Going Under Blu-ray Review

Presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, Eric Werthman's "Going Under" on Blu-ray provides a well-executed 1080p transfer. While the high-definition transfer likely stems from a pre-existing master used for the DVD release, the overall image quality exhibits notable improvement with excellent density and image depth. Despite visible traces of light sharpening and slight noise in select darker sequences, the presentation remains largely stable, free from significant debris, damage marks, or scratches. Additionally, color reproduction is steady, although a new high-definition master could fine-tune these aspects further.

The clarity and detail of the film are commendable, considering its low budget and dim lighting conditions. Textures such as the fabric on beach towels or surfaces in well-lit environments demonstrate strong detail, although the image can appear soft at times. Depth is average but generally feels cohesive within its environment, especially in more confined spaces. Black levels present occasional issues with a loss of detail and some distortions in darker scenes. Colors achieve a vibrant and bold quality under good lighting conditions, with a rich red filter applied in many instances that minimally bleeds through.

Skin tones are consistently accurate, revealing considerable detail, including wrinkles, freckles, and pores. Some scenes may appear overly smooth, possibly due to post-processing tweaks. A slight noise is noticeable in poorly lit scenes, accompanied by a healthy layer of grain across the presentation. Overall, while there is room for improvement, particularly in sharpness and noise reduction, this Blu-ray transfer from Blue Underground delivers a solid visual upgrade across the board.

The Blu-ray release of "Going Under" offers two standard audio tracks: English DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, with optional yellow subtitles. After evaluating both tracks, it’s evident that the 2.0 track stands out significantly. The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 delivers excellent depth and clarity, effectively enhancing the viewer's experience with David Darling's score, which enriches various sequences without disrupting the balance of the audio. Dialogue is crisp, stable, and easy to follow, and there are no reports of audio dropouts, pops, cracks, or digital distortions, ensuring a smooth auditory experience.

In contrast, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track feels somewhat excessive for this film. While it’s a clean and solid mix, its use of additional channels doesn’t "wow" or justify the need for them. The surround sound presentation largely relegates the rear channels to handling ambient sounds and low-volume scoring, with most action accurately depicted through the front speakers. Additionally, the low-frequency extension is minimal, with the subwoofer getting minor work from sound effects like doors closing or the occasional boost from specific scenes. Overall, the 2.0 track is the preferred choice for its exceptional balance between vocals, sound effects, and musical scoring, making it the true highlight of this Blu-ray release.

The Blu-ray extras for "Going Under" offer a well-rounded glimpse into the intricate world of this provocative film. The disc includes a treasure trove of content, providing both historical context and behind-the-scenes insights. The Audio Commentary by co-writer/director Eric Werthman and lead actor Roger Rees is particularly enlightening, shedding light on filming locations and the thematic depth of the film, especially pertaining to BDSM rituals. Interviews in "Pushing the Boundaries" provide additional layers, with actors Geno Lechner and Roger Rees discussing the unique challenges faced during production. Supplementary raw footage from the NYC Black & Blue Ball and both a theatrical and teaser trailer round out this compelling package.

Extras included in this disc:

• Trailer: Original trailer for Going Under.
• Teaser Trailer: Original teaser trailer for Going Under.
• NYC Black & Blue Ball: Raw footage from New York City's premier fetish event.
• Pushing the Boundaries: Interviews with actors discussing film challenges and experiences.
• Audio Commentary: Detailed discussion by co-writer/director Eric Werthman and star Roger Rees about the film's themes and production.

Eric Werthman's Going Under (2004) unveils itself as a complex and introspective indie drama rather than the softcore fare some might anticipate. The film deftly explores the intricate layers of a relationship between middle-aged therapist Peter (Roger Rees) and dominatrix Suzanne (Geno Lechner). This thought-provoking character study eschews sensationalism, focusing instead on the emotional intensity and turbulence underlying their interactions. Cinematographer Vladimir Subotic's lens captures the nuance of their encounters, while David Darling's ambient soundtrack enriches the film's atmospheric quality.

Werthman’s direction draws inspiration from films like Barbet Schroeder's Maitresse, emphasizing the notion that relationships founded within BDSM contexts face unique, profound challenges. Here, Peter's professional facade is stripped away as his sessions with Suzanne evolve into personal encounters, blurring the lines between pain and intimacy. Unlike many portrayals within the BDSM genre, Going Under remains predominantly restrained in its depiction of bondage scenes, opting instead to explore off-screen emotions and reactions—an approach that underscores the genuine human connection at its core.

Anchored by compelling performances, particularly from Rees and Lechner, the film scrutinizes themes of trust, emotional vulnerability, and the dichotomy of professional versus personal roles within their dynamic. By swiftly navigating these complex emotional landscapes, Going Under offers a clear-eyed inspection of the barriers and breakthroughs in unconventional love. This nuanced portrayal lays bare the evolving relationship between two people seeking more than what their initial roles suggested, making it an engaging exploration for viewers looking beyond the immediacy of its BDSM elements.

"Going Under" is a surprisingly compelling exploration of intense relationships within the challenging context of BDSM culture, directed by Eric Werthman. Unlike many films in this genre, it avoids embracing the typical cliches and presents its subject matter with an authentic and respectful attitude. This film’s narrative depth and character development make it a standout piece that delves into the complexities of human connections and desires.

The Blu-ray release delivers a slightly above average video presentation, ensuring that viewers can appreciate the nuanced visual undertones that complement the storyline. The audio quality is notably strong, providing an immersive experience that enhances the emotional and psychological intensity of the film. The included extras, while mostly carried over from a previous DVD edition, offer additional layers of insight for those interested in a deeper understanding of the film's themes and production.

There are very few good films about intense relationships such as the one observed in Eric Werthman's "Going Under." This isn't surprising, however, as even today the BDSM culture remains a taboo subject. Werthman's film unquestionably has the right attitude and, more importantly, avoids the terrible BDSM cliches which the safe films have promoted for years. If its subject appeals to you, consider adding Blue Underground's release to your collection. RECOMMENDED.