Texas Killing Fields Blu-ray Review
Score: 46
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Texas Killing Fields offers competent video and audio quality, but its sluggish pacing, flat characters, and uninspired plot make it a rental at best.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 57
Texas Killing Fields' 1080p Blu-ray transfer presents a solid rendition in the original 2.40:1 aspect ratio, with strong black levels supporting night scenes, and a generally drab color palette that fits the film's tone. Despite minor issues like crush, banding, and aliasing, the transfer does commendably reflect the director's intended look.
Audio: 53
The Blu-ray audio presentation of 'Texas Killing Fields' offers a moody DTS-HD Master Audio and Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mix, delivering clear dialogue, immersive environmental effects, and dynamic moments in action scenes. While some quiet sections may feel flat, the soundtrack effectively enhances the film's atmosphere.
Extra: 13
The Blu-ray extras of 'Texas Killing Fields' are disappointing for UK fans who lose out on the US disc's insightful Director's Commentary by Ami Canaan Mann and writer Donald F. Ferrarone, replaced only by the movie trailer in 1080p.
Movie: 50
Texas Killing Fields delivers a dark, atmospheric thriller with engaging performances and stylish direction, but it suffers from familiar, unrefined plot elements and a lack of narrative drive, leaving it as a competent yet ultimately forgettable addition to the genre. The Blu-ray provides quality video and audio but lacks substantial extras.
Video: 57
The Blu-ray release of "Texas Killing Fields" provides a solid 1080p High Definition presentation in the original 2.40:1 aspect ratio. The transfer stays true to the film's tailored atmospheric style, achieving a respectable balance between clarity and moodiness. The visual presentation is predominantly moody and dark, with scenes shot in low light and night settings benefiting from strong black levels, despite some occasional hints of crush. The color palette is intentionally drab, reinforcing the film's gloomy subject matter, yet it is accurately rendered, maintaining a consistent filmic appearance throughout.
Fine detail is handled well, revealing nice textures in close-ups of clothes, faces, and various worn-down locations. While skin tones are depicted healthily, they often carry a weathered look appropriate to the characters' circumstances. Daytime scenes exhibit strong clarity; however, they may appear flat due to the subdued color vibrancy. The presentation includes minor technical imperfections, such as occasional shimmering on specific objects and minor banding in some scenes, but these issues are minimal and do not significantly impact the overall viewing experience.
Although there are some drawbacks like slight aliasing and possible edge enhancement in certain shots, the transfer remains technically proficient. The film's visual style, with its dreamy digital camera elements, suits the narrative's somber tone well. While not achieving demo-worthy status, this Blu-ray release offers a faithful and immersive reflection of the film's intended look and feel, making it a commendable effort from Anchor Bay.
Audio: 53
The Blu-ray release of "Texas Killing Fields" features an impressive audio presentation with a DTS-HD Master Audio track that offers a distinct improvement over the original US Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track. Dialogue is delivered with precise clarity across the front and center channels, though occasional on-set recording artifacts are present, which some directors might have opted to refine using ADR. However, this does not detract from the overall quality, as the mix capably handles all elements with finesse. The sound effects, though sparse, are strikingly effective, ranging from gunshots and car chases to the natural ambiance of the marshlands. Notably, thunder effects create a standout auditory experience, immersing viewers robustly.
Complementing this, the Dolby TrueHD 7.1 lossless soundtrack excels in creating an atmospheric environment. While music tends to remain confined to the front speakers, the back channels engage actively when ambient effects are required. The film's immersive soundscape is enriched with natural elements such as passing cars, insects, and rustling leaves, making good use of environmental storytelling. During moments of action, gunshots and other effects vary from crisp to heavily pronounced, while dialogue maintains front-center clarity with no significant distortion. Although not an extraordinary track, it meets expectations admirably without any significant issues.
The English Dolby TrueHD 7.1 track further enhances the film's moody and atmospheric tone, albeit in a somewhat subdued manner. Despite being mostly quiet, the track employs a range of ambient sounds—rainfall, crickets, and automotive noise—that envelop the listener, though some quieter scenes can feel slightly flat. The audio dynamically livens up during action sequences, particularly during an intense chase near the film's conclusion, showcasing powerful bass elements from revving engines and gunshots. Overall, balance is maintained effectively across frequencies, ensuring even whispered dialogue is audible with no major distortion. This audio track offers rigorous sound design that peaks precisely when necessary.
Extras: 13
The Blu Ray of "Texas Killing Fields" offers a modest set of extras that, while limited in quantity, provide some valuable insights into the film's production and narrative inspirations. Notably, the disc includes an audio commentary with Director Ami Canaan Mann and Writer Donald F. Ferrarone, where they delve into casting decisions, location choices, and the real-life events that shaped the story. Mann highlights particular shots and visual elements, providing a deeper understanding of their significance and creation. While there are occasional lulls in the conversation, overall, the commentary is informative. Additionally, the inclusion of the film's trailer in 1080p with Dolby Digital 2.0 sound is a minor yet essential feature.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary Featuring Director Ami Canaan Mann and Writer Donald F. Ferrarone: Discussing casting, locations, production design, and real-life inspirations.
- Trailer: 1080p with Dolby Digital 2.0 sound.
Movie: 50
"Texas Killing Fields" is a moody thriller helmed by Amy Canaan Mann, navigating the often unfavorably crowded genre of serial killer police procedurals. The film possesses a dark, atmospheric tone, enhanced by diligent and, at times, dispassionate direction. While its familiar plotline doesn't break new ground, Mann’s visual touch infuses intermittent flashes of stylistic brilliance. Despite its compelling visual hygiene, the narrative stumbles with choppy pacing and a predictable structure, lacking the momentum needed to engage viewers fully. The storyline involving detectives Mike Souder (Sam Worthington) and Brian Heigh (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) weaves personal and professional conflicts as they track down a serial killer, but unfortunately, it feels derivative and uninspiring.
The film manages to offer some noteworthy performances. Worthington portrays a determined, emotionally nuanced Texas detective effectively while Morgan brings a mix of vulnerability and ethical steadfastness to his role. Jessica Chastain adds considerable depth in her portrayal of Souder's ex-wife, Pam Stall, contributing to an otherwise underutilized ensemble cast that includes Chloe Grace Moretz. However, the character development often feels perfunctory, failing to create a deeper connection with the audience. Backstories are hinted at but never fully integrated into the primary narrative, diluting their potential impact. Consequently, despite competent acting, the characters don’t rise above their archetypal molds.
For collectors and enthusiasts of darker crime dramas, "Texas Killing Fields" offers solid technical merits on Blu-ray. The video quality is notably sharp with an atmospherically rich audio track that amplifies the brooding tone of the film. However, the lack of substantial extras—such as the commentary track included in other region releases—may disappoint some aficionados. Overall, the film exhibits moments of potential and commendable style but ultimately succumbs to genre conventions and narrative fragmentation, leaving it as an average entry into the genre rather than a standout piece.
Total: 46
"Texas Killing Fields" aspires to deliver a gripping thriller but ultimately falls short on multiple fronts. The film opts for familiar crime scene tropes that render it more of an extended procedural drama rather than a novel cinematic experience. Despite possessing a heart, the film's soul feels absent, characterized by sluggish pacing, a disorganized plot, and flat character portrayals. While there are moments of visual and thematic intrigue, they are insufficient to salvage the overall viewing experience, which many audiences will find derivative of numerous similar TV shows.
The Blu-ray release from Anchor Bay provides commendable video and audio quality, with only minor issues interrupting an otherwise solid presentation. However, the disc falls short in terms of supplemental content, featuring only a single commentary track. Although the commentary offers some enriching insights into the film’s production, it does little to elevate the package as a whole.
In summary, "Texas Killing Fields" is an underwhelming thriller that fails to assemble its promising elements into a compelling narrative. The high-quality technical aspects of the Blu-ray cannot compensate for the film’s overarching shortcomings. This release is best suited for a rental rather than a purchase.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
Given a solid 1080p High Definition rendition in the movie’s original theatrical aspect ratio of 2.4:1 widescreen, this is a very respectful reflection of the director’s intended look to the film, complete...
Audio: 80
The score only adds to the atmospheric mix, further giving the surrounds some material to play with and rounding out a suitably potent track that is not quite all-encompassing, but often comes close....
Extras: 10
With Ami Mann hosting, along with the writer as well, fans will be very disappointed that this release, which follows in the wake of the US disc, should drop this single – but vital – extra....
Movie: 80
Fans of the film who aren’t Region-restricted may want to consider looking overseas just to get that extra feature; those who aren’t bothered, or who have no choice but to buy Region B releases shouldn’t...
Total: 70
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Bright daytime scenes tend to show strong clarity but also a general flatness, though fine detail in clothes, faces, and worn-down Texas City residences look awfully good....
Audio: 70
However, the back channels get in on the action when the track calls for ambient elements, which is often....
Extras: 20
Only the Texas Killing Fields trailer (1080p, 2:13) and an audio commentary track with Director Ami Canaan Mann and Writer Donald F. Ferrarone are included....
Movie: 40
Director Ami Canaan Mann, daughter of acclaimed filmmaker Michael Mann (Collateral, Heat), tries to infuse the movie with some style -- and she occasionally succeeds -- but the jumbled story, subpar acting,...
Total: 50
Pacing is sluggish, the plot is ragged, the characters are flat, and the movie's few moments of visual and thematic relevance are washed away by a greater whole that comes up well short of the mark, a...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Based on comments made in the included audio commentary, the movie seems to have been at least partially shot with digital cameras, and there is a light layer of unobtrusive noise visible from time to...
Audio: 60
Dialogue is mostly crisp, but there are some instances where speech sounds a little thin with very minor crackle and background noise....
Extras: 20
There are a few brief pauses in the discussion, but for the most part, the duo offer a steady stream of information....
Movie: 40
While not terrible, the script suffers from a lack of distinction, making it hard to stand above previous, superior efforts in the genre....
Total: 40
Though the cast is strong, as presented, the plot isn't very compelling and the direction stumbles at times....
Director: Ami Canaan Mann
Actors: Sam Worthington, Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Chloë Grace Moretz
PlotDetective Mike Souder and his partner Brian Heigh work in a small Texas town, investigating the disappearance of local women. Their investigation leads them to the desolate, abandoned marshland known as the killing fields, where bodies of murdered women have been discovered over the last two decades. The case becomes personal for Souder when the body count grows, putting a strain on his already troubled relationship with his ex-wife Pam, a fellow detective in the area. Adding to the tension is Anne, a young, neglected girl who frequently comes into contact with the detectives, revealing a disturbing connection to the victims.
As Mike and Brian delve deeper into the case, they encounter various suspects but are continually stymied by lack of evidence. They are forced to confront the grim reality that the killer could be someone from within their community. The mounting pressure to solve the case creates rifts between the two detectives, challenging their professional and personal resolve. Dark secrets begin to surface, leading them to question whom they can trust while racing against time to prevent further murders. The film paints a harrowing picture of obsession and the human cost of a relentless pursuit of justice.
Writers: Don Ferrarone
Release Date: 14 Oct 2011
Runtime: 105 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English