MI-5 Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
MI-5 is an engaging espionage thriller with great performances and superior technical merits, though it may primarily appeal to fans of the show.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 72
The Blu-ray of 'MI-5' offers a sharp and extremely well-detailed 1080p transfer in 2.39:1, with excellent fine detail in close-ups and solid contrast and black levels. While occasional aggressive color grading and minor banding issues are present, the overall clarity and vibrancy make it a strong, though not overwhelmingly amazing, presentation.
Audio: 72
MI-5's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track delivers excellent panning effects and boisterous sound elements like gunfire and explosions, with a clean and well-prioritized dialogue. Although rear channels lack engagement in quieter scenes, the intense LFE and directional front channels offer a satisfying audio experience.
Extra: 16
The Making of MI-5 offers a standard promotional insight alongside a helpful explanatory card addressing title confusion, while the deleted scenes provide minimal additional value.
Movie: 51
Struggling to rise above its TV origins, 'MI-5' offers a convoluted plot and middling performances, with occasional action sequences undercut by forced narrative twists and unremarkable character development, making it feel more like an episode of 'Homeland' than a compelling espionage thriller.
Video: 72
Lionsgate Films' Blu-ray presentation of "MI-5" offers a competent AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. The video quality is commendable, delivering a notably sharp and detailed image that excels in close-ups with abundant fine detail. Viewers will appreciate the clarity particularly in the aerial shots of downtown London which are exceptionally clear. Close-ups are rendered impressively, with intricate textures and facial details well-defined.
Despite these strengths, the presentation is not without its drawbacks. There are occurrences of aggressive color grading, predominantly tilting towards the blue spectrum, which may occasionally detract from an otherwise engaging visual experience. Moreover, certain CGI sequences, including major explosive scenes, exhibit a relatively softer image compared to the rest of the transfer.
The transfer is generally solid in terms of contrast and black levels, but it does falter slightly in darker scenes where visual depth and complexity are somewhat lacking. For instance, night-time sequences such as the one where Harry observes a terrorist faction reveal a noticeable flatness and lack of depth. Additionally, issues with intermittent banding during sky shots and some fade transitions can momentarily disrupt the viewing experience. These shortcomings are minor yet evident enough to mildly distract.
Overall, while the "MI-5" Blu-ray video transfer is devoid of any overwhelming flaws and performs competently, it lacks the stellar visual excellence seen in other high-end transfers. It provides an enjoyable viewing experience with its sharp details and impressive clarity, making it a solid yet unremarkable offering.
Audio: 72
The MI-5 Blu-ray offers a meticulously crafted DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that is superbly realized, especially during action sequences. The opening helicopter scene is a standout, with precise panning effects as it hovers over a bustling London traffic jam. The mix abounds with well-executed sound effects, from immersive gunfire to powerful explosions, providing a dynamic and engaging listening experience. Even during quieter, more serene interior moments at MI-5 headquarters, surround activity remains robust, transporting the listener directly into the film's operative environment with immaculate sonic detail. Dialogue remains clear and well-prioritized, ensuring no loss in intelligibility amidst the abundant audio effects.
However, the 5.1 mix, while strong and clear, does have areas where it could have been more enveloping. The front channels perform admirably with good directionality for voices, but some voices can occasionally seem slightly soft. Rear channels deliver less engagement than one might anticipate for a spy thriller, despite the initial excitement generated during the opening escape sequence with its cacophony of rear-channel sound. As the movie transitions to more dialogue-driven scenes, the rear channels' activity decreases noticeably.
Despite these minor drawbacks, the LFE channel shines during intense scenes, resonating profoundly with deep, satisfying low-end booms during explosions and the thumping soundtrack. The bass provides several opportunities for an enveloping experience with rolling bass that adds substantial functional value to the overall track. While there are subtle issues, such as certain audio elements that could be more enveloping and some dialogue levels requiring more balance, the strengths of this audio presentation undoubtedly outweigh any shortcomings.
Extras: 16
The extras included in the Blu-ray release of "MI-5" provide a substantial insight into the film's production, though they are fairly standard within their category. "The Making of MI-5" runs for around 11 minutes in 1080p HD and includes an explanatory card clarifying the film's original title, ensuring viewers aren't confused by references during this extended promotional segment. Additionally, the disc offers around 5 to 6 minutes of deleted scenes, which, while not particularly remarkable, do add some context to the final cut. Overall, these extras offer adequate additional content for fans looking to delve deeper into the movie's background and production processes.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of MI-5: A standard promotional look at the film’s genesis from the TV series.
- Deleted Scenes: A few notable additional scenes that didn't make the final cut.
Movie: 51
The feature film "MI-5," adapted from the long-running British TV series 'Spooks,' showcases an espionage plot centered around MI-5 agent Will Holloway (Kit Harington) and the institution’s disgraced director, Harry Pearce (Peter Firth). The central narrative involves a convoluted sequence of events starting with a well-orchestrated prisoner escape, reminiscent of Denis Villeneuve’s "Sicario." This sequence leads to Adem Qasim’s (Elyes Gabel) breakout during a dead stop traffic jam in urban London. What follows is a series of somewhat contrived plot machinations that delve into moral gray areas, particularly for Pearce, who faces dilemmas indicative of his storied past in intelligence service.
The movie expertly balances character development with action sequences, presenting viewers with well-paced car chases and hand-to-hand battles courtesy of director Bharat Nalluri. The screenplay, penned by Jonathan Brackley and Sam Vincent, intelligently distributes suspicion among three potential MI-5 moles: Oliver Mace (Tim McInnerny), Geraldine Maltby (Jennifer Ehle), and Francis Warrender (David Harewood). While it offers engaging plot twists and a focus on moral complexity, the storyline can feel overwhelming due to its multiple tangents and dense narrative structure.
Despite strong performances, particularly from Firth as the emotional anchor and Harrington’s convincing portrayal of Holloway, "MI-5" lacks distinctiveness within the spy thriller genre. Comparisons to higher calibre espionage films reveal its shortcomings in achieving a deep emotional resonance or offering fresh intrigue. The movie relies heavily on suspense-driven action rather than character authenticity or a compelling narrative. This inclination renders it more akin to an episode of "Homeland," failing to establish itself distinctively within the sphere of cinematic spy dramas. As a standalone film, it struggles with coherence and engagement but may resonate better with dedicated fans of the TV series.
Total: 59
"MI-5" is a film adaptation that seeks to bring the nuanced world of British espionage to the big screen. Its storyline weaves through competing interests within the intelligence community, offering a plot that is derivative at times yet filled with intriguing twists. Standout performances by Harry Pearce, portrayed by a gritty and experienced Firth—the embodiment of a veteran operative with a streak of disheveled resilience—are complemented by Harrington's fresh and appealing take on the next generation of spies. The supporting cast also delivers commendably, collectively enhancing the narrative.
In terms of presentation, the Blu-ray release exhibits solid audio and video quality. While there are minor technical hiccups, these do not detract significantly from the overall experience. The film's pacing maintains interest without heavily relying on grandiose action set pieces typical of the genre, which might feel subdued for those seeking fast-paced thrills. The visual and auditory aspects, although not flawless, provide a satisfactory viewing experience that aligns with the film's grounded, character-driven approach.
In conclusion, "MI-5" strikes a balance between character depth and spy intrigue, making it a reasonably engaging watch. However, it may fall short for those unfamiliar with the series, as it lacks the standalone impact some might expect. Despite this, its commendable performances and competent technical presentation render it a reasonable recommendation, especially for dedicated fans of the original show.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
While there are occasional forays into rather aggressive color grading at times (often to the expected blue end of the spectrum), detail levels are generally excellent throughout, even in some of the darkest...
Audio: 90
MI-5's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is excellent realized, with great panning effects in the opening moments as a helicopter flies over a busy traffic jam in London, and then moving on to a number...
Extras: 20
The Making of MI-5 (1080p; 11:16) comes with a "helpful" explanatory card letting folks know about the film's original title so that they won't be confused when it's referenced throughout this otherwise...
Movie: 70
In a somewhat confusing vignette, Harry is then shown making actual contact with Qasim at an initially undisclosed location, and in a viscerally disturbing scene is forced to make the first of those "shades...
Total: 70
MI-5 is at times unavoidably derivative, but it does manage to craft a rather interesting story involving various competing interests within the intelligence community....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Not a lot of noise in the blackness, just flatness where there should be at least some complexity to perceive....
Audio: 80
The opening escape sequence is rather exciting, producing a cacophony of sound in the rear channels, but as the movie moves toward a more dialogue-centric approach the rear channels don't get as much activity...
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
However, the movie fails to grasp even the rudimentary aspects that make for a good espionage thriller....
Total: 40
Yet the fact remains that if it's released as a standalone film it should be able to stand on its own....
Director: Bharat Nalluri
Actors: Kit Harington, Peter Firth, Jennifer Ehle
PlotFollowing the apparent death of prominent MI-5 officer Harry Pearce, the agency is thrown into a tailspin. Tasked with investigating, former agent Will Holloway is called back into duty from exile. Holloway is sceptical about his mission but driven by a sense of loyalty and a desire for answers. As he delves deeper, he discovers complications involving a terrorist who has escaped custody, further complicating MI-5's strained relationship with the CIA. The threat of an imminent attack on London looms large, intensifying the urgency of the investigation.
As Holloway weaves through layers of deceit and hidden motives, he realizes that the fate of countless lives is at stake. His journey takes him into the dark heart of espionage, revealing shocking truths and testing his resolve. The tension escalates with every revelation, painting a complex picture of loyalty and betrayal within the secretive world of intelligence. The lines between friend and foe blur as Holloway strives to avert disaster while uncovering the real story behind Pearce's disappearance, forcing him to confront inconceivable threats and intricate conspiracies.
Writers: Jonathan Brackley, Sam Vincent, David Wolstencroft
Release Date: 08 May 2015
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom, Germany
Language: English