Gorky Park Blu-ray Review
Reissue
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Gorky Park: divisive critiques, talent shines, technical upgrades.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 69
Gorky Park's Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber features enhanced visuals and encoding improvements, despite using an old master, offering the best presentation yet with room for future restoration.
Audio: 69
The Blu-ray's English DTS-HD MA 2.0 audio mix is praised for its clarity, balance, and dynamic contrasts, with only cosmetic improvements possible in the future. Dialog in 'Gorky Park' is clear, complemented by a distinct sound that includes Horner's familiar score.
Extra: 26
In archival features, Michael Apted discusses Gorky Park's production challenges and themes, alongside vintage trailers and TV spots. Fans lament the absence of new commentary but appreciate the retained Apted interview and standard KLSC trailer collection.
Movie: 56
Gorky Park on Blu-ray critiques its unrealistic portrayal of Soviet life and KGB, yet its thrilling narrative and strong performances engage, despite the film's language and accuracy issues.
Video: 69
Presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 with an MPEG-4 AVC 1080p transfer, "Gorky Park" emerges on Blu-ray through the efforts of Kino Lorber, marking its high-definition initiation. This release follows its older sibling from 2014, both derived from an unchanged MGM master. Nonetheless, this edition distinguishes itself by employing correct gamma levels and utilizing a dual-layer disc for encoding, promising subtle technical refinements over its predecessor. Despite these enhancements, the source's age reveals its limitations, particularly concerning light blooming in daylight scenes and noisy grain in darker segments, slightly marred yet further by occasional nicks and blemishes. Although color stability is commendable, there's a noticeable need for improved saturation across primaries and finer nuances.
Upon closer examination, the updated release exhibits an enhanced dynamic range in certain segments, slightly elevating the visual experience on large screens, hinting at an improved density in some areas without manifesting a groundbreaking difference. This nuanced improvement provides the film with the finest technical display available to date, albeit within the constraints of the original mastering. With an undercurrent of expectation set against the potential of a future 2K or 4K restoration, one can't help but anticipate what a proper overhaul might unveil for this visually demanding title. It’s pertinent to note that accessibility is dictated by regional encoding, restricting playback to Region-A or compatible players.
Kino Lorber Studio Classics' endeavor to revisit "Gorky Park" seemingly mirrors their approach to other catalogue titles, focusing on encoding optimization and disc capacity over source upgrades. The resultant video quality represents a balance between preserving the filmic essence—ensured through respectable handling of fine textures and grain—and navigating the inherent challenges posed by the original material. While black levels and contrast largely impress with their depth, occasional deviations and slight crush hint at the limitations of the existing master. Whites maintain clarity without encroaching blooming, despite sporadic film specks that scarcely detract from the overall viewing experience. This recent iteration reaffirms a commitment to elevating the visual integrity of "Gorky Park," though within the confines of its archival constraints, leaving room for future enhancements that a comprehensive scan and HDR implementation could potentially offer.
Audio: 69
The Blu-ray release of "Gorky Park" is endowed with a solitary but solid audio track, the English DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, complemented by optional English SDH subtitles for the main feature. The lossless audio track excels in delivering crystal clear, sharp dialogue, a testament to its quality when the volume is cranked up. There's an evident care in the mix that preserves the film's auditory essence, with an interesting dynamic contrast provided by its somewhat unusual soundtrack. Despite this solidity, one could argue about the potential for improvement. However, any such enhancements would likely be superficial, given the track's current state exhibits no significant signs of degradation or lack in any critical areas. The focus on clarity and stability indicates a masterful handling of the audio elements, suggesting that future remastering efforts would mainly enhance balance and perhaps add a touch of warmth to the overall sound profile.
Within this dialogue-oriented narrative, the DTS-HD MA 2.0 mix doesn’t falter, efficiently handling the weight of dialogue interspersed with occasional action sequences. The film’s soundtrack, penned by James Horner, is reminiscent of his work from the early '80s and brings with it an additional layer of nostalgia for familiar audiences, despite its peculiar placement alongside the film's visual components. Sound effects throughout "Gorky Park" are sufficiently active and create an immersive space that complements both quiet discussions and sporadic moments of intensity well.
The audio presentation for "Gorky Park" on Blu-ray manages to marry clarity with a rich tapestry of sound effects and music, ensuring that dialogue—regardless of the variety of accents—is transmitted impeccably to the audience. While the film's nature as a predominantly dialogue-driven experience could suggest a straightforward audio track, the nuanced delivery and strategic use of James Horner’s memorable score elevates it, making this aspect of the Blu-ray a noteworthy achievement in auditory experience for this classic thriller.
Extras: 26
The Blu-Ray extras for "Gorky Park" offer a modest yet insightful collection that leans heavily on archival materials to provide context and appreciation for this cinematic adaptation. The highlight is undoubtedly the interview with director Michael Apted, offering a reflective look at the film’s production challenges, themes, and its grounding in reality, which is a precious resource for fans and new viewers alike. Despite the absence of a coveted new commentary track, the inclusion of original promotional content such as trailers and TV spots, along with a KLSC trailer gallery showcasing other films, rounds out the package. These features collectively serve to not only celebrate the film's legacy but also situate it within a broader cinematic landscape, albeit leaving enthusiasts longing for a deeper dive into its making and impact.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interview with Director Michael Apted: Archival program discussing production challenges, film themes, and realities.
- Trailer: Vintage trailer for "Gorky Park".
- Teaser Trailer: Vintage teaser for the film.
- TV Spots: A couple of spots sourced from VHS.
- KLSC Trailer Gallery: Includes trailers for "Prime Cut," "Dog Day," "F/X," "Ffolkes," "The Final Option," "Runaway Train," and "The Hunter".
Movie: 56
Michael Apted's adaptation of "Gorky Park" (1983), available on Blu-ray through Kino Lorber, encapsulates a period-piece thriller set against the bleak and complex backdrop of 1980s Soviet Russia. Despite its gripping premise, revolving around a Moscow police detective Arkady Renko's (played by William Hurt) investigation into a chilling triple homicide, the film grapples with a problematic portrayal of Soviet reality, which might detract from its authenticity for some viewers. The screenplay, criticized for its far-fetched scenarios, particularly concerning the KGB's depicted leniency towards foreign entities' involvement in a domestic murder investigation, struggles to marry its fictional narrative with the historical rigor of its setting. This discord is echoed in relationships portrayed within the story, such as Renko's interactions with Joanna Pacula’s character, which seem implausible within the tightly controlled societal norms of the time.
Notwithstanding these historical and narrative incongruences, "Gorky Park" shines through its character-driven storyline and the performances of its cast. William Hurt’s portrayal of the astute detective Renko, along with notable performances by Brian Dennehy and Lee Marvin, ground the film’s ambitious plot with a sense of urgency and depth. The film’s atmospheric setting is enriched by its on-location cinematography, depicting the starkness of Soviet life alongside its underlying tensions and intrigues. However, the lack of linguistic authenticity, opting for English spoken with Russian accents rather than employing the Russian language, can occasionally pull audiences out of the immersive experience Apted otherwise meticulously crafts.
While "Gorky Park" may falter in its fidelity to historical accuracy, it compensates with a captivating murder mystery that entwines political intrigue with human drama. Despite the screenplay’s missed opportunities to delve deeper into the complexities of Soviet governance and espionage, the film manages to maintain a compelling narrative pace. Its blending of genuine character motivations with the intricacies of a well-constructed whodunit keeps viewers engaged. The Blu-ray presentation underscores the film's cinematic qualities, though it inevitably brings to fore the challenges of adapting Martin Cruz Smith's bestselling novel to screen—a task fraught with the balancing act between creative storytelling and the portrayal of a bygone socio-political era.
Total: 59
The recent Blu-ray release of Gorky Park brings back a polarizing film that has elicited mixed feelings from its audience. On one hand, the film's interpretation of Soviet reality has been criticized for its lack of accuracy, casting a shadow over the story’s credibility and the drama it aims to portray. Despite this, the movie unites a commendable ensemble of actors who deliver performances that elevate it beyond its flawed historical context, an effort likened to the ambitious, yet historically inaccurate, productions funded by Menahem Golan and Yoram Globus for the Cannon Group. The technical quality of this reissue is noted to be marginally improved, suggesting that those with adequate home theater setups might be the ones to truly appreciate the enhancements in video and audio quality.
Conversely, for fans of thrillers and murder mysteries, Gorky Park offers a satisfyingly complex narrative delivered by director Michael Apted and anchored by a compelling early performance from William Hurt, alongside a memorable appearance by Lee Marvin. The setting in Russia provides a unique backdrop that adds depth to the plot without necessarily making it inaccessible for audiences unfamiliar with Russian culture. The Blu-ray disc itself is described as visually appealing despite some imperfections, with solid audio quality that complements the viewing experience. However, the sparse selection of bonus features leaves something to be desired, although the inclusion of an interview with Apted is recognized as a valuable addition.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray release of Gorky Park serves as a testament to the film's divisive legacy. For cinephiles and enthusiasts of the murder mystery genre, this reissue offers an opportunity to revisit or discover a film that crafts its narrative in the shadowy alleys of Cold War-era Russia, supported by strong performances and a serviceable home media presentation. Despite its historical liberties and the wish for more extensive special features, this Blu-ray edition is worth considering for those intrigued by its blend of thriller elements and character-driven storytelling.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 70
For example, in most footage where daylight is present, highlights produce light blooming that impacts the perception of depth....
Audio: 90
The current lossless track does not reveal any signs of aging, in any of its registers, so any future improvements will likely address balance and the roundness/fullness of the audio....
Extras: 40
Interview with Director Michael Apted - in this archival program, Michael Apted recalls some of the obstacles that had to be overcome before and during the production of Gorky Park, and addresses some...
Movie: 40
Consider this: The KGB had a massive network of spies that monitored all activities by all Soviet citizens and international visitors, and because its leadership and top Party figures were so paranoid,...
Total: 50
It unites several very talented actors that make it appear like a legitimately ambitious project, but the truth is that it is not any better than some of the historically inaccurate films Menahem Golan...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
I imagine Gorky Park is akin to their re-release of Twice Told Tales where the transfer source is likely the same, but with a bigger disc to work with and better encoding, the image picks up some slight...
Audio: 60
James Horner’s score is excellent as ever, but it’s very much in his early 80s vein so you’re going to hear a lot of themes and motifs similar to what he did for Star Trek II, Commando, 48 Hrs., and The...
Extras: 20
On the bonus features front, we have the rare occurrence where a KLSC reissue doesn’t pick up a new commentary - which is a damned shame....
Movie: 80
It’s late in the film when you learn that Dennehy’s Kirwill fluently knows how to speak Russian explaining how a guy like that could even remotely blend into the citizenry of Moscow....
Total: 80
The image may not be perfect, but it’s still a great-looking disc with solid audio to match....
Director: Michael Apted
Actors: William Hurt, Lee Marvin, Brian Dennehy
PlotIn the snow-covered Gorky Park of Moscow, three faceless corpses are discovered, setting off a gripping investigation into their identities and the circumstances of their deaths. Leading the investigation is Arkady Renko, a chief investigator for the Soviet militsiya, who quickly finds himself entangled in a complex web of KGB agents, American businessmen, and a mysterious woman who may hold the key to solving the case. Renko's dedication to uncovering the truth brings him into dangerous confrontations with those who wish the secrets of the park's dead to remain buried. His pursuit of justice challenges the limits of his integrity and his loyalty to his country.
The investigation leads Renko into the murky world of Soviet-era corruption, where the lines between friend and foe are blurred, and trust is a commodity few can afford. As he delves deeper, Renko discovers that the murders are tied to a valuable sable smuggling operation, forcing him to navigate a treacherous path between the demands of his superiors and his own moral compass. The closer Renko gets to the truth, the more he risks – not just his career, but his life and the lives of those he cares for. Amidst the cold and shadowy confines of Moscow, the quest for justice becomes a struggle for survival, highlighting the enduring human spirit in the face of systemic oppression.
Writers: Martin Cruz Smith, Dennis Potter
Release Date: 16 Dec 1983
Runtime: 128 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English