Nowhere Boy Blu-ray Review
Score: 54
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Nowhere Boy offers a compelling coming-of-age story with superb acting and A/V presentation, but its lack of Beatles focus may leave fans wanting more.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 65
The Blu-ray of 'Nowhere Boy' features a detailed 1080p transfer with fine texturing in clothing and facial features, strong black levels, and a natural grain that enhances the filmic feel. Colors and flesh tones are slightly under-saturated, with occasional issues of white speckles and uneven gradations, but overall, it offers a clear, vibrant portrayal of 1950s Liverpool.
Audio: 58
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 track for 'Nowhere Boy' offers exceptional dialogue clarity and era-specific music, but falls short in surround activity and bass impact. The audio is well-rounded and immersive, delivering vintage tracks with authenticity, though it lacks the dynamic punch expected for such a legendary musician's story.
Extra: 23
The Blu-ray extras for 'Nowhere Boy' are a minimal collection, offering standard definition featurettes and deleted scenes that add little insight into the film's creation or historical context.
Movie: 60
Nowhere Boy offers a sincere and emotional portrayal of John Lennon's formative years, focusing on family dynamics and personal struggles with impressive performances and adequate period charm, though it sometimes teeters into melodrama and lacks cohesion.
Video: 65
The Blu-ray presentation of "Nowhere Boy" delivers a commendable 1080p high-definition transfer that effectively brings the 1950s Liverpool setting to life. The clarity and brightness of the transfer are notable, showcasing fine details in clothing and facial textures with precision. The contrast is well-pitched, allowing colors like Julia's red coat and lipstick, as well as the green double-decker bus, to achieve a modicum of pop. Black levels are robust, contributing to a visually engaging experience, while a natural layer of grain imbues the image with a cozy film-like feel. However, whites run slightly hot in some scenes, affecting finer details, and a few stray shots appear excessively soft.
Despite minor imperfections, such as occasional pasty faces and uneven color gradations, as well as a few random white speckles, the overall presentation remains strong. Background items and textures come across naturally, underscored by stable and true skin tones that enhance close-ups. Swirling cigarette smoke is particularly well-rendered, and shadows maintain necessary detail without falling prey to significant crush issues. The film's lighting and cinematography choices sometimes contribute to the perceived resolution inconsistencies, but these elements do not detract substantially from the viewing experience.
Ultimately, "Nowhere Boy's" video transfer stands as a well-executed effort from Sony. It does not aim to outshine top-tier Blu-ray releases but successfully delivers a fluid and pleasant viewing experience that should satisfy most viewers. With its blend of historical ambiance and technical finesse, the transfer aptly supports the film’s period-specific narrative while ensuring overall visual enjoyment.
Audio: 58
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track presented in "Nowhere Boy" offers a solid auditory experience, particularly notable for its articulation and clarity. Dialogue is crisply handled through the front center channel, ensuring that conversations remain front and center, although occasionally the Liverpool dialects can be challenging to decipher. The film’s era-specific music is where this track truly excels, bringing vintage tracks to life with a balanced mix of warmth and precision. High-end frequencies, from hi-hat cymbals to nuanced vocal intonations, are faithfully reproduced, allowing for an immersive listening experience.
Front sound-stage separation enhances the overall sound field, but the rear channels could have been more engaging, especially during musical performances or party sequences. This slight deficiency doesn’t detract significantly but does miss an opportunity for added immersion. Bass frequencies are present but not prominent, aligning with the film’s need rather than overpowering the scenes. Additionally, atmospheric elements are generally well-maintained across the front channels, retaining clarity without demanding significant subwoofer involvement.
While the track may not push boundaries in terms of dynamic range or rear channel activity, it remains well-rounded and free from any major flaws. It effectively balances realism with clarity; for instance, music played through in-scene speakers retains a slightly distorted authenticity that draws viewers into the setting. Overall, "Nowhere Boy" provides an audio experience that serves the narrative aptly, offering quality sound without disrupting the film's portrayal of one of music's most influential figures.
Extras: 23
The Blu-ray extras for "Nowhere Boy" provide a modest look behind the scenes but fall short of offering any deep insights into the film or John Lennon's life. The collection features standard featurettes with interviews and film clips, lacking substantial content for enthusiasts. The deleted scenes add some depth to John’s relationships but are non-essential. Both "The Making of Nowhere Boy" and "Nowhere Boy: The Untold Story of John Lennon and the Creation of The Beatles" include cast and crew interviews, yet feel promotional rather than informational. High-definition trailers for other Sony titles are also present, and the BD-Live feature offers online content access.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of Nowhere Boy: Cast and crew discuss the movie, combined with film clips.
- Nowhere Boy: The Untold Story of John Lennon and the Creation of The Beatles: Insights from cast, crew, and a Beatles historian.
- Deleted Scenes: Two scenes exploring John's emotional struggles.
- Trailers: Previews for additional Sony titles.
- BD-Live enabled: Allows access to online content.
Movie: 60
"Nowhere Boy" delves into the formative teenage years of John Lennon, presenting a subjective but intimate biographical narrative. Rather than focusing on the well-trodden path of his climb to Beatlemania, the film opts for a rich and nuanced examination of his early life experiences, exploring his complex family dynamics and nascent musical aspirations. Aaron Johnson delivers a compelling performance as young Lennon, capturing both his inherent drive and vulnerability. Kristin Scott Thomas and Anne-Marie Duff excel as Mimi and Julia, respectively, each shaping John in different yet fundamental ways. The film is successful in maintaining a balance between emotional depth and the broader implications of Lennon's evolving identity.
The cinematography and direction by Sam Taylor-Wood enrich the viewing experience, effectively highlighting the contrasts between John's tumultuous interactions with his stern aunt Mimi and his effervescent mother Julia. However, some viewers might find the juxtaposition of musical passion and familial strife uneven, potentially detracting from the overall cohesion of the narrative. The addition of Paul McCartney and George Harrison offers a tantalizing glimpse of what is to come but wisely keeps the focus firmly on Lennon, eschewing the temptation to morph into a Beatles origin story.
Technically, the Blu-ray presentation is commendable. The 1080p/MPEG-4 AVC video codec ensures visually pleasing playback with a fidelity that brings out the period-accurate settings and costumes. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track provides an immersive auditory experience, crucial for a film so entwined with music. Despite its few shortcomings of pacing and depth perception of the supporting cast, "Nowhere Boy" stands as a heartfelt tribute to John Lennon's early life, capturing the essence of a young man on the brink of musical immortality.
Total: 54
"Nowhere Boy" offers an introspective look into the early life of music icon John Lennon, presenting a coming-of-age drama rather than a Beatles-centric narrative. It delves into John's journey before the formation of the legendary band, focusing on his internal struggles and familial relationships that eventually guide him towards musical fame. The film's strong direction and a stellar performance by Aaron Johnson as Lennon make it compelling, albeit leaning more towards melodrama at times, possibly leaving hardcore Beatles fans wanting more.
Sony’s Blu-ray release delivers a commendable A/V presentation with pristine video quality and immersive audio, underscoring the film's dramatic elements effectively. However, the extras provided within this Blu-ray package are fairly standard and lack innovation, most being presented in standard definition, which might be a let-down for viewers expecting in-depth bonus content.
In conclusion, "Nowhere Boy" is nowhere near what I was expecting. The tagline and cover made me think I was seeing the creation of the Beatles, not a coming-of-age drama. Being the latter, it did fare quite well, although I can see it disappointing Beatles fans wanting more Beatles. The acting was superb, as was the A/V presentation from Sony, but the extras were run-of-the-mill. I give this an easy rental recommendation—put it in your queue and give it a spin.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
A natural layer of grain is retained over the film, but there are, oddly enough, a few random white speckles to be seen, too....
Audio: 80
The track also finds a nice balance whereby it plays a few songs as a bit squishier and less dynamic, but in an effort to lend realism to the track; for instance, tracks played through a diner's speaker...
Extras: 30
Nowhere Boy: The Untold Story of John Lennon and the Creation of the Beatles (480p, 13:10): Cast, crew, and others discuss the story of John Lennon in Nowhere Boy, again constructed from interview snippets...
Movie: 70
Director Sam Taylor-Wood plays it that way, too, by de-emphasizing the man's future and building a story of a young man whose destiny is known to the audience, but as they say it's the journey and not...
Total: 60
A film about the growth into adulthood and the self-discovery that would shape a life, an industry, and a world, Nowhere Boy is a solid little origins movie that hits all the right dramatic notes and will...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Faint grain lends the image a cozy film-like feel that suits the period material, and no digital enhancements or detrimental issues afflict the picture....
Audio: 60
The Liverpool dialects, though, often can be extremely difficult to understand (at many points I was tempted to turn on the subtitles just so I wouldn't lose the narrative thread), but when lines are not...
Extras: 20
A Beatles historian talks about how McCartney, though younger than Lennon, acted as John's mentor, and provides a timeline of events, while all the cast members praise each other's work, and director Taylor-Wood...
Movie: 60
And though Aaron Johnson terrifically evokes the young Lennon in an impressive performance that captures the musician's drive, sensitivity, and recklessness, the actors who portray the other soon-to-be...
Total: 60
'Nowhere Boy' provides a look-in on the early life of music icon John Lennon, but this frustrating portrait, though well made, favors melodrama over insight and leaves us strangely unfulfilled....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
There were some moments where the resolution was not as strong, but on the most part, any faults I spotted were lighting or cinematography related....
Audio: 88
Rears, however, were not as lively as they could have been, especially lacking in the party or musical performance scenes....
Extras: 30
Deleted Scenes (HD) Trailers: Welcome to the Riley's, Inside Job, I Get Low, Justified BD Live enabled...
Movie: 60
In a family full of secrets, John escapes into the new and exciting world of rock 'n' roll where his fledgling genius finds a kindred spirit in the teenage Paul McCartney....
Total: 67
The tagline and cover made me think I was seeing the creation of the Beatles, not a coming of age drama....
Director: Sam Taylor-Johnson
Actors: Aaron Taylor-Johnson, Kristin Scott Thomas, Anne-Marie Duff
PlotIn post-World War II Liverpool, a rebellious teenager navigates his troubled adolescence. Raised by his strict Aunt Mimi, he's frustrated by her stringent rules and longs for a deeper connection with his absent mother, Julia. Despite the tension, the teen finds solace in music, discovering a profound passion for rock 'n' roll. His life takes a dramatic turn when he attempts to reconnect with Julia, a free-spirited woman who encourages his musical interests but struggles with her own personal issues. Their reunion brings a blend of joy and confusion, prompting the teen to question his identity and his place within his fragmented family.
As he juggles relationships with both women, he immerses himself further into music, forming a band with friends from school. They experiment with various styles, honing their talents and dreaming of stardom. His growing devotion to music provides him an escape, allowing him to express his frustrations and aspirations. However, as he balances the demands of his burgeoning musical career and the complexities of his family life, he faces pivotal decisions that will shape his future. The story delves into themes of family, identity, and the transformative power of music, capturing a young man's quest for purpose and belonging.
Writers: Julia Baird, Matt Greenhalgh
Release Date: 25 Dec 2009
Runtime: 98 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English, French