Winter in Wartime Blu-ray Review
Oorlogswinter
Score: 63
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Winter in Wartime's Blu-ray boasts superb audio and video quality, though lacks special features, delivering a compelling and emotional WWII coming-of-age tale.
Disc Release Date
Video: 73
This 1080p Blu-ray presentation of 'Winter in Wartime' impresses with its high bitrate encoding, delivering superlative image resolution with detailed textures and a gentle layer of grain. The color palette is deliberately subdued, enhancing the solemn atmosphere, despite some minor issues with sharpness and contrast consistency.
Audio: 68
Winter in Wartime's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track delivers sparkling clarity and enriching detail, with impressive dialogue transparency and first-rate sound effects reproduction. The front soundstage is spacious, featuring natural ambiance and potent gunfire. Dynamic range and low-frequency effects add depth, creating an engaging and balanced audio experience.
Extra: 26
The Blu-ray of 'Winter in Wartime' includes a 24-minute making-of featurette in SD with English subtitles, focusing on interviews and behind-the-scenes footage, an HD theatrical trailer, additional previews, BD-Live capabilities, and a bonus DVD, yet the extras lack memorability.
Movie: 80
"Winter in Wartime's Blu-ray release excels with a compelling, character-driven narrative set against a meticulously crafted wartime backdrop. It juxtaposes childhood innocence with the brutal realities of war, driven by exceptional performances and flawless direction, making a lasting emotional impact."
Video: 73
The video presentation of "Winter in Wartime" is a commendable high-definition transfer that maintains exceptional transparency and integrity. Encoded at a high bitrate in 1080p/AVC MPEG-4, it delivers a striking level of image resolution with consistency. The color palette is meticulously chosen to serve the narrative, with predominant shades of black, gray, white, brown, and blue contributing to a cooler and somber ambiance. Close-up shots reveal intricate details, such as facial pores, stubble, and the texture of materials, lending a tactile quality to objects within the frame. The encoding ensures stability in black levels and contrast, allowing for strong visible detail even in darker scenes. Additionally, the video is free from any discernible artifacts or other visual distractions.
Throughout the film, Sony's first-rate transfer manages to capture the inherent natural depth and filmic quality of the source material. A gentle layer of grain persists uniformly across scenes, enriching the fine detailing of snowy landscapes and textured clothing. The deliberate choice of an understated color scheme reinforces the wintry and bleak atmosphere, while the pristine whites of snow and the profound blacks substantiate the setting's oppressive desolation. This transfer displays a crisp contrast ratio, enhancing the visual sharpness. However, there are isolated scenes where the sharpness slightly fluctuates.
The overall visual execution is laudable, preserving the delicate nuances and primary tones with ease. Although the high-contrast backgrounds occasionally reveal slight ringing around darker objects, the image quality remains largely unaffected. Shadow delineation is primarily excellent but loses some consistency in a few segments. Despite these minor imperfections, "Winter in Wartime" offers an impressive and largely impeccable visual experience that comprehensively complements its thematic and narrative essence.
Audio: 68
The audio presentation of the "Winter in Wartime" Blu-ray features a stunning DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless track that excels in both dynamic range and detailed reproduction. Dialogue is clear and transparent, ensuring that every tonal inflection is captured with precision. The front soundstage is richly layered, brimming with sonic detail that emphasizes the strengths of the source material. A standout moment includes the rumbling and nuanced sensation as a low-flying aircraft crashes, demonstrating excellent spatial accuracy and depth. The mix superbly balances ambient soundscapes, from natural woodland to manmade town environments, seamlessly integrating them.
Low-frequency effects are handled with impressive weight and punchy response, adding robust depth to music and action sequences. The surround channels contribute effectively to atmospheric presence, offering discernible discrete audio cues that enhance the immersive experience. Gunfire is portrayed with accuracy and potency, while music, even when intended to sound degraded through an old radio, maintains crispness and authenticity. Each element from mid-range action to subtle background noises is captured with succinct sharpness, creating a first-class master audio presentation.
The surrounds deliver appreciable instances of immersion, with sound effects panning flawlessly across the listening area, adding to the overall enjoyment of the lossless mix. Vocal prioritization remains impeccable throughout, rendering Michiel's emotional journey with exceptional clarity and warmth. The audio mix showcases a perfectly balanced output whether dealing with heightened activity or soft nuances, making "Winter in Wartime" a remarkable example of superior sound design in film.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray of "Winter in Wartime" offers a satisfactory though limited selection of extras, showcasing key insights into the film’s production. The primary extra, "The Making of Winter in Wartime," provides a comprehensive 24-minute exploration into the film's development, style, and cast performances, presented in Dutch with English subtitles. This featurette includes behind-the-scenes footage and interviews with the cast and crew. Additionally, the disc offers a high-definition theatrical trailer and BD-Live functionality for accessing more content. Despite their quality, these supplements are somewhat minimal and do not significantly enhance the overall viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of Winter in Wartime: Dutch-language featurette with BTS footage and interviews.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer in high-definition.
- Previews: Trailers for other Sony titles.
- BD-Live: Online content access.
- Bonus DVD: Additional copy of the film.
Movie: 80
"Winter in Wartime," directed by Martin Koolhoven and based on Jan Terlouw's bestselling novel, is a meticulously crafted wartime drama set in Nazi-occupied Holland during the harsh winter of 1945. The film centers around thirteen-year-old Michiel (Martijn Lakemeier), who inadvertently becomes entangled in the Dutch Resistance after aiding a wounded British paratrooper. This coming-of-age tale delves deeply into themes of courage, sacrifice, and moral ambiguity, portraying Michiel's accelerated loss of innocence as he navigates the treacherous landscape of wartime Europe. The narrative compellingly explores his internal struggles and external challenges, making it a universal story that transcends its historical setting.
The film's strength lies in its character-driven storytelling and attention to detail. Koolhoven adeptly immerses viewers in the stark, cold environment of 1945 Holland, creating a palpably tense atmosphere. The performances are notably excellent, with Lakemeier delivering a nuanced portrayal of Michiel's transformation from naïve boy to reluctant hero. His on-screen chemistry with Yorick van Wageningen, who plays his uncle Ben, adds layers of complexity to the film. Waggeningen’s dedicated resistance fighter presents a sharp contrast to Michiel's father, a town mayor torn between maintaining order and defying the occupiers. This dynamic forms the crux of Michiel's moral dilemma, propelling his journey towards maturity.
"Winter in Wartime" masterfully balances dramatic tension with moments of quiet introspection, maintaining focus on Michiel's personal growth amidst the chaos of war. The film eschews grandiose action sequences for more subdued but equally intense psychological and emotional conflicts. Scenes such as Michiel learning to shave under his father's guidance underscore essential life lessons about bravery and empathy. The result is a richly layered narrative that resonates on multiple levels, offering insights into human resilience and the complex nature of heroism during one of history’s darkest periods.
Total: 63
"Winter in Wartime," directed by Martin Koolhoven, stands out as an evocative coming-of-age tale set against the harsh backdrop of the last winter of World War II. The narrative adeptly explores complex themes of bravery and courage through the protagonist's journey, challenging traditional heroic fantasies. The Blu-ray release of this film, while lacking an extensive selection of special features, still commands high praise for its technical excellence. Sony's presentation is characterized by superb video clarity and robust audio that vividly brings the story to life.
The Blu-ray's technical performance does not disappoint, showcasing Sony’s commitment to delivering high-quality releases. Viewers can expect pristine, high-definition visuals that capture the film's wintry landscapes with remarkable detail, enhancing the atmospheric tension built by Koolhoven's direction. The audio presentation complements the visuals perfectly, providing a dynamic and immersive soundscape that heightens the emotional and dramatic beats of the narrative. Although the absence of a more comprehensive supplemental package is a notable downside, it does not overshadow the overall strength of the core film and the quality of its transfer.
In conclusion, "Winter in Wartime" achieves a rare balance of being both touching and uplifting despite its somber setting. The near-faultless craftsmanship, compelling storytelling, and exceptional performances contribute to its global acclaim. Despite the minimal extras, this Blu-ray release comes highly recommended for both its technical prowess and the profound cinematic experience it offers. It's a compelling addition for fans and a significant standalone title for others drawn to high-caliber war dramas.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Colors are deliberately understated and wintertime bleak; the image is overwhelmingly defined by shades of gray and blue, which reinforce both the setting and the themes that define the story....
Audio: 90
Between the sharp zoom, the inherently heavy elements of the crash, the accuracy with which the sound traverses the listening area, and the superb sense of actually being there, this is a demo-worthy clip....
Extras: 20
The Making of Winter in Wartime (480p, 24:24): This Dutch-language (with English subtitles) supplement looks at the project's history, the picture's themes, the work of the cast, the picture's unique style,...
Movie: 90
Young Michiel van Beusekom (Martijn Lakemeier) is a wide-eyed boy who's grasped the severity of the situation into which his life has been thrust, but only when he must become directly involved in life...
Total: 70
Winter in Wartime is a high quality motion picture that transcends its setting and surrounding elements and creates a universal picture about the loss of innocence but the need to retain it in a world...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The photography is intentionally drained of color, creating a solemn atmosphere, but primaries come through boldly and accurately....
Audio: 80
Rears also offer some appreciable instances of immersion as sounds pan flawlessly from one speaker to the next, creating a highly enjoyable lossless mix....
Extras: 0
The Making of Winter in Wartime (SD, 24 min) — With English subtitles and lots of BTS footage throughout, the piece is mostly made of cast & crew interviews talking about the plot, acting and production....
Movie: 80
One of the most touching sequences in the film is seeing Michiel being taught how to shave by his father, in effect being trained how to handle an open-blade straight razor — a dangerous weapon when wielded...
Total: 60
It's a touching and tragic film about a boy learning the complexities of bravery and courage, ones which challenge his previous heroic fantasies....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
The texture on the surfaces of objects is just as defining which gives them visibly apparent structure and tangible quality....
Audio: 84
Imaging and sound effects reproduction are first rate as the sound field in the front of the room bristles with sonic detail....
Extras: 40
The making of Winter in wartime - 24 minute featurette (HD) Theatrical trailer BD-Live enabled Bonus DVD of Winter in wartime...
Movie: 80
Wartime's harsh reality encroaches on childhood innocence as Michiel confronts good and evil, courage and duplicity, and his own burden of responsibility....
Total: 74
THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Martin Koolhoven
Actors: Martijn Lakemeier, Jamie Campbell Bower, Yorick van Wageningen
PlotIn the midst of World War II, a Dutch village is occupied by German forces. A young boy named Michiel is fiercely rebellious against the occupation, feeling constrained by his father's seemingly passive stance. As winter sets in, Michiel discovers an injured British airman named Jack hiding in the woods. Sworn to secrecy and driven by a sense of adventure and justice, Michiel decides to assist Jack, providing him with food, shelter, and medicine despite the immense risks involved. His acts of defiance inadvertently draw the attention of both the Nazis and his fellow villagers, some of whom are sympathetic to the German occupiers.
As Michiel delves deeper into the resistance efforts, he becomes entangled in a web of espionage, betrayal, and moral ambiguity. His relationships with his family and friends are strained as he navigates the treacherous terrain of war and loyalty. With the arrival of harsher conditions and increased German scrutiny, Michiel confronts the stark realities of heroism and survival, realizing that his actions have far-reaching consequences. The narrative builds a gripping tension as Michiel balances the innocence of youth with the grave responsibilities thrust upon him by the ravages of war.
Writers: Martin Koolhoven, Paul Jan Nelissen, Jan Terlouw
Release Date: 27 Nov 2008
Runtime: 103 min
Rating: R
Country: Netherlands, Belgium
Language: Dutch, English, German