The Sheik Blu-ray Review
Paramount Presents #25
Score: 60
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
Paramount's Blu-ray of 'The Sheik' offers an impressive restoration of a historic silent film, enhancing both its cinematic legacy and its presentation.
Disc Release Date
Video: 67
The Blu-ray presentation of 'The Sheik' employs a 4K restoration, using modern technology to preserve this silent film's original charm. Despite visible wear and frame inconsistencies due to aged elements, it showcases impressive clarity in a 1.33:1 aspect ratio with digitally applied tints, capturing vintage beauty.
Audio: 72
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Sheik" features Roger Bellon's 1996 score in 2.0 Dolby TrueHD, offering crisp, clear orchestral details with synth undertones. While the soundstage is centered, clarity remains high, capturing musical nuances and creating a dramatic yet gentle atmosphere, enhancing the silent film experience.
Extra: 26
Paramount's 'The Sheik' Blu-ray boasts collectible packaging and a single compelling featurette, 'Desert Heat: 100 Years with The Sheik', detailing Valentino's legacy and the film's cultural impact. However, it lacks the robust extras of prior editions, making it less appealing for hardcore fans seeking comprehensive content.
Movie: 63
Paramount's meticulous restoration of 'The Sheik' on Blu-ray preserves its historical significance as a pioneering silent film, showcasing Rudolph Valentino's iconic appeal in a quintessential desert romance. Despite dated gender politics, it remains a valuable cinematic artifact with impressive sets and a new Dolby TrueHD score.
Video: 67
The Blu-ray release of "The Sheik" is a testament to Paramount's meticulous restoration efforts, showcasing the film in its original 1.33:1 aspect ratio via a new HD transfer. Utilizing a combination of a print and a fine grain intermediate element, the restoration preserves the film's historical integrity. Paramount's thorough global search for the best existing elements allowed for improved image quality, revealing a faithful presentation of film grain and fine details. While scratches and signs of wear are still apparent, this is largely due to the absence of the original negatives, and the variances are inevitable given the multiple elements used. Adjustments during the digital restoration process, including tackling stretch printing to maintain a standard 24fps and applying color tints guided by original continuity scripts, result in commendable overall depth and texture stability.
Despite its age and the evident wear, "The Sheik" maintains impressive visual clarity with deftly captured textures that highlight intricate details in costumes and set designs. The film balances respectable definition and consistent, albeit aged, black levels. Paramount has adeptly applied digital tints to create a charming vintage sepia tone, with occasional lavender hues, culminating in a consistent color reproduction that bolsters the nostalgic viewing experience. Facial textures and character expressions remain strikingly detailed, offering sharp focus across various shot distances, all without significant motion distortions or artifacts.
Overall, while falling short of modern A-grade standards due to inherent limitations of century-old sources, Paramount has delivered an admirable restoration effort, arguably presenting "The Sheik" in its best possible light on home video. This edition outshines previous iterations, despite not including the film's longest cut as issued by other labels earlier.
Audio: 72
The Blu-ray release of "The Sheik" provides an engaging audio experience with a newly composed music score by Roger Bellon, delivered in Dolby TrueHD 2.0 lossless audio. This track effectively maintains high clarity and definition, allowing listeners to appreciate the fine orchestral details without experiencing distortion issues such as crackling or hissing. The soundstage, while not particularly expansive, is primarily centered, favoring a gentle and less dynamic approach that complements the film’s visual storytelling. Effective at setting dramatic and sometimes playful moods, Bellon's score sensitively intertwines with the on-screen action, offering fans a unique alternative to previous releases.
In terms of technical presentation, the Dolby TrueHD 2.0 format enhances the auditory details, ensuring that each instrumental element is faithfully reproduced. The stereo imaging remains tightly focused but does not shy away from delivering a full-bodied audio experience, rich with low tones that imbue the score with an all-encompassing ambiance. The absence of traditional dialogue and height channels is replaced by Bellon's creative liberties in musical composition, often blending traditional instrumentation with synthesizer undertones to underscore the silent film’s emotional and narrative arcs.
Overall, this release is a compelling choice for fans of silent cinema music, enhancing "The Sheik" with Roger Bellon’s lush instrumental score. The inclusion of optional French subtitles for title cards further complements the accessible presentation of this classic film, making it an enjoyable auditory experience for diverse audiences.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray release of "The Sheik" is a part of the distinguished Paramount Presents line, marking its 25th entry. It includes a collectible slipcover with fold-out original poster artwork, alongside an inner print showcasing pivotal scenes from the film. While this edition is visually appealing, it features only a single extra: the featurette "Desert Heat: 100 Years with 'The Sheik.'" This 12-minute segment in HD, with available English and French subtitles, is led by film historian Professor Leslie Midkiff DeBauche. It delves into Rudolph Valentino's enduring legacy and the film's cultural impact, yet lacks the additional features found on other releases like Kino Lorber's 2017 edition, notably omitting commentary tracks and archival footage such as Valentino’s funeral.
Extras included in this disc:
- Desert Heat: 100 Years with 'The Sheik': Professor Leslie Midkiff DeBauche discusses the film's influence, Rudolph Valentino's career, and adaptation from a romance novel.
Movie: 63
"The Sheik," a landmark silent film from 1921 starring Rudolph Valentino, remains an engaging historical piece that showcases the early allure of cinema. Directed by George Melford and based on Edith Maude Hull's bestselling novel, the film presents a classic 'desert romance' with Valentino as the charming Arabian sheik Ahmed Ben Hassan. The captivating dynamics between the sheik and the fiercely independent Englishwoman, Lady Diana Mayo, played by Agnes Ayres, form the backbone of this narrative. The restoration to Blu-ray under Paramount's 'Paramount Presents' line includes a new score by Roger Bellon, captured in Dolby TrueHD 2.0, enhancing the viewing experience and providing an immersive, auditory journey back to the silver screen's early days.
The film's allure lies not just in its storied plot but in its contribution to Valentino’s iconic status as one of Hollywood’s first true sex symbols. Despite its quaint romance and dated gender politics, "The Sheik" captures Valentino's magnetic presence and charisma, propelling him to stardom akin to a modern-day cultural sensation. The production exemplifies the era's grand scale, with impressive sets and lively performances that demand expressiveness due to the silent film format. Throughout the narrative, familiar themes of cross-cultural romance and adventure unfold, capturing audiences with a tale as timeless as it is influential.
While "The Sheik" may not hold the same entertainment value for today’s casual viewers due to its vintage mores and simplistic plot, its historical significance and pioneering spirit remain undisputed. This film underscores how cinema has evolved while honoring its roots through a meticulously crafted restoration, ensuring it continues to captivate new generations of viewers appreciating film history's journey.
Total: 60
"The Sheik" on Blu-ray presents a pivotal silent film that immortalized Rudolph Valentino as a cinematic icon. Paramount’s release provides viewers with a commendable restoration, capturing the essence of this 100-year-old classic. The HD transfer is robust, offering visuals that respect the film's vintage charm while enhancing its quality for modern audiences. Accompanied by a new musical score, which, though open for debate, complements the viewing experience. The included 12-minute retrospective, however, feels sparse for such an influential piece of cinema history.
This release of "The Sheik" marks a significant entry into the Paramount Presents label, being the oldest film featured. Despite its limited additional features, those passionate about the era will find the Blu-ray’s restoration and essay a valuable resource. The film itself serves as both a historical marvel and a cultural artifact, reminding viewers of Valentino’s once-shimmering star before its untimely dimming. Though some might miss more comprehensive special features, the sheer integrity of the restoration makes this edition a worthwhile investment.
In conclusion, "The Sheik" may not align with the expectations of contemporary filmgoers seeking modern pacing and production. Nevertheless, Paramount’s Blu-ray offers an exceptional preservation of cinematic history. The allure of Valentino’s performance and the film's legacy continue to resonate, making it an indispensable item for collectors and enthusiasts of early Hollywood cinema. Recommended for those with a keen interest in film history and its evolution over the past century.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Viewers will appreciate the rather steadfast definition and clarity in place, the pleasing filmic veneer, wear-and-tear and all, that gives the movie a satisfyingly watchable front....
Audio: 80
Clarity is fine, revealing the fine orchestral details and individual instrumental elements with impressive definition....
Extras: 20
Desert Heat: 100 Years with 'The Sheik' (1080p, 12:21) explores the film's popularity upon release, its influence on the culture of the time, cinema's growing popularity in the timeframe in which the film...
Movie: 70
The film was previously released to Blu-ray in 2017 by Kino Lorber and included a different score track as well as a couple of supplements not available with this release....
Total: 60
The Sheik may not hold the attention of audiences accustomed to the hyper-aware pace and the bells-and-whistles-first landscape of today's cinema, but it is an important piece of Hollywood history not...
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 40
The video is certainly sharper and provides more definition than earlier releases, but the trade-off is losing small portions of the original movie....
Audio: 60
Silent film scoring is a field unto itself and Mellon takes a few creative liberties which mostly complements the action....
Extras: 40
As with all films released under the Paramount Presents banner, The Sheik is presented with collectible packaging featuring a foldout image of the film’s theatrical poster and an interior spread with key...
Movie: 60
The Sheik reminds everyone of the silver screen’s primitive beginnings with its ridiculously dated romance and hokey adventure plot....
Total: 50
The landmark silent film classic marked Rudolph Valentino’s rise as a box office star and reminds everyone how far the art of cinema and filmmaking have come in 100 years....
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 80
Film grain is presented faithfully, with fine details, gray scale and color tinted scenes rendered faithfully as well; there is a definite shift in the quality – as well as the frequency of scratches,...
Audio: 90
The music score composed by Roger Bellon for the movie in 1996 (the film’s 75th anniversary) is presented on a DolbyTrue HD track for this release....
Extras: 30
Noticeably missing here from other releases are a commentary track by Gaylyn Studlar, newsreel footage of Valentino’s funeral and a trailer for Blood and Sand (1922) from the 2017 Kino Blu-ray release...
Movie: 60
Based off of the bestselling novel by Edith Maude Hull, the film had to tone down one of the most controversial aspects of the book: the rape of Lady Diana by Sheik Ahmed; even with that scene removed...
Total: 70
Paramount has likely delivered the best Blu-ray version of the movie with a solid HD transfer and a brief new featurette on the film (you may want to hold on to the previous DVD or Blu-ray edition if you...
Why So Blu? review by Brandon PetersRead review here
Video: 90
The image does employ a bit of a scratchy, grainy image, but keeping that intact preserves the details and depth within the frame....
Audio: 80
Audio Format(s): 2.0 Dolby TrueHD (Music Only)Subtitles: FrenchDynamics: This is a silent film with no real audio track attached to the film....
Extras: 20
The Sheik in first pressing, comes with a slip cover that folds open to reveal the original poster art for the film....
Movie: 70
With years and years later, the desert would be more ground and the performances ground themselves, but this silent film still manages to capture a charm and effectiveness to hold its own with such esteemed...
Total: 80
The Sheik is a solid little silent and a very welcome addition to the Paramount Presents label as the first of its kind and the oldest one now in the canon....
Director: George Melford
Actors: Rudolph Valentino, Agnes Ayres, Ruth Miller
PlotIn the vast deserts of North Africa, an adventurous and independent Englishwoman, Lady Diana Mayo, embarks on a journey, determined to explore the exotic landscapes on her own terms. Ignoring warnings from those around her, Diana sets off into the desert, fueled by a desire for freedom and the thrill of the unknown. Her daring spirit soon draws the attention of an enigmatic and powerful Sheik, who rules over the region with authority and mystery. Intrigued by her audacity and beauty, he devises a plan to disrupt her solo escapade. During one of her excursions, Diana is unexpectedly captured by the Sheik's men and taken to his luxurious tent, where she becomes an involuntary guest in his world. Though she initially resists his forceful ways and vows to escape, Diana finds herself mesmerized by his commanding presence and the allure of his lifestyle.
As days pass in captivity, Diana's defiance gradually gives way to curiosity and an understanding of the complexities beneath the Sheik's imposing exterior. Her situation becomes more intricate as she learns about the cultural clashes and personal struggles that shape their interactions. The chemistry between them intensifies, with moments of tension opening doors to unexpected compassion and mutual respect. However, as Diana starts to unravel the layers of her captor's enigmatic personality, challenges arise that test both their spirits and resolve. Soon, both are faced with choices that defy their previous perceptions and desires. At the heart of the desert, amidst shifting sands and unyielding traditions, their destinies become inextricably entwined, leaving Diana to ponder her true desires beyond the confines of her world.
Writers: Edith Maude Hull, Monte M. Katterjohn
Release Date: 20 Nov 1921
Runtime: 86 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English