Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl Blu-ray Review
Score: 76
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
'Pirates' Blu-ray dazzles with unparalleled quality; a must-have for aficionados.
Disc Release Date
Video: 72
Pirates of the Caribbean Blu-ray dazzles with impeccable 1080p quality, minimal grain, and rich colors, despite aspect ratio issues.
Audio: 75
These reviews praise the exceptional, immersive Uncompressed PCM 5.1 audio on 'Pirates' Blu-ray, highlighting crystal-clear dialogue, dynamic sound effects, and an expansive soundstage.
Extra: 83
Blu-ray release of 'Curse of the Black Pearl' impresses with a vast array of features, maintaining depth from DVD versions, yet lacks HD extras.
Movie: 77
Pirates of the Caribbean shines with Depp's iconic role, surpassing skeptics with its adventure, humor, and visual splendor; a recommended upgrade for fans.
Video: 72
The Blu-ray release of "Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl" presents an exemplary showcase of what the format has to offer, bolstered by a 1080p High Definition video rendering that sets the benchmark for visual excellence. From the intricate details visible on the open sea and characters' faces to the explosive brilliance of battle scenes, clarity is paramount, offering viewers an immersive experience. The expansive color palette, from the deep blues of the ocean to the rustic hues of pirate attire, remains faithful and vibrant throughout. Noteworthy is the handling of darker scenes—while maintaining detail, they introduce a green-blue tint that enhances the period feel without compromising black levels or shadow detail.
Disney's utilization of the BD-50 format helps in delivering a picture of remarkable depth and realism, as seen in the vivid day scenes and the nuanced rendering of night sequences. The transition between the luminous clarity of daytime shots and the rich, detailed darkness where skeletons first emerge exemplifies technical finesse in balancing contrast and color saturation, ensuring that even CGI-heavy scenes retain a tangible texture. Additionally, the release skirts common pitfalls such as edge enhancement and noticeable grain except in very low-light situations, keeping the presentation crisp and engaging throughout.
However, this visual feast comes with its caveats; reports indicate an incorrect aspect ratio that slightly crops the top and bottom of the frame. While this may not hinder the general viewing experience, it could dismay purists and collectors who expect absolute fidelity to the original theatrical presentation. Despite this, Disney has not skimped on quality elsewhere, from compression artifact avoidance to accurate skin tones against broadly rendered backdrops, cementing this release as a must-have for HDTV enthusiasts seeking reference-quality Blu-ray displays.
Audio: 75
The audio presentation of "Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl" on Blu-ray offers an enthralling auditory experience, anchored by its Uncompressed PCM 5.1 track. The soundtrack delivers a crystal-clear dialogue, predominantly emanating from the front and center channels, ensuring that every word, whether it's the bellowing commands by Geoffrey Rush or the mumbled witticisms of Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow, is intelligible and well-balanced. The film's immersive soundscape is richly detailed, from the clang of swords and thunderous cannon fire to the subtler sounds of creaking wood and lapping water, each sound effect is rendered with striking clarity and precision, contributing to an atmospheric and vibrant setting that pulls the audience into the heart of the action.
The dynamic range of the audio is impressive, stretching from the softest whispers to the booming cannon blast with ease, ensuring that the home theater experience is as close to a cinematic one as possible. The LPCM track, with its 48 kHz/24-bit bitstream, excels in delivering a wide soundstage that envelops the listener, effectively utilizing both the stereophonic depth and surround channels to produce a fully immersive experience. Explosions, splintering wood, and the foreboding rumble of deep bass not only test the limits of your home theater setup but also enhance the film's high-stakes drama and suspense.
Furthermore, the attention to atmospheric sounds and the individualization of musical instruments in quieter scenes add layers of eerie ambiance, reinforcing the film's supernatural elements without overshadowing its more explosive moments. The excellent balance between music, effects, and dialogue ensures that each element of the film's aural palette is given its due prominence, making "Curse of the Black Pearl" not only a visual spectacle but also an auditory masterpiece that sets a high bar for home entertainment audio quality. Whether through its LPCM track or its robust Dolby Digital 5.1 option, this Blu-ray release guarantees an engaging and thoroughly satisfying audio experience that complements its high-definition visual presentation perfectly
Extras: 83
The Blu-ray re-release of "Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl" aptly demonstrates Disney's commitment to preserving and enhancing the viewing experience for fans and newcomers alike. Both discs are jam-packed with a treasure trove of extras that offer a deeper dive into the making of this swashbuckling adventure. Prominent features include engaging audio commentaries by the director, stars, producer, and screenwriters, which offer varied insights into the movie's production, its inspirations, and behind-the-scenes anecdotes. The "Scoundrels at Sea" interactive feature, albeit an interesting concept, falls slightly short in execution but remains a unique addition. However, the comprehensive documentary "An Epic at Sea," video diaries, and behind-the-scenes looks at key sequences stand out for delivering an in-depth exploration of the film's creation, from CGI effects to on-set challenges. The inclusion of deleted scenes, bloopers, an historical look at the film's theme park origins, and an image gallery round out the package, making it an essential acquisition for enthusiasts. While some may lament the standard-definition presentation of these materials, their breadth and depth are undeniably impressive.
Extras included in this disc:
- Scoundrels at Sea: Interactive feature allowing viewers to learn about pirate history.
- Audio Commentaries: With director Gore Verbinski, Johnny Depp, producer Jerry Bruckheimer, Keira Knightley, Jack Davenport, and the four screenwriters.
- An Epic at Sea: The Making of Pirates of the Caribbean: A detailed documentary split into nine segments.
- Video Diaries: Including Diary Of A Ship, Diary Of A Pirate, and Jerry Bruckheimer's Photo Diary.
- Fly on the Set: Behind-the-scenes looks at five key sequences.
- Moonlight Serenade Progression: Deconstruction of the undead pirates introduction scene.
- Deleted Scenes: Nineteen scenes offering additional footage.
- Gag Reel: Cast flubs and fun moments.
- Image Gallery: Collection of around 200 images from production.
- Walt Disney's Wonderful World of Color: Historical look at the Pirates of the Caribbean theme park origins.
- Easter Eggs: Including a 3D Ship-to-Ship Animatic, a Japanese TV Commercial, a Keith Richards interview, and a Pirates Cave Construction Timelapse.
Movie: 77
"Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl" sails onto Blu-ray with an energy and charm that belies its theme park ride origins. This initial foray into what would become a defining series for Disney is both an audio-visual feast and a testament to Hollywood's ability to turn a seemingly outlandish concept into cinematic gold. At the heart of the film is Johnny Depp's iconic portrayal of Captain Jack Sparrow, a character that straddles the line between flamboyant rogue and sympathetic anti-hero. His performance, alongside those of Keira Knightley and Orlando Bloom, breathes life into a fantastical narrative, populated by undead pirates and marked by a blend of humor, adventure, and supernatural intrigue.
Visually, the Blu-ray presentation is nothing short of spectacular, boasting a pristine 1080p transfer that ensures every detail of the high seas and swashbuckling action is rendered with extraordinary clarity. The battle scenes, CGI effects, and period costumes shine, backed by a dynamic audio track that envelops the viewer in the film’s epic scope. These technical merits highlight director Gore Verbinski's vision, transforming a potentially kitschy premise into a visually stunning, thoroughly entertaining spectacle that rises far above its sequels and many contemporaries.
Technical nuances aside, what distinguishes "The Curse of the Black Pearl" is its balance of earnest storytelling and unapologetic fun. Depp's audacious take on Sparrow—combined with Rush's formidable Captain Barbosa—sets a tone that’s both eerie and exhilarating. Despite a few minor issues like the noted framing problem during the blacksmith shop fight (quickly addressed by Disney's commendable customer service), this release exemplifies how technical prowess and bold artistic choices can coalesce into a movie that not only exceeded expectations but also laid the groundwork for one of the most successful franchises in recent memory. The Blu-ray edition of this film is an essential upgrade for fans and a visual treat for newcomers, encapsulating the magic and adventure that "Pirates of the Caribbean" promises.
Total: 76
In the realm of cinematic treasures re-released on high-definition platforms, "Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl" Blu-ray edition stands out as a beacon for film enthusiasts wishing to marvel at unparalleled visuals and audio clarity. This release, greeted with enthusiasm by both Sony and Disney, measures up impressively to the growing expectations from Blu-ray offerings, quickly cementing itself as a must-have for collectors. Praised for its reference-quality video and audio presentations, it not only matches but in some aspects surpasses the plethora of titles available in this format. The addition of exclusive Blu-ray content, such as the trivia feature, further enriches the viewing experience, making it a compelling upgrade from standard-definition versions.
The film itself, a delightful adventure that effortlessly outshines its sequels, benefits immensely from the transition to Blu-ray. The vividness of the visuals and the crispness of the audio breathe new life into the captivating tale of pirates and cursed treasure, ensuring that both newcomers and seasoned fans are treated to a mesmerizing experience. The supplemental materials provided mirror those available in previous releases, yet their inclusion alongside the main feature enhances the overall package. This ensures that the Blu-ray version of "The Curse of the Black Pearl" is as comprehensive as it is visually and auditorily superior.
Conclusively, "Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl" on Blu-ray is an indispensable addition to any film aficionado's collection. Its unparalleled quality in both visual and audio presentations, coupled with a bounty of supplementary materials and exclusive features, makes it a standout release that showcases the best of what Blu-ray technology can offer. Whether for first-time viewers or long-time fans returning for another voyage, this edition promises an exhilarating journey worthy of its legendary status. In the competitive sea of Blu-ray titles, this release indeed finds its treasure map, leading directly to the hearts of enthusiasts seeking cinematic excellence.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
Blacks are deep and rich, allowing for decent shadowing and overall this is arguably one of the few benchmark video renditions that can truly be used to show off the visual excellence of the High Definition...
Audio: 90
Overall, this Uncompressed track is easily one of the best that I have come across on Blu-ray, and arguably one of the best on either High Definition format....
Extras: 90
Since when does any decent movie truly require four writers?) who understandably provide the most interesting offerings, talking about the original Theme park ride that the movie was loosely based on,...
Movie: 70
Definitively worthy of an upgrade, it comes recommended to fans of Depp or this kind of production, and a recommended rental to those who are more cautious....
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Greg MaltzRead review here
Video: 100
A minor complaint, this common factor with video subjected to CGI postproduction work is a small price to pay for the breathtaking special effects....
Audio: 100
From a classical score to screams and laughter in the midrange to cannon shots in the midbass to explosions and splintering wood in the treble and the foreboding deep bass rumble, Pirates is a system stretcher...
Extras: 90
The supplements include games and activities, a movie showcase, a backstage special, a "making of" feature and a blooper reel....
Movie: 90
Note that the first BD iteration of Curse of the Black Pearl has a slight problem related to the matting....
Total: 90
That's no faint praise because even at this young juncture in BD's rollout, we can thank Sony and Disney for a handful of jaw-dropping titles....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 100
Curse of the Black Pearl' is almost equal parts bright daylight scenes and deep, dark interiors, and I was really amazed how adroitly both are rendered....
Audio: 100
Imaging between channels, the sense of palpable realism to the dynamics and the excellent balance of music and effects -- this one delivers a 360-degree soundfield that really is just about as close to...
Extras: 80
However, once again, this release is another example of a studio simply porting over all of the same extras as before, without including any video in high-def resolution....
Movie: 80
The Curse of the Black Pearl' remains a rousing, grand adventure, but -- even more important -- it's a reminder that Hollywood entertainment flicks can still take genuine risks....
Total: 80
'Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl' holds up as a grand entertainment (especially in comparison to the over-inflated sequel), and this Blu-ray version is simply outstanding....
Director: Gore Verbinski
Actors: Johnny Depp, Geoffrey Rush, Orlando Bloom
PlotIn the 18th century Caribbean, the bustling port town of Port Royal gets rocked when the notorious pirate ship, the Black Pearl, launches a sudden attack. The crew of the Black Pearl, led by the intimidating Captain Barbossa, is pursuing a mysterious treasure that has eluded them for years. During the chaos, the governor's independent daughter, Elizabeth Swann, is kidnapped after the pirates discover she possesses a valuable piece of gold—a medallion linked to their curse. Elizabeth's childhood friend, the blacksmith Will Turner, desperate to save her, enlists the aid of Jack Sparrow, a wily and devious pirate who recently arrived in Port Royal. Sparrow has his own reasons for wanting to intercept the Black Pearl, holding a personal grudge against its crew.
Sparrow and Turner form an uneasy alliance and set sail on a daring rescue mission. Their pursuit reveals that the pirates aboard the Black Pearl are cursed to live forever as the undead, a secret tied closely to the medallion Elizabeth carries. The curse renders them unable to enjoy any of life's pleasures and can only be broken by returning all the scattered pieces of gold to its chest and sacrificing the blood of one of their own. As Elizabeth fights for her survival among the pirates, Turner discovers his hidden connection to the Black Pearl's cursed treasure, which propels him deeper into the fray, complicating the rescue and the quest to return things to normal.
Writers: Ted Elliott, Terry Rossio, Stuart Beattie
Release Date: 09 Jul 2003
Runtime: 143 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English