Reds Blu-ray Review
40th Anniversary Edition
Score: 76
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Reds, a classic restored by Paramount, offers stunning 1080p visuals and immersive audio, despite its length, making it a must-own Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 83
The Blu-ray of "Reds" shines with a stunning 1080p transfer, enhanced from a 4K restoration supervised by Warren Beatty. Featuring a beautiful film-like grain, exceptional clarity, and organic texture, it offers vibrant colors, deep blacks, and flawless encoding. A visual masterpiece celebrating its 40th anniversary.
Audio: 80
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack for "Reds" offers a newly restored and front-heavy experience with subtle surround enhancements. The audio maintains clear dialogue and well-modulated music, while preserving the original intent. Despite some muffling, bass impact and ambient details elevate its dynamic range beautifully.
Extra: 57
The Blu-ray of "Reds" delivers a comprehensive suite of legacy extras, now conveniently on a separate disc, featuring a seven-part, 75-minute "Witness to Reds" documentary in SD, and the trailer in HD, enhancing its archival value without adding new content.
Movie: 73
Paramount's remastered Blu-ray of 'Reds' brings Warren Beatty's ambitious epic to life with stunning 1080p video and Dolby TrueHD 5.1 audio, highlighting the film's technical prowess and artistic direction. However, despite its impressive performances and award-winning cinematography, the lengthy narrative lacks emotional depth, making it more a cinematic marvel than a heartfelt journey.
Video: 83
The Blu-ray presentation of "Reds" exemplifies Paramount's dedication to high-quality restorations, offering a strikingly impressive 1080p transfer. Overseen by Warren Beatty and utilizing a 4K HDR restoration from the original negative, this edition ensures a film-like experience with notable improvements over previous releases. The encode benefits from a grain structure that preserves the authenticity of the original cinematography, enhancing the film’s visual depth and texture. Fine details capture the richness of period costumes and the complexity of facial features, showcasing immaculate clarity and excellent contrast throughout. The depth of field is remarkable, rendering each scene with scale and motion that remain natural and engaging.
The color palette in this restoration presents a warm glow that amplifies the nostalgic feel essential to the film’s historical narrative. Emphasis on grays, browns, and beiges deliver a rustic aesthetic, while black levels remain deep and detailed without losing information in shadows. Whites possess a slightly creamy warmth, reflecting the film's warm color temperature. This transfer also excels in balancing skin tones with its consistent appearance from scene to scene, adding to the authenticity without introducing noise or artifacts. Blacks are robust and well-saturated, allowing for a dimensional viewing experience.
Utilizing an AVC MPEG-4 encoding on a BD-50 disc ensures robust performance with no compression issues despite the film’s over three-hour runtime. Paramount's meticulous restoration effort results in a pristine presentation free from any visible scratches or blemishes, offering a spotless print that rivals modern releases' vibrancy and detail. Fans of "Reds" will be exceptionally pleased with the exquisiteness and fidelity brought forth in this anniversary edition, making it a definitive and essential high-definition viewing experience.
Audio: 80
The newly restored Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless audio track on the Blu-ray release of "Reds" offers a refined yet predominantly front-heavy auditory experience. While the surround channels provide subtle ambient integration, the mix remains faithful to its original design, rightly maintaining prominence in the front speakers. The track boasts impressive clarity and balance, presenting dialogue with exceptional precision in the front-center channel, ensuring ease of comprehension. Music exhibits delightful spacing and fidelity, contributing to an enriched auditory landscape without overwhelming the listener. Additionally, faint ambient effects like whispering winds and chirping birds enhance various scenes without detracting from the original atmosphere.
Despite its largely front-centric nature, the enhanced stereo separation intermittently provides a broader soundstage, introducing elements of dynamism to the otherwise restrained soundscape. The audio embraces a wide dynamic range, encompassing Stephen Sondheim's poignant "Goodbye for Now" theme within a well-preserved melodic framework, supplemented by Dave Grusin's additional score work. Low-frequency sounds manifest as appreciative rumbles during action sequences, enhancing depth and presence. While the dialogue can occasionally sound slightly muffled, there is no presence of age-related audio artifacts such as hisses or crackles.
In addition to the Dolby TrueHD 5.1 mix, the disc includes a restored 2.0 Dolby Digital track, expanding listening options. This release makes strides in both video and audio quality, ensuring "Reds" is presented with contemporary clarity while respecting its historical integrity. The remix stands as an exemplary representation of preserved cinematic sound design, striking a balance between modern audio expectations and its original auditory narrative intent.
Extras: 57
The Blu-ray release of "Reds" provides an extensive array of extras, all housed on a second disc, specifically aimed at enhancing the film's immersive narrative. This disc does not introduce new content, but it consolidates existing material into a comprehensive selection, highlighted by the seven-part documentary series, "Witness to Reds." The quality of the extras remains in standard definition (SD), maintaining their original 480i resolution, except for the high-definition trailer in 1080p. The series of documentaries is an insightful deep-dive into the film's historical and production contexts, offering a detailed exploration of themes such as revolution and propaganda. Collectively, the extras provide a robust framework for understanding the multifaceted dimensions of "Reds," making them an indispensable addition for enthusiasts and scholars alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Witness to Reds: The Rising: Introduction to the film's background.
- Witness to Reds: Comrades: Explores camaraderie among the cast.
- Witness to Reds: Testimonials: Features interviews and testimonies.
- Witness to Reds: The March: Focuses on critical scenes and their impact.
- Witness to Reds: Revolution, Part 1: Delves into early revolutionary themes.
- Witness to Reds: Revolution, Part 2: Continuation of revolutionary insights.
- Witness to Reds: Propaganda: Examines use of propaganda in the narrative.
- Reds Trailer: High definition preview of the film.
Movie: 73
Paramount’s re-release of “Reds” on Blu-ray presents a significant technical upgrade from its previous 2006 version, boasting newly restored and remastered 1080p video alongside a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack. Directed by Warren Beatty, this extensive 195-minute epic traces the passionate and tumultuous lives of John Reed and Louise Bryant amidst the backdrop of the Bolshevik Revolution. Supported by a stellar cast featuring Diane Keaton, Jack Nicholson, and Maureen Stapleton, the film remains a breathtakng cinematic achievement. Beatty navigates the dual responsibility of directing and acting with sincerity, although his portrayal of Reed leans more toward heroic embellishment.
At the heart of “Reds” lies Beatty's attempt at blending romantic ideals with the gritty socio-political turbulences of the early 20th century. The film's epic scope is accentuated by Vittorio Storaro’s Oscar-winning cinematography, which vividly captures the color palette and architectural beauty of the period. Despite its technical brilliance and historical gravitas, “Reds” occasionally struggles with maintaining emotional cohesion. While Beatty and Keaton exhibit undeniable chemistry, their characters’ focus on political ideologies often overshadows emotional depth, resulting in sporadic audience engagement over such a protracted runtime.
Often likened to a quasi-documentary, “Reds” benefits from the inclusion of authentic testimonies by individuals who knew Reed and Bryant personally, enriching the narrative with their candid remembrances. Despite its formidable length, the film offers an invaluable glimpse into history; its commitment to realistic drama and exemplary performances make it a staple of cinematic study. Yet, without significant new supplemental content in this release, potential viewers should be prepared for a film experience that is more intellectual than emotionally resonant. While praised for its craft, “Reds” retains its status as an epic that commands respect more than repeated viewings.
Total: 76
The Blu-ray release of "Reds" offers an impressive restoration of Warren Beatty's ambitious historical drama, capturing the essence of John Reed's tumultuous life and political ideology. This release showcases a meticulously crafted 1080p video and enhanced 5.1 lossless audio, ensuring a visually and audibly stimulating experience. Despite some critique regarding its narrative length and pacing, the film remains an influential classic, reflecting a unique perspective on early 20th-century political landscapes.
The restoration, supervised by Beatty, highlights the intricacies of the original cinematography, adding depth to a visually complex film. It succeeds in breathing new life into this cinematic staple, allowing both enthusiasts and new audiences to appreciate its artistry. Although some viewers may find the runtime challenging, the film’s historical significance and narrative intricacies offer a compelling reason to engage with this title. The inclusion of legacy extras further enriches the viewing experience by providing valuable insights into the production and historical contexts.
In conclusion, this Blu-ray edition of "Reds" is a commendable continuation of the film’s legacy. While there are notes of intrigue regarding its exclusion from the Paramount Presents line, this package aptly honors Beatty's Oscar-winning directorial efforts. For fans of historical cinema and those interested in politically charged narratives, this release comes highly recommended, offering a comprehensive and immersive viewing experience at an attractive price point. Whether revisiting the film or encountering it for the first time, this edition stands as a significant contribution to collections of classic cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Reds boasts a beautiful film-like look about it, then, and the grain pattern is one of the many benefits of the full restoration work....
Audio: 90
I cannot comment on how specifically it compares to the original (I neither reviewed nor have access to a copy of that disc), but this is a solid presentation, front heavy as it may be; the added surround...
Extras: 60
See below for a list of what's included and please click here for full coverage; this is the entire suite of legacy Blu-ray content....
Movie: 70
Paramount has re-released the awards season darling 'Reds,' arguably Director Warren Beatty's best-known picture, to Blu-ray, replacing a severely aged and low-tech MPEG-2 video and Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack...
Total: 80
Why this was not part of the "Paramount Presents" line is a mystery, but regardless of packaging and physical presentation parameters this release comes highly recommended....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Close-ups highlight facial stubble, scraggly beards, and the witnesses' cavernous wrinkles, as well as the glamor of Keaton and Beatty, and not a single nick, mark, or errant scratch dot the spotless print....
Audio: 80
(I noticed some faint bleeding during the beach scene and more pronounced multi-channel effects as the music swelled in the moments just prior to the intermission.)...
Extras: 40
For a complete review of the seven-part, 75-minute "Witness to Reds" documentary, click here....
Movie: 80
Paramount, unsure of how to market such an esoteric production (was there really a market for a movie about one of the only U.S. citizens to be buried inside the Kremlin?), hyped Reds as a Gone with the...
Total: 80
Reds didn't captivate me when I first saw the film back in 1981, and despite a marvelous restoration supervised by Beatty himself and remastered audio, this epic historical drama failed to captivate me...
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 90
A big time improvement over the original Blu-ray with a better, healthy layer of grain, and much more natural detail and a stronger sense of style in its color timing....
Audio: 90
There are some good rumbling sounds like engines, trains and the like that allow for some subwoofer action and it hits some of the score moments very well....
Extras: 80
All extras are found on Disc 2.Witness To Reds:The Rising (SD, 6:29) Comrades (SD, 13:30) Testimonials (SD, 11:58)...
Movie: 80
Yet, it jumps around and hops along, finding great actor pairings to share scenes as well and great bigger moments with a more crowded structure....
Total: 90
The older, and more than sufficient, featurette on looking back at Reds is still here too....
Director: Warren Beatty
Actors: Warren Beatty, Diane Keaton, Edward Herrmann
PlotSet against the backdrop of the early 20th century and the tumult of the Russian Revolution, the story follows John Reed, an American journalist and communist activist. Reed becomes deeply involved in labor movements in the United States before his passion for social justice leads him to Russia, where he witnesses firsthand the profound changes of the Bolshevik Revolution. His commitment to his ideals is tested as he navigates the complex political landscape, struggling to balance his ambitions with his personal life.
Reed's relationship with Louise Bryant, a feminist and fellow writer, forms a central theme. Their partnership, both romantic and ideological, is challenged by their differing commitments and the chaotic times they live in. As they move from the bohemian circles of New York to the heart of Russia's revolution, their journey reflects the struggle between personal desires and political convictions. The narrative not only explores the historical events through Reed's eyes but also delves into the emotional turmoil and the intellectual debates that marked the era, capturing the essence of a generation caught between war and the hope for a new societal paradigm.
Writers: Warren Beatty, Trevor Griffiths
Release Date: 25 Dec 1981
Runtime: 195 min
Rating: PG
Country: United States, United Kingdom
Language: English, Russian, German, French, Finnish, Italian