unanswered questions.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 91
The Creator's Blu-ray presentation, with a 1080p AVC encoded transfer in 2.76:1, excels visually, offering superb detail even amid digital grain and low-light scenes. While 4K UHD is preferred for optimal quality, the Blu-ray's organic texture and vivid blue and yellow tones remain impressive.
Audio: 95
The Creator's Blu-ray audio delivers an impressive immersive experience. The Dolby Atmos mix offers enriching immersion with active surround use, while the DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track stands superbly on its own, offering vibrant ambient effects and clear dialogue. Both tracks effectively engage-side and rear channels, bolstered by Hans Zimmer's score.
Extra: 51
Explore the nearly hour-long featurette 'True Love: Making The Creator,' where director Gareth Edwards and crew delve into the film's documentary-style production, innovative camera techniques, and genre-blending aspirations, offering an enriching behind-the-scenes journey.
Movie: 71
The Creator, a speculative tale of AI-driven apocalypse, manages stunning visuals and intriguing echoes of District 9 and Apocalypse Now but stumbles with occasionally muddled metaphysics and some logical gaps in plot, highlighted by commendable performances from John David Washington and Madeleine Yuna Voyles.
Video: 91
"The Creator" is presented on Blu-ray with an impressive AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a wide 2.76:1 aspect ratio. The film, shot using a range of cameras including Sony models and even drones, was finished in 4K, delivering a visually striking experience that remains powerful even in this full HD presentation. While the 4K UHD version is recommended for those with compatible equipment, this 1080p release stands strong in its capacity to deliver rich visuals. Notably, the digital grain present often feels organic, especially against brighter backgrounds, contributing to an authentic textured and gritty aesthetic.
Despite the grading and several low-light sequences, the presentation maintains impressive detail levels. The film's frequent use of blue and yellow tones is particularly noteworthy — they pop vibrantly without causing significant detail loss. This balance between rich color grading and fine detailing is achieved artfully, ensuring an immersive viewing experience that remains visually compelling throughout its runtime.
Audio: 95
The audio presentation of "The Creator" on Blu-ray delivers an impressive audiovisual experience that caters to both Dolby Atmos and DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track enthusiasts. The Dolby Atmos surround mix stands out with its active engagement, employing audio objects effectively placed above the listener to create a depth of immersion that aligns perfectly with onscreen events. The implementation of atmospherics, panning fills, and discrete sounds is commendable, enriching the experience. Furthermore, nearfield sound placement in the bed channels is remarkably accurate, providing an involving listening experience that heightens the immersive "being there" effect.
Similarly, the DTS-HD Master Audio 7.1 track offers extraordinary immersion despite lacking the Atmos verticality. It captivates with its excellent ambient environmental effects, utilising the side and rear channels for compelling audio depth. The track excels during urban cacophony, shootouts, and explosions, demonstrating regular LFE presence and enveloping sound effects that consistently engage the senses. Hans Zimmer's score enhances the narrative further with subtle hints of Asian musical elements like gamelan, while the dialogue remains clear and intelligible throughout. Optional subtitles are available in English, French, and Spanish, ensuring accessibility for a wider audience.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray extras for "The Creator" offer a comprehensive look into the film's production process, providing a fascinating exploration for cinephiles and filmmaking enthusiasts. The standout feature is an extensive behind-the-scenes documentary that runs for nearly an hour, titled "True Love: Making The Creator." This featurette offers viewers insights into Gareth Edwards' unique approach, including on-location shooting during a crew road trip and the innovative use of documentary-style techniques. Additionally, the feature dives into the film’s genre-blending ambitions, offering a nuanced perspective on the creative processes involved. The inclusion of a digital copy is a convenient addition for collectors and digital enthusiasts.
Extras included in this disc:
- True Love: Making The Creator: A 55-minute featurette exploring the behind-the-scenes production with insights from the director and crew.
Movie: 71
"The Creator" sets an intriguing stage in a near-future world, embroiled in a war between humans and highly advanced A.I. systems. The premise, propelled by the notion of technology surpassing human control, explores complex themes of creation, loss, and identity. The film follows Joshua Taylor (played by John David Washington), an ex-special forces operative grappling with personal tragedy, tasked with infiltrating the A.I. community to locate their enigmatic leader. The film ambitiously blends philosophical musings with high-octane sci-fi action, reminiscent of both "District 9" and "Apocalypse Now," interwoven with unexpected spiritual undertones akin to "Little Buddha."
Gareth Edwards’ direction attempts to balance sprawling epic sci-fi with intimate human drama. The film’s production reportedly worked within constraints that seem ambitious for its $80 million budget, resulting in vivid, occasionally breathtaking visuals. Edwards' skillful incorporation of montage techniques, mirroring a documentary style akin to quasi-found footage, enhances the film's narrative depth. However, the plot sometimes wavers due to its complexity; elements such as the relationship dynamics and the depiction of simulants leave room for clearer articulation.
John David Washington anchors the film with a compelling performance, complemented by Madeleine Yuna's portrayal of Alphie, the child simulant and central mystery of the story. The film raises intriguing questions about A.I. consciousness and ethics but occasionally struggles under the weight of its narrative ambitions. Despite some script deficiencies and perplexing logic gaps—illustrated by Alphie’s unconvincing need for concealment—the emotional bond between Taylor and Alphie provides an engaging narrative thread. Ultimately, "The Creator" captivates visually and thematically, offering a compelling yet complex reflection on humanity's ever-evolving relationship with technology.
Total: 82
"The Creator" excels visually and sonically, presenting a first-rate technical experience that is sure to captivate any home cinema enthusiast. The film showcases immaculate picture quality, with its 4K Ultra HD transfer revealing every detail in stunning clarity. The color accuracy and dynamic range are impressive, delivering a visual spectacle that allows viewers to immerse themselves fully in the film's vibrant world. The audio, rendered with precision and depth, supports an engaging soundstage that matches the movie's ambitious narrative scope. The interplay between audio-visual elements is executed flawlessly, enhancing the overall viewing experience.
Narratively, "The Creator" presents a thought-provoking view of artificial intelligence intertwined with elements of personal connection. The quasi-father-daughter relationship at the heart of the film adds unexpected emotional depth, though some find the story leaves questions unanswered, impacting narrative cohesion. Despite this, the film's potential for future reflections on AI offers intriguing thematic content. The balance between its visual prowess and its story generates a mixed reception but remains compelling enough to keep audiences engaged throughout its runtime.
In conclusion, "The Creator" is recommended for its extraordinary visual and audio production values, which represent some of the best technical standards seen in modern Blu-ray releases. While it might not completely satisfy all narrative expectations, its impressive sensory experience and meaningful moments provide ample reasons to explore this cinematic effort. Whether you're drawn to it for its visuals, soundtrack, or thematic discussions, "The Creator" promises to be a rewarding addition to any collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 100
I often tend to favor 1080 presentations of 35mm material when compared to a 2160 release, but kind of ironically, the very heavy at times digital grain that attends this presentation actually struck me...
Audio: 100
Our scores above can only "say" so much, and at times I have been known to give a 1080 disc's 7.1 rendering a half point off so that I have "room" to give a full five stars to a 4K UHD disc's Atmos track,...
Extras: 40
True Love: Making The Creator (HD; 55:47) is a really interesting featurette which gets into the "road trip" Edwards and his crew took to scout locations, filming as they went....
Movie: 70
That perhaps hilarious outcome notwithstanding, The Creator posits a (near) future world where A.I. has few if any limits, and we poor, distraught humans may be on the brink of extinction as a result (something...
Total: 70
Tongues in cheek notwithstanding, as my colleague Brian Orndorf mentioned in his review of the film, Edwards probably never quite "gets there" with this effort, and for me personally there were simply...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 92
Audio: 100
Extras: 70
Disc 1: The Creator Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2: The Creator Blu-ray True Love: Making The Creator (55 Mins) - Join director Gareth Edwards and crew for nearly an hour look behind the scenes....
Movie: 80
Joshua (John David Washington), once a special forces undercover operative, sent to infiltrate the AI human simulant/human community, in order to track down their mysterious leader, is now a shell of his...
Total: 86
Ralph Potts AVS Forum Blu-ray Reviews Reference Review System: JVC DLA-NZ7 4K Ultra High-Definition Laser Front Projector (Calibrated with Calman color calibration software and Portrait Displays C6 HDR2000...
Director: Gareth Edwards
Actors: John David Washington, Madeleine Yuna Voyles, Gemma Chan
PlotIn the near future, a brilliant but reclusive scientist, Dr. Eliot Finch, has made a groundbreaking discovery that could alter the essence of human existence. Finch, played with an intense fervor, has developed a technology with the potential to create life, not just any life, but sentient, thinking beings designed from the ground up. Haunted by the tragic loss of his family, which fuels his obsession, he becomes consumed with the notion of engineering a new form of life that could fill the void left behind by his personal tragedies.
Operating from a state-of-the-art, isolated laboratory, Finch recruits a young, ambitious programmer, Ava, whose knack for artificial intelligence coding makes her an invaluable asset to his secretive project. Ava, portrayed with curiosity and a hint of naivety, finds herself enthralled by Finch's vision and the ethical complexities it brings. Their work takes on a new dimension with the arrival of an investigative reporter, Rachel, whose initial skepticism and search for truth slowly give way to conflicted feelings as she learns more about Finch’s past and the potential implications of his work. As the trio delves deeper into the moral maze of creation and responsibility, they are unaware of the looming consequences their success could unleash upon the world.
Writers: Gareth Edwards, Chris Weitz
Release Date: 29 Sep 2023
Runtime: 133 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, Thai