Men of War Blu-ray Review
Score: 64
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Men of War delivers an unexpectedly thoughtful narrative with solid technical merits and appealing supplements.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 66
The Blu-ray presentation of 'Men of War' delivers a surprisingly healthy 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 frame, despite its dated master. It features natural colors with some momentary clarity issues and commendable detail in close-ups, though plagued by occasional ringing and grain, yet retaining overall resolution integrity.
Audio: 66
The "Men of War" Blu-ray audio presentation features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that offers some ambient engagement and midrange punch, despite defaulting to LPCM 2.0. Both tracks provide crisp dialogue and balanced sound, with the 5.1 mix enhancing outdoor effects, though lacking bass and volume in action sequences.
Extra: 56
The Blu-ray extras for 'Men of War' include an insightful introduction by Director Perry Lang, 13 minutes of behind-the-scenes insights, raw footage with timecodes, a detailed photo gallery, and the theatrical trailer, all complemented by a distinctive slipcover with collectible artwork.
Movie: 66
Men of War thoughtfully revisits post-Vietnam cinematic themes with a unique twist, offering a narrative where mercenaries confront their pasts and question Western intervention. Featuring John Sayles' co-written screenplay and Dolph Lundgren's empathetic portrayal, it blends meaningful introspection with well-executed action sequences.
Video: 66
The Blu-ray presentation of "Men of War" from MVD Visual's MVD Rewind Collection delivers a surprisingly robust 1080p AVC encoded transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. Despite the lack of detailed technical specifications typically found with these collections, the visual quality stands out, particularly when compared to previous releases, such as those from Echo Bridge Entertainment. The film's representation in 1080p internationally has set a commendable standard, largely adhered to in this release. The color palette is primarily natural and well-suffused, although certain sections, especially towards the end, display a slight decline in clarity and suffusion.
The transfer provides commendable detail levels, predominantly in close-up shots that highlight fine details convincingly—including the intricate depiction of facial injuries. However, there are instances where ringing affects wider shots, though close-range precision compensates for this. The presentation maintains a heavy layer of grain throughout, which is effectively managed by the codec within its 2.39:1 confinement. Occasionally present print damage and dirt are minimal and do not considerably detract from the overall experience. Notably, the black levels exhibit variability, sometimes shifting between firm and muddy across different scenes.
Color reproduction is reliable with accurate flesh tones and vibrant primary colors, particularly the eyewateringly bright greens characteristic of the jungle setting. While the film doesn’t feature aggressive saturation, some fading is noticeable—expected due to its age. Nonetheless, this Blu-ray edition proves itself a more visually impressive representation than anticipated for a film of its era and vintage.
Audio: 66
The audio presentation of "Men of War" on Blu Ray provides a nuanced yet somewhat restrained experience, predominantly characterized by its LPCM 2.0 and DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 tracks. Initially defaulting to the LPCM 2.0 track, this implies a preference for its more natural audio signature, particularly for those seeking a straightforward and balanced auditory experience. The dialogue remains consistently clear and articulate across both tracks, ensuring that verbal exchanges are conveyed without compromise. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 does attempt to expand the auditory field, especially utilizing side and rear channels effectively during ambient outdoor sequences, thus enhancing the portrayal of the island's environmental sounds.
The comparison between the PCM stereo and DTS-HD 5.1 tracks reveals only subtle differences, with neither track emerging as distinctly superior. The 5.1 mix notably underperforms in extending the soundstage, and its low volume suggests an underwhelming dynamic range, particularly evident during action sequences that suffer from flat gunfire effects and a dearth of bass impact. Therefore, the stereo track might be favored for those prioritizing an organic audio experience, though both tracks manage to deliver a crisp balance that favors dialogue clarity over immersive effects.
Collectively, while the audio tracks complement the film's narrative with satisfactory clarity and environmental engagement, they fall short in delivering the robust sonic energy anticipated during more intense sequences. Optional English and Spanish subtitles further enhance accessibility, yet potential purchasers should anticipate an inherently subdued audio presence when engaging with this Blu-ray offering.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "Men of War" provide a comprehensive and engaging look into the film's production. Director Perry Lang offers a concise introduction, enhancing viewers' understanding of the movie's vision. The inclusion of "An Unsafe Place: Making Men of War," featuring insights from collaborator Jeremie Damoiseau, adds valuable context to the filming experience. Viewers can peruse raw footage and dailies equipped with timecode captions, bringing authenticity to the production process. A photo gallery offers visual insights into behind-the-scenes moments, while the theatrical trailer rounds out the experience by showcasing the film's promotional efforts. The disc is thoughtfully packaged with a slipcover, and additional collectibles like a folded mini poster and a close-up printed keepcase insert of Lundgren enhance its appeal.
Extras included in this disc:
- Introduction by Director Perry Lang: Concise contextual introduction.
- An Unsafe Place: Making Men of War: Insights by Jeremie Damoiseau.
- Raw Footage / Dailies of Select Scenes: Authentic set footage with timecodes.
- Photo Gallery: Behind-the-scenes visual exploration.
- Theatrical Trailer: Showcases promotional efforts.
Movie: 66
"Men of War" is a compelling entry within the action genre, blending traditional island adventure motifs with a reflective, socio-political undercurrent. The film’s narrative centers around Dolph Lundgren’s character, Nick Gunar—a mercenary tasked with invading an island to secure its jade resources for unsavory corporate figures. This plot is reminiscent of numerous historical and cinematic precedents like "South of Pago Pago" and even contemporary hits such as "Avatar," where outsiders are hired to exploit native lands. Despite predictable story arcs, the film introduces a moral complexity when Gunar faces a crisis of conscience, choosing to defend the islanders instead.
Co-written by John Sayles, "Men of War" benefits from a layered screenplay that adds depth to its otherwise formulaic premise. Sayles’ influence infuses the narrative with a more somber tone, exploring the lingering scars of post-war society. Unlike many action films that revel in relentless aggression, "Men of War" adopts a more empathetic perspective, examining the psychological toll on soldiers who are thrust back into conflict. This is particularly evident through the diverse backgrounds of Gunar's squad—each member symbolizing distinct facets of veteran life, from unemployment to unresolved trauma.
While the film eventually culminates in an explosive showdown, it maintains an intriguing balance between action and introspection. The native islanders’ apathy towards material wealth contrasts sharply with the mercenaries' desperation, underscoring themes of capitalist greed versus tranquil contentment. As tensions erupt into a climactic battle, the narrative deftly critiques western imperialism and its disruptive impact on isolated communities. Through Gunar’s transformation, by questioning whether intervention truly benefits anyone, the film poses an enduring inquiry into the ethics of exploitation and the need for harmony over hegemony.
Total: 64
"Men of War" on Blu-ray delivers a compelling viewing experience, integrating well-crafted storytelling with remarkable technical enhancements. Directed by Perry Lang and written by John Sayles, the film navigates themes of morality amidst conflict, making it an unexpectedly thoughtful entry in the post-Vietnam film roster. The high-definition transfer reveals intricate visual details, illuminating the Southeast Asian landscapes where the narrative unfolds. The picture quality is enhanced by a sharp contrast ratio and vibrant color grading, ensuring an engaging visual presentation. The audio mix is robust, offering clear dialogue and a dynamic surround sound experience that complements the tension and drama onscreen.
Special features provided in this Blu-ray release include insightful commentary tracks and interviews that delve into the filmmaking process and thematic elements. These supplements are well-curated, offering viewers a deeper understanding of the film’s narrative intentions and production nuances. The package caters to both cinephiles and casual viewers interested in exploring the film beyond its runtime. Enthusiasts of action-oriented narratives will appreciate how these features enrich their appreciation of storytelling composition and thematic exploration.
In conclusion, "Men of War" might not represent the pinnacle of John Sayles' screenwriting achievements, yet it holds its own as a thoughtful narrative infused with underlying sentimentality. The Blu-ray release is solid in its technical merits, making it a worthwhile addition to any collector interested in the genre or era. The film's ability to intertwine action with introspective themes presents a fresh angle for those intrigued by post-war narratives, offering both a powerful watch and a solid investment for prospective buyers.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
The palette is generally very nicely suffused and natural looking throughout, though there are some momentary downgrades in the last section in particular, where some of the island material can look a...
Audio: 80
Men of War actually defaults to the LPCM 2.0 track, which may indicate an acknowledgement that the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 option tends to open things up kind of fitfully, though there is some clear and...
Extras: 80
Introduction by Director Perry Lang (HD; 00;36) is accessible either as a standalone supplement or under the Play Menu, where it's authored to lead directly to the main feature....
Movie: 60
Somewhat hilariously, there's another Frances Farmer film involving a madman taking over a native island, an early Technicolor opus called Ebb Tide (based on a Robert Louis Stevenson tale), which may indicate...
Total: 60
While not as patently silly as the two Farmer outings mentioned above, it probably can't be argued that this is the best thing John Sayles has ever (co) written, though you can kind of feel some of Sayles'...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
Unimpressive and likely a dated master, Men of War hardly looks terrible, but it’s middling....
Audio: 60
Surrounds in the 5.1 mix rarely extend the soundstage, and an overall low volume make the stereo track a more organic choice....
Extras: 40
Director Perry Lang films an introduction, paired with nearly 10-minutes of raw set footage and dailies, an older 13-minute featurette, a photo gallery, and a trailer....
Movie: 80
Rather than asking if we can, “win this time,” a notable line from Rambo II, star Dolph Lundgren stares out at the sea and wonders aloud, “Was it better before we came?”Of course Men of War turns into...
Total: 60
...
Director: Perry Lang
Actors: Dolph Lundgren, Charlotte Lewis, BD Wong
PlotA team of mercenaries, led by ex-soldier Nick Gunar, is hired by a corrupt corporation to persuade the inhabitants of a small island to vacate so the company can exploit its valuable resources. Gunar gathers his crew, all seasoned fighters who share a history with him. Upon reaching the island, they encounter the peaceful villagers who are unaware of the potential threat looming over their home. As Gunar and his team try manipulating the situation in favor of their employers, they find themselves charmed by the simplicity and integrity of the islanders.
Gunar starts to grapple with his conscience and questions the morality of his mission. Conflicts soon arise within the team as some members share Gunar's newfound sympathies, while others remain loyal to their lucrative contract. The idyllic environment and interactions with the villagers force Gunar to reflect on his life of violence. This internal struggle peaks as tensions escalate, revealing complex relationships among the mercenaries and complex motives behind each character's actions. As Gunar weighs his loyalty against his moral awakening, shadows of war and betrayal loom, creating a situation more perilous than they ever anticipated.
Writers: Stan Rogow, John Sayles, Ethan Reiff
Release Date: 12 May 1995
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Spain
Language: English, Thai, Spanish