The Phantom of the Opera Blu-ray Review

Image has treated fans to three versions of this classic film on Blu-ray, with distinct offerings in terms of visual quality. The 1925 version is culled from a 16mm private collector's print and presented in standard definition at 480p in a 1.37:1 aspect ratio. Despite its age, the clarity and stability this print offers are commendable, though it remains the least vibrant due to inherent limitations. In contrast, the 1929 reissues are given high-definition makeovers: one is presented in 1080p at 24fps with a 1.2:1 aspect ratio, and the other in 1080i at 20fps. The 24fps version stands out significantly for its superior sharpness and cleaner image quality, thanks to being sourced from a pristine 35mm negative and processed using the AVC codec.

A noticeable aspect of this transfer is the intricate detail captured in the sets, makeup, and costumes, particularly in shadow depth and texture. The Technicolor sequences, especially during the “Bal Masque,” radiate with vivid reds and greens, while hand-colored sequences using the Handschiegl Color Process deliver a satisfactory, albeit slightly blurred, vibrancy. However, the 20fps version does not fare as well, showing more visible signs of wear such as scratches and specks, though it still offers sharp moments that maintain historical authenticity.

Image's restoration of "The Phantom of the Opera" is noteworthy for its minimal use of DNR and digital scrubbing, preserving the film's vintage appeal. The prints retain an appropriate level of speckling, scratching, and nitrate decomposition, evoking nostalgia without sacrificing too much clarity. The enhanced detail in brickwork, theatre stalls, and the iconic subterranean tunnels adds a layer of magnificence that aficionados will appreciate. Overall, while the original 1925 version has its limitations, the high-definition transfers—particularly the 24fps—offer an impressive visual experience that honors the film’s storied legacy.

The audio presentation of "The Phantom of the Opera" Blu-ray set offers an exceptionally detailed and dynamic auditory experience across its three included versions of the film. Notably, the 1929 reissue version at 24fps features a new orchestral score by the Alloy Orchestra, encoded in uncompressed LPCM 2.0 at 2.3 mbps. This track boasts impeccable fidelity, with balanced instrumentation and clear depth, avoiding any crossover. The choice of the orchestrated score, despite being modern and perhaps anachronistic, adds a vibrant layer to the viewing experience.

For purists, the 1929 reissue at 20fps includes Gabriel Thibaudeau's previously released orchestral score, performed by I Musici de Montreal and conducted by Yuli Turovsky. Featuring soprano Claudine Côte, this piece captures a gothic romanticism that pairs well with the visuals. Those seeking an even more authentic experience may prefer the iconic organ score by Gaylord Carter, which delivers a spine-tingling performance with its powerful, rib-shuffling dominance. Despite its sometimes overwhelming nature, it remains faithful to what audiences originally heard during early theatrical releases.

The original 1925 version is outfitted with a new piano score by Frederick Hodges, offering a sharp and clean auditory presentation. Although some may find this track sparse and overly reliant on pastiche elements ranging from Brahms to Gounod, it still provides substantial clarity throughout all frequency ranges. Moreover, Image's acknowledgment of a pressing error—where stereo mixes were incorrectly encoded as mono—has led to promises of rectification and an exchange program for affected discs. Despite this issue, the audio quality across all tracks is commendable, with each offering a unique yet equally compelling sonic landscape that complements the film beautifully.

The Blu-ray edition of "The Phantom of the Opera" boasts a commendable array of extra features that enhance the viewing experience. Particularly outstanding is the audio commentary by silent film historian Dr. Jon Mirsalis on the 1929 20fps version, which delivers a densely packed, informative, and engaging narrative about Lon Chaney, silent cinema, and the film’s production details. The materials also include an insightful interview with composer Gabriel Thibaudeau from a 2004 PBS broadcast. However, the extras fall short of providing a comprehensive retrospective making-of feature, leaving room for more in-depth exploration.

Extras included in this disc:

• Commentary (Audio Essay) by Dr. Jon Mirsalis: Detailed insights into the film and Lon Chaney's career.
• Interview with Gabriel Thibaudeau: Composer discusses his score for the 1929 version.
• Script: A continuous playthrough of the complete film script.
• Phantom Souvenir Program Reproduction: Authentic reproduction of the theatrical program.
• Photo Gallery: A high-definition gallery of behind-the-scenes stills.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original promotions for the film.

The 1925 film adaptation of "The Phantom of the Opera" starring Lon Chaney remains a cornerstone in the legacy of horror cinema and gothic storytelling. Chaney's portrayal of Erik, the Phantom, is a masterclass in conveying emotion through physicality and his unique makeup effects, earning him the moniker "Man of a Thousand Faces." The film harnesses dark-hearted themes and horror, complemented by an evocative and once-gargantuan production design that captures the opulent yet shadowy world of the Paris Opera House. Despite co-stars Mary Philbin and Norman Kerry's performances not matching Chaney’s intensity, Chaney’s haunting presence dominates the film, making sequences like the iconic unmasking deeply impactful.

This Blu-ray release offers three versions of this silent classic: two high-definition remasters of the 1929 version at 24fps and 20fps, respectively, and a standard-definition version of the original 1925 film. The source material’s age shows through varying degrees of print damage, yet it retains its atmospheric and moody essence almost a century later. The restoration work showcases the detailed set designs and technical accomplishments, such as the use of wires in Chaney's makeup to achieve his horrifying transformation and the remarkable 2-strip technicolor process in the "Costume Ball" sequence, particularly when the Phantom appears as The Red Death.

Critics and audiences alike recognize this version not just for its pioneering horror elements but also for its enduring emotional depth. Chaney's performance brings a blend of monstrousness and humanity to Erik, ensuring viewers are invested in his doomed quest for love against a backdrop of melodrama and gothic mystery. However, some technical issues with the Blu-ray’s first pressing and complex menu navigation may frustrate users. Nevertheless, the film remains a vital historical artifact that endures through its powerful imagery and Chaney’s unparalleled performance.

The Blu-ray release of "The Phantom of the Opera" is a significant addition to any silent film aficionado's collection, displaying a meticulous effort to preserve and present this classic in the best possible light. Among the highlights of this release, the 24fps 1929 version stands out, offering the cleanest and clearest viewing experience that surpasses all previous editions. Although initial pressings have encountered some issues that need addressing, these are expected to be resolved soon, enhancing the overall experience. The performance of Lon Chaney is as mesmerizing as ever, breathing life into Gaston Leroux's somewhat lackluster novel and elevating it to the status of cinematic art.

This Blu-ray edition is not merely a film but a comprehensive package that respects and celebrates the legacy of silent film horror. The visual quality is exceptional, bringing the eerie elegance of "The Phantom of the Opera" to modern audiences with stunning clarity. The disc combines various versions and special features that delve into the intricacies and historical significance of this monumental work, making it an invaluable asset for enthusiasts of film history and the silent era.

In conclusion, despite initial technical hiccups that are anticipated to be corrected in an imminent repressing, "The Phantom of the Opera" Blu-ray is a must-have for classic film collectors. Its superior visual presentation and extensive supplementary content make it more than just a movie – it's a piece of silent film heritage meticulously preserved for future generations. For fans of Lon Chaney and those with a passion for early cinema, this release is an essential acquisition that promises to reignite the magic and terror of one of horror's most iconic figures.