Fair Game Blu-ray Review
Score: 63
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Fair Game offers an engaging, well-acted political thriller with electric performances, quality video, and exceptional audio, despite needing more depth.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
Fair Game's US Region A-locked Blu-ray offers a pristine 1080p High Definition presentation with exceptional detail, rich mahogany tones, deep navy blues, and solid black levels, despite minor banding and occasional softness. The color palette is neat with lifelike skin tones, making the overall transfer visually impressive.
Audio: 66
Fair Game’s DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track delivers an intense, atmospheric soundscape with potent effects and energized music, but struggles with balance, often burying dialogue beneath powerful LFE-laden sequences and ambient noise. Despite its vibrant surround usage and immersive qualities, better vocal prioritization could enhance the experience.
Extra: 47
The Blu-ray of 'Fair Game' includes a singular but exceptional extra: an audio commentary by the real Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson. Their insightful reflections on the film’s accuracy and personal anecdotes offer a unique and compelling perspective, making this commentary an essential listen.
Movie: 60
"Fair Game," while not achieving the gripping heights of "All the President’s Men," is a timely and precise political thriller with strong performances and direction, navigating the impact on Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson's lives during post-9/11 tensions. The Blu-ray offers excellent video and audio quality, along with valuable commentary from the real-life figures involved, making it a recommended watch for fans of political conspiracy dramas.
Video: 69
"Fair Game" arrives on Blu-ray with a remarkable 1080p High Definition video presentation, capturing the film's original theatrical aspect ratio of widescreen 2.4:1. The detail is consistently excellent, showcasing resounding clarity, though there are minor and infrequent dips into softness. The transfer from the HD source is clean, free from digital defects like edge enhancement, and artifacts. The color scheme is intentionally muted to reflect the film’s somber tone—dominated by rich mahogany tones, deep navy blues, and gunmetal greys—each rendered with impressive accuracy and depth. Solid black levels display no signs of crush, although some scenes exhibit flatter blacks that may slightly obscure fine details.
Despite its source limitations, "Fair Game" demonstrates high standards in Blu-ray quality, managing occasional light banding and some minor softness in a few shots. The AVC MPEG-4 encode further enhances the image stability. The palette remains cool and sterile, with a tactile blend of grays, blacks, and whites reflective of the film's bureaucratic settings in Washington. Skin tones are natural and consistent, while earth tones—particularly in scenes set in Iraq—are rendered beautifully. Fine details, such as facial textures and subtle background elements like dry erase board marks, are captured with satisfying clarity.
Summit's Blu-ray transfer effectively captures the neutral and desaturated aesthetic of "Fair Game". While the HD source’s natural flatness and minimal noise can be observed, the overall visual integrity is maintained admirably. This presentation offers a clean experience with rarely seen digital shortcomings, making it a solid release for discerning viewers looking for high-definition quality in a serious dramatic context.
Audio: 66
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for "Fair Game" is a powerful and immersive auditory experience that, while primarily a dialogue-driven thriller, delivers the kind of intense and atmospheric sound typically reserved for high-octane action films. The soundtrack is meticulously crafted, filling every speaker with energized music and perfectly balanced natural atmospherics that significantly enhance the film's overall impact. Background sounds such as busy office environments, bar ambience, and distant gunfire or bomb explosions resonate authentically, creating a deeply engaging auditory landscape. However, this level of detail sometimes overshadows the dialogue, requiring listeners to increase the volume to catch whispered or softly spoken lines.
The technical execution of the audio mix ensures a thrilling experience with LFE-laden explosions and action-packed sequences rendering with devastating clarity. Dynamic scenes, whether depicting the pounding impacts of bombing raids or the chaos of an Iraqi traffic jam under fire, benefit from a masterful use of surround sound, lending a surreal and almost overwhelming feel to these moments. The score, reminiscent yet more restrained than the Bourne series, precisely suits the narrative's tense atmosphere. Despite its excellence, the track occasionally falters in prioritizing vocal clarity over environmental soundscaping, which diminishes its potential to be a demo-quality mix. Nevertheless, "Fair Game" offers a commendably robust and palpable audio presentation that stands out in Summit's repertoire.
Extras: 47
While the Blu-ray of "Fair Game" includes only one extra, it is a highly compelling audio commentary by real-life figures Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson. This commentary provides an engaging contrast to typical technical commentary tracks by offering an authentic and deeply personal perspective on the events depicted in the film. Plame vividly describes the accuracy of the CIA set designs, while Wilson remarks on Sean Penn's efforts to capture his mannerisms. Despite the occasional silent moments that might have been alleviated by the inclusion of a third party like the director, this unique commentary remains highly recommended for its candid and insightful nature.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: By Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson, providing personal insights and reflections on the film's events and accuracy.
Movie: 60
"Fair Game" delves into the true story of Valerie Plame Wilson, a covert CIA operative whose identity was leaked following her husband Joe Wilson's critical op-ed about the Bush administration’s deceptive practices leading up to the Iraq War. Directed by Doug Liman, the film retraces their experiences with a gripping, albeit understated, approach. The narrative primarily focuses on the personal and political fallout from the leak, rather than dramatizing action scenes, making it a distinctive political thriller. Liman's direction remains effective and tension-filled, though straightforward, as he navigates the intricacies of the scandal that captured headlines years ago. The movie's pace is commendable, although it sacrifices some depth in explaining the events leading up to the war in favor of concentrating on the subsequent turmoil faced by the Wilsons.
Performances by Naomi Watts and Sean Penn are remarkably compelling, bringing a realistic and human element to the roles of Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson, respectively. Their portrayals are bolstered by a strong supporting cast, contributing to the film’s emotional weight. While "Fair Game" does provide some balance by presenting viewpoints from multiple sides of the controversy, it leans heavily towards the Wilsons' perspective, which is expected given its basis on Valerie Plame’s memoirs. This focus, however, can make the film feel somewhat one-dimensional at times. Despite this, "Fair Game" successfully keeps viewers engaged with its blend of real-life drama and scrupulous attention to detail, making it an intriguing watch for those interested in political conspiracies and media manipulation.
Technically, "Fair Game" is proficiently rendered on Blu-ray, with high-quality video and audio that enhance the overall viewing experience. The inclusion of a commentary track from Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson provides valuable insights, adding depth to the narrative presented on screen. While it may not achieve the iconic status of other political thrillers, "Fair Game" stands out for its authentic portrayal of a significant historical event, thoughtful execution, and notable performances—elements that collectively warrant its addition to any collection centered on politically charged dramas.
Total: 63
Fair Game offers a riveting depiction of the Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson espionage affair that captivated global headlines. Directed by Doug Liman, the film could benefit from more narrative depth, but Liman effectively balances critical events with a brisk pace, ensuring the runtime is well-managed to maintain viewer engagement. Naomi Watts and Sean Penn deliver intense performances, fully embodying their roles without appearing as mere actors reenacting the story. The movie's missing pieces prevent it from being a thoroughly complete picture, however, it remains a compelling and watchable thriller that effectively captures attention despite lacking surprises.
Summit Entertainment upholds its reputation with this Blu-ray release, providing a quality video transfer and an exceptional lossless soundtrack. The disc includes a single but uniquely insightful commentary track that enriches the viewing experience. While the film rushes through many factual intricacies of the Plame case, it successfully translates a potentially dry story into a tension-filled cinematic thriller that avoids sanctimonious overtones. The audio-visual quality, combined with the special feature, makes this Blu-ray edition especially appealing to both casual viewers and enthusiasts of political thrillers.
Fair Game stands out for its engaging narrative and superior technical presentation, making it a solid recommendation for those interested in the intricacies of political espionage or anyone seeking an entertaining thriller. Although it misses opportunities for deeper exploration, it excels in maintaining interest and delivering strong performances. This Blu-ray release is certainly worth renting and is a worthwhile addition for any collector of contemporary political dramas.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 90
Detail is excellent throughout, with resounding clarity that only occasionally dips into the most negligible moments of softness....
Audio: 80
Although this is a dialogue-driven affair, the inherent lack of action means that the only way that the suspense can truly be maintained is through an intense, atmospheric soundtrack – and that’s exactly...
Extras: 70
But rather being another somewhat familiar directorial offering, here we get a commentary by the only people that we really want to hear from: the real Valerie Plame and Joe Wilson....
Movie: 70
Fair Game may not be the Bush administration version of All the President’s Men’s thrilling expose of the Watergate Affair, but it is still a very capable, and indeed remarkably timely, political conspiracy...
Total: 80
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Some light banding may be seen from time to time and a few shots go slightly soft, but this is otherwise a solid high-def image that captures colors and details nicely....
Audio: 90
A few gunshots are of a nicely potent feel, and the Iraq bombing sequence brings with it a devastating and hard-hitting feel; the action transitions to the inside of a building where the distant booms...
Extras: 20
They are happy with the results -- the performances of the leads, the film's ability to tell their story -- and despite a few stretches of silence this proves to be a worthwhile commentary track....
Movie: 60
Liman does a fine job of maintaining a level of tension and intrigue throughout, even considering that many viewers will be familiar with how the story is ultimately going to play out, whether such facts...
Total: 60
The picture could use a little more fleshing out, but Doug Liman does a fair job of balancing the need to give play to all of the critical elements while keeping up the pace and runtime necessary to make...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The presentation does harbor some of the nitpicky annoyances that come from HD sources, like some minor banding in a few scenes and flatter blacks....
Audio: 80
It seemed when the big action-oriented scenes hit that the oomph was almost to the point of overpowering, because the rest of the movie is so somber....
Extras: 60
Plame does a great job discussing exactly what it's like working in the CIA and how similar the meetings are in the movie compared to how they're run in real life....
Movie: 60
I must confess ignorance about what went on behind the scenes during the Plame scandal, so I'm just going to have to take the movie at its word and hope that it isn't embellishing....
Total: 60
'Fair Game' breezes through many of the meaty facts surrounding the case of Valerie Plame, but it's able to create a tension-filled thriller of sorts out of a story that isn't all that "thrilling."...
Director: Doug Liman
Actors: Naomi Watts, Sean Penn, Sonya Davison
PlotValerie Plame is a covert CIA operative specializing in tracking nuclear proliferation. Her husband, Joseph Wilson, is a former diplomat. After a trip to Niger where Joe investigates allegations that Iraq is attempting to acquire uranium, he concludes the claims are unfounded and writes an op-ed piece publicly challenging the Bush administration's justification for the Iraq War. In response, Valerie's identity is leaked to the press, causing a media firestorm and jeopardizing her covert status and decades-long career. The scandal puts immense strain on their personal and professional lives, leading to scrutiny, public pressure, and political maneuvering.
As Valerie and Joe navigate the fallout, their marriage faces increasing stress and challenges, leaving them to deal with the implications of the exposure. Their fight against the injustice involves intense media interactions and complex legal battles. As they struggle to maintain their integrity amidst the chaos, they confront powerful adversaries from within the government and the intelligence community. The ensuing conflict tests their resolve, loyalty, and commitment to exposing the truth while safeguarding their family's future.
Writers: Jez Butterworth, John-Henry Butterworth, Joseph Wilson
Release Date: 03 Dec 2010
Runtime: 108 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, United Arab Emirates
Language: English, Arabic, French