The Pirate Blu-ray Review

Warner Archive's Blu-ray release of "The Pirate" presents an outstanding video presentation derived from a 4K remaster. The transfer achieves a remarkable balance between clarity and film-like authenticity, with a maintenance of genuine film grain untouched by noise reduction. Fine details, particularly in costumes and set designs, are rendered with exceptional sharpness, enhancing individual textures and offering a crisp viewing experience. Notably, some behind-the-scenes technical elements, such as the now-visible strings, become apparent due to the heightened detail, but these are minor trade-offs for the otherwise stunning imagery.

Central to this presentation is its utilization of the Technicolor palette. The colors are meticulously handled, striking a balance between boldness and accuracy without succumbing to over-saturation. The vibrant reds, luxurious greens, and dynamic oranges not only intensify the film’s energetic dance sequences but also emphasize its lush visual narrative. Subtle pastels add to the richness without overwhelming the frame, while deep blacks and clear whites ensure excellent contrast and proper shadow detail, especially evident in the dramatic Pirate Ballet sequence.

The directorial prowess of Vincente Minnelli shines through in the close-ups, capturing Garland's and Kelly's features with precision and elegance. Despite some shots appearing slightly worn, the overall print sports no remnants of previous DVD-era damage. This Blu-ray release not only lives up to but exceeds expectations for a classic film of this caliber, delivering a breathtaking experience that reaffirms the artistic vision of Minnelli and the grandeur of Technicolor cinema. "The Pirate" on Blu-ray is undoubtedly an essential addition for any musical or classic film aficionado.

The audio presentation of the Blu-ray release of "The Pirate" is delivered through a DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio track, known for effectively maintaining the film's original mono mix integrity. Although the majority of the audio is rendered faithfully and clearly, a handful of scenes exhibit a tinny, slightly distorted quality that occasionally obscures dialogue clarity. This distortion is likely due to age-related source material issues and, though not overly distracting, can be noticeable. Fortunately, the inclusion of English (SDH) subtitles offers essential support in these areas. Generally, non-performance music cues may experience a somewhat strained high end.

In terms of performance, the DTS-HD Master Audio track handles the film's varied auditory demands commendably. Despite slight surface noise observed during quieter scenes—a callback to its 2007 DVD release—the track excels in presenting Garland's powerful vocals and the lush musical score with excellent fidelity and dynamic range. Notably, the audio mix adeptly handles sonic elements such as explosions and static effects with precision and polish. Dialogue remains crystal clear throughout, free from any pervasive distortion, delivering an immersive experience that aligns well with the period's musical drama standards.

A notable shortcoming is the lack of optional English (SDH) subtitles for the supplemental content, a feature available in previous DVD collections. This omission is slightly disappointing for those who rely on subtitles for a comprehensive viewing experience. However, the main feature maintains these aids, ensuring clarity where audio imperfections might otherwise hinder understanding. Overall, this Blu-ray audio presentation delivers a largely smooth and engaging experience that resonates well within its historical context.

The Blu-ray edition of "The Pirate" presents a comprehensive collection of extras that both celebrate and clarify the film's complex legacy, appealing to enthusiasts and historians alike. John Fricke's engrossing audio commentary stands out, offering an in-depth exploration of the film's production challenges, Garland's comedic prowess, and Minnelli's unique directorial flair, while dispelling myths with rigorously researched insights. The featurette "The Pirate: A Musical Treasure Chest" expands on these themes with additional perspectives from key figures connected to the film. The disc also includes historical shorts, rare audio outtakes, guide tracks, vintage radio interviews, and promotional materials that enrich the understanding of this classic musical. A stereo remix of "Mack the Black" adds an auditory highlight, enhancing Garland's performance with superior sound quality.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Insightful discussion with historian John Fricke on various film aspects.
• The Pirate: A Musical Treasure Chest: Retrospective featuring insights into the film's production.
• Pete Smith's You Can't Win: Oscar-nominated short featuring slapstick comedy.
• Vintage Cartoon: Cat Fishin': Classic Tom and Jerry short.
• Mack the Black Stereo Remix Version: High-quality audio remix of a main song.
• Audio Outtakes: Rare musical pieces excised from the final film.
• Roger Edens' Guide Tracks: Practice tracks featuring Porter's songs for the stars.
• Vintage Radio Interviews: Promotional broadcasts with Judy Garland and Gene Kelly.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original preview including unused material.
• Song Selection: Instant access feature for ten key musical numbers.

The Pirate, directed by Vincente Minnelli, is an idiosyncratic 1948 musical that showcases the cinematic might of Judy Garland and Gene Kelly yet initially faltered both commercially and critically. Adapted from Samuel Behrman’s 1942 play, this film sought identity amid numerous rewrites, ultimately positioning itself as a lavish musical with songs by Cole Porter. Despite its rocky start, The Pirate garners cult favor among musical enthusiasts today.

Visually stunning and set against a vivid Caribbean backdrop, the narrative thrives on its unique blend of comedy, romantic intrigue, and theatrical performances. Kelly shines as Serafin, a bold circus leader with a penchant for flirtation, who pretends to be the feared pirate Macoco to win Manuela's heart, played by Garland. Her desires lie with the enigmatic pirate over her arranged fiancé, town mayor Don Pedro. Their dynamic is compelling, culminating in an impressive array of song and dance numbers that include the iconic “Be A Clown”, paralleled later in Singin’ in the Rain as “Make 'Em Laugh”.

While Porter's score doesn't represent his peak, it complements Minnelli’s ornate direction and fuels the film's aura. Garland's performance marries comic finesse with heartfelt depth, particularly in numbers like “Mack the Black” and “Love of My Life”. Kelly's choreography straddles athleticism and grace, epitomized in sequences like the Spanish-flavored “Niña” and the exuberant “Be A Clown” alongside the Nicholas Brothers. Although hindered by narrative inconsistencies attributed to behind-the-scenes turmoil, The Pirate thrives on its audacity and vibrant energy.

Warner Archive’s Blu-ray release further enhances its appeal with meticulous A/V restoration and enticing bonus features. This rendition does justice to Minnelli's craftsmanship, ensuring The Pirate continues to captivate both ardent fans and new audiences alike.

"The Pirate," a 1948 musical brought to life by the stellar trio of Gene Kelly, Judy Garland, and Vincente Minnelli, stands as an intriguing yet imperfect gem. Featuring original songs by Cole Porter, the movie blends slapstick humor with lavish musical numbers, yet struggles with tonal inconsistencies and a somewhat whimsical plot that doesn't quite match the virtuosity of its cast and crew. Despite these shortcomings, fans of Kelly and Garland will find undeniable moments of enjoyment in its vibrant performances and creative direction.

Warner Archive's Blu-ray release of "The Pirate" showcases a commendable effort in preserving this classic. The 4K restoration infuses renewed life into the film, offering breathtaking visuals that capture the enchanting costumes and dynamic choreography. Meanwhile, the robust audio complements the visual prowess, ensuring the Porter score resonates beautifully. Enthusiasts will appreciate the carefully curated extras, primarily derived from the 2007 DVD, which further enrich the viewing experience.

In conclusion, "The Pirate" on Blu-ray comes with a specific recommendation. It shines as a showcase for its charismatic leads and stands out in technical restoration achievements, appealing to fans of Hollywood musicals. However, given its narrative pitfalls, it remains secondary when compared to the vast repertoire of its stars and director. If you fit the niche audience who revels in classic Hollywood cinema's eccentricities and artistic flair, this Blu-ray release offers considerable treasure despite the film's inherent flaws.