Arthur Christmas Blu-ray Review
Score: 67
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Arthur Christmas on Blu-ray 3D offers joyous animation and heartfelt storytelling, though its 3D visuals and special features fall short of perfection.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
Arthur Christmas on Blu-ray offers a superb high-definition experience with vibrant, slightly oversaturated hues, especially vivid reds, and immaculate detail. However, while the Blu-ray 3D maintains fantastic color and sharp detail, its depth is adequate but not breathtaking, with minimal pop-out moments. The overall presentation is nearly flawless but lacks the intricate textures seen in Pixar productions.
Audio: 64
Arthur Christmas's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack offers crisp dialogue, robust bass, and excellent dynamics, with precise imaging and immersive environmental effects, yet lacks some depth and wow-factor, making it a strong but not top-tier audio presentation.
Extra: 50
The Extras on the 'Arthur Christmas' Blu-ray, though spanning both 2D and 3D discs with nearly 30 minutes of content, offer a cursory glimpse into the film's creation through featurettes, progression reels, and a humorous Elf recruitment video, but feel limited in depth and breadth.
Movie: 80
Arthur Christmas features superb 3D visuals, top-notch animation, and world-class voice acting that elevate its heartfelt, clever narrative. Blending traditional and cutting-edge elements seamlessly, the film underscores the essence of holiday spirit and personal touch amidst a dazzling technological spectacle.
Video: 76
The high-definition presentation of "Arthur Christmas" on Blu-ray is simply stunning, showcasing beautifully crafted animation with vivid and slightly oversaturated hues. Reds, in particular, stand out with visible gradational stages that bring out subtle degrees of separation. Each character has distinctive physical traits that are easily discernible, and the video quality is immaculate with pristine resolution and detailed minutiae. From the varied range of emotions displayed by the characters to the balance between contrast and black levels, the attention to detail is meticulous. Whites are bright and punchy while blacks are rich with excellent dynamic range, contributing to a polished and reference-quality presentation.
For the 3D version, while it offers good general depth and enhances the sense of space in several scenes, it doesn't have many eye-popping moments that “wow” the viewer. The depth works well, particularly in shots featuring crowds of elves, where the sense of space and tangible shapes is clear. However, these moments are few, as most of the 3D visuals focus on adding scale and scope rather than providing extra-screen material. The film's 3D features a notable sharpness and vibrancy that match the 2D release, maintaining excellent color consistency and detail. While not a groundbreaking experience, the 3D presentation benefits from an accurate MPEG-4 MVC encode framed in the original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, ensuring both formats are visually impressive.
Despite these strengths, "Arthur Christmas" falls short of achieving Pixar or DreamWorks levels of detail and texture. The visuals are fantastic and true to the theatrical release, but they miss the final touch of dazzle that might elevate them to perfection. Even so, both the 2D and 3D presentations offer rich visuals and an immersive experience that should satisfy most viewers.
Audio: 64
The audio presentation of "Arthur Christmas" on Blu-ray features a well-crafted DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack. This mix is thoughtfully engineered, effectively utilizing the surround platform to deliver rich sonic clarity, crystalline dialogue, and a robust bass response. It excels in balancing discrete directional cues with rear channel ambience, creating a seamless listening experience where the front and rear sound fields work in unison for precise imaging and acoustic placement. Dynamics are notable and align well with the source material, providing an immersive soundscape that supports the film’s visual richness.
The track’s strength lies in its ability to craft a realistic atmosphere, delivering environmental sounds with precision across diverse settings—from the cavernous space of the S-1 craft to the subtle morning effects of small-town England. Sound effects and ambient noises are intricately layered, offering accuracy and an impressive sense of space. Harry Gregson-Williams' melodious score stands out, enhancing the emotional and narrative arc through scenes of action and adventure. While the mix is occasionally weighted toward front-channel moments, it includes numerous instances of surround sound immersion, enriched by well-integrated off-screen dialogues and background murmurs that add to the overall auditory depth.
In summary, the DTS-HD Master Audio soundtrack of "Arthur Christmas" delivers a thoroughly enjoyable listening experience. It balances clarity and immersion, effectively complementing the film’s vivid visuals and enhancing the viewing journey. Despite minor variances in dynamic impact, the soundtrack remains a robust and meticulously engineered audio presentation that should satisfy listeners across different age groups.
Extras: 50
The extras included with the "Arthur Christmas" Blu-ray offer insightful yet brief content. Available on both the 2D and 3D Blu-rays, these features provide a behind-the-scenes look into the film's creation. Despite the relatively short runtime, they encompass various aspects from cast and crew interviews to animation progression. The highlight is the "Unwrapping Arthur Christmas" featurette, which combines interviews and clips from the movie to explore character development, voice acting, and digital animation processes. Additionally, the humorous "Elf Recruitment Video" offers a light-hearted twist, while the "Progression Reels" detail the evolution of certain scenes from their initial stages to the final CGI renderings.
Extras included in this disc:
- Unwrapping Arthur Christmas: Overview with cast and crew interviews intercut with film clips.
- Progression Reels: Insight into scene development with segments including Arthur’s office, Grandsanta, Trelew, and more.
- Elf Recruitment Video: Humorous commercial for Christmas elf work.
Movie: 80
"Arthur Christmas" serves as a contemporary reimagining of the Santa Claus legend, blending innovative technical themes with timeless holiday spirit. The film explores how Claus is no longer a single individual but part of a longstanding family tradition. The current Santa, nearing retirement and portrayed by Jim Broadbent, has seen Christmas evolve into a high-tech operation overseen by his son Steve (voiced by Hugh Laurie). Steve's state-of-the-art S-1 sleigh and militaristic precision in handling deliveries stand in stark contrast to the holiday's traditional warmth. The plot revolves around the youngest son, Arthur (voiced by James McAvoy), who embarks on a mission to deliver a missed present using an antiquated sleigh, driven by a spirit of genuine concern for ensuring every child's dreams are fulfilled.
The magic of "Arthur Christmas" lies not only in its captivating storyline but in the exceptional animation quality and voice acting that breathe life into its characters. The film is visually stunning, with intricate details from the icy North Pole to the technologically advanced S-1 vessel. Animation enthusiasts will appreciate the film's razor-sharp visuals and carefully crafted elements, right down to the smallest details on Arthur's sweater. This meticulous design is complemented by a stellar voice cast, notably McAvoy's endearing portrayal of Arthur and strong performances from Broadbent, Nighy, and Laurie.
In addition to visual splendor, "Arthur Christmas" benefits from Harry Gregson-Williams' evocative musical score that perfectly captures the adventurous and festive spirit of the story. The film seamlessly interweaves humor with heartfelt moments, making it a multi-dimensional experience. While it may not achieve Pixar's level of visual flair, its intelligent script and emotional depth make it a standout entry in the holiday movie genre. With themes emphasizing the importance of personal touch and the true spirit of Christmas, "Arthur Christmas" stands as a modern holiday classic that will resonate for years to come.
Total: 67
"Arthur Christmas" cleverly addresses the myriad of Santa Claus myths with resounding joy and visual splendor. A rare gem among holiday films, it is celebrated for its high-quality animation and stellar voice performances. Only "The Polar Express" competes in terms of animation and emotional depth, yet "Arthur Christmas" brings a unique honesty and simplistic joy that epitomize holiday cheer.
The Blu-ray 3D version offers solid, though not outstanding, 3D visuals paired with a fine lossless soundtrack. The visual fidelity is comparable to the 2D version, maintaining brightness and vibrancy, which may influence those budget-conscious consumers. While the immersive quality of the 3D isn't groundbreaking, fans of the format will still find it enjoyable. However, the Special Features are lacking in both quantity and depth, making it a slight disappointment for those seeking extensive behind-the-scenes content.
Overall, "Arthur Christmas - 3D" stands out as an imaginative, witty, and heartwarming addition to any holiday film collection. While there are minor shortcomings in the 3D presentation and supplemental features, the film's infectious charm and festive spirit make it an essential watch. If 3D isn't crucial, opting for the 2D version could be a prudent choice without missing out on the core experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
The picture offers good general depth but there's not a single frame in the film that will truly leave viewers breathless with the scope of the 3D picture element....
Audio: 70
There's a nice sense of power and heftiness to the S-1 in exterior scenes, and some of the more action-oriented sound effects play very well, with natural spacing, great clarity, and faultless balance....
Extras: 90
All of the extras may be found on both the 2D and 3D discs, but only some of the previews are actually in 3D. Included is the following: Un-Wrapping Arthur Christmas (1080p, 13:26): A fluffy overview that...
Movie: 90
It's not about saving time but rather savoring time, cherishing those special moments that are most certainly worth the effort, whether that means a trip to the corner store or a voyage around the world...
Total: 40
Only The Polar Express truly rivals it in every category, from animation to heart, but there's a simple joy and pure honesty to Arthur Christmas that's unique to the film and also the embodiment of holiday...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Overall it works well, adding scale and scope to the vast interiors of the S1 and North Pole Headquarters, but sometimes feels a little flat in less dynamic frame compositions....
Audio: 80
Along with the terrific British voice casting, Harry Gregson-Williams' score is certainly the highlight of the mix, as it shifts from its action-spy movie opening sequences to soaring and heart-warming...
Extras: 20
There are three Special Features available on 'Arthur Christmas - 3D', totaling almost 30 minutes and, as stated above, available on both the Blu-ray 3D and Blu-ray disc....
Movie: 80
Aided by thousands of enthusiastic Elves sneaking into neighborhoods like super spies, Santa seems to be going through the motions, and yet because Steve's upgrades are so seamless, Santa doesn't realize...
Total: 80
As a Blu-ray 3D, picture and audio are just shy of greatness and the 3D presentation is virtually identical, in terms of brightness and vibrancy, to its 2D sibling....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 96
Contrast and black levels strike a great balance as whites are bright, detailed and punchy while blacks are rich with excellent dynamic range....
Audio: 88
The front and rear sound field’s never collide but work in unison to render the soundtrack with precise imaging and acoustic placement....
Extras: 50
Arthur Christmas unwrapped – 5 minutes Arthur’s office – 2 minutes Grandsanta – 2 minutes Trelew – 2 minutes Invasion – 2 minutes (HD) Elf recruitment video Disc 2: Arthur Christmas 2D Blu-ray (same features...
Movie: 80
With retired Grandsanta, a rebellious young elf, an old sleigh and some untrained reindeer, Arthur sets out in a crazy mission to deliver the last present!...
Total: 79
Screen Onkyo PR-SC5508 THX Ultra 2 Audio/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Sarah Smith, Barry Cook
Actors: James McAvoy, Jim Broadbent, Bill Nighy
PlotIn a high-tech North Pole command center, Santa Claus oversees a complex operation to deliver presents to children around the world using a massive, state-of-the-art sleigh-ship named the S-1, operated by a well-organized team of elves. Santa’s eldest son, Steve, efficiently manages the entire operation and anticipates becoming the next Santa. However, the heart of the story centers on Santa’s clumsy yet kind-hearted younger son, Arthur, who is relegated to answering letters from children and is considered a misfit in the family’s Christmas machine. Despite his awkwardness, Arthur possesses an unwavering belief in the magic of Christmas and deeply cares about every child's happiness.
When a single gift for a young girl is accidentally overlooked, Arthur embarks on a mission to deliver the present before dawn, determined to ensure no child is left disappointed on Christmas morning. With the aid of his spirited and adventurous Grand-Santa, Arthur sets off in the antique, reindeer-driven sleigh, encountering numerous challenges along the way. As they race against time, Arthur and Grand-Santa must navigate various obstacles, showcasing Arthur's determination and the importance of believing in the magic of the season, ultimately reinforcing the true meaning of Christmas and family. The journey also reveals deeper dynamics within the Claus family, emphasizing themes of unity, tradition, and modernization.
Writers: Peter Baynham, Sarah Smith
Release Date: 23 Nov 2011
Runtime: 97 min
Rating: PG
Country: United Kingdom, United States
Language: English