Lone Survivor Blu-ray Review
Score: 72
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Lone Survivor's Blu-ray delivers stunning video, immersive audio, and authentic war depiction, despite limited supplements; highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 75
Lone Survivor's Blu-ray presentation excels with its 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer, offering immaculately detailed textures and lifelike colors. Shot on the Red Epic, it captures every detail from facial hair to terrain surfaces with strong clarity and dimension, despite some minor grain-like noise and banding issues.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 mix of 'Lone Survivor' delivers an immersive and powerful listening experience with precise directionality, robust low-frequency effects, and clear dialogue. The surround envelopment and sound design authentically depict both intense combat and subtle ambient sounds, offering a reference-quality audio presentation.
Extra: 56
Engaging featurettes explore Marcus Luttrell's journey, the film's meticulous production, and heartfelt tributes to fallen heroes, all in crisp 1080p with Dolby Digital 2.0 audio.
Movie: 86
"Lone Survivor" on Blu-ray showcases a raw, intensely visceral depiction of a failed Navy SEAL mission filled with brutal action and profound emotional depth, driven by brotherhood and sacrifice. Director Peter Berg's meticulous focus on authenticity and respect creates a deeply moving tribute to fallen heroes, despite occasional superficial patriotism.
Video: 75
The Blu-ray presentation of "Lone Survivor" offers an exceptional viewing experience, characterized by an immaculate 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer in the 2.40:1 aspect ratio. Captured on the Red Epic, the movie exhibits remarkable clarity, effectively showcasing how advanced digital photography has become. The Afghanistan terrain (filmed in New Mexico) comes to life with stunning detail, making textures, such as pebbles, rocks, branches, and leaves, almost palpable. Although a hint of banding appears in a few sequences, it does not detract from the otherwise detailed and colored transfer. Facial details are particularly lifelike, highlighting every pore and unkempt whisker with precision.
The color palette is slightly stylized to emphasize the Afghan wilderness, featuring dominant browns, yellows, beiges, and greens that bring a gritty sense of realism to the film. Contrasts are high yet well-balanced, and black levels remain consistent and solid throughout the presentation. The facial and uniform details, including frays around boonie hats, patches on combat gear, and weathered weapons, contribute to the film's authentic appearance. Minor issues like grain-like noise in darker scenes and isolated instances of false contouring do not significantly impact the overall viewing quality.
Overall, "Lone Survivor" on Blu-ray delivers a sharp and intensely stylized visual experience that effectively conveys the film's gritty atmosphere. Skin tones remain accurate, and bright green vegetation stands out distinctly against the earthy terrain and gray rock formations. While there are fleeting moments where the digital look is too smooth in motion, these are inherent to the shooting methods employed. This Blu-ray transfer stands as a reference-quality presentation from start to finish.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack for the Blu-Ray of "Lone Survivor" is a masterpiece of auditory experience, especially in its handling of action sequences. The track excels in creating a fully immersive soundstage, starting from the base scenes that deliver a rich, detailed musical backdrop and ambient effects that authentically recreate a bustling military environment. The transition into action is where the mix truly shines, with gunfire, rocket-propelled grenades, and general combat sounds enveloping the listener in intense realism. Bullets whizzing by, debris scattering, and helicopter rotors slicing through the soundscape are executed with precise directionality and natural imaging, creating a frantic yet coherent auditory experience.
Dialogue clarity is maintained throughout, whether it be hushed whispers or frantic screams that often overpower even the loudest gunfire. The mix achieves a perfect balance between subtle ambient details and aggressive action sounds, ensuring that even minor effects like buzzing flies or distant helicopter blades contribute significantly to the atmosphere. The dynamic range is impressively wide, and unlike many action-heavy soundtracks, it remains distortion-free from start to finish. Explosions resonate with a deep, commanding low-frequency presence, while the score by Explosions in the Sky and Steve Jablonsky is delivered with strong fidelity and separation.
Despite an occasional minor anomaly like faint rustling of actors' microphones, these issues are negligible and do not detract from the overall exceptional quality of the audio presentation. The soundtrack is an exemplary blend of power and precision, making "Lone Survivor" not just a home theater workout but an audibly rich cinematic experience. This track is both an audio spectacle for action enthusiasts and a nuanced, layered listen for audiophiles.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "Lone Survivor" offer a comprehensive and impactful selection of supplements that delve deeply into both the filmmaking process and the real-life events that inspired the movie. These features are presented in high-definition with Dolby Digital 2.0 audio, ensuring a viewing experience that is both informative and immersive. With in-depth interviews, behind-the-scenes footage, and detailed profiles, these featurettes allow viewers an intimate look at the operational and personal aspects of the story.
Extras included in this disc:
- Will of the Warrior: A profile of survivor Marcus Luttrell, including his journey to becoming a Navy SEAL and his involvement in the film's production.
- Bringing the Story to Light: Director Peter Berg's attachment to the script, his introduction to the story, and the cast's respect for the real-life heroes.
- Recreating the Firefight: Exploration of location scouting, shooting challenges, and technical details for safely recreating action sequences.
- Learning the Basics: Actors' physical and combat training, guided by real-life Navy SEALS including Marcus Luttrell.
- The Fallen Heroes of Operation Red Wings: Multi-part profiles of Michael Murphy, Matthew Axelson, Danny Dietz, and a tribute to the fallen heroes.
- The Pashtun Code of Life: Interview with Mohamad Gulab about the code of conduct used to save Marcus Luttrell.
- Previews: Additional Universal titles.
Movie: 86
Lone Survivor, directed by Peter Berg, is a profound depiction of military valor and brotherhood. Based on the true story of Operation Red Wings, the film portrays the mission's harrowing events with a gripping intensity. Mark Wahlberg, Taylor Kitsch, Ben Foster, and Emile Hirsch deliver riveting performances as the group of Navy SEALs trapped behind enemy lines in Afghanistan. The narrative isn't just about the brutality of war; it's about human connection, sacrifice, and resilience. Berg masterfully brings these themes to life, combining visceral action with an emotionally resonant core. The connection between the characters and the audience runs deep, elevating the film beyond mere gunplay into a poignant tribute to those who served.
Visually, Lone Survivor pulls no punches. Berg’s meticulous attention to detail showcases the authentic struggles and camaraderie of soldiers in combat. The action sequences are raw and unflinching, capturing every impact and near-miss with startling realism. Scenes like the characters' perilous descent down a mountain are particularly memorable, demonstrating the sheer physical toll of warfare. Despite occasional moments that verge on video game aesthetics, the film remains grounded in its portrayal of frail humanity under duress. This authenticity is bolstered by precise depictions of weapon operations and combat tactics, making it one of the most realistic war films in recent memory.
While Lone Survivor occasionally leans into patriotic sentimentality and takes some liberties with historical accuracy, these elements seldom detract from its overall impact. The film’s strength lies in its balance of relentless action and heartfelt character development. The early scenes at the Navy base provide crucial context for the soldiers' deep bonds, enhancing the emotional weight of their subsequent ordeal. Though its treatment of war’s complexities might lack depth, Lone Survivor excels as a visceral and moving ode to heroism, rendering a powerful salute to those who laid down their lives.
Total: 72
Peter Berg's "Lone Survivor" delivers an intense and emotive portrayal of modern warfare. The film, based on true events, is an unflinchingly realistic depiction of a Navy SEAL mission gone awry. Despite the foreknown outcome, the narrative maintains relentless tension, capturing the audience with its authentic battlefield immersion. More than just a war film, "Lone Survivor" delves into themes of sacrifice and camaraderie, paying respectful homage to fallen heroes. Its brutal honesty and emotional depth are reminiscent of classics like "Saving Private Ryan" and "Platoon," marking it as a defining film of its era.
Universal's Blu-ray release of "Lone Survivor" is technically outstanding. The video presentation is visually stunning, offering sharp detail and vivid colors that bring the rugged settings to life. Equally impressive is the audio, which provides a fully immersive experience, capturing the chaos and intensity of combat with precision. Although the supplementary features are limited in number, the included featurettes are commendable, offering valuable insights into both the filmmaking and the harrowing real-life story behind it.
In conclusion, "Lone Survivor" stands as one of the most emotionally charged films in recent memory. Despite any minor criticisms regarding its somewhat simplistic patriotism, the movie's core essence and greater purpose shine through, giving profound meaning to the sacrifices depicted. Universal's Blu-ray release enhances this impactful experience with superior technical quality, making it an essential addition to any collection. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
While it doesn't display the same sort of organic feel as film, it comes very close thanks to the richness in clarity and precision detail with which it captures the largest and smallest textures alike....
Audio: 100
During the extended firefight, the stage springs to terrifyingly intense life as bullets fly all through the listening area, impacting both flesh and rocky surfaces with regularity....
Extras: 60
A look at the importance of the actors' physical and combat training for the film and the contributions of real life Navy SEALS, including Marcus Luttrell, to that training....
Movie: 100
Marcus' end-film voiceover in which he speaks of his figurative death on the mountain embodies the entire film, carries its message both within the story and through the audience, elevates it beyond mere...
Total: 90
Even as the title gives away the ending, the film's unrelenting tension and the uncanny manner in which it immerses the audience in the battlefield cannot be understated, nor can the much deeper and more...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
There are also a few moments where the picture exhibits an overly digital, smooth look in motion, but this effect is likely inherent to the shooting methods....
Audio: 80
And once bullets start to blaze, the audio kicks into high gear, becoming a relentless barrage of action that still maintains a delicate layer of balance and design....
Extras: 0
The Fallen Heroes of Operation Red Wings (HD, 16 min) – Presented in four parts viewable separately or together, these are profiles on the real life Michael Murphy, Matthew Axelson, and Danny Dietz that...
Movie: 80
Though some of the movie's inspirational aspects can be a little forced and simplistic, a solid focus on character and an absolutely gut-wrenching depiction of war-time battle helps to even out these occasional...
Total: 60
Despite some minor flaws, the movie is a gripping and inspiring piece of filmmaking, and this disc from Universal features a fantastic technical presentation....
Director: Peter Berg
Actors: Mark Wahlberg, Taylor Kitsch, Emile Hirsch
PlotIn June 2005, a four-man SEAL team is tasked with a covert mission, codenamed Operation Red Wings, aimed at locating and eliminating a high-ranking Taliban leader named Ahmad Shah in the mountainous region of Afghanistan. The team, led by Lieutenant Michael Murphy, includes sniper Marcus Luttrell, gunner’s mate Danny Dietz, and sonar technician Matthew 'Axe' Axelson. After being inserted into the Hindu Kush mountains, the SEALs establish an observation post to keep watch on a village where Shah is believed to be hiding.
As the mission progresses, the team's position is compromised when they inadvertently encounter local goat herders. The SEALs face a difficult moral decision: release the herders and risk the operation being disclosed, or eliminate the potential threat in order to ensure the mission's success and their own safety. Choosing to adhere to the rules of engagement, the team sets the herders free. Shortly afterwards, the SEALs find themselves surrounded and outnumbered by Shah's forces. A fierce and relentless battle ensues as they struggle to survive against overwhelming odds, calling on their training, brotherhood, and sheer determination.
Writers: Peter Berg, Marcus Luttrell, Patrick Robinson
Release Date: 10 Jan 2014
Runtime: 121 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, United Kingdom
Language: English, Pashtu, Arabic