Lilies of the Field Blu-ray Review
Limited Edition to 3000 - SOLD OUT 3,000 copies
Score: 72
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Lilies of the Field on Blu-ray is an engaging, heartfelt classic with stunning black and white cinematography, a crisp transfer, and exemplary bonus material. Highly recommended!
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 75
Lilies of the Field shines with a 1080p AVC encoded transfer in 1.66:1, offering excellent sharpness, rich contrast, and natural grain. The grayscale modulation is impressive, delivering deep blacks and pure whites with minimal artifacts, making it one of the studio's best catalog releases.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio 1.0 track for 'Lilies of the Field' delivers clean and clear dialogue, robust Jerry Goldsmith score, and natural environmental effects, despite the limited dynamic range typical of its period and budget; free from any hiss, crackle, or distortion issues.
Extra: 54
Lilies of the Field's Blu-ray extras include an insightful audio commentary by Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman; an isolated DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 score track with Jerry Goldsmith's compositions; the original theatrical trailer; and the MGM 90th Anniversary trailer, offering engaging insights and nostalgic context.
Movie: 87
The Blu-ray release of 'Lilies of the Field' showcases a heartfelt and intimate film, directed by Ralph Nelson, with standout performances by Sidney Poitier and Lilia Skala. The engaging narrative skillfully intertwines minor fables into major emotional effects, aided by an unobtrusive direction and a nuanced screenplay.
Video: 75
The Blu-ray presentation of "Lilies of the Field" is exemplary, providing an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.66:1 aspect ratio. The film emerges from the MGM-UA catalog with one of the more refined transfers observed from the studio. The elements are preserved impeccably, showing a remarkable absence of speckling and age-related anomalies. Contrast is well-balanced, allowing for distinct delineation within the desert setting's various whitish tones and Sidney Poitier's wardrobe. The grayscale exhibits excellent modulation, particularly evident in the deep, convincing blacks of the nuns' cowls, and the natural film grain is consistently stable, free of compression artifacts.
The sharpness remains commendably high across most scenes, enhancing texture detail significantly. However, some variability in clarity is present, chiefly influenced by the differing conditions between outdoor location shoots and controlled indoor environments. Close-up shots deliver impressive detail levels without any image instability issues. A slight increase in grain is noticeable during certain scenes, such as when Mother Maria dictates a letter and in shots featuring the sky. Though generally clean, the print sporadically shows minor white specks, and a brief instance of banding occurs along the horizon after Homer departs and the nuns walk outside. Despite these minor flaws, the video presentation is largely free from major artifacts, maintaining strong depth and sharpness throughout.
Audio: 75
The audio presentation of "Lilies of the Field" is delivered through a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track that aligns well with the film's modest sound design. The dialogue is consistently clear and well-prioritized, ensuring that conversational exchanges are intelligible despite the mono setup. It is notable that Sidney Poitier’s singing scenes were dubbed by Jester Hairston, the composer of the gospel song "Amen," which adds a rich authenticity to the soundtrack. Jerry Goldsmith's iconic score is rendered with precision, maintaining excellent clarity and contributing significantly to the film's quaint charm.
While the DTS-HD MA 1.0 track does not provide a vast dynamic range and remains typical of the low-budget films of its era, it accomplishes an involving audio experience by effectively integrating ambient environmental effects and the musical score. Despite its single-channel limitation, the sound mix successfully conveys subtle auditory details, like the delicate sound of footsteps on dirt. The track is devoid of any age-related artifacts such as hiss, crackle, or hum, underscoring its superb preservation and clean presentation.
Extras: 54
The Blu-ray release of "Lilies of the Field" offers a meticulously crafted array of special features that enhance the viewing experience. Highlights include an engaging audio commentary with insightful discussions by producer Nick Redman, film historian Julie Kirgo, and screenwriter Lem Dobbs. The isolated score track, presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, allows viewers to appreciate Jerry Goldsmith's finely composed music, albeit with some sound effects. The package also includes high-definition trailers that showcase both the original theatrical release and MGM's 90th Anniversary celebration, though care should be taken with the former to avoid spoilers before watching the film. An included six-page booklet provides additional context with images, original poster art, and a thoughtful essay by Julie Kirgo.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insightful discussions by Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman.
- Isolated Score Track: Jerry Goldsmith's score in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0.
- Original Theatrical Trailer: High-definition trailer (3:14).
- MGM 90th Anniversary Trailer: High-definition trailer (2:06).
- Six-Page Booklet: Film stills, original art, and an essay by Julie Kirgo.
Movie: 87
In Ralph Nelson's 1963 film, "Lilies of the Field," Sidney Poitier delivers an Academy Award-winning performance as Homer Smith, an itinerant handyman who fortuitously encounters a group of Eastern European nuns in the Arizona desert. From a seemingly mundane beginning—fixing a roof—Homer is drawn into an understated yet impactful narrative driven by Mother Maria (Lilia Skala), who sees Homer as the divine answer to their prayers. The subtle screenplay by James Poe, adapted from William Edmund Barrett's novel, skillfully eschews traditional conflict, allowing character development and nuanced interactions to take center stage. The film’s power lies in its gentle storytelling, authentic performances, and the portrayal of community and shared faith.
Nelson’s unobtrusive direction complements Poe's screenplay, creating a film that, despite its quiet nature, resonates with deep emotional effects. Poitier's Homer is depicted with unassuming elegance and a quiet charisma that transcends racial barriers—a poignant achievement given the societal context of 1963 America. The film subtly integrates themes of racism, highlighted when Homer decides to build a chapel after being belittled by a construction contractor, an episode that underscores the era’s racial tensions without over-dramatizing them. The supporting cast, including Skala’s compelling portrayal of the determined Mother Superior and memorable performances by Stanley Adams and Dan Frazer, contribute to the film’s earnest depiction of community spirit and mutual respect.
"Lilies of the Field" creates a palpable sense of joy and community through memorable scenes and heartfelt interactions, such as Homer teaching the nuns English and leading them in a spirited rendition of “Amen.” These moments elevate the narrative beyond its simple premise, yielding a timeless film that leaves viewers profoundly moved. The film’s enduring charm lies in its ability to weave an emotionally rich tapestry from ostensibly simple interactions, making "Lilies of the Field" a classic that continues to touch audiences.
Total: 72
"Lilies of the Field" is a timeless classic brought to high definition in a Blu-ray release from Twilight Time. Sidney Poitier's compelling performance anchors the film, and his magnetic presence is complemented by Ralph Nelson's direction, which is characterized by a refreshing simplicity and attention to character detail. The movie’s emotional depth is genuine and heartfelt, avoiding artificial sentimentality. Cinematographer Ernest Haller’s stark and beautiful black-and-white photography enhances the film’s narrative, echoing the restraint found in the performances and editing. This Blu-ray preserves every nuance of Haller’s work, along with a crisp, clear soundtrack.
The technical presentation on this Blu-ray is superb. The transfer highlights the tonal range of Haller's cinematography. Twilight Time's commitment to quality is evident, particularly with the inclusion of an isolated music and effects track and an outstanding commentary by Lem Dobbs, Julie Kirgo, and Nick Redman. These scholars offer insightful aesthetic and historical analysis in an engaging, conversational style that complements the film. The disc also features bonus materials that enhance the viewing experience for fans and film scholars alike.
In conclusion, "Lilies of the Field" on Blu-ray exemplifies how a simple yet impactful story can be beautifully presented in high definition. The film’s blend of humor and gravitas, underpinned by Poitier's spellbinding performance and Haller’s masterful cinematography, is perfectly captured in this release. With strong technical merits and comprehensive bonus content, this Blu-ray comes highly recommended. Secure a copy soon, as there are only 3,000 available.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
There is some slight but noticeable variability in sharpness and clarity, at least some of which seems to be related to outdoor location shooting environments and ostensibly more controlled environments...
Audio: 80
Lilies of the Field's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio Mono track isn't especially nuanced, but it reflects the somewhat limited ambitions of the film's sound design more than adequately....
Extras: 30
Audio Commentary features Lem Dobbs hosted by Twilight Time's Julie Kirgo and Nick Redman....
Movie: 90
Poitier's unassuming elegance may be the focal point of Lilies of the Field, but he's surrounded by a large and colorful supporting cast which brilliantly suffuses the film with authentic, earned (as opposed...
Total: 80
Lem Dobbs mentions something along the lines of a supposed "saccharine" element in Lilies of the Field in the commentary included on this Blu-ray, but I find the film's emotions less artificially sweet...
The Digital Bits review by Jim HemphillRead review here
Video: 95
Audio: 95
Extras: 95
Movie: 95
There’s really not much more to the story than that, but in producer-director Nelson’s hands (working from a screenplay by James Poe), this minor fable yields major emotional effects – effects all the...
Total: 95
Poitier is spellbinding in the movie, and the whole thing more or less rests on his shoulders – it’s hard to recall a scene in the picture that doesn’t feature him, and Nelson’s penchant for relaxed long...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
In one scene after Homer leaves where the nuns are walking outside, a bit of banding appears along the horizon....
Audio: 80
Legendary film composer Jerry Goldsmith's score rings through with great clarity, and naturally, sounds more robust on the isolated track....
Extras: 40
Isolated Score Track (with Some Effects) – Jerry Goldsmith's score can be heard DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0....
Movie: 80
He helps them learn English and then stays the night, under the presumption he is going to get paid in the morning....
Total: 60
Fans of the film and of Sidney Poitier will certainly want to get a copy of Twilight Time's limited release....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 90
The movie has been framed at 1.66:1 for this Blu-ray presentation and is presented in 1080p resolution using the AVC codec....
Audio: 90
Dialogue has been masterfully recorded, and it has been blended together with surety with Jerry Goldsmith’s enjoyable background music and the atmospheric effects into an involving mono sound mix....
Extras: 60
Theatrical Trailer (3:14, HD) MGM 90th Anniversary Trailer (2:06, HD) Six-Page Booklet: contains a few movie stills, original poster art on the back cover, and film historian Julie Kirgo’s adulatory essay...
Movie: 90
And director Ralph Nelson (who also plays the construction company owner who ends up figuring prominently into the story) stages some delightful moments that stay in the memory long after the film concludes:...
Total: 90
Lilies of the Field brings one of the 1960’s classic comedy-dramas to high definition home video with excellent bonus material and the feature looking and sounding at its best....
Director: Ralph Nelson
Actors: Sidney Poitier, Lilia Skala, Lisa Mann
PlotHomer Smith, an African-American handyman traveling through the Arizona desert, unexpectedly finds himself at a remote farmstead run by a group of East German nuns. Led by the strict Mother Maria, the nuns initially employ him for minor repairs, but soon persuade him to take on the grander task of building a chapel. Homer agrees reluctantly, motivated by a mix of faith, pity, and an increasing sense of responsibility. Despite language barriers and cultural differences, Homer and the nuns form an unlikely bond as they work together to begin construction.
As the project progresses, Homer grapples with various obstacles including scarce resources and his own doubts about the scale of the undertaking. The local townspeople become interested in Homer's efforts, with some offering assistance and others remaining skeptical. While Homer's initial intention was to move on quickly, his growing connection to the nuns and their steadfast determination compel him to stay longer than he had planned. This transformative experience for both Homer and the nuns forms the foundation of their shared journey, which is marked by humor, tension, and moments of profound understanding.
Writers: James Poe, William E. Barrett
Release Date: 05 Jul 1963
Runtime: 94 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English, German, Spanish