The Smurfs Blu-ray Review
3-Disc Holiday Gift Set
Score: 74
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'The Smurfs' Blu-ray dazzles with brilliant video, spectacular audio, and enjoyable performances, making it a fun and surprisingly engaging family film.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
The Smurfs Blu-ray is a visual marvel, offering stunning 1080p clarity with vibrant, realistic colors and impeccable fine details on both digital and human characters. While minor issues like inconsistent skin tones and occasional CG blur exist, the overall presentation is near demo-worthy and boasts serious wow power.
Audio: 83
The Smurfs' DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack is a dazzling and impeccably smooth sonic delight, with crystal-clear dialogue, immersive surround presence, precise musical elements, and superb use of rear speakers, creating a perfectly believable sonic atmosphere that enriches every scene from serene nature to bustling city streets.
Extra: 66
The Blu-ray extras for 'The Smurfs' offer a wealth of supplemental material, including two insightful audio commentaries, engaging featurettes on adapting the comic to screen and Hank Azaria's performance, and a comprehensive Second Screen Experience hampered by connectivity issues. The content spans various formats but suffers from some lackluster elements like 'The Smurfs: A Christmas Carol' in standard definition and a subpar game.
Movie: 66
**Quote:** "For all its predictable formula, 'The Smurfs' charms through seamless animation, genuine wit, and a well-performing cast—highlighted by Hank Azaria's outstanding Gargamel—all packaged in a technically superior Blu-ray release."
Video: 73
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Smurfs" truly shines in its 1080p high-definition format. The film's bright, clear, and sharp imagery is immediately engaging, with impressively vibrant colors that remain grounded in a realistic flavor, avoiding any gaudiness despite the myriad of bright hues. Details are remarkable – from the complex intricacies within the Smurfs' eyes and their textured clothes to the fine texturing of Gargamel's cat. Human characters also benefit from this meticulous attention to detail, with facial and clothing features appearing lifelike and natural under scrutiny. The digital and real structures blend seamlessly, providing a visually immersive experience that replicates both the cartoonish charm of the Smurf village and the bustling realism of New York City.
The transfer boasts phenomenal depth, clarity, and detail. Textures are vivid, as seen in the wear on the Smurfs' outfits and the lifelike representation of human skin. The film’s bright, candy-coated appearance is especially well-suited for HD, offering no aliasing, edge enhancement, or digital noise reduction (DNR). Even in darker scenes involving Gargamel’s outfit or hair, the blacks are never crushed, maintaining the high quality throughout the film. Although there are some minor issues such as occasional inconsistent skin tones or slight jagged outlines around the Smurfs due to unfinished CG work, these hiccups are infrequent and do not significantly detract from the overall experience.
Ultimately, "The Smurfs" Blu-ray demonstrates a near-perfect digital transfer that brings out the best of both real and animated components. With breathtaking clarity and vibrant visuals, it's a standout disc in the format, ideal for showcasing home theater capabilities. Despite a few minor flaws, the overall presentation exudes serious wow factor, making it an exceptional release for enthusiasts and casual viewers alike.
Audio: 83
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack for "The Smurfs" is an impeccable amalgamation of high-energy elements and crystal-clear sound performance. The soundtrack ensures a seamlessly immersive experience, characterized by its boundless energy and supremely smooth delivery. Music, dialogue, and sound effects are strikingly rich and spatially precise, seamlessly filling the soundstage with each nuance perfectly audible. The score benefits greatly from its solid surround presence, effectively enhancing the experience without overwhelming the material. Rock tunes maintain high energy without sacrificing clarity, and the low-end elements are perfectly calibrated to provide a full-bodied and realistic soundscape. Ambient effects effortlessly adapt to different environments, from the mythical grove of the Smurfs to the bustling streets of New York City, creating a naturally believable sonic atmosphere.
The track's transparency and engagement are apparent from the first scene to the last, with every moment designed to catch the listener’s attention. The audio benefits from superb channel separation and frequent, effective use of all channels, making the experience vivid and dynamic. Although the bass doesn't dominate with overwhelming power, its subtlety provides realistic scene perspectives, accentuating action like the thuds of a chasing hound or the whoosh of passing cars. The rear speakers are ingeniously utilized, featuring randomly localized dialogue that maintains fresh auditory interest throughout. The volume dynamics are well-executed, preserving clarity even amid spikes and high-activity sequences. Sony’s dedication to this lossless soundtrack is unmistakable, delivering a harmonious mix that is flawless in dialogue reproduction and overall audio quality, underscoring the exceptional work by the film’s sound department.
Extras: 66
The Blu-ray release of "The Smurfs" includes a robust array of extras, enhancing the viewer's experience significantly. The offerings range from insightful audio commentaries and engaging short films to interactive games and behind-the-scenes featurettes. Despite one technical hiccup with the Smurf-O-Vision sync feature, the supplemental content adds substantial value to this package. Particularly noteworthy are the detailed audio commentaries that provide in-depth perspectives from the director and production team. The inclusion of a Christmas-themed short film, though only in standard definition, and various engaging behind-the-scenes pieces further enrich the disc. Overall, these extras create a more immersive experience into the world of Smurfs.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Smurfs: A Christmas Carol: A standard-definition, Christmas-themed short film.
- Smurf-O-Vision: Second Screen Experience: Syncs additional content to iOS devices via WiFi.
- The Smurfs Fantastic Adventure Game: A three-level game using TV remotes.
- Audio Commentary: Two tracks featuring discussions by Director Raja Gosnell and key production members.
- Deleted & Extended Scenes: A collection of six scenes with extended or removed footage.
- The Smurfs: Comic Book to the Big Screen: Insight into adapting characters from 2D comics to 3D film.
- Smurf Speak: Meet the Cast: Reactions and discussions by the film's voice cast.
- Going Gargamel: Behind-the-scenes look at Hank Azaria's performance as Gargamel.
- Blue-Pers: A brief gag reel.
- Happy Music Montage: A music video montage of film scenes.
- Progression Reels: Detailed featurettes on the technical processes behind CGI effects.
- BD-Live & UV Copy: Online content accessible via Blu-ray Live and UltraViolet copy.
Movie: 66
Raja Gosnell’s 2011 adaptation of "The Smurfs" transposes the beloved blue characters from their medieval, forest home to the bustling metropolis of New York City. Despite being intensely predictable and formulaic, the film manages to charm its way into the hearts of its audience with an intriguing mix of comedic misadventures and genuine wit. The plot revolves around a group of Smurfs accidentally transported to New York while trying to evade their arch-nemesis, Gargamel. The ensuing chaos as these mystical beings navigate the city forms the crux of the film, which succeeds largely due to its heartfelt approach and charming portrayal of relationships, both among the Smurfs and with their human counterparts, Patrick (Neil Patrick Harris) and Grace (Jayma Mays).
The seamless integration of CGI characters with live-action elements in "The Smurfs" is nothing short of technically splendid. The visual effects team achieves a level of digital excellence that allows the Smurfs to interact believably within their real-world environment. Each Smurf is brought to life with meticulous attention to detail—from the strands of their hair to the expressive movements of their eyes. This digital prowess extends even to Gargamel's feline companion, Azrael, who often blurs the line between animated and real. The film’s animation quality stands out as a significant achievement, demanding appreciation for the man-hours and expertise involved in its creation.
Accompanying the visual spectacle is a competent human cast. Neil Patrick Harris and Jayma Mays contribute adequately to their roles, providing authenticity in their interactions with the CGI characters. However, it is Hank Azaria’s performance as Gargamel that truly steals the show. Azaria’s outrageous antics and over-the-top villainy perfectly encapsulate the playful spirit of children’s cinema, adding layers of both nostalgia and humor. Despite some regrettable missteps in storytelling and cringe-worthy moments—such as an ill-conceived dance sequence—the film thrives on its wholesome, fun-filled appeal that wins over skepticism and delivers an engaging family-friendly adventure.
Total: 74
The Blu-ray release of "The Smurfs" is a delightful blend of technical excellence and engaging content, bringing both fun and quality to the family movie sphere. This charming film manages to captivate audiences with its playful humor, catchy score by Heitor Pereira, and impressive special effects. Hank Azaria's standout performance as Gargamel adds a layer of nostalgic villainy that fans of old-time cinema will appreciate. While the film stays within the predictable boundaries of its genre, it embraces its clichés with a light-hearted approach that's perfect for family viewing.
On the technical front, Sony's Blu-ray release does not disappoint. The video quality is stunning, with near demo-level clarity that brings the vibrant world of the Smurfs to life in full high definition. The audio is equally spectacular, ensuring that every musical note and sound effect enhances the overall viewing experience. Additionally, the Blu-ray package is packed with exclusive extras that provide further immersion into the Smurfs' universe. The inclusion of bonus DVDs ensures that fans get more than their money's worth, making it a solid choice for holiday gifting.
In conclusion, "The Smurfs" is an enjoyable and well-crafted movie that surprises with its blend of humor, heart, and technical prowess. While it follows familiar formulas, it succeeds in making them entertaining and fresh. This Blu-ray release is a strong contender for any family movie collection, highly recommended for its remarkable video and audio quality alongside its entertaining and fun content.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Real and digital structures are also wonderful; the Smurf mushrooms yield very fine textures and minute little digital details that give them great lived-in character, while the various city locales couldn't...
Audio: 100
Everything in the track -- music, dialogue, sound effects -- are infinitely rich, playing with superb spacing and a natural and immersive presence that easily fills the soundstage with every little nuance...
Extras: 80
The Smurfs: Comic Book to the Big Screen (1080p, 8:15): A short but informative piece that begins by looking back at the original source material and moving on to examine the complex process of creating...
Movie: 80
There's no real rhyme or reason to it, but the picture beats the odds and proves to be a down-to-earth, honest, heartfelt, and almost always entertaining little adventure for the kids, the kids at heart,...
Total: 90
The special effects really are quite special (there wouldn't be a movie otherwise), Heitor Pereira's score is catchy and breezy, and the live action performances are fun, with special emphasis on Hank...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
I can't blame this disc for the following issues, but there are some shots where the Smurfs look a little jagged on their outlines, due to some unfinished or sloppy CG, making them look too artificial...
Audio: 100
Bass levels aren't powerful, but they're effective, as they're used mostly to provide any given scene perspective, as though you were in the room as a Smurf, the thumps of a chasing hound, the smallest...
Extras: 60
The writer/VFX track features discussion of crafting characters and settings, seven foot zebras, the attention to authenticity to source materials, and the various ways scenes were made, not only in concept...
Movie: 60
The Smurfs' has its issues, yes, and it can be rather frustrating in a few spots, but this is a family film that does have something for everyone, in terms of plot devices, gags, and references....
Total: 80
This is a cute, fun, warm family film, and it's certainly not a grating experience for adults who will be forced to watch it, but it definitely isn't for everyone....
Director: Raja Gosnell
Actors: Hank Azaria, Katy Perry, Jonathan Winters
PlotIn a magical world, a village inhabited by small blue creatures known as Smurfs is preparing for the Blue Moon Festival. The Smurfs live happily and harmoniously under the guidance of their wise leader, Papa Smurf. However, danger looms as the evil wizard Gargamel, who has been searching for the Smurf village for years to harness their magic, finally discovers their location and chases a small group of them through the woods. In the ensuing commotion, Clumsy Smurf stumbles into a forbidden grotto and the rest of the group follows, only to find themselves sucked into a vortex that transports them to New York City.
Stranded in the bustling metropolis, the Smurfs must navigate the unfamiliar and larger-than-life world of humans as they search for a way back home before Gargamel catches them. They encounter Patrick and Grace Winslow, a soon-to-be-parent couple whose lives take an unexpected turn when they meet the Smurfs. The couple decides to help their new friends, despite the challenges and chaos their presence brings into their lives. Together, they must find a way to protect the Smurfs from Gargamel's grasp while also working to find the portal that appears with the Blue Moon and will allow them to return to their village safely.
Writers: J. David Stem, David N. Weiss, Jay Scherick
Release Date: 29 Jul 2011
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, Belgium, Canada
Language: English