Portrait of a Lady on Fire Blu-ray Review
Portrait de la jeune fille en feu
Score: 72
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Portrait of a Lady on Fire is cinematic brilliance with first-rate technical merits, a stunning narrative, and an impressive A/V presentation. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 81
The Criterion Collection’s Blu-ray of 'Portrait of a Lady on Fire' offers an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in its 1.85:1 original aspect ratio, leveraging a 4K master sourced from 7K RED cameras. The presentation showcases robust image quality with vivid greens and blues, meticulous fine detail, and strong black levels, though minor compression artifacts in low light scenes are noted.
Audio: 76
Portrait of a Lady on Fire delivers a subtly immersive DTS-HD MA 5.1 track that excels in atmospheric placement and clear dialogue, with dynamic environmental sounds enhancing both quiet and boisterous scenes. A minor issue is the overpowering Vivaldi's Four Seasons mix.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras offer a rich blend of interviews and insights into 'Portrait of a Lady on Fire,' covering Sciamma's filmography, Haenel and Merlant's reflections, Mathon's cinematographic techniques, and Delmaire's painting process, yet leaves viewers desiring more than just these well-crafted segments.
Movie: 76
Engaging, intimate, and ultimately tragic, 'Portrait of a Lady on Fire' shines with electrifying performances and evocative scenery while navigating 18th-century societal constraints. Criterion’s Blu-ray edition features excellent picture quality and insightful bonus content, making it an essential addition for cinephiles.
Video: 81
The Blu-ray of "Portrait of a Lady on Fire" is presented by The Criterion Collection in a 1080p transfer with an AVC encoding, maintaining its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The digital master, created in 4K resolution, ensures the film's fully digital workflow is preserved meticulously, with the 5.1 surround soundtrack remastered from the original digital audio files using Avid's Pro Tools.
Shot with RED cameras at source resolutions up to 7K, the Blu-ray employs the 4K master pressed onto a dual-layer disc. The image quality is exemplary, showcasing a vivid and robust color palette. Scenic exteriors in Saint-Pierre Quiberon are captured with stunning detail, offering excellent depth of field and beautifully suffused palettes. Interior scenes, although dimmer, highlight burnished detail and feature precise crosshatched fabric textures on the characters’ attire. A subtle cool, bluish undertone complements the naturalistic depiction, while candlelit sequences offer buttery yellow tones.
Greens and blues are particularly impactful, enhancing both costuming and natural settings. Fine details are prominently visible, capturing nuances in performance and production design with precision. While black levels remain strong throughout, minor compression artifacts are occasionally noticeable during low-light scenes within the manor house, though these do not significantly detract from the overall presentation. Criterion’s Blu-ray release successfully delivers an engaging and visually faithful home viewing experience of "Portrait of a Lady on Fire".
Audio: 76
"Portrait of a Lady on Fire" features an immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track in the original French that superbly captures the nuanced soundscape of the film. The delicate balance between natural ambient sounds and dialogue is masterfully done, with scenes like Marianne's rowboat arrival providing a striking showcase for boisterous environmental effects. The clarity and precision of sounds, such as wind and water, are expertly panned through the soundstage, enhancing the viewer's immersion.
The audio presentation smartly creates an isolated atmosphere that brings intimate settings to life. Background effects such as servants traversing echoing hallways or the shuffling of shoes across floorboards are rendered with good discrete channelization, adding depth to indoor scenes. Exterior sequences on cliff faces and beaches benefit from rich environmental sounds, giving the mix a dynamic quality. Dialogue is consistently presented with clarity and no distortion, and optional English subtitles are available. However, the only minor issue noted is the occasionally overpowering mix of Vivaldi's "Four Seasons," which can overshadow other elements.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "Portrait of a Lady on Fire" offer an engaging, insightful dive into the film's production despite a limited selection of features. Key highlights include in-depth interviews with director Céline Sciamma, actresses Adèle Haenel and Noémie Merlant, and cinematographer Claire Mathon, providing valuable perspectives on the film's development and execution. These discussions are well-edited and richly layered, covering topics from the artistic inspiration behind the cinematography to the feminist themes central to the narrative. The included segment on Hélène Delmaire’s process in creating the film's striking paintings further enriches the viewer's appreciation of the meticulous craftsmanship involved in this exquisite period drama.
Extras included in this disc:
- Céline Sciamma: Interview by Dana Stevens discussing the film's background, challenges, and feminist perspective.
- Adèle Haenel and Noémie Merlant: Separate interviews contrasting their views on their roles and collaboration with Sciamma.
- Cinematography: Claire Mathon on lighting, color, and technical decisions, from Cannes 2019.
- Paintings: Hélène Delmaire on creating historical artwork for the film.
Movie: 76
Portrait of a Lady on Fire is a visually stunning drama set in late 18th century France, where painter Marianne (Noémie Merlant) is commissioned to paint the portrait of Héloïse (Adèle Haenel) for her arranged marriage. Marianne must observe Héloïse covertly as the latter refuses to pose, thus beginning an intricate dance of observation and interaction. Their relationship evolves from guarded companionship to deep affection, challenging societal constraints and invoking powerful themes of love and art. Sciamma's meticulous direction saturates every frame with palpable emotion, turning simple glances and gestures into profound moments.
The film delves deeply into the dynamics of female autonomy. Compelling performances by Merlant and Haenel anchor the narrative, their chemistry making every shared scene electric. Supporting roles amplify the storyline, particularly Luàna Bajrami as Sophie, a housemaid facing her own dilemmas. Valeria Golino’s portrayal of La Comtesse displays a poignant adherence to societal norms, revealing the multifaceted pressures on women regardless of social class. Sciamma's choice to exclude male dialogues accentuates the women's world, allowing an immersive exploration of their personal struggles and solidarity.
Portrait of a Lady on Fire proves both technically and emotionally resonant. Unobtrusive yet arresting cinematography captures the scenic Brittany landscape, framing each moment as a living painting. The narrative’s leisurely, contemplative pacing allows the story’s emotional weight to unfold organically. This deliberate pace coupled with exceptional production design brings an authenticity that draws viewers into the era. The film not only tells a profound story but subverts typical period drama tropes, making it a timeless examination of love, identity, and resistance against societal conformity.
Total: 72
"Portrait of a Lady on Fire" directed by Céline Sciamma stands as a powerful testament to her prowess in capturing the complexities of human emotion, particularly through the lens of strong, passionate women. The film’s narrative, while simple, is imbued with profound depth and intensity. These elements are masterfully conveyed through stunning cinematography that brings the 18th-century Brittany coast to life with vivid clarity. The Criterion Collection's Blu-ray release does justice to these visuals, offering a pristine transfer that showcases exquisite details and color accuracy.
The audio presentation is equally remarkable, preserving the subtleties of the film’s sound design and score. The lack of a traditional musical soundtrack emphasizes natural sounds, such as crackling fires and crashing waves, amplifying the film’s intimate ambiance. The Blu-ray’s supplements are comprehensive, including an insightful interview with Sciamma and other engaging features that delve into the making and thematic essence of the film. These extras add significant value for cinephiles and fans alike.
As is mentioned in the interview with Céline Sciamma included as a supplement on this disc, this is Sciamma's first historical film, after several contemporary outings that traced adolescents in transition. Sciamma is on record as stating she wanted to bring a contemporary flair to this film as well, and it is certainly forward-thinking in how it offers its depictions of women struggling to unfetter themselves from the oppressive norms of the era. "Portrait of a Lady on Fire" is subtly political in a way, but it's also surprisingly personal. Technical merits are first-rate, and the supplementary package is very enjoyable. Recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 100
Some of the cliffside and seaside material is beautifully detailed and offers an abundantly suffused palette with excellent depth of field....
Audio: 90
Scenes like Marianne's arrival at the estate courtesy of a rowboat offer great placement of sometimes rather boisterous ambient environmental sounds, and even some of the quieter moments in the mansion...
Extras: 40
Ad�le Haenel and No�mie Merlant (1080p; 17:27) are interviewed separately in this well edited piece that kind of contrasts comments by the two....
Movie: 80
In what might be called the difference between Art History and the history of art, Portrait of a Lady on Fire offers some insight into a societal norm of days of yore which many have probably forgotten...
Total: 80
Sciamma is on record as stating she wanted to bring a contemporary flair to this film as well, and it is certainly forward thinking in how its offers its depictions of women struggling to unfetter themselves...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Fine detail reveals nuances in performance and the effortless artistry within the production....
Audio: 80
Background effects trickle through the surrounds and front channels elevating the atmosphere of scenes like cracking fireplaces and the shuffling of shoes across the floorboards....
Extras: 60
Focused on the technical aspects and decisions made for the film, director of photography Claire Mathon dives deep into her process....
Movie: 80
Whether its Marianne studying the hands of her subject or the two laying in each other’s arms while the countess is away, Portrait of a Lady on Fire realizes in full form the aching need for love and connection....
Total: 80
With Portrait of a Lady on Fire, the simplicity of the narrative is drowned out by the raw passion screaming out for human connection like the undercurrent of a calm ocean wave cresting towards a beachhead....
Director: Céline Sciamma
Actors: Noémie Merlant, Adèle Haenel, Luàna Bajrami
PlotIn the late 18th century, Marianne, a talented artist, is commissioned to paint the wedding portrait of Héloïse, a young woman from an aristocratic family who is betrothed to a Milanese nobleman. Héloïse, however, is strongly opposed to the marriage and has refused to pose for previous painters. Marianne is introduced as a hired companion to accompany Héloïse on her daily walks, secretly observing her to capture her likeness and paint her in secret. As the days progress, Marianne and Héloïse begin to develop a deep and complex bond that transcends the initial pretext of the painting.
Marianne’s covert task becomes increasingly challenging as her feelings for Héloïse grow more profound. As they spend more time together, the two women discover a shared sense of understanding and mutual admiration. This intense connection allows Marianne to see Héloïse in a way no one else has, which enriches her artwork but also complicates their relationship. Their time together creates an intimate space where both women confront their desires, identities, and limitations imposed by society.
Writers: Céline Sciamma
Release Date: 14 Feb 2020
Runtime: 122 min
Rating: R
Country: France
Language: French, Italian