No Highway in the Sky Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
While 'No Highway in the Sky' falters in pacing, strong performances by Stewart and supporting cast, along with solid Blu-ray audio and video transfers, keep it engaging.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
The AVC encoded 1080p presentation of 'No Highway in the Sky' boasts acceptable detail and cinematographic textures, despite faint scratches and mild speckling. Excellent contrast and clarity, with deep blacks, crisp whites, and nicely varied grays, offer a lovely depth and presence, maintaining a pleasing celluloid feel.
Audio: 68
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mix offers a solid and clear listening experience, capturing dialogue effectively even amid robust airplane engine sounds, though some early obscured dialogue can occur. The sound is free from age-related hiss and distortion, with supportive scoring and compelling instrumentation.
Extra: 26
The Blu-ray extras for 'No Highway in the Sky' feature an engaging audio commentary with film historian Jeremy Arnold and Bob Koster, providing deep insights into the film's production, director Henry Koster's background, and fascinating trivia, alongside a collection of relevant theatrical trailers.
Movie: 61
"No Highway in the Sky" explores the era's significant topic of airline safety, blending drama, suspense, and sporadic comedy. Featuring standout performances by James Stewart and Marlene Dietrich, the film engages with its well-drawn characters but struggles with narrative pacing, resulting in a sophisticated yet somewhat emotionally flat experience.
Video: 68
The AVC encoded image (1.34:1 aspect ratio) presentation for the Blu Ray release of "No Highway in the Sky" generally holds up well, though there are noticeable signs of wear and tear, including faint scratching and some mild speckling throughout large sections of the film. Detail is adequately rendered given the cinematographic limitations of the era, bringing out textures in set decoration and costuming effectively. James Stewart's facial particulars, captured with satisfactory clarity, add depth to his performance. Although Marlene Dietrich's close-ups rely on a soft glamour focus, the delineation remains secure.
The 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer shows slight raggedness but excels with impressive contrast and clarity. While a few errant marks and vertical scratches are evident, particularly during the opening titles and early scenes, the print benefits from deep black levels, crisp whites, and varied grays, which lend the picture a pleasing depth and presence. The faint yet discernible grain preserves the film's celluloid texture, maintaining its vintage feel. Background elements are distinct, shadow detail is commendable, and no signs of digital manipulation are detected. Despite some softness in Dietrich's close-ups, which remain lush and glamorous, fans will appreciate this above-average rendering of a classic film.
Audio: 68
The 2.0 DTS-HD Master Audio sound mix for "No Highway in the Sky" delivers a satisfactory auditory experience, considering the film’s age. Dialogue exchanges remain clear, enabling viewers to appreciate emotional nuances, especially during moments when Stewart’s performance becomes more intense and borderline hysterical. While there are instances where the roaring airplane engines marginally obscure some dialogue, overall speech clarity is well-maintained despite the British accents.
The sound effects are robust, with a notable emphasis on the heavier airplane engines and testing range winds which enrich the auditory environment without any significant hiss or age-related artifacts. The soundtrack, supplemented predominantly by the hum of engines and minimal musical scoring, benefits from a wide dynamic range that handles high volumes with minimal distortion. Although the highs can come across as somewhat crispy, they generally do not detract from the viewing experience. As a whole, this 2.0 DTS-HD MA track is competent, balancing between effective sound delivery and the inevitable constraints of the source material’s vintage nature.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray extras for "No Highway in the Sky" are minimal yet substantial. The highlight is the Audio Commentary with film historian Jeremy Arnold and Bob Koster, offering an engaging exploration of the film's production, director Henry Koster's background and style, and intriguing trivia. Arnold and Koster discuss themes such as the innovative metal fatigue prediction from Nevil Shute's source novel, detailed anecdotes about the cast, and behind-the-scenes legalities. Additionally, the package includes a selection of theatrical trailers that provide context and promotional insight to the era's film industry.
Extras included in this disc:
Audio Commentary: Engaging insights from Jeremy Arnold and Bob Koster on film production, trivia, and more. Theatrical Trailers: Previews of "No Highway in the Sky" and other related films.
Movie: 61
1951's "No Highway in the Sky," based on the novel by Nevil Shute, is an intriguing blend of drama and disaster, centered around airplane safety. Directed by Henry Koster, the film is anchored by the compelling performances of James Stewart as Theodore Honey, an absent-minded yet brilliant engineer, and Marlene Dietrich in a supportive role as a Hollywood actress. Stewart's character is tasked with analyzing the structural integrity of a new airplane model amidst rising concerns about metal fatigue. While Stewart's portrayal adds layers of intellectual clumsiness and depth to his character, Dietrich's nuanced performance complements his intensity, enhancing their undeniable on-screen chemistry.
"No Highway in the Sky" promises an edge-of-your-seat experience but occasionally falls short of the suspense typically expected from airline disaster films. The narrative oscillates between cerebral debates on airplane design, moments of intimate drama, and segments of building tension as Honey realizes he is aboard a potentially doomed flight. Though the storyline can feel disjointed—at times too reserved for a disaster movie—the film's British production roots shine through in its civilized tone and sharp handling of aviation safety themes.
Despite its uneven pacing, "No Highway in the Sky" delivers commendable performances from Stewart and Dietrich, which are supported by a solid cast—including Glynis Johns as a sympathetic stewardess and Jack Hawkins as an airline executive. While the film sometimes struggles to maintain a consistent level of suspense and emotional engagement, it remains a fascinating exploration of aviation risks and the human responses to them. It's an essential viewing for fans of classic cinema, offering a unique look at early 1950s perspectives on air travel safety and scientific inquiry.
Total: 59
"No Highway in the Sky," a Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber, captures the dramatic essence of Henry Koster’s tale with commendable video and audio transfers. The film, led by James Stewart, Marlene Dietrich, Glynis Johns, and Jack Hawkins, intertwines comedy, drama, and suspense, albeit with a pacing that sometimes retreats into prolonged ground narratives. Stewart shines through as an eccentric aircraft engineer convinced that a commercial plane is doomed to crash due to metal fatigue, transforming procedural dialogues into captivating sequences.
While the film's narrative structure occasionally stumbles away from its central air-distress theme, delving deep into air safety debates and the mental state of Stewart's character, these segments are offset by the stellar performances of the cast. Stewart's compelling portrayal injects life even into the more static parts of the film. That said, despite the thrilling premise, "No Highway in the Sky" struggles to maintain consistent tension and excitement throughout its runtime.
The Blu-ray presentation includes a finely crafted commentary track that enhances the viewing experience, providing richer context and insights. Although the film may not completely fulfill the high hopes of an aviation thriller, it remains an engaging piece thanks to its strong cast and thoughtful execution. Fans of Stewart and Dietrich will particularly find this release worthwhile for its nuanced performances and historical value.
In conclusion, while "No Highway in the Sky" may not soar at every turn, it deftly navigates through its narrative with solid character work and technical merits. This Blu-ray edition, highlighted by superior audio-visual quality and insightful extras, makes it a noteworthy addition for classic film enthusiasts and those appreciative of mid-20th century cinema nuances. Thrills and character dynamics blend together to create a multifaceted viewing journey that holds its own despite occasional dips in excitement.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
The AVC encoded image (1.34:1 aspect ratio) presentation isn't riddled with damage, but faint scratching runs though large sections of the movie, highlighting wear and tear that also includes some mild...
Audio: 80
Dialogue exchanges are acceptable, maintaining emotional extremes as Stewart's performance touches on hysteria at times....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 70
While it takes time to get Stewart in the air, "No Highway in the Sky" actually achieves a wonderful fever pitch, challenging the star to come up with varied ways to communicate utter distress....
Total: 70
The rest of the film highlights conversations about air safety and the sanity of Stewart's character, making the effort more procedural, inching away from its air panic centerpiece....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Though grain is faint, there's enough texture to preserve the feel of celluloid, and the close-ups of Dietrich, while a bit on the soft side, are appropriately lush and glamorous....
Audio: 80
There's not much music in the film - the hum of engines and propellers supply the "soundtrack" - but a wide dynamic scale handles all the bombast without a hint of distortion....
Extras: 20
He also discusses how 'No Highway in the Sky' relates to other airline disaster movies, reveals Dietrich was not enthusiastic about making the film, and talks about the legal reasons behind the decision...
Movie: 60
No Highway in the Sky' reunited Stewart and Dietrich a dozen years after their legendary pairing in the classic western 'Destry Rides Again,' and even though Dietrich plays what is really a supporting...
Total: 60
Director Henry Koster's airplane-in-jeopardy film spends too much time on the ground, but winning performances from James Stewart, Marlene Dietrich, Glynis Johns, and Jack Hawkins help buoy this slow-moving...
Director: Henry Koster
Actors: James Stewart, Marlene Dietrich, Glynis Johns
PlotThe story centers around an eccentric aeronautical engineer, Theodore Honey, who works for the Royal Aircraft Establishment. He's tasked with investigating the structural integrity of the Reindeer, a new type of airplane. Honey becomes convinced that the Reindeer's tailplane will fail after a certain number of flight hours due to metal fatigue, but his warnings are initially dismissed because he lacks concrete evidence. While en route to examine a crashed Reindeer, Honey discovers to his horror that the plane he is currently on is one of the Reindeers close to reaching its critical flight hours.
With mounting anxiety, Honey informs the crew and passengers about his finding, leading to diverse reactions among those onboard. Some believe him, stirring tension and panic, while others remain skeptical. As the situation escalates, Honey's dedication and unorthodox methods clash with corporate skepticism and protocol. His determination puts him at odds with authorities and colleagues alike, challenging both engineering principles and human faith in technology. The unfolding drama revolves around whether his alarming prediction can be validated in time to prevent a catastrophic failure.
Writers: Nevil Shute, R.C. Sherriff, Oscar Millard
Release Date: 21 Sep 1951
Runtime: 98 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English