The Pink Panther 2 Blu-ray Review
Score: 56
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
High-end home theater gear reviewed with a critique on 'The Pink Panther 2's' lackluster comedy and Blu-ray quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 67
'The Pink Panther 2' Blu-ray excels with a stunning, vibrant transfer and detailed sound, overshadowing the film's own quality.
Audio: 56
'The Pink Panther 2' on Blu-ray boasts a clear, detailed DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack with crisp dialogue and the iconic theme music, offering an enjoyable yet unobtrusive audio experience.
Extra: 51
The Pink Panther 2 Blu-ray set features the film, lackluster extras across 3 discs, including a digital copy and 27 grainy classic cartoons. Extras seem uninspired, highlighting cast efforts but feeling overhyped and underwhelming.
Movie: 31
'The Pink Panther 2' impresses with strong Blu-ray visuals and audio yet falters with its lackluster humor and plot, disappointing fans despite its star-filled cast.
Video: 67
'The Pink Panther 2' dazzles on Blu-ray with its outstanding video quality, framed at a theatre-like aspect ratio of 1.85:1. The Blu-ray showcases a stellar AVC/MPEG-4 transfer, highlighting the film's vivid and lively color palette and maintaining lifelike skin tones across a range of characters. Viewers can expect a high level of detail, particularly in the picturesque nighttime scenes of Paris, which display deep, solid blacks and excellent contrast. The clarity and sharpness are commendable, with no evidence of artificial enhancement or film grain that distracts from the movie’s visual appeal. This transfer manages to retain the filmic essence, ensuring that the eye-catching details and the overall vibrancy of the scenes truly stand out.
Despite the movie’s shortcomings, its Blu-ray presentation delivers a near-reference experience that boasts high-level detail and dynamic colors. The depth and texture in both brightly lit scenes and darker moments are particularly noteworthy, providing a sense of three-dimensionality that enhances the viewing experience. Rich textures in Parisian streets and a brilliant color reproduction make every scene leap off the screen. However, some inconsistencies in flesh tones and occasional aliasing are minor drawbacks in an otherwise exceptional visual presentation.
The technical prowess extends beyond just the picture quality. The AVC MPEG-4 encode ensures that images are crisply defined and colors are beautifully saturated, even if the film itself fails to fully utilize this visual potential. The absence of notable film grain and the carefully managed sharpening contribute to a clean and immersive experience. Despite some critique over its contrast levels and a less pronounced three-dimensional feel in certain sequences, 'The Pink Panther 2' Blu-ray offers a visually stunning presentation that well exceeds the cinematic value of the film itself.
Audio: 56
"The Pink Panther 2" arrives on Blu-ray with a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 channel surround track that effectively showcases the film's audio landscape. The mix prioritizes clear, distinct dialogue, ensuring that interactions, including Clouseau's unique 'Franglais', are easily understandable. Dialogue is anchored in the centre channel, maintaining clarity even amidst the film's diverse array of sound effects and ambient noises such as traffic and occasional gunfire. The iconic Pink Panther theme, a highlight of the audio presentation, is delivered with warmth and nostalgia, engaging the main stereo channels to great effect. Despite its overall balance, the mix occasionally incorporates the subwoofer, adding a subtle but appreciated depth to specific moments without overwhelming the sonic environment.
The soundtrack displays its technical prowess with a dynamic range that captures both the subtlety of background details and the punch of more pronounced sound effects with equal finesse. Low frequency effects are used judiciously, enhancing the soundtrack's texture without dominating it. The effective use of ambient sounds contributes to an immersive auditory experience, particularly in sequences designed to showcase the film's vibrant scoring and sound design. Notably, Henry Mancini's legendary theme not only bookends the movie but also underscores its timeless appeal, sounding better than ever in this current audio incarnation.
While mostly centered around dialogue, the audio mix occasionally ventures into more active territory, utilizing the surround channels to envelop the listener. Sound effects, although used sparingly, are well placed within the soundstage, adding to the film's playful tone without distracting from the narrative flow. Ambient sounds and directional effects contribute to a sense of space and location, further elevating the viewing experience. Despite a few instances where accents may muddy the clarity of speech, overall, the audio presentation of "The Pink Panther 2" on Blu-ray is both respectful of its source material and adept at enhancing its comedic elements, making for an enjoyable listening experience.
Extras: 51
The Blu-ray release of "The Pink Panther 2" is a mixed bag when it comes to extras, served across a three-disc set. The highlights include a gag reel that, while standard, offers a few chuckles with its behind-the-scenes mishaps. "Drama is Easy...Comedy is Dangerous" and "A Dream Team like no other" are featurettes where the cast and crew lavish praise on their efforts and Steve Martin's comedic prowess, though they might leave viewers wanting more substance rather than self-congratulation. The interactive game "Master Thief - Global Crime Showdown" adds a playful element to the set. However, the absence of a director's commentary is noted and somewhat diminishes the depth of available insights into the film's production. The inclusion of 27 classic Pink Panther cartoons on DVD provides a nostalgic value that arguably overshadows the film-related extras, catering to enthusiasts of the iconic character despite the standard definition presentation. The digital copy, while a standard inclusion, extends the viewing options to portable devices, ensuring fans can enjoy the movie on the go.
Extras included in this disc:
- Gag Reel: A collection of outtakes and mishaps from the movie set.
- Drama is Easy...Comedy is Dangerous: Featurette with interviews and behind-the-scenes footage.
- A Dream Team Like no Other: Cast and crew discuss the making of the film.
- Master Thief - Global Crime Showdown: An interactive game challenging players to steal artifacts.
- Bonus Disc 1: DVD containing 27 classic Pink Panther cartoons.
- Bonus Disc 2: Digital Copy for portable media device compatibility.
Movie: 31
"The Pink Panther 2" arrives on Blu-ray with a presentation that is likely to be the highlight of the package for any fan hoping to relive—or perhaps discover—the latest escapades of the bumbling Inspector Jacques Clouseau. The AVC/MPEG-4 transfer shines with an aspect ratio of 1.85:1, showcasing vibrant colors, deep blacks, and a level of detail that does justice to every frame. However, it's partnered with a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that, while delivering clear dialogue and a subtle use of surrounds for an overall pleasant auditory experience, may not astound those looking for a more dynamic audio showcase typical of more recent cinematic offerings.
The film itself, starring Steve Martin as Clouseau alongside an impressive ensemble including Jean Reno, Alfred Molina, and Andy Garcia, aims to capture the spirit of slapstick and quirky humor that defined the original series. However, it struggles beneath the weight of a script that seems to meander through a series of vignettes rather than a cohesive plot, squandering its potential on predictability and rehashed jokes that rarely hit their mark. Despite an all-star cast's commendable efforts in inhabiting their roles, their talents are ultimately undercut by the film's inability to weave together its narrative and comedic aspirations effectively.
Technical merits aside, "The Pink Panther 2" fails to recapture the charm and wit that made Inspector Clouseau a beloved figure in cinematic comedy. While the Blu-ray offers a commendable visual and audio experience, the movie itself is mired by a script that leaves much to be desired and comedic misfires that even Steve Martin's portrayal cannot salvage. This installment, unfortunately, suggests that perhaps some memories of great characters are better left untouched, as it struggles to find its footing in both humor and storytelling.
Total: 56
"The Pink Panther 2" on Blu-ray presents an intriguing case study in balancing the technical prowess of a home theater release against the content quality of the film itself. Reviewing the overall presentation of the disc, it's evident that the quality of playback equipment and setup can significantly influence the viewing experience. Utilized were top-tier devices including a JVC DLA-RS20 1080p High Definition Front Projector calibrated by Jeff Meier, an Oppo BDP-83 Universal disc/Blu-ray Player for crystal-clear video output, and a high-quality audio setup featuring Denon AVR 5308CI preamp/video processor and Canton Ergo Series speakers among other premium components. These provided an optimal testing environment to evaluate the technical merits of this Blu-ray release.
The film, described as underwhelming in terms of comedy and narrative engagement, proves to be a lackluster sequel, lacking in substance and humor. Despite the movie's predictable plot and sparse comedic moments, MGM's Blu-ray release shines in technical execution, offering excellent video and audio quality that may appeal to audiophiles and videophiles. The package also includes appealing bonus features, notably a generous inclusion of over two dozen Pink Panther cartoons and a digital copy of the film, adding value for collectors or fans of the franchise who might derive enjoyment from these additions despite the film's shortcomings.
In conclusion, while "The Pink Panther 2" fails to deliver as a memorable sequel or stand-alone comedy, the Blu-ray presentation showcases commendable technical quality and offers sufficient bonus content to merit consideration by fans or completists of the series. The high-definition video and audio renderings are particularly praise-worthy, creating an immersive viewing experience that somewhat mitigates the film's narrative and comedic failings. This release underscores the disparity between content quality and presentation excellence, making it a mixed bag that is best appreciated by dedicated fans or those particularly interested in the bonus Pink Panther cartoons.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 80
No noticeable ringing around contours or faces made me feel that someone had left the sharpening tool alone, yet the image was pin sharp with the famous 3D 'pop' that we were so fond of mentioning in the...
Audio: 70
Surrounds are used mainly to provide general hubbub, including traffic noise, gunfire etc - but none of it fights with the dialogue for your attention....
Extras: 60
Some of it is quite amusing, but it's the usual fare of blown lines and mis-haps that we see rather a lot of in movie extras these days....
Movie: 50
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track is good if unspectacular for a recent movie but we get clear dialogue and gentle use of surrounds that make for pleasant listening....
Total: 60
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Top-notch detail is visible throughout; the opening sequence featuring Clouseau working with an unruly motorist who refuses a parking ticket reveals striking details across the board, from the clothing...
Audio: 80
Outside of dialogue and music, the track features only the occasional sound effect of any import, and even fewer still that manage to penetrate the back of the soundstage....
Extras: 60
The true highlight of the package comes on disc three, a DVD where viewers will find 27 classic "Pink Panther" Cartoons....
Movie: 20
It does manage to continue on with the romance that began brewing between Clouseau and Nicole (Emily Mortimer, Redbelt) in The Pink Panther, but it introduces, and completely out of left field at that,...
Total: 50
Sadly, the film isn't even remotely funny most of the time to make up for its predictable nature....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
However, the film doesn't possess a real three dimensional feel, as it never really pops, even in the more cartoonish of sequences, so when an opening credit sequence takes the cake in terms of visual...
Audio: 60
I say for the most part, as a few early lines are a bit indistinguishable, and later banter between Reno and Martin can be a bit of a blur due to the flat awful accents....
Extras: 40
Completely passable due to the insistence of all involved in acting like this film is the second coming....
Movie: 20
Martin's partner in crime for the first film, Beyonce, isn't back with her amazingly high spoken word to cringe ratio, but a bevy of shameless former stars do their best to make up for her absence....
Total: 40
Not even the extras package with the spiffy third disc makes this one worthwhile, though said disc does make this the version to buy (more so than the high def video and audio)....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
Dialogue is firmly planted in the center channel and clearly renders voices and effects with appropriate distinction and balance within the front soundstage....
Audio: 84
Dialogue is firmly planted in the center channel and clearly renders voices and effects with appropriate distinction and balance within the front soundstage....
Extras: 50
dangerous - 7 minute featurette (HD) A Dream Team like no other - 14 minute featurette (HD) Master thief - Global crime showdown - interactive trivia game Bonus Disc 1: DVD containing 27 classic Pink Panther...
Movie: 40
When legendary treasures from around the world are stolen, including the priceless Pink Panther diamond, Clouseau is assigned to a dream team of international detectives who are under pressure to bring...
Total: 66
Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio...
Director: Harald Zwart
Actors: Steve Martin, Jean Reno, Emily Mortimer
PlotInspector Jacques Clouseau is called back into action when the infamous Pink Panther diamond is stolen, along with a series of other thefts around the world. The thief, known only as "The Tornado," has taken artifacts from various locations, prompting an international uproar. To recover these priceless items and solve the case, Clouseau joins a dream team of international detectives, bringing his unique, sometimes clumsy, methods to the group. Each member is a top sleuth from their respective countries, creating a dynamic yet conflicting team dynamic as they embark on their mission.
The investigation leads the team across Europe, following a trail of clues that seem to mock their every move. Clouseau's unconventional techniques often lead to humorous mishaps but also unexpected insights. While the rest of the team tries to stick to traditional methods, Clouseau's persistence and unorthodox approach begin to win them over. Amidst the high-stakes chase, Clouseau's relationship with his team and his potential love interest, Nicole, begins to deepen, showcasing his development from a solely comedic figure to a more rounded character. As they get closer to the thief, the team must learn to work together, leveraging their diverse skills and Clouseau's peculiarities to solve the mystery.
Writers: Scott Neustadter, Michael H. Weber, Steve Martin
Release Date: 06 Feb 2009
Runtime: 92 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States
Language: English, French, Spanish, Italian