Father Stu Blu-ray Review
Score: 67
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Father Stu on Blu-ray delivers solid audio and video quality, showcasing Wahlberg's unorthodox role but faltering with limited extras and spiritual depth.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 81
The Blu-ray of "Father Stu" delivers a generally excellent 2.39:1 AVC picture with fine details and strong colors, though a persistent yellow tint disrupts the otherwise well-lit and vibrant visuals. The detailing is intricate, especially in faces and locations, with minimal noise and no significant encode issues.
Audio: 77
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track of 'Father Stu' excels in clear dialogue and immersive sound despite its low-budget drama constraints, offering robust engagement during key scenes like the boxing ring and car crash, ensuring a capable mix that prioritizes realism and vocal clarity.
Extra: 27
The Blu-ray of Father Stu offers over ten minutes of deleted scenes and the 'You Don't Know Stu' featurette, providing an insightful look through brief 1080p vignettes into Long's multifaceted life journey, complemented by an embossed slipcover and a Movies Anywhere digital copy.
Movie: 61
"Father Stu" offers a compelling biopic on the real-life transformation of Stuart Long, driven by Mark Wahlberg's personal passion and funding. Despite solid performances by Wahlberg and Mel Gibson, the narrative struggles with depth and coherence, leaving some spiritual elements undeveloped. While its raw charisma shines through, the film's mostly uplifting storyline is occasionally marred by an uneven tone and controversial language choices.
Video: 81
The Blu-ray release of "Father Stu" presents a 2.39:1 AVC encoded image that aligns with expectations for a contemporary film, offering a blend of clarity and occasional inconsistencies. In brightly lit scenes, the image is near flawless, delivering exceptional detail and pristine quality. Interior shots maintain strong black levels and vibrant primary colors, contributing to an overall crisp presentation. However, notable is a pervasive yellow tinge, intended to evoke a nostalgic 70s aesthetic. While this stylistic choice adds a period flair, it also causes an unnatural, jaundiced look on character makeup, particularly evident in more heavily made-up scenes.
Despite the color grading's idiosyncrasies, the finely tuned picture captures intricate facial details, from pores to facial hair, ensuring modern clarity and intimacy. The environments, whether hospital rooms or church sanctuaries, showcase resplendent definition and capture the essence of each location with precision. The palette remains expressive and balanced, with skin tones appearing healthy amidst deep blacks and crisp whites. Overall noise is minimal, with no discernible source or encoding issues detracting from the viewing experience.
While the visual execution doesn't revolutionize expectations for new format releases, it provides a dependable standard of excellence typical of Sony's recent offerings. The film’s representation under these technical specifications delivers a visually engaging and satisfying presentation that underscores its narrative without overwhelming with unnecessary embellishments or distractions.
Audio: 77
The "Father Stu" Blu-ray audio presentation features a 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track that delivers an efficiently crafted sound experience appropriate to the film's reserved, dialogue-driven approach. While not designed for high-impact surround environments, the track is proficient, with emphasis placed on clear vocal delivery. The mix handles dynamic elements with ease, notably evident in the film's opening boxing scene, where the energy of punches is rendered through immersive surround content creating an engaging atmosphere. The bass is utilized minimally, with primary engagement reserved for scenes such as the basketball game and car crash, delivering brief but impactful moments.
Throughout the film, the dialogue remains at the core, supported by a balanced mix that prioritizes clarity and intelligibility, maintaining focus on the narrative. The sonic environment shifts towards a more subtle auditory experience post-opening, aligning with the low-budget film's intent and enhancing its realistic portrayal. Although it predominantly leans towards center-focused dialogue and ambient sounds, the audio mix exhibits commendable consistency in realism and immersion.
However, occasional mumbling may necessitate subtitles for complete comprehension of certain vocal parts. Despite this minor issue, "Father Stu’s" DTS-HD MA track achieves its objective effectively. It remains in line with industry standards for contemporary films, offering sharp vocals primarily through the front stage. As a simple yet functional soundtrack, it elevates key moments without overwhelming the listening experience, demonstrating the film’s dedication to a purposeful and focused auditory narrative.
Extras: 27
The Blu-ray edition of "Father Stu" offers a comprehensive array of bonus features that enhance the viewing experience by providing deeper insights into the life and legacy of Father Stuart Long. The extras include a collection of over 10 minutes of deleted scenes, offering narratives that stretch beyond the film's final cut, while maintaining high definition production quality. Notably, the deleted scenes add dimensions to the story, with vignettes such as "A Liability," "I Got a Date," and "Can't Find God in a Bottle." Additionally, "You Don't Know Stu" is a series of succinct featurettes that delve into various facets of Stu's life journey, ranging from his days as a boxer and troublemaker to his eventual path to priesthood and lasting legacy. For keen viewers, the technical clarity and narrative depth provided in these extras are both engaging and enlightening.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scenes: Over 10 minutes of captivating, extended storylines.
- You Don't Know Stu: A series of insightful vignettes on Long's life.
- Previews: Featured promotions for additional Sony titles.
Movie: 61
"Father Stu" is a unique narrative fusion of Mark Wahlberg's impassioned portrayal and a spiritually-laden biopic about Stuart Long, a former boxer turned Catholic priest. Wahlberg invests deeply in this project, both financially and artistically, capturing Long's tumultuous journey from a life of secular struggles to spiritual aspirations. Despite the film navigating through some narrative unevenness and controversy over its candid use of language, it stands as an engaging depiction of faith tested by relentless adversities. The film occasionally leans more on Wahlberg's charismatic persona than on true character transformation, but this does not severely detract from the emotional depth of Long's transformational story.
The film's core strength lies in its portrayal of Long's gritty, earthly struggles and how these serve as pivotal moments leading up to his spiritual awakening. While some viewers find the narrative lacking in spiritual dynamism and emotional resonance, Wahlberg manages to portray Long’s persistence against life-altering challenges with raw authenticity. Notably, Mel Gibson’s portrayal as Stu’s father delivers a compelling layer of raw charisma that enriches the story, though it's framed within a limited screen time. This representation further solidifies the thematic exploration of redemption and purpose.
Despite criticisms of being less spiritually moving than anticipated, "Father Stu" offers an insightful peek into personal redemption narratives wrapped in a subtly inspirational arc. By weaving humor with deep character-driven storytelling, it creates a connection that, while perhaps not universally spiritual, remains engaging. Wahlberg’s adept interpretation ensures that Long's journey, though caught between cinematic theatrics and personal storytelling, remains sincere and captivating enough for audiences seeking a different facet of faith and human perseverance. Overall, while the film may underwhelm those expecting a profound spiritual revelation, it cultivates an appreciation for the multifaceted journey of discovering and living one's faith in a challenging world.
Total: 67
"Father Stu" is a compelling biopic that narrates the extraordinary true story of Stuart Long, brought to life by a passionate performance from Mark Wahlberg. The film showcases a shift from conventional Christian cinema, diving into challenging themes that might have contributed to its mixed reception. Mel Gibson’s charismatic presence adds depth to the narrative, although the movie struggles to convey the full spiritual journey behind the real-life tale. The storytelling balances between engaging emotional arcs and external character development, leaving audiences with a solid yet incomplete experience.
Technically, Sony's Blu-ray release offers a commendable presentation. The video displays crisp visuals in a 2.39:1 AVC aspect ratio, while the audio delivers an immersive soundscape in DTS-HD MA 5.1 for multiple languages. Although the extras are minimal, they provide some insights into the making of this passion project. The choice of an R-rating is noteworthy; it reflects the film's commitment to authenticity but might limit its reach to broader audiences seeking religious narratives.
In conclusion, "Father Stu" stands as a decent watch for those interested in faith-based stories and biographical films. While not perfect, it is bolstered by strong performances and respectable technical quality on Blu-ray. Viewers should approach it knowing the thematic weight it carries, making it an intriguing option for fans of the genre, provided they are mindful of its mature rating.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 80
The one weird thing about the film is that it’s heavily HEAVILY tinged to the yellow end of the spectrum, with a more aged “70s” look to it (even though it starts out in the 80s during Mark’s boxing days...
Audio: 80
It’s not a fault of the track itself, but simply due to the fact that this is a very low budget, low key, highly dialog dependent drama....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 70
Naturally this doesn’t actually please Carmen very much as she was hoping for a wedding band, but Stu is bound and determined to become a man of the cloth and give others the absolution he was given....
Total: 70
The Blu-ray itself is pretty bare bones with a few minor extras, and a decent set of audio and video scores....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The picture is crystal clear, revealing intricate detailing across the board, including faces most prominently which reveal pores, pits, wrinkles, lines, facial hair, and other details with A-grade modern...
Audio: 90
The listener is immediately pulled into the environment, experiencing the onslaught of surround content, hard hits, and robust immersive engagement, revealing the track's energy and vigor....
Extras: 30
Deleted Scenes (1080p, 11:54 total runtime): Included are A Liability, Ready for His Close Up, I Got a Date, Kobe Beef, I Got a Lot, Burning Up the Beads, Help the Sick Folks Hurt Themselves, I Need Something...
Movie: 60
The film is capably assembled and acted even if it's missing a certain spiritual depth and sense of movement within the audience as Long hears the call, answers it, and struggles to hold to his faith in...
Total: 70
It's a good watch, and Wahlberg is solid in an unorthodox (for him) role, but the film could have been much better were it just as concerned with the internal spiritual growth and undertones as it is the...
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 90
Interiors are well lit, offering up a generous amount of detail, flesh tones seem warm and accurate and overall the picture quality is excellent – this may or may not be a good thing when looking at Mel...
Audio: 80
All kidding aside, the opening sequence in the boxing ring is the height of the audio (see…get it now?)....
Extras: 40
the Sick Folks Hurt ThemselvesI Need Something More, PurposeWhat About My Grandbabies?Can’t Find God in a BottleThere’s a Saying in the Service You Don’t Know Stu – Essentially nine short segments that...
Movie: 0
He’s got some comedic talent as well and though it’s not on full display here, it was a treat to see him in this role....
Total: 70
Nevertheless, it’s a good showcase for Wahlberg and Gibson all the while telling the real-life tale of Stuart Long....
Director: Rosalind Ross
Actors: Mark Wahlberg, Mel Gibson, Jacki Weaver
PlotA troubled amateur boxer, Stuart Long, seeks direction in life after his career ends due to an injury. Moving from his hometown in Montana to Los Angeles with dreams of becoming an actor, he struggles with rejection and a lack of purpose. Needing a job to make ends meet, he reluctantly takes work at a supermarket, where he meets Carmen, a devout Catholic schoolteacher. Her faith intrigues him, prompting him to attend church in hopes of winning her over. Despite his skepticism about religion, a series of personal challenges and a near-fatal motorcycle accident lead him to question his life's path and the fragility of his existence.
As he recovers, Stuart undergoes a profound spiritual transformation that leads him to pursue the priesthood, determined to find redemption and meaning beyond his past mistakes. His decision is met with skepticism from those who knew him before, including his estranged parents, Bill and Kathleen, who harbor doubts about his sudden change. His journey toward ordination tests his resilience and resolve, as he confronts skepticism not only from his community but within himself. Along this path, he contends with ongoing health struggles and reconciles with elements of his past in order to embrace a life devoted to faith and service. Through his perseverance, he inspires those around him by embodying the transformative power of hope and redemption without losing his unique sense of humor and defiant spirit.
Writers: Rosalind Ross
Release Date: 15 Apr 2022
Runtime: 124 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, South Korea
Language: English