Blood and Black Lace Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Blood and Black Lace" by VCI offers an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. This contrasts with Arrow Video’s 1.66:1 framing and could appeal to enthusiasts who prefer the wider ratio, potentially considered the original intent for this cult classic. VCI’s transfer, sourced from a 2K film scan of respectable elements in excellent condition, opts for a more muted palette compared to Arrow’s vibrant and saturated colors. However, some viewers might find VCI's transfer suffering from apparent aggressive filtering and some odd color timing, including an exaggerated purplish tint observed in flesh tones and backgrounds.

Technically, the VCI version exhibits a more film-like presentation with natural flesh tones but struggles with softer definition and less dimensionality, potentially due to lesser film elements. Arrow's version, while benefiting from a sharper definition and detail, presents a more modernized appearance with vibrant primary colors that enhance visual appeal. Though VCI’s strong AVC encoding manages the grain structure effectively, the grain appears inconsistently transitory, particularly in mist-strewn scenes. Fans may also note differences in background detail and clarity across various scenes. Ultimately, while the VCI Blu-ray shows improvement in technical presentation and offers no major encoding or compression issues, those prioritizing color vibrancy, detail sharpness, and comprehensive informational content within frames might lean towards Arrow’s version for a more satisfying visual experience at 1080P resolution.

The English language track on the Blu-ray release of "Blood and Black Lace" is presented in LPCM 2.0 mono. Like previous editions, the audio quality is hindered by its historical recording limitations. The soundtrack has a notably thin and tinny sound with discernible distortion in the upper midrange, which is particularly noticeable during the film's music cues. Despite these issues, dialogue fares reasonably well, managing to cut through the age-related wear and tear without substantial loss of clarity.

Overall, "Blood and Black Lace" has consistently struggled with audio quality on home video releases, and this edition from VCI Entertainment is no exception. The English dub in 2.0 PCM continues to exhibit a flat, monaural mix lacking in fidelity. While dialogue remains intelligible, the musical score by Carlo Rustichelli suffers from high-frequency strain, resulting in audible distortions. This audio is functional but far from impressive for a classic giallo film. The release includes optional English and Spanish subtitles in a white font for accessibility.

The "Blood and Black Lace" Blu-ray extras are formidable in both depth and engagement, showcasing a mix of insightful commentary and valuable archival features. Kat Ellinger's commentary is a scholarly discourse on the film's giallo roots, while David Del Valle and C. Courtney Joyner offer a more conversational yet equally informative track focusing on the intersection of fashion and horror. Both commentaries are complemented by a detailed comparison of the American and European cuts, a photo gallery, and archival interviews that enrich the context of Mario Bava's work. The musical score segment provides a nostalgic audio experience, albeit with some fidelity limitations.

Extras included in this disc:

• Kat Ellinger Commentary: Comprehensive analysis of the giallo genre.
• David Del Valle and C. Courtney Joyner Commentary: Engaging discussion on fashion influences in the film.
• American Cut vs. European Uncut: Detailed comparison of edited scenes.
• Photo Gallery: Extensive collection of promotional materials.
• Music Score by Composer Carlo Rustichelli: Select soundtrack pieces.
• Blood and Black Lace HD Trailer: Original theatrical trailer.
• American Titles: Alternative opening titles.

Mario Bava’s 1964 giallo classic, Blood and Black Lace, has seen a plethora of home video releases, with the latest Blu-ray offering from VCI Entertainment. This visually captivating Italian thriller stars Cameron Mitchell, Eva Bartok, Thomas Reiner, Ariana Gorini, and Dante DiPaolo. VCI’s effort may surprise some given their uneven high-definition track record, but they’ve made palpable strides by delivering a release that includes two new commentaries, adding substantial value for aficionados and collectors alike.

VCI’s rendition attempts to bridge the technical shortcomings seen in its previous releases. It’s important to recognize the historical context surrounding Blood and Black Lace, which remains an influential piece revered by filmmakers and genre enthusiasts. The stylistic elements and atmospheric tension are well-preserved, ensuring that the core experience of Bava’s work is maintained. Despite mixed reactions regarding aspect ratio discrepancies seen in past releases, this edition endeavors to present the film in a manner that aligns more closely with its original intent.

For those unfamiliar with the intricate plot dynamics, additional resources such as Svet's review of Arrow Video’s Blu-ray provide comprehensive insights. It’s evident that VCI has aimed to balance technical precision with supplementary content, making this Blu-ray a notable inclusion in any collection.

Review 1: The restoration work on "Blood and Black Lace" is stellar, with colors that pop and details that astound. The Blu Ray showcases Mario Bava's eye for color and composition perfectly. The sound quality is equally impressive, with clear dialogue and a rich score. The extras, including informative commentaries, provide deep insights into the film's production and legacy. Review 2: This release of "Blood and Black Lace" brings Bava's masterful use of color back into full prominence. The transfer is sharp, with excellent contrast, though some scenes exhibit minor grain. Audio is robust, particularly the film's haunting score that has never sounded better. Commentary tracks by giallo experts offer valuable context and analysis. Review 3: VCI's treatment of "Blood and Black Lace" pays due respect to this seminal giallo. The picture quality stands out, highlighting Bava's stylistic choices, although a few scenes appear overly processed. Audio delivers a punch, preserving the atmospheric score. Bonus features are bountiful and insightful, bolstering the film's historical impact. Review 4: The Blu Ray version is almost flawless, with an impeccable restoration that stays true to Bava's vision. However, there are slight inconsistencies in some darker scenes. Sound reproduction aligns with the visual fidelity, ensuring an immersive experience. The commentary tracks provide a layered understanding of the film's significance in cinema history. Review 5: While not entirely perfect, the Blu Ray release of "Blood and Black Lace" does an admirable job in bringing out Bava's vibrant aesthetic. Image clarity is mostly pristine, save for a few minimal issues with grain. The audio quality complements the visual excellence, and the supplementary materials are as informative as they are engaging. In particular, the commentaries are a standout.

Mario Bava’s indelible and influential giallo "Blood and Black Lace" remains a standard in the genre to this day. This latest Blu Ray release exemplifies the film’s enduring legacy with remarkable restoration work that emphasizes Bava’s iconic use of color and meticulous composition. The image transfer boasts excellent clarity and contrast, though minor grain can be occasionally detected in certain scenes. The sound quality is commendable, preserving the atmospheric score with crystal clarity. This fidelity ensures that dialogue remains clear and impactful.

VCI’s release excels in providing a comprehensive viewing experience. Beyond visuals and audio, the abundance of bonus features includes insightful commentaries from noted giallo experts. These tracks delve deeply into the production nuances and historical context of the film, offering valuable insights for both new viewers and long-time fans. Other included features provide additional layers of appreciation for Bava’s stylistic innovations and storytelling methods.

Those bothered by the aspect ratio on Arrow's release of this legendary giallo may well want to check out this version, even if the presentation here isn't optimal. VCI is also offering two commentaries that are interesting in their own ways. This Blu Ray stands as a testament to Mario Bava’s monumental influence in the genre, making it a worthy addition to any film enthusiast’s collection.