Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore Blu-ray Review

Warner’s Blu-ray release of "Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore" exhibits a strong yet imperfect 1080p/AVC video transfer presented in a theatrically correct widescreen 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The film’s 3D elements, which were added in post-production, offer a mix of traditional gimmick and enhanced depth. Layer separation is reasonably distinct, particularly in CG-heavy scenes, such as when the animals are ‘flying’. Establishing shots and overhead views also display good depth. However, the overall 3D effect is somewhat flat, with characters lacking the solidity needed to achieve reference quality. While the animal fur is well-defined and detail levels are impressively high, the conversion fails to fully leverage the potential of 3D.

Colors in this transfer are rich and well-defined without wash or bleed, supporting a vibrant palette that enhances visual appeal. The 2D version excels in terms of detail, color, brightness, and contrast, much like the 3D rendition but devoid of its shortcomings. Black levels are mostly superb, maintaining detail even in shadows, although some nighttime shots appear muddy due to minor noise interference. Brightness is consistent, and despite occasional softness, the image remains clean and crisp without noticeable compression issues. Grain is generally unobtrusive but can spike, leading to brief instances of artifacting and blockiness. Crosstalk and ghosting are prominently featured throughout the action scenes and even the credits, disrupting the viewing experience at times.

Despite its limitations, the Blu-ray delivers sufficient clarity and texture to bring lifelike creatures and settings alive. Animations hold up well under scrutiny, though some effects betray their CG origins under high definition. While casual viewers may overlook some of these technical hiccups, avid home theater enthusiasts might find them a distraction. In sum, while the 3D enhancement is a mixed bag, the overall visual quality remains impressive enough to justify the purchase for fans of the film.

The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore" in DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 offers an engaging and dynamic experience, albeit not flawless. This mix is particularly notable for its aggressive surround activity and immersive soundscapes, especially during action-packed sequences like underground HQs and high-energy chases. Stereo separation is expansive, contributing to a wide soundstage, though the front and rear channels could be more distinctly delineated. The ambient noises are well-represented, adding depth to various settings within the film. Dialogue is generally centered and clear, but there are occasional moments where it gets overshadowed by the chaotic mix of explosions, effects, and music.

LFE is robust, injecting a satisfying intensity into scenes with numerous explosions and action sequences, though some might find it lacks the deepest impact compared to top-tier mixes. The score by Christopher Lennertz stands out, utilizing all available channels to create a rich, enveloping sound environment. Additionally, the dynamics of the soundtrack are bold with excellent transparency in directional effects, allowing for a convincing 360-degree auditory experience. However, voiceover prioritization can be inconsistent; animal dialogue sometimes struggles against the overpowering backdrop of loud sound effects and music cues.

Overall, while it might not reach reference quality, this DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is a commendable effort for a kids' film. It engages its target audience with bombastic and energetic sound design while maintaining satisfactory clarity and natural sounding dialogue most of the time. Additional language options for Korean and Chinese consumers in this release further ensure that the diverse audience can enjoy the animated antics without compromise.

The Blu-ray extras for "Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore" provide a mixed bag of entertainment predominantly aimed at younger viewers. The highlight is undoubtedly "Looney Tunes: Coyote Falls," an impressive, digitally animated short featuring Wile E. Coyote and Road Runner, excelling particularly in its 3D format with outstanding visual depth and animation quality. "Dogs Dishing: Tails from the Bark Side of Hollywood" offers a mock behind-the-scenes look, though its humor becomes stale rather quickly. "Meow-Takes," a collection of scripted outtakes, fails to elicit much amusement, while "Best of the Best Cat Vs. Dogs Animated Showdowns" is a brief montage reminiscent of classic Tom and Jerry antics. The "Yogi Bear" sneak peek, unfortunately, does little to elevate the overall package, drawing significant criticism for its lackluster presentation.

Extras included in this disc:

• Coyote Falls: A 3D-animated Looney Tunes short that impresses with stunning visuals.
• Dogs Dishing: Tails from the Bark Side of Hollywood: Mockumentary featuring cast and crew.
• Best of the Best Cat Vs. Dogs Animated Showdowns: Montage of classic cat vs dog battles.
• Meow-Takes: Pre-scripted gag reel that disappoints.
• Sneak Peek: Yogi Bear: Preview of the live-action adaptation seen as mediocre.

"Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore" is a child-centric film that attempts to cater to a very young audience while also throwing a bone to parents through scattered references to established movie franchises like James Bond. Despite its commendable voice cast, including performances by Bette Midler, Neil Patrick Harris, and Nick Nolte, the film flounders in delivering a cohesive, engaging narrative. The plot, centered around former M.E.O.W.S. agent Kitty Galore's nefarious scheme to drive dogs insane, presses cats and dogs into an unconvincing alliance of mutual survival. Unfortunately, the parody elements and dated references fall flat, resulting in a spate of uninspired one-liners and thin character development.

Technically, the Blu-ray package delivers an impressive audiovisual experience. The 3D and 2D Blu-ray versions boast excellent picture and sound quality, enhancing the film’s colorful and animated aesthetics. However, the extra features are underwhelming, save for the inclusion of a Looney Tunes cartoon which provides a brief respite from the main feature's shortcomings. Despite the solid technical presentation, the movie itself lacks depth and fails to sustain interest beyond its initial viewing. This release will likely bring fleeting joy to its intended young audience while leaving older viewers seeking solace in more fulfilling family entertainment. Whether catered viewing or rental, "Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore" seems best suited for occasional, rather than permanent, inclusion in one's collection.

The Blu-ray release of "Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore" presents a mixed bag for families looking to add a new title to their collection. The film itself may not meet the quality standards set by other family favorites such as "Toy Story 3" or "How to Train Your Dragon." Subpar acting, unnecessary recasting, and a largely uninspired storyline make this sequel feel more like an afterthought than a compelling continuation. However, for fans of the original, there is some solace in the technical strengths of the Blu-ray release.

Warner's Blu-ray package showcases a crisp and colorful video transfer that maintains high-definition quality throughout the runtime. The 3D edition also brings forth some enjoyable depth, although it doesn't reach the heights expected from the format. In terms of audio, the DTS-HD Master Audio track delivers a dynamic experience, bringing the chaotic action scenes to life with clarity and punch. Supplementary features, while plentiful, fall short of enhancing the overall value of the package, with most extras feeling more like filler. Notably, however, is the inclusion of a 3D Looney Tunes short, which adds some much-needed charm.

In conclusion, while "Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore" is undeniably targeted towards a younger audience, parents may want to consider a rental over a purchase. Although the Blu-ray offers commendable technical aspects, the film's entertainment value remains questionable. It stands as neither quality family entertainment nor a worthwhile investment but rather as a mediocre title best suited for the bargain bin. If you do decide to purchase, be sure to appreciate the solid video and audio production values Warner has delivered. Choose wisely.