The Deep End Blu-ray Review
Score: 58
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Deep End, while faltering into melodrama, is elevated by Tilda Swinton's superb performance, and the Blu-ray's top-notch video and audio quality make it recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 60
The Blu-ray of 'The Deep End' features a strong 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer with an accurate and lush palette, maintaining appropriate grittiness through light grain. Excellent contrast, color saturation, and sharp reflections, though minor digital artifacts and halos are present in outdoor and dark scenes.
Audio: 65
The Deep End's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix delivers clean, clear dialogue and subtle surround atmospherics, with standout sequences featuring the family boat and smart foley effects placement. While bass is minimal, the track boasts excellent fidelity, dynamic range, and tonal depth.
Extra: 41
A solid supplemental package offering a blend of technical insights and creative perspectives, with highlights including an engaging commentary from Scott McGehee and David Siegel, a detailed 'Anatomy of a Scene' featurette, and succinct promotional materials.
Movie: 61
The Deep End, a taut thriller from Scott McGehee and David Siegel, captivates with a blend of suspense and parental devotion, exploring a mother's extreme measures to protect her son. Tilda Swinton's standout performance anchors the plot, which, despite some improbabilities, maintains tension and relevance through its emotional depth and meticulous direction.
Video: 60
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Deep End" by 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment offers an impressive AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.34:1 aspect ratio. The film's lush palette is beautifully maintained, popping at key moments with vivid high definition detail. For instance, the teal sheen in the scene where Margaret discovers Reese's body is subtly but vibrantly rendered. Sharpness is generally good, though minor digital halos around objects, especially in outdoor footage, indicate some digital sharpening. Despite this, the fine detail remains commendable across the presentation, supported by consistent contrast and robust black levels.
Colors throughout the transfer are notably accurate and nicely saturated, with superior color balance evident. Reds, while sparingly used, make a significant visual impact in scenes like those featuring a flashy sports car or Swinton’s coat, whereas blues and greens blend seamlessly into the film's fabric. The addition of light grain texture enhances the cinematic feel without sacrificing clarity. The source material remains pristine with no visible nicks or scratches, contributing to the immersive experience. Solid black levels and well-maintained fleshtones add depth to the image, enhancing shadow delineation and ensuring background elements are discernible without any crush or noise issues.
Overall, the "The Deep End" Blu-ray provides a solid video presentation that elevates the film's dramatic narrative effectively. While there are slight blemishes, such as compression artifacts in dark scenes, these are minimal and do not significantly detract from the viewing experience. This transfer is a robust effort that engages viewers thoroughly while staying true to the film's atmospheric and visual intent.
Audio: 65
The lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix of "The Deep End" offers a nuanced and immersive sound experience that elevates the film's atmospheric tension. Key sequences, particularly those involving Margaret and the family boat, showcase exceptional surround activity and meticulously placed foley effects. The crisp chirping of birds, the hum of a power boat's motor, and the buzz of a doorbell are rendered with pristine clarity. The film's quiet, dialogue-driven moments are delivered cleanly, thanks to the track’s impressive fidelity and lack of distortion or surface noise.
Peter Nashel's music score benefits immensely from fine fidelity and tonal depth, enveloping the room with a rich audio texture. The dynamic range effectively captures both the subtle highs and lows, ensuring that the audio remains smooth and engaging throughout. Dialogue is presented with impressive clarity and coherence, whether it is delivered in hushed tones or during overlapping conversations, maintaining the audience's focus on the film's narrative. Although the subwoofer sees little action due to minimal bass content, the absence of low-end impact does not detract from the overall audio presentation.
Extras: 41
The Blu Ray extras for "The Deep End" offer valuable insights into the film's creation and thematic elements. The commentary by directors David Siegel and Scott McGehee provides intricate details about the adaptation process, casting choices, and technical challenges, although it may lose momentum towards the end. The "Anatomy of a Scene" featurette delves deeply into one of the movie's pivotal moments, offering a comprehensive look at the various creative decisions made during production. A brief making-of featurette and promotional content like the theatrical trailer and TV spot round out the offerings, providing a well-rounded supplemental package that will satisfy both casual viewers and film aficionados.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Anatomy of a Scene: Examination of a critical scene with storyboards and interviews.
- Featurette: Brief EPK about the film's premise.
- Commentary by David Siegel and Scott McGehee: Insights on adaptation, casting, and production.
- Theatrical Trailer: Preview emphasizing the thriller aspects.
- TV Spot: Short television ad for the film.
Movie: 61
"The Deep End" stands as both a gripping thriller and a psychological drama, driven by the powerhouse performance of Tilda Swinton. Directed by Scott McGehee and David Siegel, the film is an exploration of the lengths a parent will go to protect their child, enveloped in an increasingly desperate and labyrinthine plot. Swinton's Margaret Hall, a mother of three living in Lake Tahoe, finds herself in a moral quagmire when her son's illicit relationship with Darby Reese (Josh Lucas) seemingly culminates in Reese's accidental death. McGehee and Siegel draw from the 1949 noir "The Reckless Moment," infusing the narrative with contemporary issues that amplify its urgency and emotional weight.
The film opens with Margaret, preternaturally anxious, confronting Reese at his gay bar, setting off a chain of events that she struggles to control. As the story unfolds, the tension mounts significantly with the introduction of Alek Spera (Goran Visnjic), an enigmatic blackmailer carrying an incriminating tape. Margaret’s impulsive decision to dispose of Reese’s body propels her into an intricate battle of wits, where she must navigate blackmail and hide her son’s possible involvement in the incident. Though some narrative elements stretch credulity, such as unexplained coincidences and overly convenient developments, the film maintains suspense through its polished direction and strong character interactions.
The atmospheric Lake Tahoe backdrop provides a stark contrast to the turbulent inner lives of its characters. Cinematography captures both the serene beauty of the locale and the escalating chaos of the plot, while Swinton’s visceral portrayal of maternal determination anchors the film. Despite occasional lapses in narrative plausibility, "The Deep End" offers a compelling glimpse into extreme parental devotion, bolstered by its noir Homage and Swinton’s formidable performance.
Total: 58
'The Deep End', anchored by Tilda Swinton's compelling performance, tells the thrilling tale of a mother's desperate attempts to shield her family from catastrophe. The film initially grips with a palpable tension, but falters slightly as it veers into melodrama. Swinton's portrayal of a mother battling to maintain control in the face of mounting chaos is nothing short of stellar. This Blu-ray release boasts commendable video quality and robust audio, enhancing the overall viewing experience. Additionally, the inclusion of insightful supplemental materials enriches the understanding of this complex narrative.
Visually, 'The Deep End' delivers sharp, detailed images with minimal imperfections. The color palette, while subdued, effectively conveys the film's somber tone. Audio-wise, the Blu-ray serves up a clear and immersive soundtrack, allowing viewers to appreciate the subtleties of both dialogue and background score. These elements come together to create an atmospheric presentation that does justice to the film’s high-stakes storyline.
The Deep End has a nice sense of just barely tamped down chaos threatening to erupt at any given moment, but it starts to lose steam once the blackmailer shows up and the film starts to wobble into melodrama and over-the-top histrionics. Swinton is outstanding as a mother with a fierce desire to keep everything under control, even when fate keeps snatching order from her grasping fingertips. There are some very minor things to be aware of with regard to the video quality of this release, but despite those, 'The Deep End' comes Recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
While sharpness is generally quite good, at least some of that acuity may have been achieved through digital means, as there are admittedly minor but still noticeable halos on objects, especially in some...
Audio: 80
The Deep End's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix has a couple of standout sequences, notably a couple of scenes involving Margaret and the family boat, where surround activity is outstanding and there...
Extras: 50
"The Anatomy of a Scene" Sundance Channel (480i; 24:07) actually looks at a few moments in the film, but concentrates on an integral scene with Margaret and Spera....
Movie: 70
This is a film where members of a family barely speak to each other, but where an involved mother finds herself ensconced in an ever murkier web of death, alleged murder and ultimately blackmail, while...
Total: 70
The Deep End has a nice sense of just barely tamped down chaos threatening to erupt at any given moment, but it starts to lose steam once the blackmailer shows up and the film starts to wobble into melodrama...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Reds are used sparingly, but when they appear - a flashy sports car and Swinton's stylish coat - they make a statement, while the blues and greens of the land and waterscapes blend more seamlessly into...
Audio: 80
There's not much bass to speak of, so the subwoofer remains ineffective, and no distortion or surface noise disrupts the smoothness of the presentation....
Extras: 40
Among other things, the pair talks about the alterations they made to the story during the adaptation process, how they rearranged the opening sequence, the casting of Tilda Swinton and her meticulous...
Movie: 60
When viewed in that context, 'The Deep End' more fully resonates (Margaret often resembles the self-sacrificing Mildred Pierce, immortalized by Joan Crawford, who would go to any lengths to keep her ungrateful...
Total: 60
A finely constructed and executed thriller that's ultimately let down by its implausible plot, 'The Deep End' features top-notch performances from a stellar cast led by Tilda Swinton, who plays a mother...
Director: Scott McGehee, David Siegel
Actors: Tilda Swinton, Goran Visnjic, Jonathan Tucker
PlotMargaret Hall, a devoted mother, discovers that her teenage son, Beau, may be involved in a relationship with an older man, Darby Reese. Concerned for his welfare, she confronts Darby. However, things take a dark turn when Darby is found dead near their lakeside home. In a desperate bid to protect her son, Margaret attempts to cover up any potential involvement, disposing of key evidence that might link Beau to the incident.
As she navigates this perilous situation, her efforts attract the attention of a shady character named Alek Spera, who uses the situation to leverage his own agenda. Margaret finds herself entangled in a web of blackmail and moral dilemmas as she tries to keep her family safe. The tension escalates, forcing her to make increasingly difficult and dangerous decisions as the layers of deception begin to unravel.
Writers: Elisabeth Sanxay Holding, Scott McGehee, David Siegel
Release Date: 31 Aug 2001
Runtime: 101 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English