Broadcast News Blu-ray Review
Score: 72
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Criterion's Blu-ray of 'Broadcast News' boasts smart, playful content with excellent remastering, incisive extras, and top-notch picture and audio quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
The Criterion release of 'Broadcast News' boasts an outstanding high-definition transfer approved by James L. Brooks, with 4K scanning and 2K color correction. The 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encode offers impressive fine detail, clarity, and color reproduction, despite minor softness inherent to its original cinematography.
Audio: 67
Broadcast News' English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track is expertly remastered, featuring superb dynamics, clean and stable dialogue, and a spacious front soundstage that captures the film's hustle and bustle with exceptional fidelity, free from any disturbing audio artifacts.
Extra: 76
The Criterion Collection’s Blu-ray of 'Broadcast News' offers a rich blend of newly-recorded and insightful extras, including an informative commentary by James L. Brooks, a three-part documentary on his career, a captivating interview with Susan Zirinsky, an alternate ending with director’s commentary, and deleted scenes that provide comedic outtakes.
Movie: 81
"Broadcast News" on Blu-ray is a remarkable release by Criterion, praised for its insightful behind-the-scenes documentary, engaging commentary by James L. Brooks and Richard Marks, video interview with Susan Zirinsky, and a high-quality 18-page booklet. This romantic comedy, set against the chaotic world of television news, showcases stellar performances from Holly Hunter, William Hurt, and Albert Brooks, encapsulating the balance between their professional and personal lives amid the evolving media landscape.
Video: 72
Presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and encoded with MPEG-4 AVC, James L. Brooks' "Broadcast News" on Blu-ray is a visual treat courtesy of Criterion. Supervised and approved by director James L. Brooks and editor Richard Marks, this high-definition digital transfer was meticulously created on a DFT SCANITY Film Scanner in 4K from the original 35mm camera negative, followed by color correction on a Baselight Eight in 2K resolution. Thousands of instances of dirt, debris, scratches, splices, warps, jitter, and flicker were manually removed using MTI's DRS system and Pixel Farm's PFClean system. The telecine work was overseen by James L. Brooks, Richard Marks, and Lee Kline, with colorist John Persichetti of Sony Colorworks, Los Angeles.
The transfer results are outstanding. The 1080p presentation features exceptional fine object detail, superb clarity, and consistent contrast levels throughout the film. There are no significant issues with edge-enhancement or macroblocking. The fine film grain is well-resolved and consistent, and color reproduction impresses with rich and natural hues. Reds, blues, greens, yellows, browns, grays, and blacks all look vibrant and fresh, though minor color instability is noted at the airport scene towards the end—this appears to be inherent in the original material. Close-ups are particularly striking with depth and tightness, and darker studio scenes hold up remarkably well. There are no noticeable stability issues or major damage marks; overall, the film's visual integrity is preserved excellently.
The high-definition transfer brings a film-like quality to the image with slight grain enhancing the authenticity of the period cinematography. Despite some inherent softness attributed to the film's original characteristics and age, clarity and sharp resolution shine through. Details in actors’ faces, clothing, and architecture are distinct even in dim lighting. The contrast is pitch-perfect with crisp whites and rich black levels providing excellent depth of field. Colors especially benefit from this meticulous remastering, popping with vibrancy and conveying a lively visual quality that enhances this classic 80s comedy’s enduring charm on Blu-ray.
Audio: 67
The audio presentation on the Blu-ray release of "Broadcast News" is a robust and meticulously remastered English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track. According to the included booklet, the 2.0 surround soundtrack was restored at 24-bit from the original 35mm Dolby A magnetic tracks, with manual removal of clicks, thumps, hiss, and hum using Pro Tools HD, and additional crackle reduction via AudioCube’s integrated audio workstation.
This remastering delivers a stereo presentation that exhibits exceptional fidelity and dynamic range. Dialogue is clean, stable, and easy to follow, capturing the subtleties and emotional nuances in the actors’ performances. The front soundstage is notably spacious and immersive, providing an authentic audio experience that complements the film's network office environment seamlessly. Along with Bill Conti’s music score, which is well-balanced without overshadowing dialogue, there are no detectable audio artifacts such as pops, cracks, hissing, or dropout.
In summary, the Blu-ray's DTS-HD Master Audio track for "Broadcast News" skillfully combines warmth and clarity, ensuring an engaging auditory experience that complements the film’s unique romantic dramedy narrative.
Extras: 76
The Blu-ray edition of "Broadcast News" meticulously assembled by Criterion includes an excellent array of extras that enhance and contextualize the film. The audio commentary by director James L. Brooks and editor Richard Marks is particularly notable, providing an in-depth look into the making of the film from its conception to specific camera techniques. Notably, Brooks's overwhelming contributions make it both informative and engaging. The documentary "James L. Brooks: A Singular Voice" offers a comprehensive exploration of Brooks's influential career across television and film. Additionally, the interview with Susan Zirinsky adds depth to Holly Hunter's portrayal of Jane Craig, highlighting impressive real-life parallels. The featurette and on-set interviews provide nostalgic promotional content including cast perspectives and behind-the-scenes glimpses. Viewers will also appreciate the alternate ending with director commentary and a curated selection of deleted scenes.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary: In-depth discussion by James L. Brooks and Richard Marks.
- James L. Brooks – A Singular Voice: Three-part documentary on Brooks's career.
- Alternate Ending: Explored with director's introduction.
- Deleted Scenes: Compilation of omitted scenes.
- Susan Zirinsky: Interview with the real-life inspiration for Jane Craig.
- Featurette: Promotional material with raw footage and cast interviews.
- Interviews and On-Set Footage: Additional segments not included in the featurette.
- Trailer: Original theatrical preview.
- Booklet: Contains essay by critic Carrie Rickey.
Movie: 81
James L. Brooks' "Broadcast News" (1987), a Silver Bear Award winner at the Berlin International Film Festival, presents an incisive exploration of the news industry. The film follows three dedicated professionals: Jane Craig (Holly Hunter), a driven producer balancing her intense work ethic with personal insecurities; Aaron Altman (Albert Brooks), a talented but camera-challenged reporter harboring unspoken feelings for Jane; and Tom Grunnick (William Hurt), an attractive yet less skilled anchor pursuing corporate success. Set against the backdrop of a chaotic news bureau in Washington, D.C., their interactions unravel the complexities of work-life balance amidst the pressures of delivering world events.
At its core, "Broadcast News" delves into the intricacies of personal and professional relationships in a high-stakes environment. The characters' inability to communicate honestly highlights their paradoxical prowess in conveying global news versus managing their lives. Jane's compulsive pursuit of perfection clashes with her longing for intimacy when she is charmed by Tom, leaving Aaron to cope with unrequited love and professional jealousy. Brooks' expertly crafted dialogue and character-driven storytelling imbue the film with authenticity, underscoring the emotional depth and idiosyncrasies of his protagonists.
Against the vibrant, competitive world of television news, "Broadcast News" masterfully balances romantic tension with insightful social commentary. The film's clever subversion of romantic comedy tropes is complemented by strong performances from Hunter, Brooks, and Hurt. Their nuanced portrayals encapsulate the tension between career ambition and personal fulfillment, creating a poignant and humorous narrative. Supporting roles by Joan Cusack and Jack Nicholson add further texture to this compelling depiction of media transformation and personal vulnerability, making "Broadcast News" an enduring classic that resonates with both media enthusiasts and cinephiles alike.
Total: 72
James L. Brooks' "Broadcast News" is a compelling and sharp-witted film that skillfully balances humor and poignant observations. This romantic dramedy, starring William Hurt, Albert Brooks, and Holly Hunter, delves into the chaotic world of network news and explores the complexities of modern relationships with intelligence and wit. The film benefits greatly from Criterion's meticulous restoration, which includes contributions from Sony Colorworks. The result is a Blu-ray release with stunning visual quality and excellent audio fidelity, ensuring that the film’s intricate details and subtleties are preserved beautifully.
Visually, "Broadcast News" has been treated to a newly remastered picture that elevates the experience, bringing crisp clarity to each frame. The audio presentation is equally impressive, preserving the integrity of the original source materials while offering a finely tuned listening experience. This release also shines in its array of supplemental features. These extras are crafted specifically for this Criterion Collection edition and offer deep dives into the film’s creation, themes, and impact. They significantly enhance the viewer’s appreciation of both the narrative and technical prowess behind this classic.
In conclusion, "Broadcast News" on Blu-ray is an exemplary package that offers both an excellent audiovisual experience and insightful supplementary content. Criterion's treatment elevates an already extraordinary film, making it a must-have for fans and newcomers alike. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a smart, enjoyable, and technically superior cinematic experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
Fine object detail is outstanding, clarity terrific, and contrast levels consistent throughout the entire film....
Audio: 90
For the record, Criterion have included optional English SDH subtitles for the main feature....
Extras: 80
Featurette - a standard featurette, produced by 20th Century Fox, with raw footage from the shooting of the film, as well as interviews with James L. Brooks, Albert Brooks, and Holly Hunter....
Movie: 90
Various processes - including producing, delivering and even manipulating the news - are all carefully documented, offering the viewer a real sense of how the news networks operate....
Total: 90
Criterion's treatment (with a top-notch contribution by the guys at Sony Colorworks) of the film is excellent....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Colors receive the biggest benefit, as primaries pop off the screen with energy and vibrancy, while a lovely, bright variation in the secondary hues gives the comedy a healthy and lively quality....
Audio: 80
The front soundstage feels impressively spacious and welcoming with terrific fluid movement between the three channels, displaying the hustle and bustle commotion of a network office with fantastic fidelity...
Extras: 80
James L. Brooks: A Singular Voice (HD, 36 min) — Made exclusively for this Criterion edition of the movie, the three-part documentary is a look at Brooks' influential career and features interviews of...
Movie: 80
They're proficient at reporting major world events, as seen in the brilliantly-crafted sequence involving the bombing of a U.S. military base, and they display a talent for capturing the deeply emotional...
Total: 80
The supplements are a new set of extras produced especially for this Criterion Collection release, and they offer a terrific assortment that provides further insight into the film and its story....
Director: James L. Brooks
Actors: William Hurt, Albert Brooks, Holly Hunter
PlotIn a bustling Washington, D.C. television newsroom, three distinctly different professionals navigate the high-pressure world of broadcast journalism. Jane Craig, a talented and fiercely dedicated news producer, is as passionate about the integrity of reporting as she is about her demanding job. Alongside her is Aaron Altman, an intelligent and witty reporter who harbors unrequited feelings for Jane. Their dynamic is upended by the arrival of Tom Grunick, a handsome and charismatic sports anchor with limited journalistic skills but a natural gift for on-camera presence. Jane finds herself professionally torn and personally conflicted, as Tom’s charm and ambition clashing with her principles.
As Jane wrestles with her growing feelings for Tom and her loyalty to journalistic ethics, the newsroom becomes a battleground for idealism versus pragmatism. Aaron’s resentment towards Tom leads to rising tensions, exposing deep insecurities and professional jealousies. The trio’s intertwined relationships come under strain as they confront ethical dilemmas and personal ambitions within the fiercely competitive environment of network news. The story delves into the personal and professional struggles of these characters, exploring themes of integrity, ambition, and the complexities of human relationships in the media world.
Writers: James L. Brooks
Release Date: 25 Dec 1987
Runtime: 133 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish, French, German