Bee Movie Blu-ray Review
Score: 66
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Bee Movie: Mixed reviews on story, top marks for Blu-ray quality.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 76
Bee Movie" impresses with a stunning 1080p Blu-ray transfer, boasting vibrant colors, meticulous details, and clean imagery that highlights DreamWorks' digital artistry, though slightly less immersive than Pixar's texture-rich style.
Audio: 60
'Bee Movie's Dolby TrueHD 5.1 sound offers crisp dialogues and effective use of LFE, smoothly navigating between surround channels with balanced, natural-sounding voices, despite occasional volume adjustments.
Extra: 67
Bee Movie Blu-ray packs myriad extras, from engaging behind-the-scenes glimpses to lesser interactive features, blending humor, animation insights, and promotions with varying reception.
Movie: 50
Bee Movie, envisioned by Jerry Seinfeld, misses its mark as a comedy with forced humor and an unfocused plot, despite its vibrant visuals and satirical undertones on societal contributions and legal absurdities.
Video: 76
DreamWorks’ “Bee Movie” on Blu-ray flaunts an exceptional visual presentation, leveraging the strengths of a meticulously crafted 1080p AVC-encoded transfer that brings the animated world to vibrant life. The digital craftsmanship is apparent in every frame, boasting clean lines and a rich tapestry of textures that capture attention and admiration. Viewers are treated to a dazzling display of colors that are bright and distinct without being oversaturated, allowing for a visual experience where every hue pops without bleeding into one another. The animation studio’s commitment to detail is unmistakable, from the intricacies of the characters' appearances—the fine hair on Barry's head and the stitches on his sweater—to the dynamic backgrounds and environments. This attention to minutiae extends to the charming representation of fuzzy textures on objects such as tennis balls, elevating the visuals to a nearly three-dimensional quality.
The brilliance of this Blu-ray presentation does not stop at its spectacular color range and sharpness. The deep, inky blacks and commendable contrast levels enhance the visual depth, adding to the overall clarity and immersion. DreamWorks has succeeded in creating scenes filled with a vast array of characters and elements, all rendered with the same level of precision. This becomes especially evident in scenes where Barry ventures into the outside world; the explosion of detail and color makes for an unforgettable visual experience. Despite a few minor instances of banding, the transfer remains exceptionally clean without any significant artifacting, noise, or other distractions that might detract from the viewing experience.
However, despite these strengths, comparisons to Pixar’s offerings reveal slight differences in artistic style that some may find render "Bee Movie's" visuals slightly less impactful. DreamWorks' animation, while stunning, adopts a cartoon-flavored aesthetic that may look somewhat flatter next to Pixar's use of textured and subtly lit environments found in their high-definition releases. Nonetheless, this does not significantly detract from the Blu-ray’s appeal as a visual spectacle. The direct digital transfer ensures a technical proficiency that dazzles and entertains, establishing “Bee Movie” as a noteworthy high-definition achievement that both fans and newcomers will enjoy for its visual prowess and animation artistry.
Audio: 60
DreamWorks' "Bee Movie" is presented with a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 audio track that expertly balances clarity, depth, and immersion. The dialogue, critical for an animated feature relying heavily on its voice work, is exceptionally well-handled, anchored firmly in the center channel to ensure voices are consistently crisp, clear, and naturally smooth. This precision allows for each actor’s performance to be appreciated fully without ever sounding tinny or harsh. Surround usage enhances key moments effectively, with ambient sounds and directional audio bringing scenes to life — from the bustling activity within the hive to the dynamic flight of the Pollen Jocks, creating a realistic and enveloping soundscape.
However, the audio experience isn’t without its minor setbacks. Some viewers might find the overall volume slightly lower than expected, necessitating a modest increase in amplification to achieve the optimal listening level. Despite this, the sound design excels in its spatial distribution, creating a seamless auditory journey that tracks movement and action across the soundstage with impressive accuracy. The LFE channel is employed judiciously, adding meaningful impact to specific scenes without overwhelming the mix, enriching the viewing experience with a solid foundation of bass when required.
The soundtrack’s adept manipulation of rear channels and selective but impactful use of LFE underscore the meticulous sound mixing that went into the film's production. Instances of naturalistic panning and strategic placement of sound elements across the channels conjure an immersive auditory illusion, sometimes making sounds appear to emanate from beyond the confines of the speakers. While there are moments where ambient noise could stand for improvement and the whimsical sound design might not convince in quieter scenes, the Dolby TrueHD track overall enhances "Bee Movie," ensuring that its audio presentation is as engaging and delightful as its visuals.
Extras: 67
The Blu-ray extras for "Bee Movie" present a wide array of content that caters to both kids and adults, mixing educational features with light-hearted entertainment. The audio commentary might disappoint those looking for in-depth insights due to its lackadaisical nature; however, it provides a casual, albeit unfocused, look behind the scenes with Jerry Seinfeld and team. The deep dive into the technical aspects of animation in "Tech of Bee Movie" is concise yet informative, contrasting the more playful and less enlightening "Meet Barry B. Benson" interactive feature. Highlights include "Inside the Hive: The Cast of 'Bee Movie'," offering delightful glimpses of the actors at work, and "TV Juniors," delivering genuine laughs reminiscent of Seinfeld's humor. The DreamWorks Kids section, with its blend of creative and educational content, ensures younger viewers have plenty to engage with, albeit other extras like the music video and DreamWorks Animation Video Jukebox might not hold the viewer's interest. Ultimately, the extras feature a mix of hits and misses, with the hits providing enough entertainment and insight to make exploring them worthwhile.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Roundtable discussion with Jerry Seinfeld and crew.
- Lost Scenes and Alternate Endings: Rough animatics and storyboards for unseen content.
- Inside the Hive: A detailed look behind the scenes with the cast.
- TV Juniors: Mockumentary-style shorts promoting the film.
- Tech of Bee Movie: Insight into the animation and technical aspects.
- Live Action Trailers: Promotional trailers featuring Seinfeld.
- Jerry’s Flight Over Cannes: Publicity stunt at Cannes Film Festival.
- Meet Barry B. Benson: Interactive Q&A with limited engagement.
- We Got the Bee - Music Video: A less compelling musical addition.
- DreamWorks Animation Video Jukebox: Collection of musical clips from DreamWorks animations.
- Trailers: Previews for other DreamWorks feature films.
- DreamWorks Kids: Educational and creative activities for children.
Movie: 50
Jerry Seinfeld's "Bee Movie," a high-profile DreamWorks animated feature, flies into the realm of home entertainment with a buzz, albeit one that hovers uneasily between innovative satire and missed opportunities. Seinfeld's venture into animation emerges as a visually vibrant journey, presenting the life of Barry A. Benson (voiced by Seinfeld himself) with all the polish and color we've come to expect from high-definition releases. The Blu-ray disc shines technically, boasting an excellent lossless soundtrack that enhances the viewing experience, alongside a multitude of extras that may sweeten the deal for potential buyers on the fence.
Despite its impressive presentation and Seinfeld's celebrated comedic mind behind its creation, "Bee Movie" struggles to fully capitalize on its premise. The narrative, which ambitiously tackles themes of individuality, societal contribution, and environmental consciousness, often feels disjointed. Diverting into a court drama that playfully mocks America's litigious nature, the film shifts focus from Barry’s adventures and his interactions with the human world, including his friendship with Vanessa (Renée Zellweger), to a broader yet less cohesive commentary on labor and justice. These plot shifts and thematic explorations, while inventive, leave viewers in a muddle, especially younger audiences, possibly diluting the impact of its intended messages.
The humor of "Bee Movie," laden with pop culture references and situational comedy typical of Seinfeld's oeuvre, does not always hit the mark. Whereas DreamWorks tends to lean on contemporary jokes and sarcasm, this approach might alienate viewers expecting the timeless wit found in rival studios' works. Notwithstanding strong vocal performances from a star-studded cast, including Matthew Broderick and a humorously cast John Goodman, and moments of genuine laughter—particularly those spoofing iconic film scenes—the overall comedic effort feels inconsistent. Ultimately, "Bee Movie" oscillates between moments of brilliance and zones of mediocrity, never fully realizing its potential as either a thought-provoking parable or a universally engaging animated comedy.
Total: 66
"Bee Movie" on Blu-ray presents an intriguing dichotomy between its content and technical presentation. The film itself, a DreamWorks animation endeavor, often stumbles in its attempt to weave together comedy and life lessons, delivering a mixed bag of genuinely funny moments and plots that may confuse or elude its younger audience. Critics describe the narrative as convoluted and peppered with inane references that fall flat, juxtaposing this with its brilliant high-definition visual quality that stands on par with, if not surpasses, contemporaries like "Happy Feet" and "Ratatouille." Despite the movie's lackluster impact on both adults and children alike, it garners praise for its A-grade effort in animation quality, achieving a pinnacle in Blu-ray presentation with its vivid video transfer and comprehensive, high-definition supplementary material.
The Blu-ray edition shines where the storytelling falters, elevating "Bee Movie" through its technical merits. The disc is lauded for a pristine video quality that delights the visual senses and a TrueHD audio track that, while slightly underwhelming, supports the viewing experience adequately. Additionally, the abundance of special features, many exclusive to this format, adds a considerable value proposition for enthusiasts and collectors. This juxtaposition of mediocre film reception against exceptional presentation quality offers potential buyers a unique decision matrix; while the movie may not enchant all audiences, its Blu-ray rendition serves as a demonstration of DreamWorks' commitment to excellence in home entertainment technology.
In conclusion, "Bee Movie" on Blu-ray emerges as a product of two distinct halves: the film, somewhat lacking in universal appeal due to its uneven execution and humor, and the Blu-ray presentation, which sets a high standard for animated features in high-definition formats. Despite the film's narrative shortcomings, the Blu-ray edition is a technological triumph that may merit inclusion in collectors' libraries for its visual and auditory showcase alone. Buyers are encouraged to evaluate their interest based on the movie's content first but can rest assured that, from a technical standpoint, this edition represents a sterling effort by DreamWorks.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 90
When Barry flies into the outside world for the first time accompanied by the Pollen Jocks, the mass of colour, detail and images that burst onto the screen is a wonderful sight to behold....
Audio: 80
The voices of all the actors never appear harsh or tinny and in fact have a lovely natural sounding smoothness to them....
Extras: 60
Considering that everything relates to frames from the original movie itself this appears simply to be a directive portal....
Movie: 60
Not only that he's been an influential one in order to get DreamWorks to make this movie and the combination of the two should really have been a formidable one....
Total: 70
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
The digital artists are certainly to be commended; they have nailed the visuals, and every frame is a pleasure to look at....
Audio: 80
The subwoofer occasionally rattles and rumbles, a scene in chapter seven where the humans at the honey farm walk around, their heavy steps reverberating nicely as though we were hearing them as a bee would,...
Extras: 90
The majority of the track is a self-congratulatory party where they discuss the interactions between the characters, the animation, changes in the story, and generally laugh at and discuss their favorite...
Movie: 60
Tell me why, again, the lawyers pander to the jury, but the judge decides the case on a whim, completely ignoring the jury's presence and role?), but will probably find themselves entertained by more talking...
Total: 80
The story itself is fine, if not a bit out of left field (even for a kids' movie) with a decent life lesson, but one that may well go straight over the younger audience's heads....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Even so, there wasn't a single shot in the hive that could prepare me for the explosion of color and detail that accompanies Barry's exploration of the outside world....
Audio: 80
LFE support is selective at times, but altogether aggressive considering the whimsy of the tale -- it pumps extra oomph into the pollen jocks’ wings and plenty of additional menace into the city traffic....
Extras: 60
Funnier than the film itself and frequently nailing the tone of the ‘Seinfeld’ series, these shorts are another good stop on the disc....
Movie: 40
Still unsatisfied with the plot, the filmmakers then offer a trio of conflicting morals that never allow the story to resonate at any level....
Total: 80
In the end, your interest in ‘Bee Movie’ should fall squarely on the shoulders of the film itself -- if you haven’t watched this DreamWorks production, be sure to give it a rent before making a purchase...
Director: Simon J. Smith, Steve Hickner
Actors: Jerry Seinfeld, Renée Zellweger, Matthew Broderick
PlotBarry B. Benson, a bee who has recently graduated from college, is disillusioned at his lone career choice: making honey. When he ventures outside of the hive for the first time, he breaks one of the cardinal rules of the bee world by talking to a human, a New York City florist named Vanessa. Barry's life is saved by Vanessa, and as they become friends, he discovers the joy and flurry of human life. However, Barry's wonder turns to shock as he learns that humans consume honey, and that the bees work tirelessly just for their food to be stolen. This revelation prompts him to take action in a way no bee has dared to before.
Driven by a newfound purpose, Barry decides to investigate further into the human use of honey, embarking on an adventure that takes him through the bustling city of New York. His inquiries lead him to learn more about human-bee interactions, revealing the massive scale at which bees' labor is exploited for honey production. Determined to seek justice for the exploitation of bees, Barry explores the human world, making unexpected alliances and challenging the status quo. His mission not only questions the relationship between humans and bees but also aims to redefine it, setting off a chain of events that could change both their worlds forever.
Writers: Jerry Seinfeld, Spike Feresten, Barry Marder
Release Date: 02 Nov 2007
Runtime: 91 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, Canada
Language: English