Whip It Blu-ray Review
Score: 63
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Whip It charms with buoyant performances, a killer soundtrack, and impressive Blu-ray quality, despite a predictable story and minimal special features.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
‘Whip It’ shines on Blu-ray with an impressive 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer, showcasing vivid colors, tight contrasts, and deep blacks. The DTS-HD MA soundtrack delivers clear, dynamic audio with robust bass. The fine grain structure and texture detail create a cinematic, engaging viewing experience.
Audio: 67
Whip It’s DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track delivers clear dialogue, dynamic range, and a room-penetrating presence, but occasionally lacks the immersive, aggressive edge that roller derby's brash aesthetics demand.
Extra: 37
The Blu-ray extras for 'Whip It' are underwhelming, lacking anticipated features like a director’s commentary or a documentary on roller derby. The limited offerings include nine deleted scenes (HD, 15 min), a brief interview with screenwriter Shauna Cross (SD, 3:04), and a short soundtrack promo, leaving fans wanting more.
Movie: 72
Despite a predictably familiar plot and occasional clichéd moments, Drew Barrymore's directorial debut, 'Whip It,' charms with its vibrant energy, endearing performances, and unique roller derby setting. The Blu-ray release includes a well-crafted BD50 disc with supplemental features and a glam-rock themed main menu.
Video: 70
The Blu-ray presentation of "Whip It" exhibits an outstanding 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer that masterfully blends color vibrancy and detailed imagery. Vividly saturated primaries and contrasting hues, such as the pine green of Hurl Scouts' uniforms and Babe Ruthless' yellow helmet star, are vividly showcased. The visual depth is noticeable in scenes with mixed content, particularly in well-delineated foreground elements and revealing shadow details within darker sequences. Skin tones are rendered naturally, maintaining a lifelike complexion throughout. Grain structure remains fine and uniform, adding a cinematic quality to the overall viewing experience without being intrusive. The transfer skillfully avoids common compression artifacts such as banding and macroblocking, ensuring a smooth and engaging video output.
This high-definition encode maintains impeccable fidelity and dimension, effectively capturing the film’s tight contrast and deep black levels that extend into oily depths while preserving shadow detail. The level of textural detail is impressive, evident in instances like the threaded detailing on clothing and the visible atmospheric layering in dimly lit scenes. Despite a few minor soft spots, the overall image is crisp, stable, and richly colorful, reflecting its theatrical look. With minimal edge enhancement and no unwarranted digital manipulation, this Blu-ray release from Fox stands out as a technically superb and visually captivating experience, appealing both to videophiles and fans of the roller derby genre alike.
Audio: 67
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack for "Whip It" delivers a clean, clear, and controlled audio presentation that complements the film's vivid and dynamic visual style. Dialogue is distinctive and free of sibilance, maintaining a clear and appropriately elevated position within the front soundstage. The surround mix is engaging, with atmospheric sounds during the Derby sequences and the upbeat indie-rock music score coming across with crystal clarity and precise acoustic spacing. However, the mix tends to be front-heavy, largely positioning the effects and ambient sounds toward the front, which slightly diminishes the potential immersiveness one might expect from roller derby's brash and rugged aesthetic.
In terms of dynamics, the soundtrack exhibits punchy and tangible bass that adds depth to roller derby hits and falls. The rear channels, while engaged, often lack the potency that could have further enhanced the intensity of the sport's sonic landscape. The mix generally opts for a more subdued approach, keeping the sound effects and ambient volume at a moderate level to ensure dialogue clarity. Despite that, there are moments when the music takes center stage, adding plenty of low-end and detailed highs, particularly during scenes featuring The Ramones, The Breeders, and Cut Chemist. Overall, while the audio presentation might not go to 11 in terms of aggressiveness, it remains a thoroughly enjoyable and well-rendered experience that matches the film's enthusiastic spirit.
Extras: 37
The Blu-ray extras for "Whip It" fall short in providing a comprehensive behind-the-scenes experience, with a noticeable absence of a director's commentary or an engaging making-of featurette. However, what is presented is moderately interesting for fans, particularly the Deleted Scenes (HD, 15 min), which include an alternate opening and several extended sequences that offer further insight into the film's narrative. The brief feature Fox Movie Channel Presents Writer's Draft: Shauna Cross of Whip It (SD, 3:04) gives viewers a quick glimpse into the screenwriter's personal connection to the story. Additionally, the Whip It Soundtrack Spot (SD, 00:32) serves as a promotional push for the film’s eclectic soundtrack.
Extras included in this disc:
- 7 Deleted Scenes: Includes an alternate opening and extended sequences.
- Fox Movie Channel Presents - Writers Draft: Interview with the screenwriter Shauna Cross.
- Whip It Soundtrack Spot: Promo for the soundtrack album.
- Digital Copy Bonus Disc
Movie: 72
"Whip It," Drew Barrymore's directorial debut, offers an exuberant dive into the kitschy, girl-power world of roller derby. Ellen Page stars as Bliss Cavendar, a small-town Texas teen who's tired of conforming to her mother's beauty pageant aspirations and finds her true calling with the roller derby team, the Hurl Scouts. The film powers through familiar sports movie clichés, such as the training montage and the big game, but redeems itself with its unique and empowering subject matter. The world of roller derby injects a one-of-a-kind adrenaline shot into this coming-of-age narrative, capturing both the intensity of the sport and the spirited camaraderie among team members.
"Whip It" thrives on its eclectic cast, which includes Kristen Wiig, Zoë Bell, and Juliette Lewis, each adding a distinct flair to their characters. The film's numerous strengths, such as its engaging pace and genuine humor, make up for occasional dramatic stumbles and an overly familiar plot. While Barrymore's direction sometimes lacks focus during action scenes, her passion for the project is undeniable, adding a layer of infectious joy to the experience. Ellen Page's portrayal of Bliss avoids falling into the overly quirky trap seen in "Juno," instead offering a heartfelt and nuanced performance that grounds the film emotionally.
Based on Shauna Cross's novel "Derby Girl," the screenplay effectively deconstructs traditional notions of femininity by showcasing women in powerful, unconventional roles. Roller derby serves as both an escape and a stage for self-discovery, offering Bliss—and the viewers—a vibrant alternative to small-town monotony. Despite its conventional plotline, "Whip It" succeeds in creating an animated, charming adventure that's memorable for its spirited depiction of a subculture where strength, independence, and camaraderie reign supreme.
Total: 63
Review of Blu-ray "Whip It"
"Whip It," directed by Drew Barrymore, is a delightful film that's easy to fall in love with despite any perceived narrative imperfections. The movie's vibrant energy, buoyant performances, and captivating soundtrack make it an engaging experience from start to finish. Ellen Page shines as the underachieving misfit who finds her passion in the quirky world of roller derby, lending authenticity and charm to the familiar storyline. The Blu-ray presentation does justice to the film's spirited nature, echoing its visual and auditory appeal with impressive high-definition video and audio quality.
From a technical standpoint, "Whip It" on Blu-ray stands out. The picture quality is sharp and detailed, providing a colorful and immersive viewing experience that enhances Barrymore’s directorial debut. Accompanying the exceptional visual presentation is a robust audio track that captures the energetic soundtrack and on-screen action seamlessly. Despite the limited supplementary features available on this disc, the excellence of the core audio-visual experience makes it a worthy addition to any collection.
In conclusion, "Whip It" may not break new storytelling ground or garner prestigious awards, but it offers an infectious charm that is hard to resist. Combining stellar performances with top-notch Blu-ray quality, it delivers both technically and emotionally. Whether you're a fan of roller derby or simply appreciate well-crafted, entertaining films, "Whip It" provides an enjoyable escape that is definitely worth experiencing. Recommended for both avid fans and casual viewers alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 90
The transfer also succeeds on a technical level; the film's ultra-thin grain structure is untouched, unwarranted edge enhancement is wholly absent, and banding, macroblocking, and other compression-related...
Audio: 80
The rear channels are engaged through much of the film, but the track still seems somewhat front-heavy to me, mostly because it plays it safe by keeping the volume of sound effects and ambience fairly...
Extras: 20
I would've been stoked to have a documentary on real life roller girls, a commentary track with first-time director Drew Barrymore and key members of the cast, or even a standard making-of featurette....
Movie: 70
As a sports movie, a young love story, an indie comedy, and a drama of the leave the nest and learn to fly variety, Whip It employs some almost unavoidable conventions that would seem much too familiar...
Total: 70
Whip It is one of those films that's easy to love despite its flaws�it's got infectious energy, buoyant performances, a killer soundtrack, and if that weren't enough, it's all about roller derby, the kookiest,...
The Digital Bits review by Dr Adam JahnkeRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 95
Extras: 70
Movie: 75
Still, there is a history to live up to and Drew Barrymore’s Whip It succeeds admirably as a fluffy but entertaining girl power flick....
Total: 83
Nobody is going to argue that Whip It was robbed of richly-deserved Oscar nominations but it’s a difficult movie to dislike....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Though it comes with a few noticeable soft spots, the picture quality displays strong definition in foreground objects, and there is clear visibility of all background information....
Audio: 80
Surround activity isn't as overwhelming or immersive as it probably could be, considering the loud, rambunctious applause of derby patrons, but the unruly cheers of the crowd display some very light bleeds...
Extras: 0
The release doesn't even come with an audio commentary, a making-of featurette, or at the very least, a short documentary on the history and revival of the roller derby....
Movie: 80
The sport is such a great escape from life's monotony, a place where spectators are immersed in the exuberant cheers that celebrate the ladies' beauty, independence, toughness and sportsmanship....
Total: 60
The Blu-ray comes with very good video and audio, but a meager collection of special features....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
Detail in shadowy backgrounds and uneven lighting in the hotel and nighttime exterior sequences is quite good which gives those segments appreciable depth of field....
Audio: 82
Detail in shadowy backgrounds and uneven lighting in the hotel and nighttime exterior sequences is quite good which gives those segments appreciable depth of field....
Extras: 30
(HD) 7 Deleted scenes, alternate opening, extended scene Fox Movie Channel presents - Writers draft: Shauna Cross of Whip it Whip...
Movie: 70
She discovers a way to put her life on the fast track when she lands a spot on a rough-and-tumble roller derby team....
Total: 68
THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-83 Universal disc/Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Drew Barrymore
Actors: Elliot Page, Drew Barrymore, Kristen Wiig
PlotBliss Cavendar, a misfit teenager from a small town in Texas, is constantly pressured by her mother to participate in beauty pageants. Feeling out of place and longing for something more exciting, Bliss discovers the world of roller derby. Struck by its intensity and empowerment, she secretly joins a roller derby team called the Hurl Scouts, adopting the derby name "Babe Ruthless." As she practices and competes, she starts building meaningful relationships with her new teammates while gradually coming into her own.
Bliss must balance her newfound passion with the expectations of her family and the social pressures of her small-town life. She faces challenges both on and off the derby track, forcing her to decide what truly matters to her. The story explores themes of self-discovery, empowerment, and the importance of following one's own path, setting up a journey where Bliss navigates personal dilemmas and external conflicts, ultimately seeking to find her own identity in an unconventional way.
Writers: Shauna Cross
Release Date: 02 Oct 2009
Runtime: 111 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English