Magnificent Obsession Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Magnificent Obsession" by Criterion boasts a 1080p transfer in the original 2.00:1 aspect ratio, encoded with MPEG-4 AVC. Utilizing a high-definition transfer from a 35mm interpositive, meticulous digital restoration has effectively minimized dirt, debris, and scratches. Advanced tools like MTI's DRS and Digital Vision's Phoenix were employed to address jitter and chroma breathing. The soundtrack received a remaster from the original 35mm DME magnetic track, employing Pro Tools HD and iZotope RX, ensuring a polished audio-visual experience.

In comparison to previous releases, the Criterion edition demonstrates superior cosmetic work, effectively reducing background color flutter and removing numerous specks, nicks, and blemishes, contributing to a cleaner and healthier visual presentation. However, some inherent weaknesses in the original elements remain evident. Larger panoramic shots occasionally lack optimal depth, and darker scenes could benefit from improved balance and nuance. Instances of color ringing suggest that registration could be more precise. Nevertheless, image stability is commendable.

The earlier 1935 version has also been digitally restored, displaying remarkable depth and consistency in high-definition. Minor blemishes aside, it offers stronger nuances and fluid grain exposure, enhancing overall image stability. The grading feels convincing, adding to the viewing pleasure. Despite some minor issues like registry errors and occasional dirt or scratches, this represents a significant improvement over previous DVD releases, likely delivering the best home-video rendition of "Magnificent Obsession" to date.

The audio presentation of the Blu-ray release of Magnificent Obsession features an English LPCM 1.0 track, with optional English subtitles available. Compared to other releases, such as the Italian version which includes a lossy English 2.0 track, this Blu-ray provides a noticeably superior listening experience. The lossless track delivers a healthier sound, particularly in the mid- and upper registers, exhibiting greater clarity and balance throughout.

The original mono soundtrack is pristinely preserved on a PCM audio track. Dialogue is consistently strong and clear, harmonizing effectively with the film’s overall sound mix. Frank Skinner’s score, alongside selected classical music pieces, is rendered with excellent ambiance and fidelity, avoiding any overpowering or intrusive effects. Remarkably, the track is free from any common audio issues such as distortion, crackling, popping, or hissing, ensuring an exceptionally clean audio experience—likely the best rendition of the film's audio to date in a home video format.

Criterion's Blu-ray edition of "Magnificent Obsession" boasts a wealth of meticulously curated extras that deepen appreciation for this classic film. The archival interviews, tributes, and documentaries provide invaluable insights into Douglas Sirk's unique directorial vision and his significant impact on cinema. The highlight of the extras includes a robust commentary by film scholar Thomas Doherty and a detailed documentary chronicling Sirk's career transition from UFA to Hollywood. Equally noteworthy are the tribute interviews with contemporary filmmakers such as Kathryn Bigelow and Allison Anders, who elucidate Sirk’s enduring influence on their work. Additionally, the inclusion of the original 1935 film adaptation offers a fascinating comparative study.

Extras included in this disc:

• Trailer: A vintage trailer for "Magnificent Obsession."
• Robert Blees: Archival interview with screenwriter Robert Blees.
• From UFA to Hollywood: Douglas Sirk Remembers: Archival documentary on Douglas Sirk.
• Tributes to Sirk:
  • Interview One (Allison Anders).
  • Interview Two (Kathryn Bigelow).
• Commentary: Film scholar Thomas Doherty.
• Magnificent Obsession (1935): Digital restoration of John Stahl's film.
• Leaflet: Illustrated leaflet featuring critic Geoffrey O'Brien's essay.

"Magnificent Obsession" (1954), directed by Douglas Sirk, has made a notable arrival on Blu-ray courtesy of Criterion. This adaptation of Lloyd C. Douglas' novel explores deep themes masked by melodrama, offering a rich viewing experience despite some of its narrative flaws.

The core myth of the film revolves around the idea that wealth cannot buy true love and happiness. Rock Hudson stars as Bob Merrick, a wealthy and reckless playboy whose misguided actions lead to a series of tragic events, including the death of Dr. Wayne Phillips. Merrick's subsequent quest for redemption sees him embracing charity and striving to win the affection of Helen Phillips (Jane Wyman), the widow of the deceased doctor. The narrative's strength lies in its compelling portrayal of Merrick's transformation, albeit punctuated by instances where Hudson's performance appears stilted and unconvincing. Otto Kruger shines as Edward Randolph, the artist who sets Merrick on his path to redemption, alongside memorable performances by Agnes Moorehead and Jane Wyman, whose portrayal earned her an Oscar nomination.

Technically, the film embodies Sirk’s distinctive touch, skillfully balancing melodrama with subtle critiques of societal norms. Screenwriter Robert Blees' decision to forgo the comedic aspects of the earlier 1935 adaptation in favor of a more grounded narrative is commendable. Despite occasional contrived plot developments, "Magnificent Obsession" captivates with its stylistic finesse and emotional depth. This Criterion release includes valuable supplemental features such as vintage interviews and a documentary by Eckhart Schmidt, enhancing understanding of the film’s intricate production and cultural impact. Overall, while "Magnificent Obsession" may not be Sirk’s most flawless effort, its combination of visual splendor and intricate storytelling makes it a significant addition to any classic film collection.

Criterion's Blu-ray release of "Magnificent Obsession" presents a meticulously crafted package that honors Douglas Sirk’s renowned 1954 melodrama. The transfer boasts an enhanced audio and visual presentation that far surpasses previous DVD editions, offering a detailed, high-definition experience. Despite some inherent source limitations, the restoration exhibits the classic vintage Hollywood look with remarkable elegance and clarity. The melodramatic narrative, while characteristic of Sirk’s style, may strike some viewers as excessively emotional. Nevertheless, the charm of the film remains undeniable, owing much to Sirk's distinctive subversive approach.

Included in this release is a brand new digital restoration of John Stahl's original 1935 adaptation, given its own high-definition treatment. This addition provides valuable context and historical depth, showcasing the evolution of this narrative by contrasting Stahl's directorial style with Sirk’s more stylized vision. The retention of legacy special features further enriches the experience, appealing to both long-time fans and new viewers. Comprehensive extras, including interviews and commentaries, offer insights into the film's production and thematic nuances.

In conclusion, while "Magnificent Obsession" stands out for its aesthetic appeal and historical significance in Sirk's oeuvre, its melodramatic tendencies might not resonate with everyone. Nonetheless, Criterion’s Blu-ray release significantly enhances the film's enjoyment through superior technical execution and thoughtful supplementary material. It’s an offering that cinephiles and enthusiasts of classic Hollywood filmmaking should not overlook. RECOMMENDED.