The Black Waters of Echo's Pond Blu-ray Review
Score: 36
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Black Waters of Echo's Pond offers a promising concept marred by poor execution, with only decent audio and video quality saving an otherwise dismal Blu-ray release.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 45
The Black Waters of Echo's Pond Blu-ray offers a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer that, while revealing sharp detail and good shadow delineation, also suffers from inconsistent style, pale black levels, and an overexposed look in daytime scenes. Despite some technical flaws such as minor noise and blocky backdrops, the clarity and gruesome gore details remain solid and true to the source.
Audio: 50
The Black Waters of Echo's Pond features a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track that, while not spectacular, provides a balanced and immersive experience. Heavy bass can occasionally overwhelm dialogue, but the soundstage offers clear effects and solid low-frequency kick during action scenes, enhancing the film's horror elements effectively.
Extra: 6
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Black Waters of Echo's Pond' include only an alternate opening sequence—offered in both SD (2:36) and HD 1080i (3 min) with Dolby Digital 2.0 audio, described as a gorier yet equally unnecessary flashback.
Movie: 16
The Black Waters of Echo's Pond makes a futile attempt to blend classic horror and board game premises similar to Jumanji and Evil Dead, but is marred by a low budget, poor acting, weak storytelling, and lack of character depth. Despite notable contributors like Robert Patrick and Danielle Harris, the film fails to deliver anything beyond gory but uninspired scenes.
Video: 45
"The Black Waters of Echo's Pond" is presented on Blu-ray with a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. While the film’s low-budget origins are evident, it offers a reasonably detailed and technically solid visual experience. Facial details and textures around key settings, including the house and the pivotal board game, are sharply captured in parts. However, the visuals suffer from inconsistency; numerous scenes exhibit a softer, less defined look. The picture quality remains clear enough to effectively showcase the film's extensive gore, particularly in the latter acts. The saturated reds and moody lighting add some vividness, but overall, the film adheres to a rather flat and dim color palette.
Black levels are mostly steady, providing decent shadow delineation despite occasional pale appearances. Flesh tones are somewhat pasty and lack vibrancy, contributing to the general low-grade video feel of both the sepia-toned prologue and the subsequent modern-day sequences. The film exhibits clean and artifact-free visuals for the most part, though minor noise and false contouring occasionally emerge, particularly in darker scenes and certain sky shots. The image frequently appears blown out in daytime scenes, and blocky backdrops are not uncommon, further highlighting the low-budget production quality.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray presentation of "The Black Waters of Echo's Pond" is true to its source material albeit with evident limitations. While it doesn't present an aesthetically beautiful image, it achieves a balance between clarity and authenticity to the original film, providing a satisfactory viewing experience given its budget constraints.
Audio: 50
The Black Waters of Echo's Pond features a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack that, while not exemplary, provides an adequate aural experience. The mix leans heavily on bass, which can sometimes overpower dialogue, particularly in the opening scenes. Despite this, the various sounds of horror—from revving chainsaws to gunshots—are conveyed with robust low-frequency impact. The subtler elements, such as nighttime atmospherics and the placement of ambient noises like crickets and crackling fires, create a reasonably convincing soundscape. Dialogue generally remains clear and full-bodied, maintaining coherence even amid the chaotic sequences.
These technical attributes ensure the sound design works effectively for the film's intent. The heavy, violent sequences are impactful, enhanced by the soundtrack's heft and volume. However, the balance isn't always perfect, with some music cues and effects occasionally overshadowing speech. The stage presence is quite good, whether in a cacophony of horror or simple ambient acts such as bottles breaking off-screen. While the track falls short of the truly great horror soundtracks, it ultimately offers a balanced and engaging auditory experience from start to finish.
In summation, while The Black Waters of Echo's Pond may not provide a memorable audio experience on par with high-end horror films, it successfully instills a creepy and aggressive atmosphere that serves the film's narrative and genre conventions adequately.
Extras: 6
The extras included with the Blu-ray release of "The Black Waters of Echo's Pond" provide a modest but noteworthy addition to the main feature. Anchored by an alternate opening presented in both standard and high definition (with an unnecessary yet slightly gorier sequence), the supplemental material offers some insight into the filmmaker's creative decisions. The alternate opening is available in 1080i resolution with Dolby Digital 2.0 audio, catering to technical enthusiasts seeking comprehensive AV quality.
Extras included in this disc:
- Alternate Opening: A more violent but largely unnecessary flashback sequence, presented in 1080i with Dolby Digital 2.0 audio.
Movie: 16
“The Black Waters of Echo's Pond,” a low-budget horror film, attempts to merge the elements of classic fantasy adventure films like "Jumanji" and "Zathura" with the horror intensity of "Evil Dead." Unfortunately, the film falters significantly in execution, despite a premise that holds substantial potential. Set in 1927 Turkey with a group of explorers discovering a demonic board game and fast-forwarding to modern-day Maine where a group of twenty-somethings unwittingly unseal the ancient curse, the story quickly devolves into a predictable and chaotic bloodbath.
While noteworthy actors like Robert Patrick and Danielle Harris can be found in the cast, their performances do little to elevate the clichéd and painfully stereotypical characters. The narrative is convoluted, introducing numerous personal conflicts and secrets among the characters, only to use these as weak pretexts for eventual violence. As the demonic influence grows, the friends turn on one another under supernatural coercion, but the intended suspense is lost due to the film's lack of cohesive direction and authenticity.
The special effects, though competent in delivering gore, provide little else. Scenes intended to be terrifying or tense fall flat, culminating in uninspired and uninvolving sequences of supernatural mayhem and violence. The character dynamics, script, and overall film composition often feel amateurish, riddled with awkward dialogues and disjointed plotting. Despite the infusion of horror staples such as demonic possessions and grotesque creatures, the movie remains devoid of genuine scares or emotional investment. For those seeking quality horror, opting for genre staples like "The Conjuring" or revisiting the original "Evil Dead" would be a far more satisfying experience.
Total: 36
"The Black Waters of Echo's Pond" presents an intriguing concept with its demonic board game premise, but unfortunately, it fails to capitalize on this potential. Despite the abundance of gross-out violence catering to gore enthusiasts, the film's weak character development and artificial story arcs detract significantly from its overall impact. The amateurish direction, clumsy acting, and lack of genuine scares further undermine the experience. Moreover, the movie's low-budget nature is evident in its production values, which fail to compensate for its numerous shortcomings.
Anchor Bay's Blu-ray release of "The Black Waters of Echo's Pond" delivers a mixed bag in terms of technical quality. While the video and audio presentations manage to maintain a decent standard, they are far from impressive. The video quality explicitly reveals the film's low-budget roots, with mediocre clarity and detail. The audio fares slightly better, providing adequate but unremarkable sound. The release is notably lacking in substantial supplements, offering only a brief and largely insignificant alternate opening.
In conclusion, "The Black Waters of Echo's Pond" is a rather disappointing entry in the slasher horror genre. Its combination of a lackluster narrative, poor acting, and subpar production values results in a forgettable viewing experience. Horror aficionados seeking depth or frights are likely to be left wanting. Anchor Bay's Blu-ray does little to elevate the film, making it hard to recommend this release. While some low-end horror fans might find it worth a watch, most would do well to skip this one.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 60
However, it is clear enough to showcase much of the nasty gore that appears in the second and, primarily, third acts....
Audio: 70
More subtle nighttime atmospherics are well implemented, and general stage presence is quite good, whether in the most chaotic spread of violence or the simple act of a character throwing a bottle and...
Extras: 10
All that's included with this Blu-ray release of The Black Waters of Echo's Pond is an alternate opening (SD, 2:36)....
Movie: 20
They're all Horror fodder of the worst kind, wannabe deep characters who just come across as needlessly and, ultimately, incompletely shaped for a movie of this scope and ambition....
Total: 40
It's quite gory, but the characters are poorly drawn and saddled with artificial arcs that only serve as a framework for the slicing and dicing to come....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The source is mostly clean and artifact free, but there is some minor noise in dark scenes and some marginal false contouring visible in certain shots of the sky....
Audio: 60
Dialogue is clear and full-bodied throughout, but as one might expect, there's a fair amount of spooky, overwhelming music cues that can overpower speech....
Extras: 0
Alternate Openning (HD, 3 min) - Presented in 1080i with Dolby Digital 2.0 audio, this is an alternate, slightly gorier and equally stupid and unnecessary flashback opening sequence....
Movie: 0
Initially all this really leads to is a droll series of clunky scenes where the group yells at each other for all the horrible things they've done, and these sequences play out like a really bad afterschool...
Total: 40
The demonic board game premise has some potential and there is a lot of gross-out violence for gore-junkies, but the acting is clumsy, the drama is forced, the direction is exceedingly amateur, and there...
Director: Gabriel Bologna
Actors: Danielle Harris, James Duval, Robert Patrick
PlotA group of friends decides to vacation on a remote island and stay in an old mansion that one of them inherited. While exploring, they discover a hidden door in the basement, leading to a dark room filled with unusual artifacts and an ancient, mysterious board game. Intrigued and seeking thrills, they decide to play the game, unaware of its sinister origins. As the game progresses, dark secrets and unresolved conflicts among the friends are revealed, exposing hidden animosities and tensions. Deeper into the night, the game begins to have a horrifying influence on them, causing hallucinations and driving wedges between even the closest companions.
Unsettling events escalate as malevolent forces from the game take hold, pitting the friends against each other in a fight for survival. As paranoia and violence intensify, the group must uncover the truth behind the mansion’s history and the game’s curse. Facing their fears and the real possibility of betrayal from within their ranks, they desperately search for a way to end the malevolence gripping them before it’s too late. Each turn of the game brings them closer to a terrifying revelation that threatens to consume them all. The desperate struggle to break the game's hold tests their sanity and friendships, leading to an unforgettable and chilling conclusion.
Writers: Michael Berenson, Gabriel Bologna, Sean Clark
Release Date: 09 Apr 2010
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English