Seven Samurai Blu-ray Review
DigiPack 七人の侍 Shichinin no Samurai
Score: 73
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Criterion's Blu-ray of "Seven Samurai" offers the film's best A/V presentation to date and includes top-tier supplemental features—a must for serious film enthusiasts.
Disc Release Date
Video: 66
Criterion's 1080p AVC MPEG-4 (1.33:1) Blu-ray presentation of 'Seven Samurai' showcases notable restoration achievements for its 60-year-old source, with exceptional detail, rich black levels, and stable contrast in a 2K digital transfer; however, inherent issues like minor scratches, flicker, and edge enhancement persist, reflecting the limitations of the original materials.
Audio: 61
The Criterion Blu-ray of 'Seven Samurai' offers two Japanese LPCM tracks – a 1.0 Mono and a 2.0 Stereo mix – both remastered to reduce noise and imperfections. While minor hiss, occasional shrillness, and slight inconsistencies in dynamics reflect the film's age, Fumio Hayasaka’s score shines through, providing a robust and authentic audio experience.
Extra: 92
The Criterion release of 'Seven Samurai' stands out not only for its exceptional video and audio quality, but also for its comprehensive extras, including dual audio commentaries featuring film scholars and experts, enriching documentaries, engaging interviews, vintage trailers, insightful photo galleries, and a detailed 60-page booklet.
Movie: 98
Criterion’s Blu-ray of 'Seven Samurai,' presenting the uncut 207-minute version, is an extraordinary release, impeccably remastered with pristine visuals and sound, extensive interviews, documentaries, and a 60-page booklet, making this timeless masterpiece of action, character depth and socio-political commentary an indispensable addition to any film collection.
Video: 66
Criterion's Blu-ray presentation of Akira Kurosawa's "Seven Samurai" triumphantly showcases the best visual restoration possible for a film over sixty years old. The original negative being unavailable, Criterion used the original fine-grain master positive to create a duplicate negative through wetgate processing. This high-definition transfer, crafted in 2K resolution on a Spirit Datacine, presents the film in its theatrical 1.33:1 aspect ratio. Despite the inherent age-related imperfections, Criterion utilized an array of digital tools such as da Vinci’s Revival, Discreet Fire, and Digital Vision's ASCIII to reduce flicker, instability, dirt, scratches, and manage grain, successfully delivering an impressively balanced monochromatic presentation. Contrast and black levels are exceptionally rendered, making daylight scenes notably crisp, while the sophisticated detail maintains fidelity in both extensive shots and close-ups.
However, the Blu-ray disc's video quality, encoded with MPEG-4 AVC at 1080p, does have its nuanced issues. While clarity and contrast are commendable—providing fresh visuals with well-balanced grayscale—the consistency varies. Minor and sporadic flickers persist along with occasional frame transition issues. Despite Criterion's effort to suppress edge-enhancement and macroblocking, viewers may notice the subtle presence of dirt and scratches due to source limitations. Mild ringing and background noise do surface occasionally but are not overly intrusive. Criterion applied specific noise reduction strategies while keeping the film's innate grain structure intact, though there are moments where detail levels fluctuate mid-shot causing slight distraction. Despite these manageable imperfections, this restoration conveys the finest home media version of "Seven Samurai" to date. Thus, Criterion’s meticulous efforts merit recognition for presenting this cinematic gem in its best visual form amidst inevitable age-related concessions.
Audio: 61
Criterion's Blu-ray presentation of "Seven Samurai" includes two distinct Japanese audio tracks: a Linear PCM 1.0 Mono track and a Linear PCM 2.0 track, despite the packaging incorrectly mentioning a DTS-HD track. The LPCM 1.0 track has been mastered at 24-bit from an optical soundtrack print, providing an authentic, albeit historically limited, sound experience. The LPCM 2.0 mix was created using original optical track recordings, music masters, and production sound effects masters, offering a more immersive stereo experience that some may find preferable.
Both tracks have undergone significant restoration to remove clicks, thumps, hiss, and hum using Pro Tools HD, with crackle attenuated via Audio Cube’s integrated workstation. This meticulous process results in an impressively clean audio environment where dialogues remain coherent and stable, even if occasionally buried beneath other sound elements. The LPCM 2.0 track provides slight advantages in dynamics and surround separation, enhancing the prominence of Fumio Hayasaka’s memorable score and atmospheric elements like rain and wind. However, purists may still lean towards the original mono offering for its authenticity, despite some inherent shrillness due to the film’s age.
Despite the thorough audio restoration leading to a cleaner and clearer soundtrack, some age-related artifacts like minor background hiss and occasional harshness remain. The dynamic range allows Hayasaka's legendary score to shine through with rich highs and lows, while dialogues are generally pleasingly stable and discernible. Overall, Criterion’s audio treatment enhances the film’s historical soundscape, marking this release as the best audio presentation "Seven Samurai" has ever had. The optional English subtitles are accurate and support comprehension without detracting from the experience.
Extras: 92
The Blu-ray extras for "Seven Samurai" are a comprehensive and scholarly accompaniment to this cinematic masterpiece. Criterion has curated a substantial collection including two full-length audio commentaries, four documentaries, four trailers, and two galleries. The audio commentaries from various film scholars and critics provide deep historical and thematic insight, while Michael Jeck’s solo commentary is rich in detail about Japanese cinema. The documentaries are equally compelling, with "Akira Kurosawa – It Is Wonderful to Create" offering behind-the-scenes insights from Kurosawa’s collaborators, and "Seven Samurai: Origins and Influences" exploring the historical and cultural impact of samurai in Japanese cinema. "My Life in Cinema: Akira Kurosawa" provides an intimate look into Kurosawa's life and career through a conversation with Nagisa Oshima. Completing the package are vintage trailers and extensive photo galleries, making it an invaluable resource for enthusiasts and scholars alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Scholars' Roundtable: Commentary by Desser, Mellen, Prince, Rayns, and Richie.
- Michael Jeck Commentary: Insightful details on Japanese cinema.
- Akira Kurosawa - It Is Wonderful to Create: A making-of documentary.
- My Life in Cinema: Akira Kurosawa: Lengthy interview with Kurosawa.
- Seven Samurai: Origins and Influences: Documentary on samurai's cultural impact.
- Trailers and Teaser: Original and silent trailers.
- Behind the Scenes Gallery: Collection of black-and-white photos.
- Poster Gallery: Various international poster designs.
- Booklet: 60-page illustrated booklet with essays and reflections.
Movie: 98
Seven Samurai, directed by Akira Kurosawa, stands as one of the most influential films in cinematic history, epitomizing the action/adventure genre with a deep focus on character development. This legendary film, centered on masterless samurai defending a village from bandits, introduces an ensemble of richly crafted characters whose motivations and backgrounds resonate deeply with audiences. The characters' genuine emotional dynamics and the compelling socio-political themes interwoven within the narrative elevate the film beyond mere action. The portrayal of nature as both an adversarial and defining force is poignant, crafting a realistic atmosphere where human resilience is tested against the impersonal cruelty of the elements and societal inequities.
Cinematographically, Seven Samurai remains groundbreaking, employing innovative techniques such as dynamic camera movements and slow motion to enhance storytelling. The 207-minute runtime is a testament to Kurosawa's dedication to detailed character arcs and immersive world-building, offering a narrative complexity rarely matched by subsequent films of the genre. Each samurai, from Takashi Shimura’s dignified Kambei to Toshiro Mifune’s brash Kikuchiyo, is expertly acted, reflecting a profound connection to their roles. These performances, coupled with Kurosawa's meticulous direction, ensure the film’s enduring impact on filmmaking worldwide.
Criterion's Blu-ray release of Seven Samurai does justice to this masterpiece with a stunning visual and audio restoration. The enhanced clarity and balanced soundscape amplify the viewing experience, presenting the film in its most pristine form yet. Complementing the film is a rich array of supplemental features, including insightful commentaries and documentaries that provide deeper context and appreciation for Kurosawa's work. The inclusion of a 60-page booklet with essays from prominent critics and directors further enriches the set, making it indispensable for collectors and new audiences alike. Criterion’s dedication ensures that this timeless classic continues to inspire and captivate.
Total: 73
Criterion's Blu-ray release of Akira Kurosawa's "Seven Samurai" is a monumental achievement in film restoration. The meticulous efforts clearly shine through, delivering what is arguably the finest presentation of this landmark film to date. This edition not only surpasses the already impressive 3-disc DVD version but also sets a new benchmark for high-definition cinema releases. The supplemental features are extensive and well-curated, offering deep dives into the film's production and Kurosawa's visionary direction. This Blu-ray is a treasure trove for cinephiles, packed with historical context, interviews, and critical essays.
"Seven Samurai" is timeless, continuously revered as one of the greatest films ever made. Criterion’s high-def upgrade enhances the experience significantly with crystal-clear visuals and improved audio, making it a crucial addition to any serious film collector's library. While the technical elements may not be flawless, they represent a significant improvement over previous versions. This Blu-ray encapsulates the enduring brilliance of Kurosawa's masterpiece, ensuring that it remains accessible and engaging for contemporary audiences.
In conclusion, Criterion's Blu-ray release of "Seven Samurai" is an unmissable opportunity to experience one of cinema’s most enduring classics in its best form yet. The visual and auditory enhancements elevate the film to new heights, while the comprehensive extras enrich the viewing experience with invaluable insights. Highly recommended for both long-time admirers and new viewers alike, this release ensures the legacy of Kurosawa's "Seven Samurai" continues to inspire and captivate generations.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 80
Honestly, Seven Samurai has never looked this good, and with a decent layer of perfectly-suitable grain to round off the proceedings, this remains yet another indisputably excellent video presentation...
Audio: 80
Choosing between the two tracks is largely personal preference – some may want the more natural, original mono offering, which is a solid, authentic offering; whilst others will not mind the mildly tinkered-with...
Extras: 100
As such, it is of immense interest to any fans of the man and his work, a quality, fittingly substantial addition (again completely in Japanese with English subtitles).GalleriesThere are two galleries...
Movie: 100
And with a plethora of worthy extras, many of which feature extensive footage and interview contribution from the legend behind the movie, Kurosawa himself, this set is a must-have for all film collections....
Total: 90
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 90
A lot of work has gone into the restoration of Seven Samurai, and it definitely shows - a lot of the daylight scenes, for instance, look quite remarkable; clarity and contrast levels are without a doubt...
Audio: 90
There are some marginal advantages pertaining to low and mid range dynamics, specifically with the woodwinds, but I prefer the more organic spectrum of dynamics the LPCM 1.0 track houses....
Extras: 100
Seven Samurai: Origins and Influences - a very good documentary, recorded exclusively for Criterion, focusing on the important role the samurai occupy in Japanese history, art, and cinema....
Movie: 100
The way they carry themselves suggests otherwise, but the longer Kurosawa's camera follows them, the easier it is to see that like the villagers they are men who have struggled a lot (in fact, Kikuchiyo,...
Total: 100
Not only is this the best presentation of Seven Samurai I have ever seen, but the supplemental features included with it are also of the highest caliber....
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 100
Audio: 80
The main audio IS Japanese LPCM mono, but the optional Japanese 2.0 surround mix is LPCM as well – not DTS-HD....
Extras: 95
Movie: 100
With its classic story, archetypal characters, abundant action and powerful human drama, this is the one film that every reader of The Digital Bits owes it to himself or herself to see....
Total: 94
Criterion’s previous 3-disc DVD was already a triumph for Kurosawa fans and admirers, but this Blu-ray enhances it further by way of the film’s best A/V presentation to date....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
If it weren't for the random dullness mid-shot, this would have been a pretty great release, regardless of the fine sprinkling of dirt and debris that remains....
Audio: 60
The liner notes of this release detail the process and work done to the sound elements, but even with the added attention, this film doesn't sound amazing, and chances are, it never will....
Extras: 80
We learn of the screenwriting process, abandoned scenes, scoring the film, the themes of the seven lead characters, visit the Akira Kurosawa Memorial Hall (with its damn nice collection), and finally the...
Movie: 100
However, with each passing year, there is a new breed of budding cinema fanatics that may not have heard about this particular film, its impact, and place in history....
Total: 80
New films may come and go and capture the minds and hearts of the people, but on pure execution, story strength, acting and direction, few films can even enter the same stratosphere as the Samurai classic...
Director: Akira Kurosawa
Actors: Toshirô Mifune, Takashi Shimura, Keiko Tsushima
PlotIn 16th century war-torn Japan, a small, beleaguered village of farmers anticipates a brutal attack by a gang of ruthless bandits who have previously ransacked their harvests. Desperate and helpless, the villagers seek the guidance of the village elder, who advises them to hire samurai to defend their home. With limited resources, the villagers manage to recruit seven disparate and sympathetic samurai, each brought together by their own reasons and personal honor. Among the samurai, the compassionate leader Kambei takes charge, while the brash, exuberant Kikuchiyo adds a complex dynamic with his unpredictable behavior.
Together, the seven samurai train the villagers in self-defense and prepare elaborate strategies to confront the impending invasion. The farmers learn to overcome their fears and weaknesses, gradually gaining confidence under the tutelage of their skilled protectors. The bond between the villagers and the samurai strengthens as they fortify their positions and brace for the inevitable clash with the marauding bandits. The tension builds as the villagers, once passive and downtrodden, turn their fears into gritty determination, facing an uncertain and formidable battle that will test their resolve, unity, and survival.
Writers: Akira Kurosawa, Shinobu Hashimoto, Hideo Oguni
Release Date: 19 Nov 1956
Runtime: 207 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese