The Sand Pebbles Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
High-end home theater equipment list & 'The Sand Pebbles' Blu-ray review: a thoughtful war film.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 62
The Sand Pebbles' Blu-ray transfer impresses with detailed, faithful imagery and strong audio, earning praise for its high quality and preservation of filmic texture.
Audio: 60
The Sand Pebbles' DTS-HD MA track offers an impressively immersive yet occasionally unnatural sound, with Goldsmith's score shining.
Extra: 86
The Blu-ray release of 'The Sand Pebbles' is praised for its extensive special features, including insightful commentaries, a deep dive into the film's score, making-of documentaries, and intriguing trivia, offering a comprehensive look at the film's production and impact.
Movie: 78
The Sand Pebbles, led by McQueen, delivers a thought-provoking, character-driven epic that navigates the rough waters of morality, duty, and humanity against a backdrop of military and political tension, enriched by standout performances and technical excellence.
Video: 62
"The Sand Pebbles" Blu-ray presentation showcases a commendable high-definition MPEG-2 transfer, respectful of its source material and its era, evidencing 20th Century Fox's commitment to preserving the fidelity of their classic cinema library. Maintaining the 2.35:1 aspect ratio, the video quality is robust, adorned with a pleasing level of film grain that enhances rather than detracts, affirming its filmic integrity without succumbing to overzealous digital noise reduction (DNR). This lack of DNR presents an image that's true to its celluloid roots, offering an exceptionally clean print that's free of significant damage, reinforcing its archival value. The transfer's fine detail is strikingly evident in both foreground and background elements—be it the intricacies of the ship's engine room, the fabric of military uniforms, or the expressive features of actors' faces—affording a newfound clarity to the visuals.
Contrast and color reproduction stand out as particularly impressive aspects of this release. Blacks are deep and solid, contributing to excellent shadow delineation and night scene fidelity, while colors are well-balanced, capturing the vibrant blues of the water and skies, the stark whites of naval uniforms, and the nuanced hues of 1960s cinema. Despite occasional softness in some shots and minor fluctuations in contrast, these instances are few and do not detract from the overall excellence of the transfer. Sight issues with edge enhancement and occasional print wear are noted but are minimal distractions from what is otherwise a stellar visual presentation.
Technical merit aside, the meticulous care put into this transfer is evident, ensuring "The Sand Pebbles" is presented with a level of detail and authenticity that honors its cinematic heritage. Coupled with accurate flesh tones and the preservation of the film's natural grain structure, this Blu-ray edition succeeds in delivering an immersive viewing experience that emphasizes texture and depth. While slight inconsistencies are present, they do little to overshadow the transfer's achievements, making it a benchmark for future classic film restorations by Fox.
Audio: 60
The Sand Pebbles' release on Blu-ray features an impressive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that skilfully balances the challenge of modernizing the audio without sacrificing the film's original auditory essence. Despite instances where the discrete effects and dialogue may not sound completely natural or appear slightly compressed, the overall audio presentation significantly enhances the immersive quality of this wartime narrative. The soundscape, underpinned by the periodic hiss that some may find nostalgic, helps bridge the movie’s vintage charm with contemporary expectations of clarity and spatiality. Particularly, the mix excels during its more dynamic sequences - gunfire, explosions, and the distinctive clatter of the ship's engine room - ensuring these elements are forceful yet integrated smoothly across the soundstage. This effort maintains a level of respect for the film's period, ensuring that while the action is engaging, it does not overshadow the primarily dialogue-driven storyline.
Jerry Goldsmith's legendary score receives a commendable treatment, arguably standing out as a highlight of this audio remaster. The score is presented with a warmth and expansiveness that breathes new life into the film's atmospheric settings, effectively acting as an additional character that enhances the emotional and narrative depth. The brass and strings sweep majestically, at times dominating the mix but never to the point of detracting from the overall auditory experience. This clear, clean delivery allows for an intimate encounter with the music’s intricacies, making it evident that considerable effort has been placed on ensuring Goldsmith’s compositions are given due prominence.
Though some minor issues persist – including occasional flatness in the music's lower tones and moments where dialogue feels clipped – these do not significantly mar the overall experience. In fact, they serve as reminders of the film's age and provenance, grounding the updated audio presentation in a context that respects both its historical and cinematic significance. Consequently, while this DTS-HD MA track may not stand toe-to-toe with modern recordings in technical perfection, it surpasses expectations for films of its era, proving itself as a thoughtful, enriching update that honors The Sand Pebbles' enduring legacy.
Extras: 86
"The Sand Pebbles" Blu-ray extras deliver an exhaustive and enriching suite of supplements that match or arguably surpass those found in classic Fox releases such as "Patton" and "The Longest Day." The compilation is spearheaded by a piecemeal commentary involving the late director Robert Wise and actors Richard Crenna, Mako, and Candice Bergen. Despite being recorded separately, their insights form a cohesive narrative that is both insightful and, at times thanks to Crenna's humor, entertaining. This is complemented by an isolated score track with layered commentary from music experts and snippets from Jerry Goldsmith himself, providing a meticulous dissection of the film's auditory landscape. A trivia track, comprehensive making-of documentaries, featurettes ranging from reflections on Steve McQueen and Robert Wise to historical contexts, alongside deleted scenes, vintage featurettes, promotional trailers, radio documentaries, and spots round off a package that is as informative as it is nostalgic. While some content skews towards the promotional, the overall depth and variety offer a rich insight into the film's production, its narrative message, and historical significance, making it a treasure trove for aficionados of cinema history.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary by Director Robert Wise and Actors Candice Bergen, Richard Crenna, and Mako: A posthumous collaboration providing deep insights into the creation of the film.
- Isolated Score Track with Commentary: An innovative presentation offering detailed analysis of Jerry Goldsmith's score.
- Trivia Track: Engaging facts and tidbits that run parallel to the movie viewing experience.
- Road Show Scenes: A collection of deleted and extended scenes enhancing the narrative depth.
- The Making of The Sand Pebbles Documentary: An extensive look at the film’s creation, from challenges to triumphs.
- Steve McQueen Remembered Featurette: A tribute to the iconic lead actor through reflections from his contemporaries.
- Robert Wise Remembered Featurette: Celebrates the illustrious career of the veteran director.
- China 1926 Remembered Featurette: Provides historical context to the film’s setting.
- A Ship Called San Pablo Featurette: Focuses on the construction and significance of the film’s central vessel.
- The Secret of San Pablo Featurette: Goes deeper into the history and fate of the ship post-filming.
- Radio Documentaries Narrated by Richard Attenborough: Offers additional production insights set against vintage photographs.
- Radio Spots: Time-capsule promotions from the movie’s original release.
- Original Theatrical Trailer: A glimpse back at how the film was marketed.
Movie: 78
"The Sand Pebbles," directed by the legendary Robert Wise, is a film that transcends its era, offering a poignant, character-driven exploration of love, racism, duty, and honor amidst the complicated backdrop of the 1926 Chinese Revolution. Starring Steve McQueen in a role that earned him his sole Best Actor Oscar nomination, the movie showcases not just his undeniable charisma but also the depth of his acting prowess, supported by a stellar cast including Richard Attenborough, Richard Crenna, Mako, and Candice Bergen. This cinematic venture is not only remarkable for its narrative but also for its technical achievements, receiving eight Oscar nominations that testify to its quality and impact.
At its core, "The Sand Pebbles" is a slow-burning epic that defies traditional pacing to weave a complex and engaging story. Set against the historically rich and tumultuous period of naval diplomacy in China, it focuses on McQueen's character, Jake Holman, a U.S. Navy machinist on the USS San Pablo who struggles against the established norms aboard the gunboat and the wider geopolitical challenges outside it. The film's deliberate pacing, detailed storytelling, and deep characterizations allow audiences to immerse themselves fully in the narrative and the authenticity of the era it represents. Wise’s direction ensures that even the film's quieter moments contribute to its build-up, leading to a suspenseful and dramatically intense final act that leaves a lasting impression.
However, "The Sand Pebbles" battles with its own ambitious scope and length, with some viewers finding its more subdued scenes testing their patience. Despite these pacing issues, the film is undeniably impactful, highlighted by its superb set design, Jerry Goldsmith's evocative score, and exceptional performances all around. It doesn't merely entertain but also invites reflection on its themes that remain relevant decades after its release. "The Sand Pebbles" stands as a testament to Wise's directorial capabilities and McQueen's acting legacy, making it a must-see for aficionados of classic cinema and those seeking a film that combines historical insight with compelling storytelling.
Total: 68
"The Sand Pebbles" Blu-ray presentation is a masterclass in how classic films should be revitalized for modern audiences. Fox has meticulously brought this unconventional war film to life, not by polishing it with digital noise reduction, but by preserving its original aesthetics and enhancing them with a stunning video transfer. The clarity and fidelity of both picture and sound—bolstered by an impressive DTS HD MA audio track—bring out the nuanced performances and the atmospheric setting, immersing viewers in the narrative’s rich, historical backdrop.
Crafted with the audiophile and cinephile in mind, this release utilizes high-end equipment to ensure the optimum home theater experience. Tested across an array of devices from the Sony VPL-VW50 SXRD projector to the Oppo 970HD universal disc player, and supported by audiophile-approved components such as the Denon AVR 5308CI preamp/video processor and Canton Ergo Series speakers, "The Sand Pebbles" Blu-ray proves to be an exceptional example of technical prowess meeting cinematic artistry. The supplemental package is not only massive but filled with informative and entertaining extras that deepen one’s appreciation for the film’s production and historical context.
In conclusion, Fox's Blu-ray rendition of "The Sand Pebbles" transcends being merely a revisit to a classic; it's an essential addition to the collection of those who value meticulously crafted cinema presentations. By balancing a high-fidelity audiovisual experience with substantial extras that enrich the viewer's understanding of the film’s thematic depth and historical significance, this Blu-ray edition not only honors the legacy of a thought-provoking epic but sets a benchmark for how classics should be celebrated in the digital age.
avforums review by Chris McEneanyRead review here
Video: 80
Distant shorelines and the great sweeping vistas of the foothills and the San Pablo chugging down the centre of two great banks of rolling foliage have moments that really shine with detailed beauty -...
Audio: 70
There is a majestic sweep of the brass and the strings and, at times, the score literally engulfs the room - which, to me, is not a problem, although some could say that the music is given a little too...
Extras: 80
Charting the story's underlying messages and the motives of the characters, the budgetary concerns of the elaborate shoot, the casting and the locations used, this documentary more than delivers the goods...
Movie: 90
For a big-screen, militaristic spectacle, this wallowing in psychology, attitude and the social and moral ambiguities of the era, the location and the crucial politics of the period is a refreshing experiment...
Total: 90
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
There is not a lot in there, but the wear and tear on the machinery and the authenticity of its appearance is brought up in all its glory here, truly a wonder to look at, as are the rest of the interior...
Audio: 80
Ambience is wonderful, and the track effortlessly fills the room with the subtlest of nuances as well as the loudest of screams and cheers, the ship's alarm recalling the crew to the ship, and the action,...
Extras: 90
Finally, three radio advertisements for the film conclude this impressive array of special features....
Movie: 80
The film's sprawling story line intertwines beautifully, and while parts of the movie are almost unbearably slow (more on that in a minute), nary a shot is wasted as the story progresses, be it through...
Total: 80
In fact, there is very little shooting in the film, and moviegoers expecting three hours of guns and explosions will come out of the experience incredibly disappointed, although the prominent image of...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Sure, ‘The Sand Pebbles’ shows a bit of wear and tear in a few scattered shots, but for the most part, the print has been skillfully restored to its former glory....
Audio: 80
Better still, the rear speakers get a decent workout as they enhance the reverberations of the hull, the dense roar of cheering sailors, and the impact of explosions....
Extras: 100
Likewise, this secondary featurette showcases the film’s original theatrical trailer, a look at the construction of the navy vessel used in the film, and the replica ship’s rather intriguing fate....
Movie: 80
Wise focuses on the men of the ship far more than the conflicts they encounter, humanizing the story and allowing it to develop into a more realistic tale of men who buck the system and erase intolerance....
Total: 80
‘The Sand Pebbles’ is an unexpectedly relevant classic that focuses on its character-centric conflicts far more than its geopolitical arena, battle scenes, or wartime drama....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 82
I would not put it on the same level of a track recorded today but the mix was certainly decent....
Audio: 84
I would not put it on the same level of a track recorded today but the mix was certainly decent....
Extras: 80
Commentary by Director Robert Wise and Actors Candice Bergen, Richard Crenna and Mako Isolated Score Track with commentary by music producer Nick Redman, Film Music Historian Jon Burlingham and Film Historian/Screenwriter...
Movie: 70
Directed by Hollywood icon Robert Wise (West Side Story) and nominated for eight Oscars?, the definitive naval epic THE SAND PEBBLES (1966, Fox) stars Steve McQueen, Richard Attenborough, Richard Crenna,...
Total: 79
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Outlaw Audio Model 7700 seven channel amplifier B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Canton "Ergo"...
Director: Robert Wise
Actors: Steve McQueen, Richard Attenborough, Richard Crenna
PlotSet in 1926, against the backdrop of the tumultuous Chinese revolution, the story revolves around an American gunboat, the USS San Pablo, patrolling the Yangtze River. This gunboat, nicknamed the "Sand Pebble," has a new engineer, Jake Holman, who prefers working directly on the engines rather than delegating. Holman's unconventional ways and individualistic approach immediately put him at odds with his shipmates and the existing naval practices. His technical proficiency and dedication to the engine room earn him respect, yet his disdain for authority complicates his position on the ship. The narrative explores Holman's internal struggle with military protocol and his efforts to navigate the complexities of his new environment.
As the political situation in China intensifies, the San Pablo's mission becomes ever more perilous. The crew finds themselves in a quagmire of diplomatic tension, caught between their orders from distant leaders and the reality of the nationalist fervor sweeping across China. Amidst this, Holman forms a bond with a local missionary schoolteacher and befriends a Chinese coolie working on the boat. These relationships deepen his connection to the country and its people, further complicating his feelings towards the ongoing conflict. The crew's loyalty and unity are tested as they are drawn into the violent struggle, forcing them to confront their roles as foreigners in a country fighting for its sovereignty.
Writers: Richard McKenna, Robert Anderson
Release Date: 20 Dec 1966
Runtime: 182 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English, Mandarin