The Great Escape Blu-ray Review

The recent Blu-ray release of "The Great Escape" manifests a clear improvement over its DVD version, yet it falls short of the high standards set by other classic film restorations. Presented in its original 2.35:1 aspect ratio with an AVC-MPEG4 encode, the transfer is generally clean, lacking scratches and blemishes, with vibrant colors such as reds and greens standing out effectively. However, the upgrade feels half-hearted; despite being sharper and more colorful than the DVD, the Blu-ray retains a flat and soft presentation. Process shots, including dissolves, suffer notably, and while grain is retained intact and edge enhancement minimal, occasional ringing and banding are present.

The purported restoration from a 4K scan is questionable, as the resulting image often appears to be sourced from duplicates several generations removed from the original camera negative (OCN). The sporadic flickering and instability, accompanied by fluctuations in film grain’s natural appearance, further exacerbate this issue. Although not digitally eliminated, the grain occasionally looks odd, suggesting manipulation or addition of artificial grain to simulate a film-like texture. This inconsistency in visual quality is disappointing given the expectations set by genuine restorations of similar era films such as "Lawrence of Arabia" or "The Bridge on the River Kwai."

Sharpness fluctuates through the film, sometimes delivering moderate detail but often leaving images looking flat with inconsistent line structure. Blacks suffer from a lack of dynamism, and shadow detail remains only above average. Given MGM’s claims of a restoration and a new 4K scan, one would expect higher fidelity to the original film’s look. However, it becomes evident that the transfer’s limitations stem from a possibly compromised source and insufficient restoration methods. A dedicated Blu-ray disc free from extras could have potentially offered better preservation of the source elements at higher bitrates. Despite these limitations, the Blu-ray remains a worthy upgrade from DVD but lacks the exemplary restoration quality seen in other classics.

The audio presentation of "The Great Escape" Blu-ray disc leverages the DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack to deliver a satisfying experience from a technically aged source. Dialogue, characterized by its clarity and precisely mixed fronts, emerges distinctly, even amidst the varying accents of the characters. Key sound effects, such as the iconic roar of Hilts's motorcycle, manifest with noticeable impact, thanks to the determined dynamism achieved through the DTS-HD codec. Although slightly dated, the sound editing is sufficiently detailed, underscoring the film's ambiance with nuanced auditory cues, making for an enriched cinematic experience.

MGM has preserved the integrity of Elmer Bernstein's score through high-quality audio reproduction. The music where it adopts the benefits of the HD format, displays crisp highs and thumping lows that inject life into the military beats and orchestral arrangements. While true bass extension is absent and lower frequencies are sporadic, the mix compensates through its clear instrumentation and stereo separation. Despite limited rear-channel engagement and minimal LFE presence, the surround sound subtly enhances spatiality and scene envelopment, contributing positively to overall sound fidelity and immersion within the context of its original recording constraints.

The Blu-ray extras for "The Great Escape" provide a comprehensive and engaging look behind the scenes and delve into both historical facts and filmmaking. Fox and MGM’s decision to port over the content from the 2004 DVD Collector’s Edition ensures that the supplements are thorough, although unfortunately, they remain in standard definition, aside from the trailer. The commentary features insights from numerous key figures, skillfully moderated through edited interviews by Steven Jay Rubin. Multiple documentaries produced by The History Channel offer in-depth exploration of historical events, film preparation, and its reception. Despite some user-unfriendly features such as the lack of a main menu and bookmark functionality, these extensive and well-curated extras enhance the viewing experience significantly.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary by Director John Sturges, Cast & Crew: Edited interviews providing various insights.
• The Great Escape: Bringing Fact to Fiction: Examines the difference between real history and film.
• The Great Escape: Preparations for Freedom: Details the real-life escape efforts.
• The Great Escape: The Flight to Freedom: Compares film’s portrayal with actual events.
• The Great Escape: A Standing Ovation: Discusses the film’s reception.
• The Great Escape: The Untold Story: Chronicles post-war efforts to identify and prosecute Gestapo members.
• The Great Escape: The Untold Story – Additional Interviews: Extended content from the documentary.
• The Real Virgil Hilts: A Man Called Jones: Portrait of David Jones, inspiration for Steve McQueen’s character.
• Return to The Great Escape: 1993 retrospective documentary.
• Original Theatrical Trailer: High-definition promotional trailer.

"The Great Escape," released in 1963, remains a seminal war film celebrated for its emphasis on intellect, camaraderie, and resolve rather than battlefield heroics. The plot revolves around Allied POWs detained in the German Stalag Luft North, a high-security camp intended to quell escape attempts. However, it inadvertently gathers the finest escape artists of the war, led by a stellar ensemble cast including Steve McQueen, Richard Attenborough, James Garner, and Charles Bronson. Director John Sturges masterfully balances multi-faceted tones—ranging from tense to whimsical—creating a film that captivates across its nearly three-hour length.

Central to its allure is the meticulous depiction of escape logistics, underscored by a gripping narrative of solidarity and ingenuity. Richard Attenborough’s character, Squadron Leader Bartlett, orchestrates an ambitious plan for the mass escape of 250 men through three tunnels. Each character serves a purpose: James Garner’s Hendley skillfully procures essential items, Donald Pleasance as Blythe forges documents, and Charles Bronson’s Danny digs tunnels. Particularly memorable are McQueen’s scenes; his rebellious Captain Virgil Hilts, encapsulates the spirit of defiance as he repeatedly challenges the camp authorities, culminating in an iconic motorcycle chase.

Sturges' direction elevates the narrative, maintaining clarity through complex logistics and shifting tones adeptly—from moments of celebration, such as making moonshine, to the harrowing escape sequences. Even the contrasting moods enrich the viewing experience, heightening the poignancy of triumphs against a backdrop of impending danger. While deviations from actual events exist, the film remains grounded in authentic emotional and historical contexts.

Overall, "The Great Escape" stands as a testament to resilience and ingenuity. Its blend of historical drama and thrilling escapism continues to resonate, cementing its status as an enduring classic in war cinema.

"The Great Escape" consistently captivates with its blend of suspenseful drama, comedic undertones, and poignant tragedy, brought to life by an all-star cast. As a Blu-ray release, this film offers fans a welcome high-definition experience, though it is not without issues. The HD transfer leaves room for improvement; the picture can appear soft and lacks the depth expected from Blu-ray technology. However, the transition to a DTS-HD MA soundtrack is a significant auditory enhancement, though some purists may miss the original Mono audio.

The special features on this Blu-ray are comprehensive but carry over mostly from the 2004 two-disc DVD Collector's Set. Unfortunately, these features remain in standard definition, with the notable exception of the HD theatrical trailer. Despite these shortcomings, this Blu-ray release stands as likely the best available version for "The Great Escape" in the foreseeable future. MGM's recent history suggests that a full negative-level restoration is improbable due to cost constraints.

In conclusion, "The Great Escape" on Blu-ray is a commendable addition to any collection, primarily due to its value and content continuity. Its technical flaws do not overshadow its historical and cinematic significance. True fans and collectors will appreciate owning this classic in its current best form, but casual viewers or those concerned with perfect quality might opt to rent or await further reductions in price.