United 93 Blu-ray Review

"United 93" is presented in a VC-1 encoded 1080p transfer in the film's original 2.35:1 aspect ratio. Paul Greengrass’ commitment to a verit� aesthetic results in numerous scenes filmed with natural lighting, leading to increased grain, particularly in low-light sequences. Despite this, the overall image is remarkably sharp, especially in scenes blessed by the early autumn light. The recreation of fall’s golden hues penetrating the airplane windows and the blue-green hue of air traffic control screens are noteworthy highlights, with colors maintaining a natural and lifelike appearance. The fine details are exceptional, especially in close-ups, providing a profound depth of field and clarity. However, some darker scenes, particularly in shadowy areas, do suffer from minor crush.

The comparison between the Blu-ray and previous DVD version reveals significant improvements. The Blu-ray boasts a sharp, highly detailed picture with an even color palette that far surpasses the gritty and grainy DVD quality. The grain present is naturalistic, enhancing the film's authenticity without the artificial effects of digital noise reduction. Skin tones match their settings perfectly, and despite the film's muted color scheme, the Blu-ray provides an optimal visual representation as intended by the filmmakers. Additionally, there is a notable absence of dust, scratches, or damage, except for some stock footage that exhibits inconsistent quality and graininess.

In summary, while "United 93" may not serve as demo material on par with colorful animated films or modern action fare, it excels in its faithful reproduction of the theatrical release and aligns closely with the director’s vision. Frequent instances of blown-out whites in brightly lit airplane scenes and near flawless black levels enhance the immersion, keeping technical flaws to a minimum. This Blu-ray transfer stands as a commendable release for this intense and poignant film.

"United 93" boasts an exceptionally engaging and immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, executed with remarkable precision. The film’s audio track initially sets a quiet, atmospheric tone as characters arrive at Newark airport, punctuated by detailed surround elements. The auditory dynamics intensify significantly once on the tarmac, with jet engines delivering robust LFE and meticulously crafted panning effects. Dialogue is expertly positioned within the soundfield, maintaining clarity even amidst the confined spaces of the aircraft or air traffic control towers. The fidelity of the track is impeccable, offering a rich spectrum across all frequency ranges. It's noteworthy that even during the chaotic climax, the mix remains clear and well-separated, highlighting the excellence in sound design.

The audio's immersive quality extends further with stunning ambient effects that enhance the film's realistic portrayal. From the subtle creaks of the plane’s fuselage to the continuous hum of a printer at Boston Air Traffic Control, each sound effect contributes to a compelling auditory experience. The music score stands out as well, effectively using percussion to heighten tension and transition scenes smoothly. The LFE is particularly impactful, resonating powerfully during takeoffs and intense drum sequences in the score. The surround imaging from front to rear and left to right encapsulates the listener, delivering an enveloping and engaging auditory presence.

Overall, the soundtrack impresses not just through its expansive capabilities but also in its ability to convey intimate, realistic moments. While it may lack the overwhelming chaos of large-scale action films or CGI spectacles, it excels in portraying a more grounded and authentic audio landscape. This balanced mix of grandiosity and subtlety makes "United 93" a standout example of superior sound engineering in film.

The Blu-ray release of "United 93" offers a detailed and emotional collection of extras that enhance the understanding of both the film's creation and the events of 9/11. The director's commentary by Paul Greengrass is particularly compelling, offering deep insights into the film’s production, the sensitivities involved, and the broader implications of the tragic events. The included documentaries, such as "United 93: The Families and the Film" and "Chasing Planes: Witnesses to 9/11," provide first-hand accounts and touching interviews with those directly affected. These supplements not only expand on the movie's narrative but also give a poignant, real-world context that adds to its impact.

Extras included in this disc:

• Feature Commentary by Director Paul Greengrass: In-depth commentary providing insights into the film’s creation and sensitive handling of the subject matter.
• United 93: The Families and the Film: Documentary on the interaction between the filmmakers and the families of Flight 93 passengers.
• Chasing Planes: Witnesses to 9/11: Focuses on air traffic controllers' experiences during the hijackings.
• Memorial Pages: Access to biographical data on Flight 93 passengers.
• Twin Towers: Trailer for an Oscar-winning documentary about two brothers involved in the tragedy.
• Flight 93 National Memorial: Video dedicated to the Shanksville memorial.

"United 93," directed by Paul Greengrass, is a harrowing and emotionally charged depiction of the tragic events of September 11, 2001. The film begins with a solemn portrayal of the terrorists preparing for their grim mission, a narrative choice that underscores the disquieting human element behind the attacks. Greengrass refrains from providing detailed backstories for the passengers, opting instead for a quasi-documentary style that relies on snippets of dialogue to convey their ordinary lives. This approach heightens the emotional impact, as the audience already knows the heartbreaking fate awaiting these individuals. The film methodically builds tension, blending moments of banal routine with the surreal unfolding of real-time horror, thus evoking an intense sense of empathy and dread.

The narrative control extends beyond Flight 93 to include scenes from air traffic control centers, FAA headquarters, and NORAD, masterfully illustrating the broader chaos and confusion of that day. The film’s authenticity is amplified by Ben Sliney, an actual FAA National Operation Manager, playing himself, which lends an extraordinary level of realism. The technical aspects of “United 93” are equally commendable—the handheld camera work immerses viewers into the action, creating an almost visceral experience. The minimalist musical score acts as a ticking clock, further intensifying the sense of urgency and inevitability. Greengrass’s decision to abstain from sensationalism allows the raw human emotions and collective bravery to take center stage, particularly during the passengers' final valiant effort to thwart their captors.

"United 93" stands out not only for its cinematic craftsmanship but also for its respectful and poignant tribute to the heroes of that day. It confronts viewers with the harrowing realities of terror while celebrating the indomitable human spirit. The narrative’s commitment to truth, bolstered by stunning technical execution, offers a powerful memorial that both preserves and honors the memories of those who perished.

The Blu-ray presentation of "United 93" is undoubtedly a testament to the film's stark portrayal of the tragic events of September 11th. With precise and skillful filmmaking, it captures an experience that remains seared into the collective memory of many. Technically, the Blu-ray disc excels with its superior video quality, showcasing sharpness, color accuracy, and detail that are vastly improved over earlier DVD releases. The audio experience is immersive, boasting a near-perfect surround sound track that balances power and subtlety, heightening the emotional impact without straying into sensationalism.

Enthusiastically recommended for its potent combination of emotional resonance and technical excellence, "United 93" stands out as both a memorial and a cinematic achievement. The performances are subtly authentic, enhancing the film’s immediacy and somber tone. For viewers who can handle the intense emotional ride, this Blu-ray is an essential addition to their collection. The presentation retains a composed and clear-headed technique, refusing to sensationalize or trivialize the harrowing events it depicts, an approach that respects both the subject matter and the audience.

The tenth anniversary of 9/11 provides an opportunity to reflect and remember a day marked by profound loss and heroism. With "United 93," you’ll be drawn back into the chilling intensity of that morning, finding it both difficult to watch and yet compellingly executed. If you can bear to relive the moments captured in this film, the high-quality Blu-ray presentation makes it an invaluable viewing experience. Highly recommended for its emotional depth and technical prowess—whether for purchase or rental—this Blu-ray edition allows for a reflective engagement with one of history’s defining moments.