Philadelphia Blu-ray Review
Score: 78
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Philadelphia's UHD release is a technologically and emotionally triumphant revival.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 84
Sony's 4K UHD of Philadelphia wows with lifelike details, HDR colors, and filmic texture, setting a high bar for home video.
Audio: 72
The Dolby Atmos mix enhances the films' soundscapes with natural depth and precision, balancing dialogue and effects without overwhelming the original essence, offering a modest yet noticeable auditory expansion.
Extra: 73
The 'Philadelphia' Blu-ray set boasts a mix of new and classic extras, enriching its cultural legacy with documentaries, commentary, deleted scenes, and more.
Movie: 90
Philadelphia" addresses discrimination with powerful performances by Tom Hanks and Denzel Washington, leaving a mark on American cinema amidst its re-release in striking 4K.
Video: 84
Sony's Ultra HD release of "Philadelphia" is a testament to the power of high-definition restoration and remastering, offering a viewing experience that is unparalleled when contrasted with its predecessors. The exceptional 2160p/HDR UHD presentation brings Jonathan Demme's and Tak Fujimoto’s carefully crafted visuals to life with an astounding level of detail and color fidelity that was previously unimaginable. Particularly, the film’s varied palette, from the deeper, rich reds and blues that pop with vibrancy to the subtlety of skin tones, is rendered with remarkable precision. This is further complemented by the nuanced application of high dynamic range (HDR), enhancing both the natural and artificial lighting conditions without ever compromising the original cinematographic intentions. As a result, scenes are imbued with a tangible depth, granting them a lifelike quality that maintains the film's dramatic gravity while simultaneously elevating the overall home viewing experience.
Grain texture, a pivotal aspect of the film's visual identity given its original shot-on-film nature, is treated with utmost respect. It is consistently well-managed across the board, preserving the filmic essence with only occasional and minor increases in density that do not detract from the overall clarity. The detail in close-up shots is breathtaking, revealing the intricate textures of clothing and facial features with an intimacy and complexity seldom seen in home video releases. The restoration work ensures that these details shine through without any source deterioration or encoding anomalies, bringing forward an image quality that feels both fresh and authentically cinematic.
Moreover, the 4K UHD version significantly outperforms its Blu-ray counterpart, offering enhancements in color saturation, depth, and overall image fidelity that make it a must-have for aficionados seeking the ultimate filmic experience. The improved contrast levels introduce more pronounced whites and richer blacks, adding a dramatic flair to the visual narrative that is both striking and immersive. This release manages to stay true to Demme’s and Fujimoto's original artistic vision while breathing new life into the visual presentation of "Philadelphia," setting a high bar for future 4K remasters of classic films.
Audio: 72
The newly released Blu Ray of "Philadelphia" brings an auditory experience that stands out with its Dolby Atmos mix, capitalizing on the technology to expand the soundstage significantly. This encompassing sound design doesn't merely add volume but creates a layered atmosphere where both off-camera sounds and lower-level ambience enrich the storytelling. The implementation is carefully done, ensuring that the mix enhances rather than overshadows, with music and orchestral elements gaining a natural depth that complements the film's narrative beautifully. Noteworthy is how dialogues remain crystal clear and firmly centered, even as the soundscape around them grows more intricate, especially during pivotal courtroom scenes or when capturing the essence of the city's busy streets.
Despite the Atmos mix's impressive expansion of auditory space, the alternate DTS-HD Master Audio 5.0 soundtrack provided is almost as commendable. While it might lack some of the Atmos version's spaciousness, particularly in scenes requiring nuanced auditory depth like those in courtrooms, it remains a solid option that respects the film's original auditory aesthetics. The switch between tracks showcases a conscientious preservation of audio clarity and fidelity across both formats, ensuring that dialogues drive the narrative forward without loss of clarity or detail, and musical scores by Howard Shore resonate with warmth and precision.
It's evident that the Blu Ray's audio offering strives for an immersive experience, with both tracks prioritizing clarity, dialogue precision, and a well-rounded musical presentation. The Atmos track, in particular, stands out for its ability to create a sprawling soundstage, bringing to life the bustling ambiance of Philadelphia and providing a more enveloping feel to Howard Shore's emotional score. The lack of deep bass is a minor shortfall in an otherwise meticulous audio restoration. In sum, both audio options present with high clarity and prioritize the essence of this dialogue-driven film, allowing viewers to fully immerse themselves in its powerful narrative and thematic depth.
Extras: 73
The Blu-ray release of "Philadelphia" brings an impressive collection of extras, seamlessly blending archival content with newly minted features to enhance the viewing experience further. Notably, the disc includes insightful commentaries from director Jonathan Demme and screenwriter Ron Nyswaner, providing a deeper understanding of the film's production and thematic depth. Fresh additions to the Blu-ray are the engaging (RED) and Coca-Cola® featurette teaser, spotlighting the movie's cultural significance and its impact on AIDS awareness, along with "One Foot on a Banana Peel, the Other Foot in the Grave," a poignant documentary delving into the day-to-day lives of those living with AIDS. Another notable inclusion is the "People Like Us: Making Philadelphia" documentary, offering a comprehensive look at the making of this landmark film. These features, alongside deleted scenes, music videos, and original making-of featurettes, collectively offer a well-rounded perspective on the film's legacy and enduring relevance.
Extras included in this disc:
Featurette Teaser from (RED) and Coca-Cola®: A new interview with cast members, reflecting on the movie's influence.
Commentary with Director Jonathan Demme and Screenwriter Ron Nyswaner: Insightful discussions on the movie's production and impact.
Deleted Scenes: A collection of unused footage providing more context to the story.
Music Video for “Streets of Philadelphia”: Bruce Springsteen's Academy Award®-winning song.
People Like Us: Making Philadelphia: An extensive documentary on the film’s creation and its cultural impact.
One Foot on a Banana Peel, the Other Foot in the Grave: Documentary featuring real-life experiences of people living with AIDS.
Courthouse Protest Footage and Interviews: Additional perspectives on the film's depicted protests.
Joe Miller’s Macready & Shilts Legal Services TV Spot: A fictional commercial featuring Denzel Washington's character.
Original Making-of Featurette: An early look behind the scenes of making the movie.
Theatrical Trailer: The original promotional trailer for the film.
Movie: 90
Jonathan Demme’s 1993 landmark film "Philadelphia" re-emerges on Blu-ray, presenting a poignant and groundbreaking drama that tackled themes of homophobia, discrimination, and AIDS with unprecedented clarity and empathy at the time of its release. Starring Tom Hanks in an Oscar-winning role as Andrew Beckett, a lawyer who conceals his homosexuality and HIV status amid the conservative environment of a powerful law firm, the film charts his journey from being unfairly dismissed to fighting for justice with the help of attorney Joe Miller, portrayed by Denzel Washington. Hanks’ portrayal remains a career-defining performance, showcasing a depth and vulnerability that marked a significant departure from his earlier comedic roles. His nuanced expression of Beckett’s struggle against societal prejudices and his fight for dignity in the face of discrimination is both compelling and heart-rending.
Sony Pictures Home Entertainment’s release of "Philadelphia" to Ultra HD Blu-ray brings a stunning visual upgrade with a 2160p/HDR presentation, alongside a standard Blu-ray inclusion featuring both new and previous supplements. This marks an important step in preserving the film's visual essence and ensuring its accessibility on modern platforms. The film’s technical execution, from Demme's direction to Ron Nyswaner's script and the cinematography, complement the emotional depth and narrative powerfully. Despite occasionally stylized camerawork that may distract, Demme crafts memorable visuals, particularly through close-ups and long takes that emphasize Hanks’ emotional performance.
Denzel Washington’s role as Joe Miller is equally significant, offering a portrayal of personal evolution from skepticism to empathy, reflecting a broader societal shift in understanding AIDS and confronting prejudice. The film's impact extends beyond its narrative, contributing to discussions around AIDS, homophobia, and the role of cinema in challenging societal norms. As Philadelphia continues to resonate with audiences through this high-quality Blu-ray release, it stands testament not only to the performances of its leads but also to its historic and cultural significance in American cinema.
Total: 78
The Ultra HD Blu-ray Combo Pack release of "Philadelphia" by Sony Pictures Home Entertainment elegantly underscores the timeless appeal and cinematic mastery of Jonathan Demme's landmark film. This edition not only commemorates the movie's 25th anniversary but also elevates its home viewing experience with a meticulously restored Ultra HD video and an enriching Dolby Atmos sound mix. The pairing of Tom Hanks and Denzel Washington delivers an unparalleled emotional and dramatic depth, standing out as one of their most compelling performances to date. The film’s transition to Ultra HD is nothing short of spectacular, offering a visual feast with its enhanced textural details and HDR colors that faithfully amplify the original cinematic essence. Complemented by an Atmos soundtrack that perfectly aligns with the film’s audio expectations, this release also includes a commendable array of both legacy and new bonus content, making it a highly recommended acquisition for both newcomers and seasoned fans equipped to immerse themselves in the upgraded presentation.
Jonathan Demme's "Philadelphia" was pioneering upon its release, tackling subjects like AIDS and homophobia with a mainstream approach that was both sensitive and bold for its time. Its impact is undiminished, thanks in part to the poignant performances from its leading actors and Demme's directorial finesse. The film’s narrative remains as compelling and absorbing as ever, distinguished by its beautiful composition, legendary soundtrack, and its deliberate, though conservative, engagement with complex themes. The 4K HDR10 presentation significantly outshines its HD SDR precursor, delivering an audio-visual experience that enriches the film's emotional and thematic gravitas.
In conclusion, the Ultra HD Blu-ray of "Philadelphia" is a definitive edition that effectively celebrates the film's enduring legacy and relevance. Through its superior visual and auditory restoration, it not only serves as a testament to the film's original brilliance but also enhances the overall viewing experience. This release, with its addition of new and legacy bonus materials, merits the highest recommendation for both avid collectors and those looking to experience this impactful story in the best possible presentation. Whether revisiting or discovering "Philadelphia," this edition proves to be an essential addition to any discerning film enthusiast’s collection.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
The picture is home to nicely appointed suits and neckties, which are amongst the most prominent visuals highlights, both yielding amazing textural complexities in practically every scene, whether in law...
Audio: 90
Dialogue does open up a bit during courtroom scenes beginning in chapter seven, building a seamlessly mild location expansion that naturally recreates the room's acoustics, allowing speech to reverberate...
Extras: 90
"One Foot on a Banana Peel, the Other Foot in the Grave" (1080i, 1:18:37): From Directors Juan Botas and Lucas Platt, this film from 1994 documents life with AIDS from various perspectives with emotional...
Movie: 100
The studio has also included the film on Blu-ray, the first time it has released to the 1080p format under the Sony label in the United States....
Total: 90
Sony's UHD release is visually flawless, a delight of sight that masterfully presents the movie for home viewing with exceptional textural grace and perfectly balanced and nuanced HDR colors....
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 90
Viewers can also appreciate the tighter, narrower specular highlights, allowing for better clarity within the hottest, brightest spots while giving metallic objects and the edges of varnished wood furniture...
Audio: 70
Some of those effects occasionally travel into the front heights, creating a fairly captivating half-dome ambiance....
Extras: 60
People Like Us (1080i/60, 58 min): Also from the same DVD release, this making-of doc is pieced together mostly from cast and crew interviews, as well as tons of BTS footage, focusing on the various technical...
Movie: 80
The film will be remembered not only as one of the first mainstream Hollywood productions centered around a homosexual protagonist, but it will also live on as the first from a major studio to candidly...
Total: 80
Nevertheless, with memorably moving performances by Tom Hanks and Denzel Washington, the film remains a powerfully poignant, gut-wrenching motion picture that brought public awareness to an important subject...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 90
Its application is appropriately applied here, keeping within the boundaries of the film’s cinematography and visual aesthetic....
Audio: 84
The music is mixed over the sound field, adding natural depth to its orchestrated elements while complimenting the film’s thematic details....
Extras: 80
Disc 1: Philadelphia Ultra HD Blu-ray Disc 2: Philadelphia Blu-ray • ALL-NEW: Featurette Teaser from (RED) and Coca-Cola® – featuring new interviews with Tom Hanks, Denzel Washington and Mary Steenburgen...
Movie: 100
Fearing it would compromise his career, lawyer Andrew Beckett (Tom Hanks) hides his homosexuality and HIV status at a powerful Philadelphia law firm....
Total: 89
If you aren’t, and already own the previous release, the decision to upgrade for the additional features/restored video will depend on how important that is to you....
Director: Jonathan Demme
Actors: Tom Hanks, Denzel Washington, Roberta Maxwell
PlotA skilled senior associate at a prestigious law firm in Philadelphia is abruptly dismissed from his job after a misplaced file incident, which he suspects is a pretext for his firing. The real reason for his dismissal is that the partners at the firm have discovered he has contracted AIDS. Despite his deteriorating health, he resolves to fight back against this injustice and sue his former employers for discrimination. Battling societal stigma and overwhelming odds, he is determined to prove that his termination was solely due to his diagnosis, constituting a blatant violation of his civil rights.
With no lawyer willing to represent him, he finally teams up with a reluctant and initially homophobic attorney who runs a small personal injury practice. The attorney's initial discomfort with his client's homosexuality and condition is evident, but as the two men work together on the case, mutual respect develops. Together, they prepare to take on a formidable legal battle against the powerful law firm. The case not only challenges their personal ethics and prejudices but also places them at the center of national attention on the issues of AIDS discrimination and gay rights in the workplace.
Writers: Ron Nyswaner
Release Date: 14 Jan 1994
Runtime: 125 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English