Guns for San Sebastian Blu-ray Review
La bataille de San Sebastian Warner Archive Collection
Score: 68
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Guns for San Sebastian is a unique Spaghetti Western set in Mexico, featuring a strong performance by Anthony Quinn and excellent Blu-ray presentation by Warner Archive.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 82
The Blu-ray of Guns for San Sebastian delivers an outstanding 1080p transfer from 2K or 4K scans, featuring a sharp, clean image with rich detail and natural film grain. Colors pop vividly amid earth-toned settings, with deep blacks and smooth motion enhancing the visual experience. Compression is expertly managed with no banding or artifacts.
Audio: 82
The DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio of 'Guns for San Sebastian' faithfully replicates the original mono track, delivering clear dialogue and a robust presentation of Ennio Morricone's score with minimal distortion. While lacking in high-end depth, effects are well-layered, satisfying audio purists.
Extra: 21
The Blu-ray extras offer a glimpse into the film's production with a stiffly-narrated but intriguing behind-the-scenes featurette, 'San Sebastian: 1746 in 1968,' showcasing set footage and language dynamics, complemented by theatrical trailers that enhance the vintage appeal.
Movie: 66
Guns for San Sebastian showcases Anthony Quinn's magnetic performance in this multifaceted Spaghetti Western, filmed in Mexico, featuring a strong original score by Ennio Morricone and notable stunt work. The film, while overstuffed with minor characters, delivers engaging action and an intriguing narrative.
Video: 82
The Blu-ray presentation of "Guns for San Sebastian" receives a commendable visual treatment, showcasing the consistent high-quality restorations typical of Warner Archive. Leveraging a 1080p transfer via a dual-layered BD-50 disc encoded in MPEG-4 AVC, this release reflects meticulous crafting from source elements likely stemming from 2K or 4K scans. The image quality is notably crisp, with a fine grain layer that preserves the film's authentic texture without succumbing to over-digitalization issues like artificial sharpening or excessive noise reduction. The visual narrative prevails with distinct clarity across both close-up and wide-angle shots.
Colors are strategically vivid, although predominantly subdued to match the film's aesthetic. The initial sepia-tinged opening transitions into a vibrant palate featuring clear blue skies and earthy tones—integral to its desert village setting. Select sequences break this muted palette with striking reds and greens, bringing scenes such as the church invasion and festive gatherings to life. Notably, this high-resolution transfer maintains excellent color reproduction, allowing flesh tones to appear natural and smooth from beginning to end. Black levels are well-handled, offering deep, natural shadows and preventing detail loss via crushing.
In terms of technical execution, the Blu-ray maintains an impressive depth through keen handling of scale and motion fluidity—conveying distance and dynamic movement unblemished by digital artifacts or banding issues. A strong compression strategy ensures no visible traces of artifacts that could detract from the viewing experience. Overall, this release stands as a testament to Warner Archive's dedication to delivering legacy films with unparalleled fidelity and an engaging visual experience for collectors and enthusiasts alike.
Audio: 82
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Guns for San Sebastian" offers a commendable reproduction of its original one-channel source using the DTS-HD 2.0 Master Audio format. The restoration brings forth Ennio Morricone’s iconic score with remarkable clarity and presence, ensuring that it resonates powerfully alongside the film’s action scenes. While some may note a slight thinness on the higher end, the sound effects such as gunshots and explosions deliver considerable impact and depth. This mix remains free of common audio imperfections like distortion, hiss, or location sync issues, speaking to the effective restoration efforts that cater well to audio purists.
The mono track provides an impressive dynamic range, with solid low-frequency tones adding weight to the audio landscape. The elements of effects, dialogue, and music are well-integrated, achieving a balanced layering without any noticeable analog hiss. An interesting aspect is the blend of live audio typical of spaghetti westerns, which maintains crisp and clear vocal reproduction, diverging from the fully ADR-driven approach often used in the genre.
However, a point of critique is the lack of optional English subtitles during the extras, though they are available for the main feature. This is a minor frustration in an otherwise expertly crafted audio release, which brings a satisfying aural experience to the viewer.
Extras: 21
The Blu-ray release of "Guns for San Sebastian" offers a selection of extras that, while stemming from earlier DVD editions, provide valuable insights into the film's production. The highlighted featurette, San Sebastian: 1746 in 1968, presents a historically enriching behind-the-scenes exploration directed by Floyd L. Peterson. This segment, albeit with a somewhat formal narration, succeeds in engaging viewers with significant on-set footage and informative interviews. It sheds light on the linguistics challenges faced during production, ameliorated by Anthony Quinn’s multilingual capabilities. Complementing this is the Theatrical Trailer, which offers a succinct promotional glimpse into the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- San Sebastian: 1746 in 1968: An insightful behind-the-scenes featurette with on-set footage and discussion of production nuances.
- Theatrical Trailer: A brief and engaging promotional trailer.
Movie: 66
"Guns for San Sebastian," filmed in Mexico and directed by Henri Verneuil, offers a unique twist on the traditional Spaghetti Western, notable for its original location audio, diverging from the genre's standard post-production ADR approach. Starring Anthony Quinn in the lead role, the film features his nuanced portrayal of Leon Alastray, a fugitive mistakenly taken as a priest. This adaptation of William Faherty's "A Wall for San Sebastian" combines action-adventure with existential undertones, enriched by Ennio Morricone's powerful score and striking editing. The film stands out for its engaging narrative arc, despite an overabundance of minor characters, driven by Leon's reluctant leadership connected to a village threatened by violent Yaqui Indians and internal treachery from vaqueros led by Charles Bronson’s character, Teclo.
Opening with a dramatic encounter in a church sanctuary, the movie leverages its thematic depth by exploring Alastray's transformation from an army deserter into a leader and pseudo-savior of the besieged community. The dynamic chemistry between Quinn and Bronson adds compelling tension to scenes, while the film's narrative pivots introduce unexpected plot twists, maintaining the audience's interest. The climactic final act is marked by intense action sequences and stunts that enhance the dramatic stakes, showcasing the stark realities of survival and leadership under siege. The film channels a spirit reminiscent of both Western and samurai genres, weaving a narrative of identity, redemption, and communal resilience.
Despite not reaching classic status, "Guns for San Sebastian" is a visually and emotionally engaging cinematic experience that deserves recognition, not just for its captivating performances and narrative subtleties but also for its ability to stand out in a crowded genre with its unique production choices and narrative flair.
Total: 68
Henri Verneuil's "Guns for San Sebastian," distinctively set against Mexico's vibrant landscape, offers a refreshing take on the spaghetti western genre. Anchored by Anthony Quinn's commanding performance, the film remains a captivating adventure, though Charles Bronson’s admirers might find his limited appearance disappointing. The narrative unfolds with a deliberate pace, sprinkled with memorable sequences and culminating in a robust third act. Despite occasional narrative lulls and a plethora of supplementary characters, the story sustains interest through its unique setting and thematic depth.
The Blu-ray release by Warner Archive presents this hidden gem with a high-quality audio-visual experience, faithful to the film's original cinematic impact. The video quality exhibits excellent clarity, preserving the film's vivid color palette and intricate details. Surround sound enhancements ensure an immersive experience, pulling viewers into the heart of San Sebastian's unfolding drama. Additionally, the disc includes modest bonus content that provides insightful perspectives without overshadowing the main feature, enhancing the film’s appreciation without overwhelming it.
In conclusion, "Guns for San Sebastian" is a noteworthy entry in the Western genre with its distinctive Mexican setting and powerful lead performance. While not perfect, it achieves a compelling blend of action and atmosphere that warrants re-examination decades after its initial release. This Blu-ray version is an ideal choice for Western aficionados and curious newcomers alike, offering a chance to experience the film in an optimized format that respects and revitalizes its original charm. Recommended for purchase or rental, it’s an opportunity to discover or rediscover a unique take on Western cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Randy Miller IIIRead review here
Video: 90
Once the yellow-tinted veil is lifted after the opening titles, Guns for San Sebastian establishes a specific appearance that's maintained during the bulk of the film: clear blue skies, dry and earth-toned...
Audio: 90
Like the 1080p transfer, this is a nicely-restored mix that's largely free of any real distorion, hiss, drop-outs, and on-location sync issues....
Extras: 20
This stiffly-narrated but enjoyable behind-the-scenes piece, produced and directed by Floyd L. Peterson. features an overview of the legend as well as a good amount of on-set footage including director...
Movie: 70
But the film plays fast and loose with some of its left-field plot developments, and a few minor characters could have easily been written out with little consequence to the most interesting part of this...
Total: 70
Either way, it's a slow-burn story with plenty of memorable moments and a solid third act, even if the film spins its wheels a bit along the way and feels a little overloaded with inconsequential supporting...
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 90
Scale comes across pretty impressively as you get a sense of distance with the pushback on the hills, the village, characters and object medium in frame and the like....
Audio: 90
Effects, vocals and music are all wonderfully balanced and wound together with good space on one another....
Extras: 30
A decent little piece of vintage behind the scenes work, narrated and featuring on-set footage and interviews....
Movie: 70
The film has a lot of fun with its set, its battles and characters to make it one to check back in on every once in a while....
Total: 80
Warner Archive Collection provides it with a pretty rock solid presentation to go with a nice little archival feature to add a little more heft to the disc....
Director: Henri Verneuil
Actors: Anthony Quinn, Anjanette Comer, Charles Bronson
PlotIn the 18th-century Mexican desert, a fugitive named Leon Alastray seeks refuge from soldiers pursuing him. After managing to escape, he befriends a sympathetic priest who provides him sanctuary in his church. However, when hostile forces falsely accuse the church of harboring enemies of the Crown, chaos ensues, leading to tragic consequences for his benefactor. With no other choice, Leon adopts the identity of a priest and escapes to the remote village of San Sebastian. The villagers, unaware of his true identity, welcome him with open arms, seeing him as a figure sent to revive their abandoned church.
In San Sebastian, Leon discovers a community beleaguered by Apache raids and paralyzed by fear and superstition. Leveraging his new role, he becomes an unlikely leader, inspiring the villagers to rebuild their defenses and confront their oppressors. As he navigates his own past misdeeds, Leon struggles with the responsibilities that come with his assumed identity. Tensions rise as he attempts to forge unity among the villagers, setting the stage for inevitable confrontations with both the local governance and external threats. Throughout this journey, Leon must confront moral dilemmas and the question of redemption as he attempts to transform San Sebastian from a desolate town into a thriving community.
Writers: William Barby Faherty, Serge Gance, Miguel Morayta
Release Date: 02 May 1968
Runtime: 111 min
Rating: G
Country: France, Italy, Mexico, United States
Language: English