Summer School Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Summer School shines with Reiner's playful direction and engaging cast, while Shout's Blu-ray offers both new and classic features for fans.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
The AVC encoded image of 'Summer School' delivers a satisfactory experience with an older scan, featuring bold California hues and acceptable detail. It lacks the finesse of a 4K restoration, but remains visually pleasing with a manageable grain that doesn't detract from its overall quality.
Audio: 68
The Blu-ray's 5.1 DTS-HD MA audio provides a primarily frontal soundstage with clear dialogue and punchlines. While surround contributions are minimal, the audio efficiently supports comedic and musical elements with acceptable instrumental details and crisp, immersive beats.
Extra: 66
The Blu-ray extras of 'Summer School' are a nostalgic deep dive, with engaging commentary by Carl Reiner and Mark Harmon, insightful interviews capturing the film’s creative journey, and retro featurettes offering a vivid look at cast dynamics and production memories, despite some previously seen content.
Movie: 76
Summer School, a 1987 Carl Reiner-directed comedy, offers a nostalgic dive into the quintessential teen-surfer-slacker genre with Mark Harmon's engaging portrayal of a gym teacher turned reluctant English instructor. Despite its editorial gaps and predictable plot, the film delivers light-hearted humor, distinct character personalities, and a breezy narrative that remains enjoyable, enhanced by its Blu-ray presentation.
Video: 68
The video presentation of the Blu-ray release of "Summer School" is grounded in an AVC encoded image with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, originating from an older scan. Despite this, the overall viewing experience remains satisfactory. The level of detail, particularly when it comes to skin textures, horror-themed makeup, and classroom settings, is mild yet passable. Colors are well-rendered, capturing the vibrant hues typical of California settings, such as lush greenery and standout blood reds. Skintones appear natural, and the delineation of objects is generally clear. The grain, while present, presents a processed look that does not overly detract from the visual quality. The source material itself is in commendable condition.
Shout! has executed a new transfer for this Blu-ray edition, though it is evidently taken from an older master. It’s apparent that extensive efforts on a full "4K restoration" were not prioritized, which shows in the final presentation. Nevertheless, colors are vividly bold and bright, with numerous instances of suntanned visuals that add to the authenticity of the film's setting. The detail surpasses average expectations for a catalog release, contributing to an acceptable viewing experience. However, a thin layer of grain persists throughout but remains non-intrusive to the viewer's enjoyment. While the visual quality may not reach exceptional levels, it satisfactorily revitalizes this classic film for home viewing.
Audio: 68
The "Summer School" Blu-ray audio presentation manifests a 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track that is primarily anchored on the front channels, effectively delivering clear dialogue exchanges, which are crucial for the comedy's dynamic. The banter and punchlines come through crisply, ensuring the comedic timing remains intact and engaging. While the soundtrack features moments of robust low-end beats, these instances themselves are infrequent and do not substantially ignite the surround channels.
Overall, the audio track is straightforward and functional rather than captivating. The surround sound presence is minimal, with the film's structure seeming to prioritize visual comedy over auditory enhancement. The scoring cues perform adequately, supporting scenes without overpowering them, and maintaining an appropriate balance with the diegetic elements. However, this results in an average auditory experience that does little beyond supporting the film's primary narrative functions.
While "Summer School" doesn't exploit technical auditory enhancements such as surround involvement to full potential, it achieves its primary goal of clear and unobtrusive dialogue projection. Though enhancing a dedicated home theater setup might not be justified by this release, its competence in delivering dialogue and soundtrack remains respectable.
Extras: 66
The Blu-ray extras for "Summer School" provide an engaging and comprehensive behind-the-scenes look at the film's production, effectively blending newer insights with nostalgic reflections. Notable is the audio commentary from director Carl Reiner and actor Mark Harmon, a highlight offering fans in-depth discussions about the filmmaking process and delightful anecdotes from the set—virtual catnip for loyal enthusiasts. Complementing this is the "School's In for Summer" featurette where Richard Steven Horvitz provides a retrospective on his career and experiences on set, delivered through a captivating video conference. "Inside the Teacher's Lounge" offers detailed production insights with a diverse range of interviews from key members involved in the film's creation. Lastly, "High School Yearbook" presents an ensemble of cast and crew reflections, detailing the rich character development and casting stories. A classic theatrical trailer is also available for those seeking a touch of nostalgia.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Features director Carl Reiner and actor Mark Harmon.
- School's In for Summer: Video interview with actor Richard Steven Horvitz.
- Inside the Teacher's Lounge: 2007 making-of featurette with cast and director interviews.
- High School Yearbook: Featurette with cast insights and archival footage from 1986.
- Theatrical Trailer: An original preview of the film.
Movie: 76
"Summer School" is a classic representation of 1980s teen comedies, embracing the era’s fascination with carefree adolescent narratives. Directed by Carl Reiner, the film combines a vintage comedic approach with typical late-80s teenage themes. Reiner utilizes his seasoned comedic touch to craft a story centered on Mark Harmon's portrayal of Coach Shoop - a gym teacher unexpectedly tasked with teaching a remedial summer English class. The character-driven narrative, penned by Jeff Franklin, pivots around Shoop's reluctant transformation from beach bum to mentor for a motley group of students. While the screenplay isn't groundbreaking, it benefits from distinct characterizations that contribute to its charm. Each student, from Pam the surfer girl to Chainsaw and Dave, the horror movie enthusiasts, adds vibrancy and humor to the episodic storyline.
Harmon's performance as Shoop is pivotal, offering an engaging blend of affable laziness and blooming dedication. His chemistry with co-star Kirstie Alley and his rapport with his students are highlights, bringing depth to a film that doesn't take itself too seriously. His portrayal strikes a fine balance between comedic timing and earnestness, enhancing the film's overall appeal.
The movie maintains a lighthearted tone throughout, adeptly weaving moments of heart and humor without veering into melodrama. Although "Summer School" lacks the depth found in contemporaneous works by John Hughes, it delivers reliable laughs and encapsulates the carefree energy of its time. The removed subplots and certain disjointed sequences might occasionally leave viewers bewildered, but such gaps do little to diminish its breezy charm. Reflective of its era’s tropes, "Summer School" succeeds as an entertaining period piece made more enjoyable by its engaging characters and Harmon’s standout performance.
Total: 68
The Blu-ray release of "Summer School" offers an engaging nostalgia trip that stands out due to Reiner's dynamic enthusiasm for the material. The film, rooted in the comedic and lighthearted portrayal of adolescent life, showcases a playful mix of mischievousness and sensitivity, even while incorporating unique elements like grotesque horror movie makeup and subtle indications of alcoholism. The casting is noteworthy, effectively capturing young talent that adds depth to seemingly one-dimensional characters, ensuring each brings a distinct perspective on teenage concerns. Reiner's directorial touch imbues the narrative with a dose of maturity, expertly balanced by pure comedic chaos.
This home media release delivers a crisply remastered visual presentation, breathing new life into the film's vibrant color palette while enhancing its overall viewing experience. Additionally, the disc boasts a combination of fresh supplemental features and familiar ones from past releases, collectively enriching the understanding and appreciation of the film. The Blu-ray serves both as a celebration of the movie’s original spirit and a testament to its enduring appeal, ensuring that long-time fans and new viewers alike will find value in this collection.
In conclusion, "Summer School" remains a delightful spectacle that continues to resonate due to its unapologetic embrace of fun and whimsy. While it may not strive to convey profound messages, its charm and nostalgia make it a valuable addition to any collection. This release highlights Reiner's unique ability to blend maturity with unabashed silly humor, offering a refreshing reprieve from more serious-minded entries in its subgenre. Fans of the film should definitely consider picking up this edition.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 70
However, the viewing experience remains acceptable, providing a mild amount of detail on skin surfaces, horror makeup extremes, and classroom decoration....
Audio: 80
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA is a largely frontal listening experience, focusing on dialogue exchanges from a wide range of performers....
Extras: 80
The interviewee recalls a "friendly rivalry" among the cast, and he offers extended memories of Reiner, Kirstie Alley, Robin Thomas, and especially Mark Harmon, with the pair reuniting a decade ago to...
Movie: 80
Chainsaw and Dave are mostly in charge of silliness in "Summer School," triggering many laughs with their recklessness and attention to exchange student Anna-Maria (Fabiana Udenio), and the general mood...
Total: 80
Reiner's enthusiasm for the material helps "Summer School" rise above the competition, giving the production a defined mischievousness and gentleness (even with grotesque horror movie makeup visuals and...
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 80
That said, Shout! has given the film a new transfer, though it’s clearly sourced from an older master....
Audio: 70
Reiner’s films have all the comedy on screen and don’t rely on 5.1 sound to make their statements....
Extras: 60
School’s In for Summer – One of the cast members, Richard Steven Horvitz, does a video call recounting his audition as well as the experience of working with Carl Reiner and the ensemble cast....
Movie: 0
I have no idea why this film got the double dip treatment of all the catalog titles in Paramount’s library but hey, it’s nice to have this film looking its best and with a commentary track to boot....
Total: 80
It’s fun to watch and while the characters might be one-dimensional, I still enjoyed it after all these years....
Director: Carl Reiner
Actors: Mark Harmon, Kirstie Alley, Robin Thomas
PlotFreddy Shoop, a laid-back high school gym teacher, is eagerly anticipating his summer vacation in Hawaii. His plans are abruptly halted when Vice Principal Phil Gills assigns him to teach a remedial English class for underperforming students during the summer. Shoop, inexperienced and completely unprepared for the task, reluctantly agrees to teach the motley group of disinterested students after being bribed with promises of tenure. The class is composed of a diverse group of underachievers, each with their own quirks and reasons for needing summer school. From the rebellious surfer to the aspiring makeup artist, these students are more interested in sunbathing and skateboarding than cracking open books.
As the summer rolls on, Shoop finds unconventional ways to reach his students, making deals to help them with their problems in exchange for a slight effort in their academics. Slowly, he earns their trust and respect by addressing their individual issues while creatively engaging them with lessons that extend beyond traditional academics. Meanwhile, Shoop's casual approach to teaching attracts the attention—and disapproval—of Gills, who continually threatens to fire him if test scores don't improve. As Shoop and his students form a unique bond, the unlikely group begins to realize their potential. However, with Gills watching closely, Shoop must find a balance between keeping his job and inspiring his class to succeed against the odds.
Writers: Stuart Birnbaum, David Dashev, Jeff Franklin
Release Date: 22 Jul 1987
Runtime: 97 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English