Winter's Tale Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
Winter's Tale enchants with deep themes amidst fantastical elements, offering a thoughtful journey with superb visuals.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 75
Winter's Tale boasts a clean, accurate 1080p transfer with detailed textures, vivid colors, and precise imagery, though it has a slightly flat digital feel.
Audio: 75
Winter's Tale's Blu-ray features a high-quality DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack, excellently presenting nuanced details in a dialogue-heavy film with clear soundstage moments, defined atmospherics, versatile musical delivery, and impactful sound effects.
Extra: 46
Winter's Tale DVD includes smart featurettes, a mix of deleted/extended scenes, insightful behind-the-scenes on adaptation and filming nuances, contrasting characters' morality, and detailed cast contributions, all highlighting the film's deep love story and thematic richness.
Movie: 76
Winter's Tale is a multi-themed cinematic journey mixing romance, magic, and metaphysics, driven by strong performances and a story both complex and beautifully simple.
Video: 75
Winter's Tale" arrives on Blu-ray with a stunning 1080p visual presentation that strikes a delicate balance between preserving the film's visual aesthetic and offering a window into its lush, detailed environments. The digital origin of the movie ensures a pristine image quality, free from the grain and imperfections associated with traditional film, yet this choice does lead to a marginal detachment from the texture that film inherently carries. Despite this, the clarity of the image is uncompromised, delivering exceptional detail in every frame. From the intricate designs of period costumes to the subtlest facial expressions, the transfer captures nuances with remarkable precision. This ensures that both the historical and contemporary attire showcased throughout the film are represented with unparalleled fidelity, highlighting the meticulous attention to detail in fabric and stitching.
The handling of colors within this Blu-ray presentation is noteworthy. It navigates through a varied palette with ease, adapting seamlessly to reflect the tonal shifts intended by the filmmakers. Scenes are bathed in everything from muted, sepia tones that evoke a sense of nostalgia and age, to vivid bursts of colors that bring intensity and life to the screen. Such careful color grading enhances the visual storytelling, allowing emotions and themes to resonate more deeply with the audience. Notably, the darker sequences and moments laden with digital effects maintain their clarity and depth, avoiding common pitfalls such as muddiness or loss of detail. This ensures that even in its most visually ambitious moments, "Winter's Tale" remains visually coherent and engaging.
The technical prowess of this Blu-ray release cannot be overstated. It serves as a testament to the capabilities of high-definition digital transfers, offering an image that's both crisp and teeming with life. Even with its slightly flat affectation—a consequence of its digital shoot—the image quality presents a remarkable viewing experience. The depth and texture of materials, whether it be clothing or environmental elements, are rendered with extraordinary detail, ensuring that each scene, regardless of its setting or timeline, is as immersive as it is visually spectacular. This Blu-ray does not merely display a film; it encapsulates an era, a mood, and a visual feast that transcends ordinary home viewing experiences, setting a benchmark for HD presentations.
Audio: 75
Winter's Tale" is delivered to Blu-ray audiences with an immaculate DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack, showcasing an exceptional handling of audio despite the film's lean towards a dialogue-driven experience rather than action-heavy sequences. The audio quality is notable for its precision and clarity, especially in the way it presents spoken words. Dialogue is crisply relayed through the center speaker, ensuring that every word is heard with an impressive distinctness. This focus on clarity extends to a remarkable scene in chapter five, where dialogue reverberates across the soundstage, adding depth to the auditory experience. Even the subtle soundscapes, such as those depicting the ambient noise of a bustling newspaper office, are captured with a lifelike authenticity that enhances the film's immersive qualities.
The handling of music in the soundtrack deserves special mention. Whether it's the gentle nuances of the score, the intensity of aggressive piano pieces, or the vibrancy of upbeat orchestral arrangements, each is rendered with a fidelity that spans the full auditory spectrum without compromise. Despite its quiet confidence, the soundtrack occasionally ventures into more dynamic territory. Sound effects, including the stark clarity of gunfire, are executed with a realism and presence that command attention, albeit sparingly used throughout the film. The deep bass that underscores one of the movie's most sonically rich moments towards its conclusion adds a satisfying depth to the overall soundscape.
In sum, "Winter's Tale" on Blu-ray benefits from a soundtrack that, though it might not boast the non-stop kinetic energy of other titles, excels in delivering a nuanced and richly textured audio experience. It's particularly commendable for its masterful balance of dialogue clarity, atmospheric sound design, and musical diversity. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track ensures that every sonic element, from the subtlest of whispers to the most robust of musical cues, is presented with utmost fidelity, making it a standout aspect of the film's home entertainment release.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "Winter's Tale" enrich the viewing experience by delving into the film's intricate layers and production nuances. Two featurettes provide a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look; one focuses on the overarching themes and love story adaptation from the novel, highlighting the cast's performances and the picturesque New York backdrop. The other contrasts the elemental battle between good and evil, shedding light on the film's aesthetic choices. A compilation of both extended and deleted scenes offers further insight into character development and narrative directions not fully explored in the film. Additionally, DVD and UV digital copies ensure accessibility for all types of viewers. These extras, particularly the in-depth featurettes, cater to fans and newcomers alike by providing valuable context and enriching the overall appreciation of the film’s artistic intentions.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Scenes: Winter's Tale - A Timeless Love: Cast and crew discuss themes, adaptation process, cast performances, and more.
- Behind the Scenes: Characters of Good and Evil: Exploration of the film's moral contrasts and use of light.
- Additional Scenes: A collection of extended and deleted scenes providing more depth to the storyline and character arcs.
Movie: 76
Winter's Tale," a film directed and written by Akiva Goldsman, delves into a world where romance and metaphysics merge, creating a narrative that demands the viewer's attention beyond a single screening. Based on a voluminous book, the movie encapsulates an array of genres including magic and the mystical, all while maintaining a core narrative that is surprisingly straightforward despite its complex presentation. Goldsman, known for his work on films such as "I, Robot" and "I Am Legend," once again showcases his knack for blending the profound with the peculiar. The film emerges as a beautifully crafted piece, urging viewers to abandon their preconceived notions and immerse themselves in its uniquely woven story that fluently communicates themes of life, love, and destiny against a rich thematic tapestry.
Set in an early 20th-century New York, "Winter's Tale" narrates the life of Peter Lake (Colin Farrell), a man marked by fate with a background steeped in crime and loss yet destined for something far greater. His encounter and subsequent love affair with the terminally ill Beverly Penn (Jessica Brown Findlay) under the cloud of his past and her impending doom offers a poignant exploration of love's enduring power. The narrative complexity is matched by the film's ambitious thematic scope, addressing the elemental struggle between light and darkness, intertwined destinies, and the metaphysical force of love—all while maintaining coherence and accessibility. It stands apart from similar genre attempts through its skillful balancing of intricate themes without overwhelming its audience.
The technical aspects of "Winter's Tale" might not break new ground, but they competently support the story's deeper intentions. Farrell delivers a performance that is both nuanced and deeply felt, anchoring the film's emotional and thematic explorations. His chemistry with Findlay is particularly noteworthy, as it brings a tangible depth to their ill-fated romance. Meanwhile, Russell Crowe's portrayal of Pearly Soames provides a compelling contrast, embodying the film's darker elements. Together, the cast elevates the narrative, making "Winter's Tale" an engaging experience that resonates on both an emotional and cerebral level.
Total: 69
Winter's Tale" on Blu-ray presents an intriguing mix of fantasy and reality, weaving a tapestry of magical elements with a foundation in a remarkably simpler narrative that spans a century. Despite an initial impression that might seem overly complex due to its ambitious overlay of visuals and themes, the film distinguishes itself with a clarity of storytelling at its heart. This dichotomy ensures that the deeper, more thoughtful themes are not lost among its more fantastical components, such as airborne equines and temporal anomalies. Furthermore, the Blu-ray edition excels in delivering this visually stunning tale with impeccable video and audio quality, though it could have benefited from a more robust set of supplements.
The technical excellence of the Blu-ray enhances the overall experience, ensuring that the film's detailed environments and nuanced soundscapes are conveyed with precision. This release stands out for its ability to compress a lengthy and complex story into a digestible two-hour format without sacrificing depth or wonder. The adaptation process from a potentially more elaborate narrative to a focused cinematic journey is commendable, providing a rich viewing experience that invites audiences to immerse themselves in an extraordinary world that deviates from conventional storytelling.
In conclusion, "Winter's Tale" on Blu-ray is a must-watch for those eager to explore a film that breaks away from mainstream cinema to offer something uniquely enchanting. The combination of a well-crafted story, exceptional video and audio quality, and even if slightly limited, meaningful supplements makes this release highly recommended. It stands as a testament to the power of cinema to blend the fantastical with the profound, creating an experience that is both intellectually stimulating and visually spectacular.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The digital source lends a slightly flat feel to the picture, one that lacks the organic nature of film, but it's still a technical achievement that's bound to satisfy even the most demanding viewer....
Audio: 90
The film lacks the sort of action-packed dynamic listening experience that's frequently associated with top-of-the-line soundtracks, but Warner's audio presentation handles every nuance and sonic detail...
Extras: 50
Behind the Scenes: Winter's Tale: A Timeless Love (HD, 6:08): Cast and crew discuss the film's themes, the love story and the tale that grows from it, the source novel and the process of adapting it to...
Movie: 80
From the Biblical parallels to Moses to a magical flying horse, from a classic good versus evil narrative to a string of themes that deal in fate, time, determination, inner strength, outer perseverance,...
Total: 80
Nevertheless, the film is an enchanting one, very well done in all areas and capable of taking a lengthy, significantly more detailed and in depth story and reducing it to not only a consumable two hours,...
Director: Akiva Goldsman
Actors: Colin Farrell, Jessica Brown Findlay, Russell Crowe
PlotSet in a mythic New York City at the turn of the 20th century, the story focuses on Peter Lake, a master thief on the run from his former boss, a ruthless gangster named Pearly Soames. Peter's life takes an extraordinary turn when, during a burglary, he meets Beverly Penn, a young woman dying of consumption. Despite the vast differences in their backgrounds and the dangers surrounding them, the pair quickly falls in love. This connection unlocks a hidden, magical world to Peter, revealing that he is central to a much larger, cosmic story. Faced with the power of eternal love and the menace of those who would thwart it, Peter and Beverly's bond is tested in ways they never imagined.
As Peter battles to save Beverly and come to terms with his own destiny, he encounters a series of unique characters, including a mysterious white horse that becomes his guardian. The narrative weaves through time, exploring themes of love, destiny, and the possibility of miracles. With Pearly and his minions relentlessly pursuing him, Peter's journey is fraught with challenges and revelations. The story delves into the deep connections between the characters, the nature of time, and the idea that love can transcend death, all set against the backdrop of a magical and transformative New York City.
Writers: Akiva Goldsman, Mark Helprin
Release Date: 14 Feb 2014
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English